RAINA ライナ 🍱 lorecrafters (@RAINAplease) header
RAINA ライナ 🍱 lorecrafters (@RAINAplease) profile picture

Virtual producer & loremaster behind your oshi's personal stories. Let me help you with yours! ✨ ・hire me @heylorecrafters ・also cooking at @teatomesstudio

Support my work ➡
Joined November 2020
Photo by RAINA ライナ 🍱 lorecrafters (@RAINAplease)Photo by RAINA ライナ 🍱 lorecrafters (@RAINAplease)Photo by RAINA ライナ 🍱 lorecrafters (@RAINAplease)Photo by RAINA ライナ 🍱 lorecrafters (@RAINAplease)Photo by RAINA ライナ 🍱 lorecrafters (@RAINAplease)Photo by RAINA ライナ 🍱 lorecrafters (@RAINAplease)Photo by RAINA ライナ 🍱 lorecrafters (@RAINAplease)Photo by RAINA ライナ 🍱 lorecrafters (@RAINAplease)Photo by RAINA ライナ 🍱 lorecrafters (@RAINAplease)Photo by RAINA ライナ 🍱 lorecrafters (@RAINAplease)
Replying to @RAINAplease
My un-NDA'ed story of working in online entertainment, as promised. Given how many people resort to whisper networks when talking about work conditions, because speaking up publicly in this space is risky - I realize talking about things like this will paint a massive target on my back. But after the recent agency + merch company collapses, and seeing people ask "why doesn't anyone call bad actors out publicly until it's too late?" - this is part of why I'm posting. And for the record: I exhausted every avenue available to me at the time to resolve things internally first. Some industry staff might side-eye me for "not having discretion" and deem me a risk just for posting this, and I don't expect everyone to believe me either. Which I get - the people on the other side of this will have their own view of things. Still, I'm hoping this story will reach the people who need it most. Maybe it'll help people already in this scene recognize red flags, whether in how they're treating people - or how they're being treated. *** I was scouted for and offered a "project manager" role a few years out of uni, while I was working as a research assistant by day, and a freelance editor + online community manager by night. I was frank with them: "I have no PM experience". That didn't stop the company leads from begging me for over a year to join full-time, with promises they'd "pay and look after me properly". I was cautious about why they were so keen, because again - no PM experience. I did eventually take the leap - and while there were good moments, and some degree of struggle is expected in any job...what happened is quite the laundry list. When I was there, I: - received no structure or expectations for skill or biz development - just "trust me" and "we're loyal, so we expect that from you" - was told "I pay you so much to figure shit out" when I asked uppers for guidance to calibrate to expectations - was told "you don't put in enough effort" or "you're not passionate enough" whenever work I'd had to figure out alone (or was still waiting on direction for) was deemed "not good enough" - was told "the reason you're not getting anywhere and you're being shat on by uppers is because you have an ego and you're lazy" - right after I raised concerns about quality slippage due to scope creep being requested on a crunched project - had my job scope balloon over 4+ full-time years as many new initiatives launched that I had to manage, without pay to match (I never got an official JD - this is partly on me for not spotting the red flags) - ended up working 50-60 hours/week across those initiatives (both internal and external), going beyond a typical PM's remit because I was "being paid so much" - was denied extra support staff to reduce my load for that same "paid so much" reason - watched the one underpaid dedicated support staffer I managed to get (and trained for a year before they left) get treated the same way by uppers ("you're paid so well, a million people would kill to be in your position, why can't you do more/better") - had uppers tell other staff I "did nothing" despite all of that, and was told "doubt you're actually working 8 hours a day" (it was more because I was often exhausted and slow) - was forbidden from having my own projects outside the role under my name (ones that wouldn't have competed with the company's direction anyway) - either because "it's risky making it out on your own, why not focus on your role with us and grow this company", OR because "we pay you so much" and wanting something outside of the job was "ungrateful" - was regularly threatened with being fired or having my pay cut - but told "we don't want to do this, but threats are the only way we can get you to actually perform" - actually had my pay cut as "punishment" because I posted something general about what stressful workplace dynamics look like, and had to beg after 6 months for it to be restored (there was no such thing as a formal code of conduct) - was told there were no yearly increments for salaried staff - raises had to be requested and justified, and "obviously" weren't automatic - watched anyone who asked for a raise (whether salaried or freelance) get called "not good enough" on undefined whims, to justify depressed pay and verbal abuse - while unbudgeted "bonuses" went to whoever was the favorite of the hour - saw no defined way of recognizing actual impact (because so many management outcomes are invisible) - was told, when I pointed all this out, that my pay (no medical or pension, btw) was "generous" and that asking for more was "disloyal" - was not allowed to talk to anyone else in the company, let alone industry friends, if I had problems - because that would be "gossiping", and "we wouldn't do that to you" - while they talked about me to others anyway. (I kept to it even without an NDA, because I had a weird heady mix of integrity out of "loyalty" and low self-esteem at the time) - was told by others in the company (when I started to break my silence internally before leaving) that I was "just as toxic, what did you