Pinned Tweet
The question was unanswerable. They both knew it. Poilievre was the joke.
This Post is from a suspended account. Learn more
So where do cows get a dog to protect them from carnivore absolutists?
A chicken farmer saved a penguin colony in Australia with a sheepdog, after the experts had watched it fall from 600 birds to fewer than 10.
Middle Island sits a short wade off the town of Warrnambool in Victoria. In 2000 it had hundreds of little penguins, the smallest kind there is, about a foot tall. Then the sand shifted, the channel got shallow, and at low tide the foxes found they could walk across.
A fox in a colony kills far more than it eats. By 2005 a count found 4 birds.
There were surveys and meetings. Meanwhile a local man called Swampy Marsh was running free-range hens down the road and losing none of them, because since 1997 he had kept Maremmas. They are big white Italian dogs, bred for two thousand years to live with a flock and stand between it and the wolves. He said the answer was so obvious he could not believe nobody had thought of it.
It took a while to persuade the council. In November 2006 one of his dogs, Oddball, was put on the island for a four-week trial.
The killing stopped the day she arrived. Not one penguin has been lost to a fox with the dogs on duty. In 2017 bad tides kept them off for a spell and foxes took 140 birds in a few nights, which settled any remaining argument.
There are about 200 penguins on the island again.
The dog was bred by shepherds to guard whatever it grew up beside. It has never once asked what the flock was.
5
So a poor diet is a nutritional and health issue? Who'd have guessed. You really paint them into a corner when all you have to offer is steak.
Thailand's Buddhist monks eat less than anyone else in the country, fast for eighteen hours a day, and nearly half of them are obese.
The monks eat one or two meals a day, all of it before noon.
The monks eat nothing solid from midday until the following dawn.
The monks take in fewer calories than the average Thai.
The monks, by every rule in the diet book, should be the leanest 300,000 men in Asia.
The monks are 48% obese.
The monks have high cholesterol in 42% of cases and high blood pressure in 23%.
The monks are diabetic at a rate of one in ten, and some have lost toes to it.
The monks may not choose their food. They live on what the faithful put in the bowl, and it is a sin to refuse it.
The monks are allowed drinks in the afternoon, because a drink does not count as eating.
The faithful bring sweet tea, fruit juice, soda and energy drinks.
Fewer calories, fewer meals, a daily fast most people could never keep, and all of it was undone by a carton with a straw.
The researchers said they were baffled. The calories had added up perfectly.
4
The cow has no choice, stop with the games. One more time, you bred the cow to be a super milker so it's a necessity for her. If she doesn't then it's the slaughterhouse. What's her treat: a steak? Or seeds?
Activist: "You take her milk by force. Machines clamped on her twice a day whether she likes it or not."
Farmer: "Nobody takes her anywhere. See that box in the corner of the shed?"
Activist: "The metal thing."
Farmer: "That's the milking robot. The gate's open day and night. She walks in when she feels like it."
Activist: "And if she doesn't feel like it?"
Farmer: "Then she doesn't. Nobody's fetched a cow in this shed for six years."
Activist: "So how often does she actually go?"
Farmer: "Three times a day, on average. That black one's been five times since breakfast."
Activist: "Five?"
Farmer: "It turned her away three of them. It reads her collar. If she was milked an hour ago it opens the front gate and sends her off."
Activist: "Why would she keep going back?"
Farmer: "Her udder's full and there's a handful of cake in the trough."
Activist: "So you bribe her."
Farmer: "Do you get paid at your job?"
Activist: "That's different. I chose it."
Farmer: "There's a queue at that box at four in the morning. I'm in bed. Nobody's making them stand there."
Activist: "It's still her calf's milk."
Farmer: "She makes thirty-five litres a day. The calf takes eight. He's had his."
Activist: "I just don't think an animal can agree to something like that."
Farmer: "She's coming round again. It'll tell her no. You can explain exploitation to her while she waits."
