BeingIs (@Being_Is_IT) header
BeingIs (@Being_Is_IT) profile picture

Pointers for mature spiritual listeners in both English and Chinese.

Joined December 2022
Photo by BeingIs (@Being_Is_IT)Photo by BeingIs (@Being_Is_IT)Photo by BeingIs (@Being_Is_IT)
Fearless Facing 'death' in its eye is probably the fastest way to know yourself. No, I don't suggest that you contrive a death experience in order to experiment it. Any contrivance with a motive won't be effective. The so-called moment of 'death' will come sooner or later, no one can avid that, don't be afraid, look at it in its eyes and you know instantly that all is a joke. Many people fear this or fear that, when you realize that even the so-called 'death' is not something to be afraid of, and realizing that 'death' is not actually death, realizing that it's entirely not what you imagine it to be. Then, all your system of belief is collapsing like a sand castle. You don't need to wait till the moment of death, i.e., death bed, to realize nothing will die and nothing is what you hold it to be. You can realize it now while breathing, right at this moment immediately, nothing is what you think it is unconditionally. When you see fear, you are seeing the Mind's presumptions, you are seeing the illusions that the Mind is weaving. I don't suggest that you become reckless upon that realization, you should continue to follow the logic of the storyline. But following the logic of the storyline doesn't hamper you from realizing that the entire storyline is an illusion weaved by the Mind.
2
7
304
超越恐惧 直面“死亡”的眼睛,大概是明白你自己最快的途径。不,我并不是建议你去刻意制造一次死亡体验来做实验,任何刻意行为的效果都不好。所谓“死亡”的时刻迟早都会到来,没有人能避免,不要害怕,直视它的眼睛,你就会立刻明白,一切不过是一场笑话。很多人害怕这个、害怕那个,当你发现就连所谓的“死亡”也没什么可害怕的,发现“死亡”其实根本不是死亡,意识到它完全不是你想象中的那样时,你的整套信念系统就会像沙堡一样崩塌。 你不需要等到死亡的时刻、临终的那一刻,才去明白没有任何东西会死,也没有任何东西是你所认定的那样。你现在就可以明白,就在呼吸的当下,就在这一刻,立刻明白:没有任何东西是你所想的那样,无条件地不是你所认为的那样。当你看到恐惧时,你看到的是心智的预设,你看到的是心智正在编织的幻象。我并不是建议你在发现了之后变得鲁莽,你仍然应该继续遵循故事 线中的逻辑运行。但遵循故事线的逻辑,并不妨碍你明白到:整个故事线都是心智所编织的幻象,无需当真。
1
6
386
你唯一拥有的仅仅是感受而已 读者:如果那个“知道”并非大脑产生,而是某种超越个体的觉知,或者说“大我”的觉知,那么它是否仍然需要借助大脑,才能成为我们所理解的“知道”?如果不借助大脑,这种“知道”又如何存在? 我最终想请教先生的是:“知道”究竟也是一种体验,还是有某种比体验更根本的觉知?很期待先生从自身体验出发的理解。 BEINGIS:不要怪我吹毛求疵,上面的句子已经把大脑这个概念当成有一个实际存在的大脑了。不是这样的,就像梦里的大脑不实在存在一样,当下此刻你认为存在的大脑也不实在存在,不但当下此刻的大脑不实际存在,那个称为“我”的人也不实际存在,方便交流起见,我可以说只有感觉存在,感觉上看似有‘大脑’,感觉上看似有‘我’,感觉上看似有‘我的思想’。什么是这个感觉呢?无法说清,看似有无数多的感觉,但感觉到空间不等于有实在的空间存在,感觉到时间不等于表明有实际的时间这样的东西,感觉到‘大脑’或视觉中看到了‘脑袋瓜’不等于有实际的脑袋瓜这回事,感觉中看到的无数的众生不等于有实际存在的无数众生,感觉到的“死亡”不等于有实际的死亡,感觉到的“出世”不等于有实际的出世。你可以明显地感觉到所有这些感觉,但所感觉到的情况都是心智解释出来的,不是实在发生的情况。你可以享受这些感觉,却不要把这些感受当真了。就像你可以自由地感受到梦里发生的一切的同时, 不把所感受到的内容当成实际存在的情况一样。 视觉,是一种感受,听觉,也是一种感受,思想,也是一种感受,醒来,是一种感受,睡着,也是一种感受,时间和空间,当然仅仅是一种感受,你唯一可以说拥有的就是感受,感受,感受,一直感受下去,除了感受之外,你无法确定所感受到的情况是实在发生的情况。非常类似昨晚的梦境,你可以感受到梦里的一切,却无法确定梦里的一切到底是什么,到底在哪里,到底真的发生过没有,通通无法确定。当下此刻没有不同,所有你认为发生的,都无法确定发生,所有你认为存在的东西或情况,都无法确定存在。 注意或察觉就是品味所有的感受,却不把所感受到的情况当真。比如说,你可以注意到“失败的感受”,却不把“失败”当真了,你可以注意到“成功的感受”,却不把“成功”当真了,你可以感受到“时空”,却不把“时空”这样的感受当真。你可以感受到“大脑”,却不把“大脑”这回事当真了,所谓的“大脑”不实在是大脑,而是一种纯粹的感受而已。有人把感受说成是“觉知”或“意识”,好像这样说的话就高级一点了,其实是一样的,无论你给纯粹的感觉取什么FANCY的名字,纯粹的感觉仅仅是感觉而已。 哪天,你感受到了‘死亡’,这真的是某个‘我’死亡了吗? 开大玩笑了,从来没有‘我’出现过,哪里可能有属于‘我’的死亡呢?所以,感受到‘死亡’的那位没有死亡这回事。
1
2
16
595
