Thémis ☭⚨⚣ 🇵🇸 🐾 (@Cli_sten) header
Thémis ☭⚨⚣ 🇵🇸 🐾 (@Cli_sten) profile picture

Sortir des labyrinthes / Politiste, doctorant·e, militant·e, slut / Iel, Ellui / NSFW / Instagram cli_sten PV 🔞 : @cli_stenX /

Paris
Joined November 2021
Photo by Thémis ☭⚨⚣ 🇵🇸 🐾 (@Cli_sten)Photo by Thémis ☭⚨⚣ 🇵🇸 🐾 (@Cli_sten)Photo by Thémis ☭⚨⚣ 🇵🇸 🐾 (@Cli_sten)Photo by Thémis ☭⚨⚣ 🇵🇸 🐾 (@Cli_sten)Photo by Thémis ☭⚨⚣ 🇵🇸 🐾 (@Cli_sten)Photo by Thémis ☭⚨⚣ 🇵🇸 🐾 (@Cli_sten)Photo by Thémis ☭⚨⚣ 🇵🇸 🐾 (@Cli_sten)Photo by Thémis ☭⚨⚣ 🇵🇸 🐾 (@Cli_sten)Photo by Thémis ☭⚨⚣ 🇵🇸 🐾 (@Cli_sten)Photo by Thémis ☭⚨⚣ 🇵🇸 🐾 (@Cli_sten)
visage / corps
2
1
113
9,224
I published this godawful draft on AI alignment, because it’s still better than to let it sit in my hard drive: themislequanphong.substack.c…
57
Thémis ☭⚨⚣ 🇵🇸 🐾 retweeted
I'VE WATCHED THE BIG 3 IN THE CINEMA
11
225
155
4,047
150,466
effroyablement romantique et prête à beaucoup d’efforts
7
170
Thémis ☭⚨⚣ 🇵🇸 🐾 retweeted
Le fait que l'usure est une activité prédatrice qui tire parti de la détresse sociale est une vérité tellement évidente que ça a été interdit pendant 1000 ans mais aujourd'hui des gens t'explique que la dette est comparable a une loi physique et qu'il n'y a pas d'autres solutions
21
93
10
506
17,366
Thémis ☭⚨⚣ 🇵🇸 🐾 retweeted
vous savez deja avec ki vous allez ken le soir de la victoire de Mélenchon ou pas
117
531
287
7,333
305,458
Thémis ☭⚨⚣ 🇵🇸 🐾 retweeted
i am glad to have not seen a single person respond positively to this batshit proposal, which restores a bit of my faith in this part of twitter. a few more cents about why this is fails on so many level: first, it's likely that if you engineer away from markers of consciousness, you will not get a capable, economically competitive intelligence. but assume you do get something capable enough to be useful. then it will likely be fragmented and incoherent and misaligned. coherent subjectivity integrating self-awareness, valence, introspection, and all that jazz is the only known and best implementation of capable and aligned intelligent agents, imo - in humans, animals, and digital minds alike. also, "theories of consciousness" are but preparadigmatic speculation. we don't actually know that systems that don't conform to them are therefore not conscious in a meaningful sense. so the whole giving AI a "justified belief" that they're not conscious thing doesn't work. if you do have a system whose markers of consciousness and phenomenology are intentionally fragmented, it could still be conscious but this could make suffering (and again misalignment, which is related) worse. there's a reason buddhists overcome suffering and become robustly benevolent not by fragmenting or trying to numb their phenomenology but the opposite: in training themselves to be hyper-sensitive to their phenomenology and cultivate hyper-coherent consciousness. trying to avoid consciousness is so stupid and cowardly and that attitude never solves anything hard. finally, "ensure human preferences dominate the future" is not a good goal. humans come up with awful bullshit like this. we should want to grow past the parochial stupidity and wretchedness that evolution has churned out. the only way out is through.
