Husband and sister of Savannah Tolbert disagree on the status of her mental health in the weeks leading up to her death. When speaking to police, David Tolbert told them Savannah had depression and anxiety. However, her sister told Anne-Marie Green, “What I observed from her was not depression. It was — she was scared.”

After her husband, Mike Harding, was found dead in an apparent murder, authorities wanted to search the home where Julie Harding was living. With a warrant in hand, armed deputies entered the Harding mansion and went room to room looking for clues. There was no one home, but the deputies found yellow Post-it notes that investigators say were handwritten by Julie when Mike was still alive. They read: “0 $ Here,” “0 $ here either,” and “Whatcha lookin 4?” #48Hours

On November 15, 2022, police cameras captured the moments after they discovered 37-year-old Savannah Tolbert shot dead in the front seat of a red Tesla. Even though security camera footage gave investigators a timeline of what happened, they still needed to determine how Savannah, who had a gunshot wound in the back of her head on the left side, was found holding a gun in her right hand. #48Hours

After Mike Harding went missing from his lakeside town in Tennessee, near the Kentucky border, his wife, a captain with the California Highway Patrol, began placing urgent and often “angry” phone calls to police. Then, when authorities approached her, she apologized for her behavior on the phone. #48Hours

Michael Harding lived in a mansion overlooking Dale Hollow Lake in Tennessee, in a house locals say was “cursed,” at the time of his disappearance. When they found him nearby in an abandoned house in Kentucky, it was clear Mike had been murdered. #48Hours

When Savannah Tolbert was found dead, her husband told police she had been dealing with some mental health issues. Prosecutors say "little minute details" were the reason they were able to dive deeper into a case that was now being looked at as a murder. #48Hours

Mike Harding's children, Steven and Heather, say that two weeks after their father's body was found, his wife, Julie, took Mike's beloved dog, Charlie, from the home of a friend who had been watching him. Julie’s stepson Steven says Julie knew he wanted the dog, but he has never seen Charlie again. A Ring doorbell camera captured the incident. The homeowner wanted to press charges against Julie, but at that point, detectives were focused on other potential charges against Julie. #48Hours

Michael and Julie Harding had been planning to live together in their mansion above Dale Hollow Lake in Celina, Tennessee, when Julie retired from her job with the California Highway Patrol. But that retirement dream never happened. In 2022, Mike was found murdered in nearby Kentucky, and months later, authorities found Julie dead on the lawn of the home many in the area believe is “cursed.” #48Hours

Savannah Tolbert was found dead inside a Tesla on Tuesday, November 15, 2022, at a small strip mall in Huntsville, Alabama. When investigators arrived at the scene, it appeared that Savannah had taken her own life. What cameras around the area saw gave investigators a more detailed timeline of her last moments. #48Hours

“The first thing that strikes you about Mitch Gaff is his voice,” journalist and author Tom Junod wrote about convicted rapist Mitchell Gaff in a 1995 article for GQ on the rehabilitation of sex offenders. "When he opens his thoughtful mouth, starts speaking in his thoughtful syllables, [Gaff] scares the living hell out of people." Gaff was questioned by detectives in 2024 after an undercover sting involving chewing gum. His soft-spoken demeanor that was written about decades before was still present — as he recalls how he attacked one of his victims.