expect" - and at one point, "an imbecile" - was told "if you leave, you won't make it elsewhere, you have nothing in this industry" - was told when I was leaving, "if only you had more confidence" - was earning just over 36k a year by the time I left - and that was after the one raise I had to beg for to keep up with inflation (I live in Singapore of all places.) I'll be the first to admit I was (ironically) overpaid when I was recruited, given the company's inflow and my experience at the time - but massively underpaid by the time I left. I was paid a monthly salary and referred to as an employee, with employee expectations - but in hindsight was actually legally a contractor - so no employee benefits or protections. Realistically, looking at what the company was bringing in and all the stuff they were trying to do...I don't think they had the capacity, nor did they think to prioritize that sort of thing. I don't claim to be the perfect "employee" - and on reflection, there's lots of stuff I did back then that I'm really not proud of. But I also know I did the best I could with what was afforded and "promised" to me, given the internal environment at the time. And I'm still grateful for the initial "break" into the industry, and that most of it was remote (small mercies, though mostly because there was office money for leadership's own priorities...just not for the mostly underpaid Southeast Asian staff being put through the wringer, welp). But no amount of pay was worth some of the horrors of that job, nor the opportunity cost of staying out of "loyalty". Looking back, so much of it was exactly what I talked about in my first quote-reply to Dizzy's "lack of good managers in this scene" post - skill gaps and scope issues being framed as character flaws, with a heavy dose of shaming to match. It took me a long time to finally break my silence to the right people - what came after is in the reply below, and I promise the payoff is positive! 👇 #RAINArambles nitter.gq/RAINAplease/status/210…
I've been mulling on whether many of the people who have both the actual dedication/passion - never mind the competencies - to be good managers in VTubing/content creation would just rather work in other fields, simply because of how underpaid it can be here on the whole, given that this is a known "passion industry"... 🙁 Which is ironic, because you DO need some level of pragmatism to qualify as a good mane-san - but that's the kind of trait that would make you go "I need to eat first, doing this [full-time] isn't exactly sustainable." 🤷‍♀️ Also - many of the skills needed to be a good mane-san sometimes just get assumed to be personal character values, like "either you have it innately as a good person, or you don't and you're just lazy/malicious" - as if they're not actually learnable or teachable things. But it's mostly just skill [gap] issues, and those CAN be fixed with time + the right (social) conditions. Believe it or not: - "Being organized" is a teachable skill. - Diagnosing/problem solving is a teachable skill. - Emotional resilience is a teachable skill (yeah, surprising! doesn't mean stuffing your emotions btw) - Learning to read people is a teachable skill. - Communicating well with different personality types + needs is a teachable skill (yes, even with many of the neurospicy people in this space!) And they're all things you can find step-by-step frameworks for, and decision logic etc to learn about - not "character problems". But there are a bajillion ways to do all these things, because there are SO many frameworks - and in a space that's full of neurospicy people, some of these frameworks/methodologies are written to suit different "normie" spaces/people. To top it off, some resources don't always teach you the first-principles logic (the actual "why" behind these things) - many things can sometimes be a case of "because I said so", if it's being taught by a person. That's an issue because many ND people may learn SOME of these things, hit a wall where they don't work (because they don't get taught the actual "why", so they can't deduce when something doesn't fit the criteria). And even if they can tell there's a mismatch, they also don't always have the knowledge/confidence to know what to do differently. So these "resources" may end up being just hard to understand to begin with, let alone apply. Or they just straight up don't work 1:1 with vtubing/content creation - simply because of the many different people and other situational/environmental differences you have to deal with. That's also not including the challenge of knowing which teaching resources are actually legit, and not just some fly-by snippet on a YT short/reel designed to rack up views/likes...let alone even knowing the people who CAN actually help you build those skills up. Because you can't practice these things in a vacuum (knowing the theory alone by taking courses is nowhere near enough), having the actual space - AND hands-on correction/feedback from others to do those skill-building reps to begin with - is so important. But trying to find one with less of the shaming or traumatizing that's common in many spaces - where they just call that sort of shit "character building" for their people...that's another can of worms altogether. Which makes the trial and error process quite demotivating for many backend staff who may have the passion to git gud, but really just need more help in building up the skillset to begin with. Not to say that we should be sheltering/coddling the people who want to learn/go into this space to be backend staff - but given how many competent aspiring managers/support staff I've known who have quit, and have cited all those reasons above to me... Well, let's just say that performers in this space aren't the only ones who should have their welfare throughout the learning process considered. #RAINArambles
13
24
3