10
Formerly ready sweeteners weren't commonly available. They weren't cheap. Honey and maybe something like plant sap or fruit sugars were used until we stepped up to corn syrup and sugar cane plantations. What don't we abuse?
Visitor: "Why is he making that noise?"
Guide: "He's calling the bird. A trill, then a grunt. His father taught him. It's used for nothing else."
Visitor: "Calling it to do what?"
Guide: "Take us to a bees' nest. There, in the tree. The small brown one shouting at us."
Visitor: "That's a wild bird?"
Guide: "Completely. Nobody feeds it or trains it. It finds a nest, then it goes and finds a person."
Visitor: "Why does it need a person?"
Guide: "The nest is inside a trunk and the bees would kill it. We've got an axe and smoke."
Visitor: "So it gets the honey."
Guide: "It doesn't want the honey. It wants the wax and the grubs. It's about the only bird alive that can digest wax."
Visitor: "You take the sugar and it takes the fat."
Guide: "The bird thinks it got the better half."
Visitor: "Does the call actually work?"
Guide: "Cambridge came out and tested it. With the call they found a nest three times as often."
Visitor: "How long has this been going on?"
Guide: "Nobody knows. Possibly since before we were this species. The bird needed something with fire."
Visitor: "Does it lead anything else? Honey badgers?"
Guide: "That's the story. Nobody has ever seen it. Just us."
Visitor: "And if nobody answers?"
Guide: "Further north people buy their sugar in a shop now. The birds there have stopped calling."
Visitor: "They gave up on us?"
Guide: "A wild animal spent a few hundred thousand years hiring us as its predator. We stopped turning up."
7
Living is complicated.
Attitudes aren't easily dismissed, mistakes will always be made, and determined contrarians live amongst us.
Society cooked up a temperance movement with alcohol the convenient scapegoat for much that ailed it. True or not, many profited.
For the best part of twenty years Rita Hayworth was written off as a drunk by her studio, the press and her doctors. She had Alzheimer's disease, and it had started in her forties.
She was the most desired woman of the 1940s. Her picture was taped inside the lockers of half the American army. Gilda made her the biggest star at Columbia.
Around 1960 she started losing her lines. Directors found she could not hold a page of script. By her last film, in 1972, the words had to be fed to her one sentence at a time. She had rages she could not explain afterwards. She accused friends of things that had not happened.
She did drink, and everybody knew it, so the drink was taken as the whole explanation.
In 1976 she got off a plane at Heathrow confused and dishevelled, and the photographs went round the world. The following year a California court declared her unable to manage her own affairs because of chronic alcoholism. She stopped drinking altogether, and she kept getting worse.
It was 1980 before a physician in New York gave it the right name. By then she no longer knew her daughter.
Medicine at the time held that Alzheimer's was a rare disease of the middle-aged. Ordinary decline in the old was just senility and needed no further thought. A beautiful woman who forgot things and shouted was assumed to have done it to herself.
Her daughter Yasmin cared for her until she died in 1987. Then she took the story public. The charity galas held in her mother's name have raised tens of millions for research, and it was Hayworth's case, more than any paper, that made the disease a household word.
In her lifetime it was thought to be vanishingly rare. It is now the leading cause of death in Britain.
She spent her last clear years being blamed for an illness that nobody had thought to look for. The rarity was in the textbooks. She had never been rare, and neither had the millions who were diagnosed once doctors started looking.
9
Carnivore Commandment # 5: Never forget that "they" are out to get you.
The grumpy carnivore is a worrier. lol
Your top teeth sit in front of your bottom teeth because of the fork.
Nearly every European skull older than about 250 years has the same bite. The front teeth meet edge to edge, like the blades of a pair of pincers. An American anthropologist, Loring Brace, spent decades measuring jaws and found the overbite arriving in Europe in the late 1700s, among the well off first, exactly when the knife and fork reached the table. Before that you clamped the meat in your front teeth and cut it off at the lips, and the tugging held the bite level all through childhood.
He checked it in China. There the overbite turns up about 900 years earlier, with the chopstick, when food started coming to the table already cut small.