All you have is sensation alone. Reader: If that “knowing” is not produced by the brain, but is instead some awareness that transcends the individual—or, we might say, the awareness of the “greater self”—does it still need to rely on the brain in order to become the “knowing” we understand? If it does not rely on the brain, how does this “knowing” exist? What I ultimately want to ask you is this: is “knowing” itself also an experience, or is there some awareness more fundamental than experience? I very much look forward to your understanding based on your own experience. BEINGIS: Don’t blame me for being nitpicky, but the sentence above already treats the concept of the brain as though there were an actual brain. That is not the case. Just as the brain in a dream does not actually exist, the brain you believe exists right now does not actually exist either. Not only does the brain right now not actually exist, but the person called “I” does not actually exist either. For the sake of convenience in communication, I can say that only sensation exists: it seems as though there is a “brain,” it seems as though there is an “I,” and it seems as though there are “my thoughts.” What are these sensations? It cannot be defined. There seem to be countless sensations, but sensing space does not mean that an actual space exists; sensing time does not mean that there is something called actual time; sensing a “brain” or seeing a “head” in vision does not mean that there is an actual head or brain; seeing countless sentient beings in sensation does not mean that countless sentient beings actually exist; sensing “death” does not mean that actual death occurs; and sensing “leaving the world” does not mean that one has actually left the world. You can clearly sense all of these sensations, but what is sensed is interpretations by the mind; it is not what actually happens. You can enjoy these sensations, but do not take them as real. It is like being able to freely feel everything that happens in a dream without taking what you feel as something that actually exists. Seeing is a sensation, hearing is also a sensation, thinking is also a sensation, waking up is a sensation, and sleeping is also a sensation. Time and space, of course, are merely sensations. The only thing you can say you have is sensation, sensation, sensation, sensation continuing on and on. Apart from sensation, you cannot be certain that what you sense is what actually happens. It is very much like last night’s dream: you can sense everything in the dream, yet you cannot be certain what any of it is, where any of it is, or whether any of it actually happened. You cannot be certain of any of it. Right now is no different. You cannot be certain that anything you think has happened has actually happened, and you cannot be certain that anything you think exists actually exists. Noticing or awareness means savoring all sensations without taking what is sensed as real. For example, you can notice the “sensation of failure” without taking “failure” as real; you can notice the “sensation of success” without taking “success” as real; you can sense “time and space” without taking the sensation of “time and space” as real. You can sense a “brain” without taking the “brain” as real. The so-called “brain” is not actually a brain, but merely a pure sensation. Some people give pure sensation a fancy name as “awareness” or "consciousness" as though that made it sound more elevated, but it is the same thing. Even if you give a fancy name, it's none other than just a pure sensation from You, yourself. One day, you sense “death.” Does this really mean that some “I” has died? What a joke. There has never been an “I,” so how could there be a death belonging to an “I”? Therefore, the one who senses “death” does not die.