113
8,834
Yes, I've seen the mixed and concerned sentiment over a recent agency's paid event and merch sales cadence. I've actually been working on something to address the surrounding discourse for a while. “It’s just business and companies need profit, duh" is the easy answer to "why do companies make decisions like this that seem to work against their talent" - but it's really not that straightforward. For this specific case, I've been reading the parent company’s own investor reports, and it's actually quite interesting seeing which things get counted as profits or losses...and which numbers never show up anywhere in reporting. It's been a real challenge because I'm pulling up reports from over a number of years, and mapping quite a few corpo restructuring events and timelines - and I want to do this #RAINArambles explainer right. My journo training and personal code apply here, after all - I know most fans didn’t sign up for corpo analysis, so I want the final piece to be readable instead of a wall of numbers. (Cari's actually been suggesting this should be a video essay, but I'm still finding the courage to record one.) In the meantime, here’s an older piece I wrote on where your corpo oshi’s bag actually comes from 👇
There's a subset of people who can't tell the difference between an independent contractor and an employee, and where they differ in terms of the obligations a company has to them. Which is fair, since people also use "salary", "wage" and "fee" interchangeably - when there are actually slight differences. Just so everyone's on the same page: Most corporate vtubers you know are independent contractors, NOT employees. They're paid fees from percentage cuts on stream revenue, merch and voice packs, appearance fees, collab licensing - and it goes up and down month to month. So: not a salary, which is a fixed amount paid at fixed, regular intervals. Some agencies might offer a minimum guarantee if the talent hits their minimum content output goals for the month - which is generally a goodwill thing offered when the talent hasn't hit sufficient monetization goals in the early months, more as a safety net. Given the independent contractor relationship, the agency isn't actually REQUIRED to do this. This is the "[low] base salary" people are referring to with some early agency talents who have talked about it on their streams, and it's probably why people get confused about what talents are actually entitled to. (Worth noting: in some cases, the minimum guarantee "salary" is a "draw" - as in, it's recoupable against future earnings. So it's an advance, not an income. I don't speak for Cover Corp, but I have seen this "recoup from future earnings" arrangement at some other agencies.) Now - revenue sharing with an indie contractor only makes sense as a structure if both sides are actually putting something in, to give the VTuber IP its best chances of success. And usually, both parties are clear on expectations - or rather, who provides what. The talent brings the performance, the hours, and usually the audience relationship/community building. That last one is very much a talent contribution no matter how big or small the agency is, because more audience = more people who can be monetized from, so agencies and vtubers will obviously seek to grow that. A more known agency may provide an "initial fanbase" at debut so you're not entirely starting from zero, but it's still entirely on the talent to retain and further grow it. The agency is supposed to bring the things a solo creator can't easily buy: back in the day, it was enough to provide just a model and rigging for it. But getting a VTuber model is a lot more accessible nowadays, so you've also got to consider things like production and music budgets, promo reach, management, event and sponsor access, sometimes training (singing, dancing, Japanese) or studio time. That's what the agency cut is for. And under formal employment, a lot of that would attach automatically by law - more on that in a moment. But under contractor status, the agency owes exactly what's in the contract and nothing else - which puts a LOT of weight on how well that contract was drafted, and how much leverage a debuting talent had to negotiate it at the time. Plenty of what gets promised lives in the recruitment ads, the interviews, the pitch meetings - rather than in the document. And even then, the contracted stuff sometimes doesn't materialize - budgets shrink, staff turn over, companies overcommit across a whole wave and can't follow through. On paper, yes - the talent is entitled to what's on the contract. In practice, enforcing it means one contractor going after an agency, often across borders...usually while still signed to them. (Side-eyeing you, microcorps.) Now - about "employee status": It's a lot more protected. In most countries, if you hire someone as an employee, you're required by law to pay and provide a bunch of things in a timely manner. So that's things like fixed(!) salaries, overtime pay (if applicable), pensions, insurance, other statutory benefits - whether the employee brought in 2k or 20k in revenue. You also often have strict thresholds for things like termination or making someone redundant, especially in Japan. (Hooray for labor laws and protections!) On top of that, a functional employer is also expected to give employees the means to do the job - so that's why things like equipment and courses can be, and often are, covered by companies. But the minimum legal obligations aren't cheap. In Japan, employer-side social insurance contributions alone run roughly 15-16% on top of gross salary, and that's before you count anything else (equipment, training, anything discretionary.) It's not a viable expense for many companies, especially when you're launching new VTuber IP (x4-5 batches of costs, given a wave size) - and you don't always know how