Two continents, and on each the bite changed when the cutlery did. It takes one generation.
The rest of the jaw went the same way. Hunter-gatherer skulls have wide arches, straight rows, and room at the back for all four wisdom teeth. Crooked teeth are scarce in any graveyard before the Industrial Revolution. A jaw grows to the work it is given, and ours get porridge, pouches and sliced bread.
Even the language moved. Linguists showed in 2019 that the sounds F and V are only easy with an overbite, and are rare in the languages of people who still chew hard food. Much of the world could not comfortably say "fork" until it owned one.
About a third of British children are now judged to need braces, and Americans have some 10 million wisdom teeth pulled a year.
An entire profession straightens, by wire, a jaw that was only ever short of something to chew.
9
Carnivore absolutists won't be content until vegans are bred to produce fleece just as sheep were bred by carnivores to produce the fleece that's such a problem for them now. Or some such. It's confusing.
Wool is the most vegan thing in your wardrobe, and vegans have banned it.
A sheep does not moult. We bred that out thousands of years ago, and the fleece now grows until somebody takes it off. Leave it on and you get Shrek, a New Zealand merino who hid in a cave for six years and came out in 2004 under 27kg of wool, looking like a cloud with a face. Or Chris, found near Canberra in 2015 carrying 41kg and barely able to walk.
So once a year a sheep gets a haircut. It takes about two minutes. Nothing dies. She walks off several pounds lighter, looking faintly embarrassed, and starts on the next one. In Britain the fleece usually sells for less than the shearer charges, so the farmer is paying for the haircut out of concern for the client.
That is the cruelty.
The approved alternative is a fleece made of plastic. Polyester, acrylic and nylon are oil, drilled, refined and spun into thread, and they shed fibres by the hundred thousand in every wash. About a third of the microplastic going into the sea comes off somebody's clothes. A wool jumper buried in the garden is soil in a year or two. An acrylic one will see out the next ice age.
One fibre needs an oil rig. The other needs grass, rain and an animal that carries on with its day.
The objection is that the sheep cannot consent. True. It also cannot consent to flystrike, heatstroke, or rolling onto its back under the weight and dying there, which is what the unshorn version of freedom consists of.
Veganism has looked at an animal that needs a haircut and decided the kind thing would be for it never to have existed.
6
So Ethiopia is bursting at the seams because the gelada are everywhere? Be sure to carry a steak knife, eh. Grumpy carnivore just happens to have one for sale?
University debate: "If humans were meant to eat meat, we would have fangs."
Vegan: "Open a lion's mouth, then open your own. Daggers on one side, a row of piano keys on the other. Nature gives every meat-eater a set of knives in its face. She gave us none. The case closes itself."
Anthropologist: "Which land animal has the biggest fangs?"
Vegan: "A tiger."
Anthropologist: "A hippo. Half a metre. He eats grass."
Vegan: "One freak."
Anthropologist: "The gorilla has canines the length of your thumb and lives on stems. There's a monkey in Ethiopia, the gelada, with fangs like a leopard's. Nine tenths of his diet is lawn."
Vegan: "Then why grow them?"
Anthropologist: "To frighten other males. Fangs are for arguments. Dinner hardly comes into it."
Vegan: "So teeth prove nothing, and you've thrown out your own evidence."
Anthropologist: "Ours prove one thing. They shrank. About the time somebody in East Africa knocked a flake off a stone and found it went through hide."
Vegan: "A rock is not anatomy."
Anthropologist: "It was ours for 3 million years. We're the one predator that keeps its teeth in a drawer."
Vegan: "I don't own a steak knife."
Anthropologist: "Then you're the first ape in three million years to leave the house unarmed. I'd stay out of Ethiopia."
9
God is proclaimed to be all powerful. He can do anything.
Once upon a time nuns commonly warned their students not to ask questions like whether God can make a stone too heavy for Him to lift.
10
Avoiding accountability for religious claims is part of a way of life for the religious it seems.
I'm open to changing my position.
