
It is more honorable to walk in dignity than ride in humiliation - MLK Jr. Senior Director of Strategic Initiatives at @Jfederations. Opinions my own.
Joined May 2018
- Tweets4.4K
- Following397
- Followers422
- Likes13.5K
Alisa Bodner retweeted
#IsraelParade- Why NewYork Muslims must march in solidarity…
Israel is fighting wars on multiple fronts. Jewish communities around the world are experiencing fear, isolation, and growing hostility. This is precisely the moment when friendships matter most.
For the first time, Muslims will march in the Israel Day Parade in New York.
And we should.
Because peace is not built by standing apart. It is built by showing up.
At a time when the world is becoming more polarized, when antisemitism and hatred are rising, and when too many voices seek division, Muslims marching alongside Jewish communities sends a powerful message: we refuse hate, and we refuse separation.
Some political leaders have chosen not to march. That is their decision.
But leadership is not only about politics — it is about courage, bridge-building, and standing with communities in difficult times.
As Muslims, we can disagree on politics while still standing for humanity, coexistence, dialogue, and peace. Marching together does not erase Palestinian suffering, nor does it erase Jewish pain. It affirms that our futures are interconnected.
We will promote unity with our Jewish neighbors.
We will reject extremism and hatred.
And we will continue building relationships rooted in dignity, trust, and peace.
History is not changed by those who stay silent on the sidelines.
It is changed by those willing to walk together.
@LeoTerrellDOJ
@IsraelinNewYork
@CLARITyCoaltion
Alisa Bodner retweeted
People say the left and the right can’t agree on anything these days. But there is this one thing:
No Jews, No News
HBO Real Time May 15, 2026
Alisa Bodner retweeted
Eyal Waldman hired 20 engineers in Gaza, donated $360K to a Gaza hospital, and spent years building partnerships toward between Israeli and Palestinians.
Pro-Palestinian protesters screamed “murderer” at him in Venice this week. His daughter was killed at Nova on October 7.
Alisa Bodner retweeted
Lt. Col. (ret.) Geoffrey Corn and I document in our op-ed that Iran has, in the past three years alone, orchestrated over 200 attacks against U.S. military forces overseas. During the same period, Iran, as documented by the Biden and Trump justice departments, has attempted to assassinate on American soil President Donald Trump, former secretary of state Mike Pompeo, former national security adviser John Bolton, and Iranian-American women's rights activist Masih Alinejad. 3/6 washingtonpost.com/opinions/…
Alisa Bodner retweeted
NEW: In the past 24 hours, the Israeli Chief of Staff spoke with his Arab military counterparts across the region—another sign of the evolving defense architecture that first began to form following the Iranian attack back in April 2024.
Alisa Bodner retweeted
Israel and the United States of America are fighting side by side.
We will forever be grateful to the brave men and women of the United States armed forces who have made the ultimate sacrifice to make the world a safer place 🇺🇸
Alisa Bodner retweeted
I’ve watched Tucker Carlson debate “Christians in Israel” for weeks. Stop.
I am Israeli. I am Christian. Tucker argues these loyalties cannot coexist. He’s wrong.
While he’s talking, we’re growing. We build churches. We worship freely. We thrive.
As an Ambassador, I represent Israel’s sovereignty. As a Christian, I submit to the sovereignty of Christ.
My flag protects my faith. Narratives like his only endanger it.
Stay in the studio (or at the airport), Tucker.
We’ll stay in the Holy Land ☦️🇮🇱
Alisa Bodner retweeted
Starting a year ago, I have been repeatedly sharing this image that Al Jazeera itself captured of Hamas's terrorists emerging out of the al-Nasser Hospital in Khan Younis, southern Gaza, after the first ceasefire was announced when Trump first became president, pleading with journalists, humanitarian advocates and organizations, and political mediators to demand Hamas end its horrendous activities in medical facilities. It took over a year, thousands of dead, tortured, jailed and beaten Gazans at the al-Nasser Hospital for @MSF (Doctors Without Borders) to stop its operations there and publicly acknowledge that Hamas terror operatives are in the facility and endangering the sanctity of this critical medical installation. Shame on all who knew, and most NGOs have in fact known about this, but chose to remain silent, opting instead to just "keep the focus on Israel" for political and fundraising convenience.
Alisa Bodner retweeted
Replying to @shashj
Hi Shashank,
I am abroad (with glitchy internet) traveling for research, so I apologize for the brevity.