soon it'll get monetized, how much it's going to rake in, how long that audience gravy train will last...well, that's kind of hard to justify in the budget for the performers - on top of the asset costs, and agency staff costs. A former VTuber agency director once told me that "corpo vtubing is very much gacha - you release a bunch of IPs built together with a bunch of performers and staff, and you hope one of them catches on, and that the rising tide lifts all boats in the agency. There's no clear target dates or numbers for a return on your investment." So it's understandable why agencies try to exercise that control over their performers, in order for their vision to be realized, for success and profit to roll in, yada yada. But they can only do so much, because well - independent contractor, not employee. To be clear: independent contractor status isn't necessarily a "downgrade" for the talent. It's not really a choice either; it's the model basically every agency offers, so "choosing" it mostly means choosing to sign. And most showbiz veterans can tell you that many areas in the entertainment business work this way: musicians live and die by revenue splits with their labels on album/streaming numbers, tour sales, brand deals etc. (Different industries have various workarounds for the "not earning enough in the early days" issue. Kpop agencies defer this - they cover a LOT more costs upfront for things like training, food and housing, though it's usually recouped from earnings later. J-idols at the lower rungs do a lot of unglamorous dispatch work while their own IP isn't paying yet. All of these solutions have different trade-offs, but that's for a different analysis post.) But there are also benefits to being an indie contractor on a revenue split: your upside isn't capped, so if you blow up, you're not on a fixed salary watching your agency bank the difference. (Keyword: "if" you blow up.) So when people say "just pay them a proper salary," even if it's out of consideration for their oshis, they're not just describing a baseline - they're also describing a ceiling, and usually a shorter leash (without realizing it.) And importantly, the exclusivity clause for VTuber performers typically binds professional conduct related to the performance identity and possible competition, not the whole person. Yes, you're generally exclusive as a VTuber talent, and yes, the persona is usually the agency's IP. But without naming names, for obvious reasons: some of your corpo oshis still run their prior creator brands from before they went corpo, albeit usually on reduced schedules and changed scope/branding. Some other corpo oshis do paid work (illustration, for example) that's not performance-related under their other identities. So yes, your oshi at the bigger agencies might be slammed - but generally, if you have the capacity for it, you CAN still have other income streams outside of your corpo vtubing gig. (Other than working a regular day job, that is.) The tradeoff is real, though - and it's not the same tradeoff for everybody, which is why some people have expressed curiosity or concern on the whole "moving to Japan" uptick amongst corpo vtubing talent under JP agencies. (Even if yes, sometimes your oshi wants to move there just because they like the place.) Contractor status doesn't produce one risk profile; you often get wildly different ones depending on where the talent physically lives. A Japan-based talent is on National Health Insurance and the national pension by default (mandated by law for all residents) - so the safety net under them exists, whether or not the agency built it. European-based talents have similar fallbacks for health coverage. SEA-based talents who have mostly paying audiences from the west can make their money go further, so it's less about safety nets and more that the maths is in their favor. But if you're in the US...well. Insurance has to be self-sourced if your employer doesn't cover it, and we know how infamous US healthcare costs are. Same contract, same agency - but completely different risk and exposure tiers. That's why "does the agency cover medical/(insert benefit here)" is a question with all sorts of different correct answers, depending on who's asking it. Also worth knowing, because it's recent and barely discussed: "not an employee" thankfully no longer means "no protections," at least in Japan. The Freelance Act took effect in November 2024, and it requires all sorts of things: - written contract terms upfront - payment within 60 days of delivery - no unilateral reduction of agreed remuneration - 30 days' notice before termination or non-renewal on continuous contracts of six months or more (with reasons disclosed on request) - actual harassment-prevention measures - which matters because freelancers were previously outside workplace harassment law entirely. These are a direct answer to a lot of what I said earlier about promised things not materializing - well, at least on the parts that involve getting paid. The stated government position is that these rules apply where all or part of the business activity is considered to be undertaken in Japan. How it will play out in practice for remote streaming talent outside of Japan, though - I can't tell yet. But these protections are only for how your oshi gets treated by the company, not how much they actually bring in raw revenue. Nothing in here obliges a paying audience or a brand sponsor to show up. Now there's also actually a hard boundary on how much control companies in general can exercise before the "independent contractor" classification is moot. There have been MANY cases around the world where businesses got taken to court because they exercised too much control over an independent contractor, and courts ruled: no, you should be classifying them as an employee, and paying them a proper salary and benefits