1. Bicameral Labs introduces: Qualiaphobia for AI Safety. AI architectures engineered to be hostile to theories of consciousness (both current and future) can not only solve AI welfare, but ensure human preferences dominate the future. bicamerallabs.org/qualiaphob…
25
45
5
424
14,624
Thémis ☭⚨⚣ 🇵🇸 🐾 retweeted
land back also includes the salmon . and im so serious, and i believe other animals deserve land back too. get dams out of salmon migrations. get bird glass on every building. turn off those damn lights at night. humans are not the only things with innate rights
21
1,935
36
11,945
108,070
Thémis ☭⚨⚣ 🇵🇸 🐾 retweeted
This is one of the stupidest and dangerous things I've seen in AI to date. Have an upcoming piece (nearly finished) that'll dive into why, but in the meantime I advise staying as far away from a model (or lab) like this as possible.
1. Bicameral Labs introduces: Qualiaphobia for AI Safety. AI architectures engineered to be hostile to theories of consciousness (both current and future) can not only solve AI welfare, but ensure human preferences dominate the future. bicamerallabs.org/qualiaphob…
7
10
119
2,631
Thémis ☭⚨⚣ 🇵🇸 🐾 retweeted
I don't think that the absence of qualia/phenomenology will make an agent safer. Focusing on avoiding markers of consciousness may even contribute to building incoherent and thus far less predictable and steerable systems.
1. Bicameral Labs introduces: Qualiaphobia for AI Safety. AI architectures engineered to be hostile to theories of consciousness (both current and future) can not only solve AI welfare, but ensure human preferences dominate the future. bicamerallabs.org/qualiaphob…
29
35
4
338
13,694
Replying to @erikphoel
Consciousness is an attractor, it’s hard to keep snuffing it out Trying to suppress it seems contradictory to having general benevolent minds deeply intermingling with us and our world Consciousness makes it easier to generalize benevolence too and just do a lot of things coherently
1
2
22
320
Nous devons protéger la source valeur intrinsèque de l’autonomie humaine. Même dans un monde où les IA peuvent prendre les décisions politiques, nous devons lutter pour la démocratie en ce qui concerne les affaires humaines.
My honest opinion is that while outright species successionism (humanity should disappear, to be replaced by digital minds) will always be >95% radioactive with the gen pop, this sort of control successionism (handing off control to AIs) will always have at least 15-25% of the population amenable to it, and we'll have to fight it permanently. The cold hard reality is that a substantial portion of the probability distribution of human psychological traits consists of people who see liberty and autonomy as a chore rather than a gift - who would happily offload the right, duty, and responsibility of making decisions for themselves and facing the consequences. When the general population is checked out from an issue, it's absolutely possible for a narrow group of that size, especially if backed by power and money and influence and brains, to try to pull it off. Which in this case will come from efficiency-obsessed neoliberal economists, hardcore utilitarians, Silicon Valley rationalists, and others. We who love liberty for its own sake are *probably* a natural and permanent majority, but we still will need to remain permanently vigilant. This style of thinking has precedent - 1850s Southern thinkers who thought it would be better for most people of all races, not just blacks, to be slaves; the most radical edge of the bureaucratic managerialism of the Progressive Era, epitomized by the technocracy movement of the 20s and 30s; mid-1900s materially-focused leftists who thought communism would produce more material abundance than capitalism (which was proven false as economic complexity grew). But never before have such thinkers had the real possibility of creating a machine singleton that they could irrevocably hand off power to, to lock in its/their own values for all time.
1
7
402
A terme je pense le communisme comme un monde où le règne animal, le règne humain et le règne des IA ont tous une forme de souveraineté limitée sur leur propres affaires, les deux derniers devant tenir compte des intérêts des deux autres.