I do not think this is a good article to rely on. I was surprised it was published. It is poorly sourced, built on faulty logic, and repeatedly makes bold assertions without the data required to support them. Much of it is opinion presented as fact, and several key claims are contradicted by the historical record.
The core problem is that the piece leans heavily on death toll estimates, including those beyond the Hamas-run Gaza Health Ministry (such as Lancet-referenced figures), while failing to separate combatants (those participating in hostilities) from noncombatants. Yet it states as fact that a majority of those killed in Gaza are civilians and cites sources that do not support that claim. For example, the Guardian piece often referenced for an “83% civilian” rate explicitly acknowledges that it does not count unnamed combatants. That alone should disqualify it from being used as decisive evidence for a civilian majority claim.
From there, the author builds the rest of the article around the opinion that Israel does not take adequate civilian harm mitigation measures or accepts a collateral damage calculus that an American military would not. He tries to justify this by citing personal experience in two counterinsurgency battles, Fallujah and Mosul, but the comparison is weak and contextually mismatched. The scale and composition of the enemy (Hamas, PIJ, and other armed groups), the terrain and extensive tunnel system, pre-prepared defensive belts, IED density, the hostage situation, the intentional use of human shielding, and persistent rocket fire into Israeli cities create a fundamentally different operational environment. Those variables matter when assessing proportionality, feasible precautions, collateral damage estimates, and how commanders actually make targeting decisions.
I cannot speak to the author’s experiences in Ukraine or Iraq. I can say I have primary research and case study work that contradicts his analysis and key assertions. Through the Urban Warfare Project podcast, I have interviewed multiple Second Battle of Fallujah veterans, including an armor task force commander and a battalion fire support officer, whose experience contradicts the author’s framing. I have also coauthored detailed case studies on the First and Second Battles of Fallujah and the 2016–2017 Battle of Mosul.
The most telling problem is the article’s claim that Israeli strikes reflect a calculus U.S. doctrine would not permit, followed by examples like destroying residential towers to eliminate a single militant, bombing multi-family homes where civilians were likely present, and routine use of 1,000- and 2,000-pound munitions in dense urban blocks. Those things occurred in Iraq. In Mosul and other battles, entire buildings were destroyed to eliminate specific threats; there were tragic incidents where large numbers of civilians were killed in structures that were not known to be occupied; and 2,000-pound munitions were employed, including against hardened or militarized facilities. The author’s argument depends on an implied American restraint standard that is not supported by the historical record of urban warfare under the laws of armed conflict.
The one point the author gets right is that individual strikes and specific incidents must be examined on their merits. But that is precisely what the article does not appear to do. It reads like an argument constructed from selective anecdotes rather than primary research.
It also appears the author conducted no meaningful primary research on IDF targeting processes or civilian harm mitigation. No visits to Israel or Gaza. No engagement with those who design or implement collateral damage estimation, preplanned and dynamic targeting procedures, warnings, evacuations, protected civilian routes, or other mitigation measures that have been used throughout the war. He seems to dismiss my analysis despite my fieldwork, including multiple trips to Israel and repeated research visits into Gaza focused on IDF operations across echelons and commands.
You are right that there are other credible assessments. A number of senior, experienced retired military leaders and legal experts have traveled to Israel and examined these issues and reached conclusions that differ sharply from the author’s. Just a few examples include General (Ret.) Sir John McColl; Admiral (Ret.) José María Terán; General (Ret.) Vincenzo Camporini; Lt. Gen. (Ret.) David Deptula; Brig. Gen. (Ret.) Alain Lamballe; Brig. (Ret.) Ian Liles; Col. (Ret.) Richard Kemp; Lt. Col. (Ret.) Geoffrey Corn; Lt. Gen. (Ret.) H.R. McMaster; and General (Ret.) Mark Milley, among others.
General Milley’s comment is worth highlighting. When asked what the United States would do after an October 7-style attack on U.S. soil, his response was essentially, “Can you imagine what the United States would do?” That gets to the heart of the article’s most unrealistic premise: that the U.S. would have fought a fundamentally different war. The U.S. military would follow the law of armed conflict and take reasonable and feasible precautions to protect civilians. It would also apply overwhelming military power to accomplish the mission as rapidly as possible. Anyone arguing otherwise has to contend with both U.S. doctrine and U.S. practice in urban combat.