1
6
233
There is no one here, nor is there a single person experiencing anything. Yet the mind explains it as “a person called I is experiencing this.” That is the basic joke This is the most basic joke: there is clearly no “person,” no “you,” no “I,” or “he” to be found here, yet the mind interprets it as though there were countless people, including one called “I,” along with so many others—“you, he, they.” There has clearly never been any such thing as space, yet the mind interprets it as though there were a vast space extending outward from the center called “I,” and an infinitely vast space at that. There is clearly no such thing as “time” here, yet the mind interprets it as though “time were passing,” with an infinite history behind and an endless future ahead, as though an “I” were progressing along a timeline. All of these are the same joke: these interpretations seem real, but they are actually illusions in which you fool yourself, or jokes you play on yourself for your own amusement. All these unreal things — “I, people, space, time, my life” — are the empty energetic impressions of your own SELF, or THAT, oscillating automatically. Your own actuality is not doing anything, but in terms of energetic sensations or energetic effects, it can seem as though you have become an “I,” become countless sentient beings, become an infinitely vast world and universe, become an infinitely fragmented situation. None of these are actual situations; they are merely apparent energetic impressions. Once you take your own energetic impressions seriously, it is like a cat seeing its own reflection in a mirror and taking that reflection seriously as a threat that is not itself, giving rise to fear, worry, and a need for protection. This is why taking energetic impressions (illusions) seriously produces apparent suffering. Note that this kind of suffering is not actual suffering, but apparent or seeming suffering. It seems just as serious as the suffering you dreamed of last night, yet it is completely empty, with no actual harm whatsoever.
4
1
13
411
这里根本没有一个人,也不是一个人在体验,心智却解释成这是“一个称为我的人在体验”,这就是笑话 这就是最基本的笑话,分明这里找不到任何“人”或“你”,或“我”,或“他”,心智却解释出看似有无数的人,其中有一个“我”这样的人,还有“你,他,他们”那么多人。分明从来没有空间这回事,心智却解释出看似有一个巨大的空间从“我”这个中心延展开来,而且是无限巨大的空间。分明这里没有“时间”这样东西,而心智却解释出有“时间在流逝”,前有无限的历史,后有无尽的未来,看似有一个“我”在时间线上发展。这些都是同一个笑话,也就是这些解释看似真实,其实是你自己忽悠你自己的幻觉,或者说是自我娱乐的玩笑。所有这些不实在的“我,人,空间,时间,我的生活”,是你自己(SELF)或(THAT)的空性的能量印象在自动震荡,你自己不实在在干什么事情,但是在能量感觉上却可以看似你自己变成了“我”,变成了无数众生,变成了无限巨大的世界宇宙,变成了无限分离的情况,这些都不是实在的情况,而是看似的能量印象。一旦你把你自己的能量印象当真了,就像一只猫在镜子中照见了自己的印象,把自己印象当真为不是自己的威胁而产生了害怕,担心,需要保护的感觉,这就是为什么把能量印象(幻觉)当真了就会产生看似的痛苦。注意,这样的痛苦不是实在的痛苦,而是看似的痛苦,就像昨晚梦里梦见的痛苦那样看似严重,却完全空性,完全没有实在的伤害性。
4
22
507
There has never been any such thing as disappearance. Reader: But what really confuses me is this: if someone finally attains enlightenment and directly realizes that all things are one, even the originally separate “self” disappears—then what exactly is that “knowing” at that point? Is it still an experience produced by the brain? Only this experience is different from ordinary “understanding”: it is more profound, and perhaps there is no longer even an “I” as a subject? BEINGIS: No, no “person” can attain enlightenment. Rather, one suddenly discovers that the very concept of “self” or "person" is an illusion, rather than some actually existing “self” or "person" disappearing. There has never been any actual creation or disappearance. From beginning to end, you begin to discover that all sorts of illusions are merely jokes you play on yourself. It is not that something (or someone) or some situation has disappeared, but that you discover those jokes were never actually real. “Knowing” does not mean “having acquired some new knowledge” at the mental level within experience. “Knowing” is more like realizing that “all mental knowing” is not actually real, unreal in the same way that the very concept of “mind” is not actually real. To take a simple example, when you suddenly wake up and realize that not a single detail of the dream you just had was actually real or actually happened, the shock is immense. “The brain”? Last night in your dream, you also seemingly dreamed that you were “a person,” and dreamed that “this person was thinking with a brain.” Now, can you still find that “me” you dreamed of? Can you still find “that me’s brain” or “that me’s head”? You cannot find them at all, as though none of it ever happened. What grounds do you have for being certain that you are not currently in some dream experience as well? What grounds do you have for thinking that the supposedly real “brain” is actually “the brain”? So the so-called “brain” is merely the mind’s interpretation or narrative. Apart from the situations the mind describes, they are not at all what the mind describes them as being, just as everything that happened in last night’s dream was not at all what the mind described it as being. “The brain” is part of the content of experience. Experience does not arise from “the brain.”