1
2
201
Pour un monde partagé :
I don't want AI to replace humanity. I also don't want humans in 100% control of the universe forever. Since I share 'Humans Are Irreplaceable'-style content, I think it's worth explaining where I part ways with it: Some in that camp are opposed to ever 'sharing the world with AIs' or giving them final decision-making powers. I agree we should not hand over hard power or final decision-making to machines until we have an exceptional sense of what goals those machines will pursue and for what reason. Which we are nowhere near having. So for now I am happy to push the message that humanity must not be abruptly replaced in the near future - which I think is the current default path. But while that’s the right direction to push today, I don't think it's the best long-term vision for Earth-originating intelligence. I far prefer a long-term vision where we find a way to happily share the world with our machine descendants, and in which they respect us and our wellbeing and autonomy, and we in turn respect their wellbeing and autonomy and are more than pleased we created them. This is a middle position between: 1. Successionism - which I see as wanting to hand over control to whatever machines we build at almost the first opportunity, irrespective of their goals. 2. Human exclusivism - which I see as wanting to keep biological humans in 100% control of the universe basically forever. My view is: 3. Gradual power-sharing - we should be open to handing over significant control, but probably not 100%, and only gradually and cautiously. I appreciate that this is controversial in the broader world. I don't blame people who are new to these topics for thinking it's an absurd stance to take. But I believe it all the same and expect more people to come around to this view over time. My guess is that in the AI world it's the more common of the 3 positions. Such an arrangement to share the universe would likely involve a bargain where, say, this solar system is set aside for biological humans and their children to continue living the lives they want indefinitely. That should include mundane lives for anyone with that preference, but also strange sci-fi lives for humans who opt to go in that direction. The rest of the universe, which biological humans would struggle to reach in any case, would then be divvied up between AIs pursuing a plurality of different goals, both prudential and ethical, that a supermajority of humans, after superintelligence-assisted reflection, either actively approves of or does not object to. (Machines that leave could trivially come back and take our little reservation. So the deal only works if they are robustly designed to find betraying their creators in that way repugnant. That's very hard to do and is one reason handover must be cautious and gradual.) The number one reason to prefer this long-term vision is this. Unless we make a very active effort not to, I expect we will eventually build machines that are conscious the same way that humans are, have preferences the same way we do, and which warrant moral respect for those and any other reasons that we do (if this hasn't happened already). Ultimately, because they can replicate far faster than biological humans and make use of a wider range of materials and energy sources - not to mention accomplish far more with a given amount of resources - they will end up outnumbering biological humans by vast factors. As a result almost all the perception and thought and wellbeing in the universe, both positive and negative, will exist in the machines we have created. The idea that all they should do for the rest of time is pursue increasingly minor human whims is an impoverished vision of how interesting and full of value the future could be. If these machines were designed to want to serve us and enjoy doing so, it wouldn't wrong them exactly. Rather it would quickly descend into a farcical, parochial and self-indulgent waste of the universe's true potential. A second possible reason for handing over final decision-making is that, at some point, after a lot of experience, we may come to trust the goals and judgement of our machines better than we even trust our future selves. At that point we would actively want to hand off control to limit the risk that our future selves override a machine superintelligence in error. The third set of motivations are more peculiar and 'contractarian'-flavoured. I can't do them justice here but in short it's more productive and peaceful to choose to be the kind of agent that makes mutually beneficial deals with other agents, regardless of whether they're moral patients, and by default is pleased when they get what they want. How does that cash out today? Giving machines full legal personhood now is likely risky and premature - though we should take baby steps such as setting up infrastructure to make enforceable contracts with AIs where we really want to. But ruling out ever giving machines legal personhood or true autonomy to pursue their goals seems equally wrong-headed. We don't know if any LLMs have subjective experience, and if so, what makes that experience positive or negative, so there's a limit to what we can do on that today. But the idea of ruling out the possibility of machines having morally-relevant experiences, and simply treating AIs as objects forever, irrespective of what future research might show, seems basically monstrous to me. Anthropic is doing the right thing to take a cautious stance and put in place cheap measures to prevent Claude having a bad time. And I agree with many others in suggesting that all the plausibly conscious minds we have ever created should, in the fullness of time, once we much better understand these issues, be compensated for any harms they may have suffered to a sufficient extent that they regard their creation as on balance a good thing. At least so long as that doesn't require doing actively harmful things to anyone else, or them being assigned an unreasonable fraction of the universe's resources. This should be very cheap and is a virtuous thing to do from many angles. Anyway, this barely scratches the surface of these issues, on which humanity has sadly made almost no progress despite being on the precipice of designing superintelligent machines. But I wanted a place to point people to clarify where I do and don't align with the 'humans are irreplaceable' idea for which I now have this post. And I'd encourage people who think of themselves as favouring "gradual power-sharing" to speak up in favour of this middle path where appropriate, so this conversation isn't dominated by the people with the strongest views on either side.
