Otto Lindholm (@0tt0M) header
Otto Lindholm (@0tt0M) profile picture

Tech and data lawyer, attorney, photographer, musician

Helsinki, Finland
Joined May 2011
Photo by Otto Lindholm (@0tt0M)Photo by Otto Lindholm (@0tt0M)Photo by Otto Lindholm (@0tt0M)Photo by Otto Lindholm (@0tt0M)Photo by Otto Lindholm (@0tt0M)Photo by Otto Lindholm (@0tt0M)Photo by Otto Lindholm (@0tt0M)Photo by Otto Lindholm (@0tt0M)Photo by Otto Lindholm (@0tt0M)Photo by Otto Lindholm (@0tt0M)
Holy hell. Lightroom just introduced an AI blur tool. I'm not sure what to think of it. And it's not even that good, considering that LR is an app catered to photographers.
260
I've begun to assume that public sector freedom of information and the right to data protection are not equally protected under the EU Charter of Fundamental Rights (GDPR goes first). Finnish constitution literally recognises both as equal so it took me a while to figure it out.
1
3
417
Finnish court (KHO): Burden of proof for GDPR violations is on the DPA. Accountability won't change it. Controller denied claims of unlawful collection. Fines were issued on the back of suspicion, not evidence. Court: Presumption of innocence applies. DPA didn't bring evidence.
2
5
10
1,419
The aftermath of EUCJ's Bundeskartellamt decision has made one thing clear for me. The privacy pro community by and large (and DPAs also) keep ignoring that 'contract' is a gamut of rights and obligations (incl. economic ones). It's a lot more than just a function or a service.
1
2
265
Q2 Monochrom firmware 5.0 broke the Fotos app on all of my Android devices (camera wont pair). I've been asking for help from @leica_camera for 2+ months. Each reply takes days and there's still no fix. I really wish a luxury brand claiming quality would commit to their software.
1
191
I'm confused. CJEU says contractual necessity is applied only to obligations "intented for the user". But art 6.1(b) talks about "a contract to which the data subject is a party". The Court doesn't explain how it limited its reading of the article. Contract is a two-way vehicle.
1
7
458
This (curia.europa.eu/jcms/upload/… / curia.europa.eu/juris/docume…) is nonsense to me, but not surprising: Continental Can (1973) broke the causal link between dominance and abuse (networklawreview.org/repeal-…). We logically end up with this poor decision. Next step: infringing the AI Act, the Data Act, etc., when in a dominant position, will be tantamount to violating Article 102.
2
8
15
4,469
CJEU says contractual necessity may work as legal basis assuming the "processing is objectively indispensable" to the "main subject matter of the contract". Question remains: Who's to determine what the "main subject matter" the contract consists of. That's contract law.
9
305
Something may be lost in translation but the DPA seems to say it doesn't have burden of proof on GDPR applying to IP addresses (i.e. whether they're personal data). I can't find basis for this in GDPR. If the authority claims GDPR applies the onus is on them to prove it, AFAIK.
2
176
I'm growing less interested in what the law says and increasingly interested in who gets to decide 1) what the law should say and 2) how it will be enforced. EU seems keen on creating a system where both 1 and 2 fall under the same authority. Not sure I'm conformable with that.
4
223
CJEU just said (C-579/21) that the right of access doesn't necessarily extend to other peoples' data (= who has been looking at your data). Whether it could, depends on case-by-case analysis. It's been a while since EUCJ put out a data protection ruling that emphasizes balancing.
2
6
355
Otto Lindholm retweeted
First Ford. Now GM. Both have teamed up with Tesla. Its charging network is quickly becoming the industry standard. Of course, it took a decade to get here. Here’s more on the journey… 🧵
84
488
52
5,751
4,670,374
Otto Lindholm retweeted
GPT jailbreak live on stage
36
395
53
4,026
473,280
Things that didn't exist last time the Toronto Maple Leafs won a playoff series: iPhone YouTube Instagram Twitter TikTok Snapchat  WhatsApp Twitch  Bitcoin Gmail iPad Etsy Reddit Netflix streaming Amazon Prime  Google Maps Spotify Shopify Airbnb Uber Pinterest  Chrome Messenger Oculus VR Dropbox DoorDash DraftKings ChatGPT Zoom AirPods Alexa Ethereum Fortnite Tesla Model S Disney+ Apple Watch Tinder Telegram Slack Bumble Canva Cameo Venmo Discord Dogecoin App Store Nest Lyft Peloton Square Chromebooks Apple Music
142
481
91
1,954
466,794
The term "data" is highly contextual. It's akin to a word like "object" in conventional markets. Without nuance, the term doesn't contribute much to furthering a well informed, holistic understanding of digital markets. "Data" can make debates vacuous and unproductive.
1
4
9
1,347
Both my Twitter and Instagram feeds are increasingly crowded with Midjourney-prompted stuff. My use case for AI would be to filter out all of this stuff. Is anything of that sort available?
5
513
Otto Lindholm retweeted
On this day in 1969: a 25-year old grad student published a document about ARPANET. He stayed up all night quietly writing it in a bathroom so he wouldn’t wake people up where he was staying. It helped pave the way for the Internet.
17
129
9
839
256,369
Today, the @Europarl_EN is debating the Data Act (europarl.europa.eu/doceo/doc…). My thoughts on the latest version of Article 30 (#smartcontracts). ➝ The immutability of smart contracts is key to their survival (i.e., immutability is their main differentiating feature). Article 30, as currently drafted, goes a step too far in addressing the issues raised by immutability. Instead of enacting "practical immutability" (where immutability remains the principle and alterability the exception, see papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.…), it makes alterability the principle. In doing so, it endangers smart contracts to an extent that no one can predict. ➝ There is no definition of what "smart contracts for data sharing" are. This is problematic because it could be argued that any smart contract by definition involves some form of data sharing. I would recommend a very narrow definition of what these smart contracts are. This would mitigate my first criticism. ➝ As currently drafted, Article 30 does not provide clarity as to who should be able to "terminate the continued execution of transactions". Is it the creator of the smart contract? Public authorities? Courts? If the EP wishes to proceed with Article 30, future versions should at least make it clear that only the creator of a smart contract can terminate it. @SLagodinsky @ibangarciadb @delcastillop @AdamBielan
11
34
8
66
11,638