7
313
从来没有消失这回事 读者:但真正让我困惑的是:假如一个人最终开悟,直接体认到万物一体,甚至原本那个独立的“自我”也消失了,那么此时的那个“知道”,究竟是什么? 它是否仍然是大脑产生的一种体验?只不过这种体验与日常的“明白”不同,更加深刻,甚至不再有一个作为主体的“我”? BEINGIS:不,没有任何‘人’可以开悟。而是突然发现‘自我’这个概念本身是幻觉,而不是某个实际存在的‘自我’消失了。从来没有实在的创造或消失,至始至终,你开始发现各种各样的幻觉仅仅是自己对自己开的玩笑,这并非是什么东西或情况消失了,而是你发现了那些笑话从来不实在成立。 “知道”不是指在经验中的在心智层面“知道了某种新知识”。“知道”好像是明白了“心智上所有的知道”都不实在成立,连“心智”这个概念本身也不实在成立那样的不成立。换一个简单的例子,当你突然醒来明白了刚才梦见的梦情节里面没有一丁点的内容是实在成立的,实在发生的的那样,这种震撼是巨大的。 “大脑”?昨晚梦里你也看似梦见了你自己是“一个人”,梦见了“这个人在用大脑思考”,现在,你还找得到梦里梦见的“那个我”吗?还找得到“那个我的大脑”或“那个我的脑袋瓜”吗?完全找不到,就像丝毫没有发生过一样。凭什么你可以确定当下此刻不在某个梦经验之中?凭什么你认为实实在在的“大脑”就是“大脑”呢?所以,所谓的“大脑”即是心智的解释或叙述,除了是心智描述出来的那些情况,它们完全不是心智描述的那回事,就像昨晚梦里发生的一切完全彻底不是心智描述的那些回事一样。 “大脑”是经验内容的一部分,经验并非出自于“大脑”。
6
316
逐渐地,你有了这样一种奇怪的感觉,看似同时既不再陷入,又看似仍在陷入中。 读者:我有时觉得自己好蠢。感觉自己在勉强做所有事情:试图观察、质疑、试图理解。别人看起来那么轻松,而我即使知道心智并不真实存在,却仍不断陷入心智的叙事之中。 BeingIs:觉察(或注意)确实是毫不费力的。很高兴你此刻就发现了这一点。觉察并不是你在所有看似做出的决定之外的一种行为,它不是额外采取的一个明确动作。觉察也不是一种让你可以骄傲的成就。觉察更像是静默的见证,它完全自然、本自具足,并非你在经验之内刻意造作的动作或决定。这一点非常微妙,我无法把“觉察”描述成一个需要采取的动作。它更像是敏感度的提升。“陷入心的叙事”的情况在你自然地注意到它时,就是无害的了。这时你可以把“陷入心智叙事”视为一种纯粹如梦的体验,然后就可以轻松地耸耸肩,一笑置之。没有必要去停止“陷入心中”。不,你没有“停止”或“消灭”任何情况这样的任务。你所需要的只是觉察:觉察到“陷入心智叙述中”看似正在发生,是多么有趣,并发现这种看似的发生完全是空的、完全无害的;你可以毫无努力地觉察到“心智一直在担忧或不安”,并发现这种表象也完全是空性的、无害的。逐渐地,你看似可以同时既不再陷入,又看似仍在陷入。很奇怪,这两种矛盾的状况看似同步并进,而你却不再受困扰。 你的敏感度会自动加深。慢慢地,你会发现所谓的“心”(心智)其实并不是一个叫做“心”(心智)的东西。你并不真正知道心到底是什么,更不用说试图去停止它了。当你并不真正知道心是什么时,你也就不会知道“陷入心的叙述中”到底是什么了,你将不再评判“陷入心的叙述中”是负面的还是正面的,你所知道的只是你自己的存在性,你所知道的只是你自己的“如是”。那么,你还有什么需要在乎呢?