if you're going to demand this much. (Whether you have the resources to take the business to court, though, is another story. Depending solely on the law to protect you can be slow and resource-heavy.) In a nutshell: Yes, the pay structure really is "just the way it is". This independent contractor structure is the model that corpo vtubing + the wider entertainment industry largely runs on - and for the most part, both talent and agency are aware of this when they enter into agreements. Neither party chose a conventional or stable 9-5, so expecting corpo vtubing to behave like one - even for the bigger agency names - is where a lot of the "but my corpo oshi deserves a regular bag" arguments go to shit. I can't speak for whether this business model is sustainable or not - your corpo oshi is an adult who made the choice to do it this way, and things can change with both audiences and brands/sponsors over time. But I don't think having "contractor status" as a talent is the actual risk here. The main danger is getting into a bad deal, or one that disproportionately requires more time and money out of you than what you're getting back from the job - and in some cases, you end up having to pull the plug before your time + effort invested get a proper fighting chance to pay off. Or as we've seen with many other now-dead agencies (Specialite EN, FSP JP)...your company just pulls the plug instead. Issue is - as an individual performer, that's a good chunk of your time and lots of opportunity cost that's now sunk. For the company? That's just a few gacha rolls that didn't work out. #RAINArambles
2
12
100
3,139
there's vtuber merch discourse? people are divided on what counts as "fair" for artists to charge for merch art? for fulfilment services to offer as a royalty split? for production + fulfilment timelines and quality? people also don't fully know the difference between fulfillment/white glove providers, vs having your own store where you do inventory management and fulfilment yourself? people are also saying that "if you're doing merch for the money, that's wrong, it should be just for the fans"? hooooo boy where do I even begin to unpick this... 💦 if @CarillusArt could speak it would be a riot
3
27
852
RAINA ライナ 🍱 lorecrafters retweeted
You saw a small glimpse of her in both the comic and Hades's reference but here she is~! Say hello to Persephone! Our artiest did such an amazing job with her! I love the different forms she takes depending on the time of the year~ 🎨@reonufa
1
7
1
20
714
RAINA ライナ 🍱 lorecrafters retweeted
OTSUUU V@V AND THANK YOU FOR AN EXTREMELY FUN AND JAM PACKED WEEKENDDDDD 🫶 #VtuberatVAX
19
47
6
141
4,449
we have FGO at home and I'm proud to have supervised it \o/ happy halloween (in advance!)
Tales From the Divine Halloween Special! Who would fight for Zombie feet pics??
1
8
351
RAINA ライナ 🍱 lorecrafters retweeted
⚠️VTuber@VAX New Schedule⚠️ Due to the major change in venue and time, the timeslot for almost all guests is changed. Please look carefully and plan your arrival accordingly. Once again, we apologise for the inconvenience caused.
31
12
59
6,181
Heads up to those coming for mine + @CarillusArt's talk tomorrow: Our timeslot has changed to 11:15AM, Oct 31 - right after Oscen's own talk. So you get a full family affair if you attend our panels back to back! See you at Lecture Hall 14 @ Taylor's Lakeside tomorrow~
⚠️VTuber@VAX New Schedule⚠️ Due to the major change in venue and time, the timeslot for almost all guests is changed. Please look carefully and plan your arrival accordingly. Once again, we apologise for the inconvenience caused.
5
11
479
RAINA ライナ 🍱 lorecrafters retweeted
⚠️URGENT ANNOUNCEMENT⚠️ CHANGES TO VTUBER@VAX It is with regret that VGakuenLIVE is announcing many major changes to VTuber@VAX due to VAX unable to provide the original agreed venue. Please read through the details if you're attending. We sincerely apologises for all the inconvenience. VGakuenLIVE is doing everything we can to continue to make this program happen, as our dear guests and fans have been anticipating for this. More details on what happened will be released soon. We are still waiting for VAX to release their statement.
36
8
63
5,041
RAINA ライナ 🍱 lorecrafters retweeted
Agree with every point here. Problem is, most creators hiring an editor can't evaluate any of it. At most, they can feel when an edit works or doesn't, but can't fully say why. That's not enough to hire on. This list is all craft knowledge and skill: intention, communication, reading the room - and being able to show all of that through video. It's mostly senior stuff that needs time and experience. And there's a catch-22: Can't evaluate editing → you have to trust your editor → the editors worth trusting cost real money → the cheap ones, you can't evaluate. Toxena's bonus tip in the replies is a good example. Knowing the Kuleshov effect is a great sign - but to check for it, a creator has to know what it actually means and why it matters. And plenty of editors already apply it on instinct, without even knowing that it's got a fancy name. If you treat knowing the name as a box to tick (easy to do when it's on a checklist), you'll miss good editors. You might also end up hiring bad ones who are essentially "posers", simply because they can spew fancy editing jargon to sound smart - without being able to deliver on it. (A test edit helps, admittedly - but only if you can judge it. Told you it was a catch-22.) "But RAINA, I CAN evaluate editing!" Okay, then - there's a high chance you've edited for yourself in the past. And if you don't have the time or ability to teach an editor your taste + judgement, you need one who already gets it - which means weeding out the good from the bad on VGen/in your replies/in your DMs. Half the time, it ends in “I might as well do it myself.” (That's a trap, btw. It's a delegation and documentation