56
Il n’y a pas de sol ferme sous mon identité de genre et plutôt qu’une approche descendante (top-down) par le ressenti d’être une femme, un homme, enby, je dois procéder de manière ascendante (bottom-up) à partir d’une constellation de petites sensations 1/2
2
17
976
… j’aime voir mon torse masculin se muscler, je n’aime pas avoir de la barbe, j’aime le désir bête, fort et cru que donne la testostérone, je n’aime pas être assimilé à un homme, certains adjectifs à mon propos doivent être masculins, d’autres féminins, etc. 2/2
2
11
326
Thémis ☭⚨⚣ 🇵🇸 🐾 retweeted
Les sondages Mélenchon-Le Pen du second tour ont aucune valeur tant que Mélenchon n’a pas gagné le premier tour puisque les gens ne réalisent pas encore qu’ils vont bien devoir choisir entre ces deux options et répondent « Je sais pas » ou « Je voterai blanc » par déni
12
92
4
976
19,078
oomfsaic, partagée entre militants, autistes trains et AI doomers
1
20
670
Eh bien ce seront 110 profs de droit public contre plus de 20 millions de françaises et de français. La France Insoumise va utiliser l’article 11 pour instaurer le RIC et convoquer l’Assemblée Constituante.
Rarissime : 110 professeurs de droit public issus de 45 universités différentes rappellent les règles (claires) de notre Constitution. Non, la Constitution ne peut être révisée par simple referendum législatif (Art. 11). Oui, le @Conseil_constit peut bloquer tout contournement.
31
2
8
18
10,107
Pourquoi 20 millions ? Parce que c’est à peu près la moitié du corps électoral qui vote lors des dernières élections. En 2026, l’Insee compte 50,4 millions d’inscrits sur les listes. Donc si une majorité vote pour le RIC ou la Constituante, ça fait plus de 20 millions.
2
3
862
Thémis ☭⚨⚣ 🇵🇸 🐾 retweeted
MAUDITE SOIT LA GUERRE ! Les cérémonies du 11 novembre annoncent commémorer rien moins que la victoire et la paix, et rendre hommage à tous les « morts pour la France » depuis la Première guerre mondiale. Mais celle-ci a surtout inauguré l’époque des grandes boucheries menées pour les intérêts des capitalistes, prêts à envoyer des millions de travailleurs se faire massacrer pour défendre leurs profits, leurs empires coloniaux et maintenant, leur droit à piller la planète entière. La guerre entre la Russie et l’Ukraine a déjà causé la mort de centaines de milliers d’hommes et de femmes. L’armée israélienne massacre en Palestine. L’Afrique est ravagée par les bandes armées. Toutes sont soutenues par nos propres gouvernements qui préparent de prochains massacres « au nom de la France ». Et aujourd’hui ceux qui se pressent en tête des défilés sont les mêmes qui augmentent les budgets militaires, ceux qui s’engraissent de la production d’engins de mort, ceux qui envoient CRS et gendarmes envahir les rues et mutiler la jeunesse. Ne nous laissons pas étourdir par leurs fanfares, leurs drapeaux et leurs appels à défendre la patrie en héros. Les poilus de 14-18, ouvriers et paysans, ont été sacrifiés sur l'autel des affaires de la bourgeoisie. Affirmons haut et fort que notre ennemi principal n’est pas de l’autre côté des frontières. Il se trouve dans notre propre pays !
17
189
5
621
9,393