1
6
336
Gradually, you seems to be free of getting caught up while seemingly getting caught up simultaneously Reader: I feel so stupid sometimes. It feels like I’m forcing everything: trying to observe, questioning, trying to understand. It seems so effortless for others, but I keep getting caught up in the mind’s narrative, even knowing that the mind doesn’t actually exist. BeingIs: Noticing is indeed effortless. I am glad you find out right now. Noticing is not a well defined action you take in addition to all the decisions you seem to make in experience. Noticing is a sort of achievement you make so that you can be proud of yourself. Noticing is more like silent witnessing, it's completely natural and given, it's not a contrived action you take inside experience. This is very subtle, I cannot characterize 'noticing' as an action to take. It's more about sensitivity increase. "Getting caught up in the Mind's narrative" is harmless when you notice it naturally. Then you can take "getting caught up in the Mind" as a purely dream-like experience, then you are free to shrug it off and smile. There is no need to stop 'getting caught up in Mind'. No, you don't have such a task of 'stopping' anything. All you need is noticing, noticing how funny that 'getting caught up in Mind' appears to be happening, and realize such happening is completely empty and completely harmless, noticing that 'the Mind keep getting worried or upset', and realize that such appearance is completely empty and harmless. Gradually, you seems to be free of getting caught up while seemingly getting caught up. It's so weird that both contradictory situations seem to happen simultaneously, and you are no longer bothered. Your sensitivity will automatically deepen. Slowly, you will come to realize that the so-called 'Mind' is not actually a thing called Mind. You don't really know what Mind is, let alone trying to stop it. When you don't really know what Mind is, you will not know what 'getting caught up in Mind' is, and you will no longer be critical about whether or not 'getting caught up in Mind' is negative or positive, all you know is your own BEINGNESS, all you know is your own "Is-Ness". Then, what more do you care?
2
6
301
What should you do when you run out of money? Reader: I’d like to ask what your current view of money is. Of course, I know that nothing in the mind is real, but I still have a deep sense of lack around spending money and don’t dare spend it. I feel this affects my life and my fears. Once you understand this, how do you view money and how do you spend it? Do you see it as something that manifests in the moment, so you just buy whatever you want without worrying about your savings balance going down? Is that how it is? Thank you. BEINGIS: I have no opinion about the content of the story, just as I make no judgment about whether the story in a dream is right or wrong. If you have money, spend it; if you don’t, spend a little less. The body still has to function according to the logic of the story. What does that have to do with you? It’s just like the “having money” or “not having money” in last night’s dream—it has nothing to do with you. If you dream of worrying about running out of money, then earn a little more or spend a little less. The body will handle it automatically, just as your hand automatically pulls back when it touches fire. Everything in your experience is handled automatically. You yourself are not actually in the story; you merely notice (become aware of) these stories. Once you realize this, you can rest assured.
3
12
419
钱不够了怎么办? 读者:想请先生对于金钱观目前是什么看的呢? 当然我知道头脑的一切都不成立,我对于花钱还是很深的匮乏感,不敢花钱。我觉得这个会影响到我的生活跟恐惧。 明白之后会怎么看待金钱以及怎么花钱? 认为它是即时即刻的呈现,就想买什么就买什么,不用担心金钱存款的数字会减少,是这样吗?谢谢。 BEINGIS: 对于故事情节中的内容我没有看法,就像我对梦中的故事没有对或错的评判一样。有钱就花,没钱就省着点,身体还是需要按照故事内容的逻辑运行,和你有什么关系?就像昨晚梦中的‘有钱’或‘没钱’和你没有什么关系一样。梦中会梦见钱不够了的担心,那就做赚些,或少花些,身体会自动处理的,就像手碰到火会自动缩回那样,经验中的一切都会被自动处理的,你自己不实在在故事中,你自己仅仅注意到(察觉到)了这些故事,明白了这点你放心了。
7
288
明白(开悟)不像你认为的那么难 读者:我感觉自己现在正经历着一种实时的心智诠释,我在想这是不是开悟(realization)本身,或者它还能比仅仅觉察到心智的诠释更深入。 BeingIs:是的,正在觉察就是开悟。以前,你被心智的叙事所控制,仿佛心智所诠释的一切就是你的“现实”。现在,你的敏感度提高了,你能够超越心智的叙事,并注意到所谓“我的现实”其实是心智所诠释的,而非真正的现实。你开始从心智之外观察心智的运作。这种开悟会自动加深。当心智继续担心、恐惧、兴奋、不安……时,所有这些感觉都被你所觉察。然后你注意到,虽然心智可以持续担心、害怕、兴奋、不安……,但你实际上并没有被这些感觉消耗或奴役。这是一种无需停止心智执着的解脱。现在你进入了一种奇特的状态:你可以感受到担心的感觉的同时,却并非真的在担心;可以感受到恐惧的感觉的同时,却并非真的在害怕;可以感受到悲伤的感觉的同时,却并非真的在悲伤;可以感受到发怒的感觉的同时,却并非真的在发怒。这种状况对于心智的逻辑合理性来说无法想通的,不和逻辑的,但这正是开悟的味道,也是一种奇特的味道,它带给你终极的放松,同时无需消除任何担心、恐惧、不安、快乐等等在经验中感觉。
1
4
17
500