Case Green (@CaseGreen4) header
Case Green (@CaseGreen4) profile picture

“Green Man was good. It got me through some hard times”

Joined September 2020
god I hate RE+
2
8
744
the funny thing about the grid-protection-from-foreign-adversaries discourse is that you could pay 15 back woods gun nuts to shoot a few select MPTs and cause absolute mayhem
1
8
798
no need for the subterfuge and “back doors” into our infrastructure. you could probably task rabbit the entire job for $1,000
2
171
this is an under appreciated dynamic of energy policy and power market structure. all roads lead to the load meter - some of them just take the long way around.
I hate to break it to you but load always pays. It’s most efficient for it to be direct so consumers have maximum ability to manage those costs as they see fit
3
451
if you follow the line of reasoning for most of the discourse on both sides of this debate, you end up back at the question of how you should price carbon emissions, and if the cost is high enough to justify the challenging aspects of deploying lots of intermittent resources
“If solar and wind are the most affordable and fastest to build resources, why do they need tax credits?” A reporter asked me this fair question yesterday. Here's the steelman case, in my view: 1) Market failure correction: Social value of solar and wind (e.g. reduced fuel price volatility, CO2 emissions, air pollution) exceeds private market value; tax credits help internalize these public benefits 2) Offsetting non-price barriers: Solar and wind face significant non-price barriers (e.g. permitting delays, interconnection challenges, transmission constraints) that favor incumbent resources; tax credits help counterbalance 3) Energy security: Solar and wind don’t rely on globally traded fuels, providing insulation from potential actions of adversarial governments while enabling lower-cost fuel export to allies 4) Supporting rapid load growth: With electricity demand rising quickly, tax credits help scale up new generation faster and mitigate backsliding into higher-emission resources 5) Accelerating deployment: Even in regions where solar and wind are cost-competitive, the pace of market-driven adoption may not align with public objectives; tax incentives help close the gap 6) Offsetting tariff impacts: Tariffs have raised costs of a variety of input materials and grid equipment; tax credits help offset these added burdens and keep projects economically viable 7) Addressing uneven economics: While solar and wind are the most affordable new energy sources in many markets, this isn’t universally true, especially in regions with weaker RE resources 8) Consistent w/ historical precedent: Nearly all major energy sources in US history have received federal subsidies; supporting renewables continues that tradition in service of modern priorities
5
3
1
26
4,774
it’s not honestly about whether solar/wind are cheapest to deploy. in some spots of the country they are. in other parts of the country you need big subsidies (higher implied price on carbon)
1
8
420
but carbon pricing is off the table politically, so we’ve inserted subsidies and a whole new language surrounding pros/cons of renewables and IMO most of it is a giant smoke screen to avoid mentioning GW or carbon
9
386
I love how the right romanticizes coal - as if every movie about a coal town wasn’t about someone trying to escape because the jobs suck and everyone dies of black lung or mine collapse - and burning it isn’t an expensive way to cause respiratory disease and hasten global warming
12
3
1
52
3,571
If you want new generation, your only viable option over the next ~3 years is solar/wind/BESS based on timeline to procure/deploy other tech. A few implications: This bill doesn’t kill RE near term, it just makes it more expensive, that’ll mostly be carried by rate payers.
5
6
38
2,336
also if your thesis for eliminating ptc/itc is “eliminating grid instability from intermittent resources,” me thinks you’ll be disappointed
1
9
321
not to say this won’t eat into deployment. more expensive RE will delay retirement of some shitty old coal and natural gas projects, but load growth has already done a lot of the heavy lifting on that front
5
227
the most important credential for a right leaning expert: do they trigger the libs? please consider this as you try to drag the dude pushing shitty energy policy. your reactions raise his status, which I believe is the opposite of your intent
1
4
21
1,603
some thoughts from a solar dev: -most people overestimate the value of ptc/itc - it’s reasonable to say we should do without them from the perspective of industry only - BUT tax credits are a stand in for the correct free market solution to CO2 externalities = carbon tax (1/n)
4
11
2
91
15,418
- the industry has shifted their narrative away from climate scare tactics to a pro-industry stance (jobs! US energy! capital!) to try to capture mods/Rs who don’t give a shit about GW. turns out that didn’t work, potentially bc the “liberal hoax” die was cast long ago
1
2
14
1,122
- there were many naive onlookers who thought trump 2.0 wouldn’t be so bad for RE - needy load growth, he extended ptc/itc in his 1st term, R districts won big on IRA money, RE is now big capital/big industry -I was one of those onlookers. shame shame, green man is your name
2
1
15
897
The crazier thing about today’s youth is they think jimi is overrated and sloppy. no respect I tell ya
Six Electric Guitar Oddities (from a guitar owning non-musician hobbyist): A) During the 1970s (say before Van Halen's first album) there was a raging 3 way schoolyard battle/discussion over guitar supremacy. Hendrix vs Page vs Clapton. Jeff Beck was never mentioned to the best of my recollection. Everyone knew he was there, but he was not seen as remotely in the running. Today, I don't think this group of 3 makes sense to many. Even for the period. Were we just blinded and confused? B) I see guitarists today with solos that blow my mind. Regularly. None of them have a hit song. Many don't have a band. They seem to live on Instagram. C) Jam sessions have disappeared...like nearly completely disappeared...when top tier guitar heros get together socially. Even if there are guitars everywhere in the room. The only exception I've seen seems to be if the guitarists are somehow in the nostalgia camp of folk, blues and classic rock. D) Guitars have become somewhat rare in dorm rooms. E) Almost every electric guitarist I've met comments on the aesthetics of a guitar as the most consistent and reliable thing they will evaluate. Not the action. Not the pickups. Not the fretboard. Just the looks. And in no way self-consciously. F) We have likely never had better guitarists than we have right now...and basically they follow each other and go to each others shows. But very few people who are not musicians care at all what they have to 'say' with their instruments. This is very different from the 1970s when non-musicians cared a great deal. -------------- That is the perspective of a guitar lover who is not a serious musician. I would be curious to hear from my guitar following what they think I have wildly wrong. 🙏
325