Prove two things and I will leave Christianity today, no hesitation:
1. That Jesus did not rise from the dead.
2. That the universe did not have a beginning.
If you can't prove those two, then stop asking me to abandon a risen Saviour for an eternal universe nobody can prove.
11
Bears have their reasons. We aren't bears. Duh.
The polar bear, the largest meat-eater on land, cannot live on lean meat.
When a bear kills a seal in a good season it peels back the skin and eats the blubber. Often it eats nothing else. The red meat is left on the ice for the foxes, the gulls and whichever young bear is following at a careful distance.
Measured in the wild, the diet comes out at about two parts fat to one of protein. When researchers gave zoo polar bears a free choice between blocks of pure lard and blocks of lean meat, the bears picked the same ratio, having never set foot on an ice floe.
For decades zoos had fed them as big white lions, on rations running two or three parts protein to one of fat. Zoo bears died young, and what killed them most often was their kidneys, with liver disease and cancer second. Over 600 wild bears have been examined for either and none had it.
A wild polar bear carries a cholesterol reading that would have a GP reaching for the phone, with no sign of the heart disease that number is supposed to bring.
The scientists put it in plain terms. A polar bear handles protein less like a cat and more like a primate. More like us.
So the great white carnivore turns out to be a fat-eater who gets ill on the meal plan printed on the side of a protein shake.
The only people who ever shared the ice with it ate the same way. They kept the blubber and the marrow and gave the lean to the dogs.
Everything that has lived well at the top of the world did it on fat, and threw the lean to whoever was following.
1
30
The grumpy carnivore always serves his raw milk with a hefty serving of baloney. He's just that considerate.
Public health notice: raw milk is extremely dangerous, and the following populations are to be considered at risk.
The French, who eat close to 200,000 tonnes of raw milk cheese a year. Roquefort has to be made from raw milk by law. So does proper Camembert. The outbreak has been running since about the year 1070.
The Swiss, whose Gruyère and Emmental are made from raw milk straight off the mountain.
The Italians. Parmesan cannot legally be made from anything else. Every wheel of it ever grated over a bowl of pasta began as unpasteurised milk in a copper vat.
Anyone who has eaten a cheeseboard in Europe.
Life expectancy in the affected countries currently stands at 83 or more. Authorities describe the situation as ongoing.
In several American states, meanwhile, a farmer can be raided by armed officers for selling a bottle of the same liquid to a neighbour who asked for it.
Members of the public who have consumed Parmesan are advised that it is too late.
10
The grumpy carnivore's discombobulation is itself enough reason to drink the almond milk. Usually his concern is the thirstiness of those poor almonds or maybe something about the bees they employ. Today it's Sunday, so it's about the church.
Almond milk is 800 years old, and it was invented as a punishment.
The medieval Church banned meat for about a third of the year. In the forty days of Lent it went further and banned milk, butter, cheese and eggs as well. For a peasant that meant six weeks of bread, pease and salt herring, and no argument.
For a lord it meant a problem for the cook. The great kitchens of Europe ran on cream and eggs, and the answer they found was to buy almonds by the sack from Spain and the Levant, at a price no labourer could have dreamed of, pound them in a mortar, steep them in water and strain off the white liquid. It looked like milk. It could be thickened like cream. Cooks set it into mock cheese, and poured it into blown eggshells with a saffron centre, so that His Grace could have an egg on Good Friday without having an egg. In one German cookbook of 1350 nearly a quarter of the recipes call for it.
Everybody understood what it was. It was the thing you put up with until Easter, when the real milk came back and the whole of Christendom fell on it. Nobody drank almond milk on Easter Monday. When the Reformation swept the fasts away, the stuff vanished from northern kitchens inside a generation, unmourned.
It has since returned, at twice the price of milk, with about 2% almond in it, the rest being water, gum and added vitamins to stand in for the ones milk has anyway.
The medieval nobleman drank it because the alternative was hellfire. The modern customer has no such excuse.
9


