Much of the Gaza situation is unprecedented in scale and context. Hamas’s deliberate use of human shielding and coercion, the depth of terrain preparation including tunnels and IEDs, proximity to friendly civilian populations, the hostage reality, the trapped nature of the civilian population, sustained rocket fire into cities, and the intensity of the information war all combine in ways that do not map neatly onto Iraq comparisons.
Dr. Anthony King is a good friend. I would be surprised if he would argue that there are many wars, or even battles, that truly compare across the full set of variables.
Again, apologies for the brevity. A full deconstruction of the data gaps, logic failures, and historical errors would take more time than I have at the moment. But I would strongly recommend not relying on this piece as a factual foundation for claims about civilian casualty ratios, proportionality, or what U.S. commanders would or would not have done.
Alisa Bodner retweeted
🧵
Iran saying out loud what I’ve been told by U.S., Israeli, Qatari, and Iranian officials. Iran is digging in its heels over ballistic missiles, claiming they are for defensive purposes when they’ve been used offensively. They are badly misreading the U.S. and Israel again.
In this week's Torah portion B'shalach read by Jews around the globe, Moses carries the bones of Joseph from Egypt towards Israel in fulfillment of his brothers' oath not to leave him behind. On January 26, 2026, the @IDF fulfilled its oath to bring all the hostages back home.
40
Alisa Bodner retweeted
רן גאוילי ז״ל, אחרון החטופים הישראלים בעזה, חוזר לקבורה ראויה בישראל.
לדורי דורות, נזכור ונזכיר, את רני אשר קפץ מביתו ונלחם בחירוף נפש מול מחבלים בשביל להגן על קיבוץ עלומים.
בגבורתו הציל נפשות רבות.
התנועה הקיבוצית מחבקת אל ליבה את המשפחה, ומודה לחיילי צה"ל הגיבורים שהשיבו את רני הביתה.
יהי זכרו ברוך.
"First to enter. Last to return."
🇮🇱
Ran Gvili, the last hostage, is brought home after 843 days 💔
First to enter. Last to return.
Staff Sergeant Ran (Rani) Gvili from Meitar was a YASSAM Negev fighter in the Southern District of the Israel Police. Ran took great pride in being a police officer and wearing the blue uniform.
On the morning of October 7th, Ran was at home recovering from a motorcycle accident and suffering from a fractured shoulder. Upon learning of the terrorist infiltration, he immediately put on his uniform and went out to assist his fellow unit members in the fighting. On his way, he encountered terrorists and fought with courage and determination on the front line at the entrance to Kibbutz Alumim. Members of the kibbutz community later gave him the name “Ran, the Defender of Alumim.”
After several months, assessments concluded that following a fierce battle, and only after his ammunition had run out, Ran fell in combat and was abducted to Gaza.
Ran, with his broad shoulders and radiant smile, was all heart. A true friend, loved by everyone. He loved life, was a young man of deep values, always spoke at eye level, and carried a powerful yet calm presence. At 24 years old at the time of his death, Ran is survived by his parents, Talik and Itzik, his brother Omri, his sister Shira, and an extended family.
Ran Gvili was the last hostage 🎗️
The Hostages and Missing Families Forum bows its head in sorrow and shares in the profound grief of the Gvili family.
There are no words to express the depth of this pain.
22
Int. Law Prof. @JPTrachtman:
"Hamas’ strategy may be characterized as peak lawfare, & the result has been to cast extreme doubt on the legality of a legitimate defense by Israel against an attack that posed an existential genocidal threat to Israel..."
sites.duke.edu/lawfire/2026/…
28
Alisa Bodner retweeted
Joel Trachtman takes a hard look at Hamas’ “peak lawfare” and how it has been used to challenge the legality of Israel’s self-defense. His analysis gives readers a stark warning about what this trend means for the future of international humanitarian law: sites.duke.edu/lawfire/2026/…
Alisa Bodner retweeted
Hamas’ Peak Lawfare--A challenge to the integrity of the international legal system. sites.duke.edu/lawfire/2026/…
Alisa Bodner retweeted
"יש סרטון אחד שאני חושבת שכל אזרח במדינת ישראל צריך לראות. אני לא מכירה את אלכס מפחד, והם היו מפחדים על החיים שלהם - מאוד": מחבלי החמאס תיעדו את השישה שעות על גבי שעות מתחת לאדמה. ויש רגע אחד, מצמית - שמלווה את מיכל לובנוב, אשתו של אלכס, מאז צפתה בו. הנה הקטע מהכתבה ששידרנו הערב:
@netta_se
