problem: spend the time once writing down what you want, instead of constantly fixing what you didn't get during every video. Refine it as you go.) Or you haven't actually edited video before, and you might not understand what it takes to execute an edit well. Spoiler: it costs more time and money than you expect. With cheap editors, the time cost climbs even higher: they're still learning the tools, so they end up manually rawdogging what a plugin could do, or burn hours trying to wrangle one they've never used. Then there's your end: all the revisions and notes you gotta do. This knowledge gap is why audiences for shows, games and the like sometimes get called "entitled": they may be right about taste and quality, but way out on what's reasonable for production volume, speed and cost. An editor who’s built that craft knowledge - AND can reproduce it consistently, on a schedule - is not going to be cheap. If they are, they’re underpaid AF. (Yes, even by VTubing standards - where rates for quality editing and audio are already undervalued.) I've seen listings asking for editors who can "produce without guidance" for ~$20 a short. That's editor + creative/marketing director at editor rates. Someone still has to make the director calls (judgement, taste, what the video's actually for). If you're not providing guidance, you're outsourcing all of that to your editor-slash-director. And no, "make it more grand/cinematic" isn't direction or guidance. (If your editor can understand that, I sure hope you're paying them properly.) Poaching works to a degree (so does the "more ethical" option of asking for recommendations), because you're borrowing another creator's judgement on who a good editor is. But that judgement was tuned to their channel's goals, work style and skillset - not yours. You still have to know what you want from the editor. Hiring a band's drummer doesn't automagically get you the band's sound - that's made up by the whole band, not one player. And just so we're clear: not even Travis Barker (of Blink-182 fame) can save a lead guitarist who can't play in time, or an off-key singer who hits notes only dogs can hear. That’s kind of what happens when someone wants an editor to produce without guidance, then keeps saying “not good enough” without saying why. (Ask me how I know.) One more trap, and it's about the math: When budgets are tight, it's tempting to judge a video by what it makes back in ad revenue (which is a painfully tall ask given CPM rates for things like shorts) - but that's rarely where its value is. Some videos are designed to attract new/cold audiences, some to nurture existing ones, and some to convert them into long-term paying customers: channel/Patreon subs, merch buyers, customers of your product or service. In plainer language: Attract = are new people finding you? Nurture = are they staying and coming back? Convert = are they clicking, subbing, buying? That makes editing a marketing cost, and it should be budgeted and measured like one. And no, "why I no viral" isn't how you measure whether a video worked. Surprise: this whole essay boils down to "I can't find a good editor [on a budget that doesn't break me]" actually being a marketing skill issue on your end as the creator. Plus a few more: delegation, documentation, and communication. At a base level, you don't need to learn editing to hire well - but you DO need to learn what your videos are for, and how to measure them properly. That's how you get out of the catch-22. Those parts are on you, and thankfully, it's all learnable. Lowkey curious whether @GeneralGEEGA's team at Level One Talent will be tackling this issue (or already is!) She said "YouTube" was the top topic in their manager sessions, and that members said editors were the hardest hire - which sounds like the same problem from two directions. With audio and voice pros already coming in month 2, it feels like a natural fit - so fingers crossed! (For the record, Toxena's list is really useful to know. I'm just here to fill in the gaps on actually putting it to work.) #RAINArambles
🎬EDITING TIPS🎬 How to find a good editor? A month ago @GeneralGEEGA opened her vtuber management service and posted some stats from that period a few days ago. Finding an editor is something most people had trouble with. Here's why I think that may be:
14
25
3
178
8,221
RAINA ライナ 🍱 lorecrafters retweeted
I changed my profile to keep up with our fast-paced reality Welcome to the new era
I'm considering a rebrand: Forward-deployed feelings engineer, where engineering meets chronology-based communication of intent. We e-meet aspiring entrepreneurs in the field of live asynchronous virtual entertainment, promoting story synergy to move people. What do you think?
3
2
42
950
RAINA ライナ 🍱 lorecrafters retweeted
They'll never find out I'm secretly moonlighting as a super patriotic TV presenter
📢📣🚨 ATTENTION CITIZENS 📢📣🚨 Lorecrafters is proud to announce its involvement in a vital strategic broadcast, produced for Helldivers For A Cause - a brilliant initiative led by @Transdivers_NOW to raise charity funds for @Streamcause. While @Jadedoedesu commanded the final video editing, our squad deployed key support: a newly-released report features the voice and script edits of "Zhang Lorecrafter" @CarillusArt, alongside further edits by producer @RAINAplease. Meanwhile, @heyitsoscen handled the session engineering and rapid audio cleanup to purge enemy transmission noise. We have proudly done our part for Super Earth, liberty, and charity. 🌎🔥 Watch the approved broadcast linked in high definition below, and help us spread Managed Democracy! 🚀🫡🎖️
1
2
10
577
Damn, this announcer sounds familiar...🤔 Anyway - I provided some script edit work for this and yoinked @CarillusArt + @heyitsoscen along for the fun! The family that spreads Managed Democracy together, stays together \o/ Thanks for having us!
WELCOME BACK TO CHARITIES LATEST In this special report we cover Helldivers for a Cause's communications repairs and Reinforcements Schedule, as well as REWARDBONDS TODAY and Liberty Day Celebrations. #helldivers2 #helldivers
1
8
339
RAINA ライナ 🍱 lorecrafters retweeted
📢📣🚨 ATTENTION CITIZENS 📢📣🚨 Lorecrafters is proud to announce its involvement in a vital strategic broadcast, produced for Helldivers For A Cause - a brilliant initiative led by @Transdivers_NOW to raise charity funds for @Streamcause. While @Jadedoedesu commanded the final video editing, our squad deployed key support: a newly-released report features the voice and script edits of "Zhang Lorecrafter" @CarillusArt, alongside further edits by producer @RAINAplease. Meanwhile, @heyitsoscen handled the session engineering and rapid audio cleanup to purge enemy transmission noise. We have proudly done our part for Super Earth, liberty, and charity. 🌎🔥 Watch the approved broadcast linked in high definition below, and help us spread Managed Democracy! 🚀🫡🎖️
WELCOME BACK TO CHARITIES LATEST In this special report we cover Helldivers for a Cause's communications repairs and Reinforcements Schedule, as well as REWARDBONDS TODAY and Liberty Day Celebrations. #helldivers2 #helldivers
3
3
1
12
777
RAINA ライナ 🍱 lorecrafters retweeted
introducing my husband @CarillusArt, now in his accidental VA era, doing his part for Super Earth and charity as he is Asian, you may call him Zhang Lorecrafter
WELCOME BACK TO CHARITIES LATEST In this special report we cover Helldivers for a Cause's communications repairs and Reinforcements Schedule, as well as REWARDBONDS TODAY and Liberty Day Celebrations. #helldivers2 #helldivers
1
2
14
643
RAINA ライナ 🍱 lorecrafters retweeted
Translation: he makes your oshi's backstory make you cry. If you haven't seen our script + direction work for @roychiato, check his 5.0 lore video work below!
I'm considering a rebrand: Forward-deployed feelings engineer, where engineering meets chronology-based communication of intent. We e-meet aspiring entrepreneurs in the field of live asynchronous virtual entertainment, promoting story synergy to move people. What do you think?
1
1
7
150
RAINA ライナ 🍱 lorecrafters retweeted
I'm considering a rebrand: Forward-deployed feelings engineer, where engineering meets chronology-based communication of intent. We e-meet aspiring entrepreneurs in the field of live asynchronous virtual entertainment, promoting story synergy to move people. What do you think?
We’re building out a new program at @NotionHQ: We call it field storytellers. Where Internet filmmakers & creators meet local businesses. All around the world. They travel there to apprentice a business for a day/two, and come back with stories, documented and published. Field storytelling is a bet that stories are best told and relationships are best built when it’s done out on the field. If you’re great with a camera, love traveling to meet local businesses, and Internet savvy with an audience, reach out 🖤
9
3
4
26
2,760
Agree with every point here. Problem is, most creators hiring an editor can't evaluate any of it. At most, they can feel when an edit works or doesn't, but can't fully say why. That's not enough to hire on. This list is all craft knowledge and skill: intention, communication, reading the room - and being able to show all of that through video. It's mostly senior stuff that needs time and experience. And there's a catch-22: Can't evaluate editing → you have to trust your editor → the editors worth trusting cost real money → the cheap ones, you can't evaluate. Toxena's bonus tip in the replies is a good example. Knowing the Kuleshov effect is a great sign - but to check for it, a creator has to know what it actually means and why it matters. And plenty of editors already apply it on instinct, without even knowing that it's got a fancy name. If you treat knowing the name as a box to tick (easy to do when it's on a checklist), you'll miss good editors. You might also end up hiring bad ones who are essentially "posers", simply because they can spew fancy editing jargon to sound smart - without being able to deliver on it. (A test edit helps, admittedly - but only if you can judge it. Told you it was a catch-22.) "But RAINA, I CAN evaluate editing!" Okay, then - there's a high chance you've edited for yourself in the past. And if you don't have the time or ability to teach an editor your taste + judgement, you need one who already gets it - which means weeding out the good from the bad on VGen/in your replies/in your DMs. Half the time, it ends in “I might as well do it myself.” (That's a trap, btw. It's a delegation and documentation problem: spend the time once writing down what you want, instead of constantly fixing what you didn't get during every video. Refine it as you go.) Or you haven't actually edited video before, and you might not understand what it takes to execute an edit well. Spoiler: it costs more time and money than you expect. With cheap editors, the time cost climbs even higher: they're still learning the tools, so they end up manually rawdogging what a plugin could do, or burn hours trying to wrangle one they've never used. Then there's your end: all the revisions and notes you gotta do. This knowledge gap is why audiences for shows, games and the like sometimes get called "entitled": they may be right about taste and quality, but way out on what's reasonable for production volume, speed and cost. An editor who’s built that craft knowledge - AND can reproduce it consistently, on a schedule - is not going to be cheap. If they are, they’re underpaid AF. (Yes, even by VTubing standards - where rates for quality editing and audio are already undervalued.) I've seen listings asking for editors who can "produce without guidance" for ~$20 a short. That's editor + creative/marketing director at editor rates. Someone still has to make the director calls (judgement, taste, what the video's actually for). If you're not providing guidance, you're outsourcing all of that to your editor-slash-director. And no, "make it more grand/cinematic" isn't direction or guidance. (If your editor can understand that, I sure hope you're paying them properly.) Poaching works to a degree (so does the "more ethical" option of asking for recommendations), because you're borrowing another creator's judgement on who a good editor is. But that judgement was tuned to their channel's goals, work style and skillset - not yours. You still have to know what you want from the editor. Hiring a band's drummer doesn't automagically get you the band's sound - that's made up by the whole band, not one player. And just so we're clear: not even Travis Barker (of Blink-182 fame) can save a lead guitarist who can't play in time, or an off-key singer who hits notes only dogs can hear. That’s kind of what happens when someone wants an editor to produce without guidance, then keeps saying “not good enough” without saying why. (Ask me how I know.) One more trap, and it's about the math: When budgets are tight, it's tempting to judge a video by what it makes back in ad revenue (which is a painfully tall ask given CPM rates for things like shorts) - but that's rarely where its value is. Some videos are designed to attract new/cold audiences, some to nurture existing ones, and some to convert them into long-term paying customers: channel/Patreon subs, merch buyers, customers of your product or service. In plainer language: Attract = are new people finding you? Nurture = are they staying and coming back? Convert = are they clicking, subbing, buying? That makes editing a marketing cost, and it should be budgeted and measured like one. And no, "why I no viral" isn't how you measure whether a video worked. Surprise: this whole essay boils down to "I can't find a good editor [on a budget that doesn't break me]" actually being a marketing skill issue on your end as the creator. Plus a few more: delegation, documentation, and communication. At a base level, you don't need to learn editing to hire well - but you DO need to learn what your videos are for, and how to measure them properly. That's how you get out of the catch-22. Those parts are on you, and thankfully, it's all learnable. Lowkey curious whether @GeneralGEEGA's team at Level One Talent will be tackling this issue (or already is!) She said "YouTube" was the top topic in their manager sessions, and that members said editors were the hardest hire - which sounds like the same problem from two directions. With audio and voice pros already coming in month 2, it feels like a natural fit - so fingers crossed! (For the record, Toxena's list is really useful to know. I'm just here to fill in the gaps on actually putting it to work.) #RAINArambles
🎬EDITING TIPS🎬 How to find a good editor? A month ago @GeneralGEEGA opened her vtuber management service and posted some stats from that period a few days ago. Finding an editor is something most people had trouble with. Here's why I think that may be:
14
25
3
178
8,221
Oh, sweet liberty! Now that it's public, I can say this: John Helldiver (Craig Lee Thomas) is joining my colleague Jade Doe and several other VTubers on Helldivers for a Cause, a charity initiative! They'll be on Jade's channel Friday Oct 30th, which I'm hella excited for \o/
Helldivers for a Cause Special Guest Announcement! Join us this Friday with John Helldiver himself, Craig Lee Thomas! We'll be diving for charity to help support Stream for a Cause!
2
7
431
RAINA ライナ 🍱 lorecrafters retweeted
Mini ramble 🧵: I think Tokino Mery's debut is a great example of how a good singer's stream is enhanced by a great audio setup. There's been some discourse going around how some people think the performance was pre-recorded, or heavily produced, which confuses me. Auto-tune can be used in a live setting. Any engineer with experience in live shows will tell you this. Auto-tune is also not some secret hack cheat code that makes everyone sound good. If you don't sing close to your target pitch, your tuning will snap to the wrong note and you will sound like butt. Compression, EQ, reverbs and delays can also be used live. The beauty of streaming and DAWs like Reaper is now you can setup a whole live vocal chain with minimal latency, whereas previously you'd have big ass live mixing consoles that were the only way to get vocal processing done in a live setting. VTubing is a tech industry and I think everyday content creators strive to break the norm and discover new ways to provide the best experience to their viewers. The fact is this level of broadcast setup isn't groundbreaking new tech, it's just audio setup done extremely well. Saying stuff like 'the vocal is too processed for a live stream' or 'it sounds too heavily produced' in this instance just means that this space has a long way more to go in terms of understanding what's really possible with polished audio. If you have a team backing you to present your talents to the world in the highest quality possible, there's no reason you shouldn't do it. If you want to hear imperfections and raw live singing, that's a preference, but it doesn't have to be everyone's standard.
🥳스텔라이브 4기생 어비스 [토키노 메리] 데뷔🪡🧸 🎙️에메(Aimer) 🎵브레이브 샤인(Brave Shine) 💿페이트/스테이 나이트(Fate/stay night) [UBW] s2 OP #maryclip_
12
70
6
771
48,292