Dick Janssen (@DickJanssen7) header
Dick Janssen (@DickJanssen7) profile picture

Nieuws, wetenschap en buitenlucht. In bezit van toga, fietsen, kijker en een rode pen. Houdt niet van frames, dogma's en onzin. Toppers: Bach, Nansen, Crick.

Joined March 2021
Replying to @bob_deen
Trump en Poetin willen geen staakt het vuren maar een stabiel vredesakkoord. Poetin heeft een deel van zijn eisen al binnen (Hygseth): territoriale concessies, geen NAVO lidmaatschap voor Oekraïne. Als er nog wat bij komt, bv het opheffen sancties door de VS, kan Rusland instemmen met een tijdelijk staakt-het-vuren. Het is goed mogelijk dat Trump en Poetin in die periode een stabiel en duurzaam vredesakkoord sluiten. Rusland zal veel eisen ingewilligd krijgen, bv de Krim en Donbas worden definitief Russisch, geen troepen uit NAVO-landen in Oekraïne, geen VS-kruisraketten in Duitsland, en reductie van de  Amerikaanse militaire presentie in Oost-Europa, incl het sluiten raketschildbases in Polen en Roemenië. Met die concessies kan Rusland worden overgehaald in te stemmen met een vredesakkoord en zich er aan te houden. Dat is veel gunstiger dan hervatting of voortzetting vd strijd. Rusland kan Oekraïne niet verslaan, ondervindt heel veel schade vd oorlog, heeft geen belang bij uitbreiding vd oorlog naar andere Europese landen en kan flink gaan profiteren van normalisatie van diplomatieke en economische relaties met de VS. Ook neemt de gepercipeerde dreiging door de VS+NAVO af en blijft de strategische positie aan de Zwarte Zee behouden (voor wat het nog waard is). Voor Oekraïne is het gunstig dat de oorlog, die een groot humanitair, demografisch en economisch drama is, snel eindigt. Verder heeft Oekraïne niet veel keus. De VS zal net als met het staakt-het-vuren een vredesakkoord opleggen door (te dreigen met) het stoppen van militaire steun en inlichtingen, desnoods Starlink uitzetten. Tandenknarsend moet Oekraïne instemmen met wat de VS en Rusland afspreken. Neutraliteit, beperkt leger. Grondwet aanpassen. Mogelijk kan restant Oekraïne bij de EU, die dan de kosten van heropbouw betaalt. Samen met de mineralendeal verzacht dat de pijn vd zinloze oorlog enigzins. Wat resteert is een nationaal trauma. De VS onder Trump zit daar niet zo mee. Voor toeschouwer EU is het een complete afgang. Eerst meegegaan in de VS-neocon geïnspireerde NAVO- en EU-uitbreiding; een grote strategische blunder die normale economische relaties met Rusland heeft verziekt. Onvoldoende werk gemaakt vd uitvoering vd Minsk akkoorden en onder druk van Kallas niet onderhandeld met Poetin toen het heel urgent was. Later veel te lang vastgehouden aan loze slogans als "as long as it takes", terwijl evident was dat Oekraïne niet kon winnen. Zelfs nadat Trump duidelijk maakte de oorlog te willen stoppen heeft de EU geen eigen belangen ingebracht maar is afgeleid door discussies over vredestroepen (die er niet komen) en defensieuitgaven. Nordstream herstellen? Als de EU niet snel bij zinnen komt is Nordstream straks een Rusland-VS project. De VS profiteert van goede relaties met Rusland. Haaks daarop bewapenen de EU-landen zich ten koste van welvaart en sociale cohesie tegen een Rus die niet komt en die samen met de Yank op defensie bezuinigt. Trump heeft al 50% reductie met Poetin besproken en bepleit zelfs denuclearisatie. Door verkeerde geopolitieke ambities, foute strategische keuzes en propaganda die uitgroeide tot zelfmisleiding dreigt in het gunstigste geval de EU een irrelevante toeschouwer te worden. In het slechtste geval neemt de EU de proxyoorlog van de VS over nu die er zelf geen brood meer in ziet. De eerste reacties uit Brussel wijzen daar gelukkig niet op.
63
182
41
557
53,594
Dick Janssen retweeted
Replying to @ewaldeng
Destinus aan de Haaksbergerstraat in Hengelo dus. Komt op de hitlijst van de Russen. Heeft @DefensieMin bij Hengelo al Patriot luchtafweer laten plaatsen? Of heeft dat geen zin omdat Patriots toch geen Russische supersone ballistische raketten kunnen neerhalen? Bovendien is het ver van Den Haag.
1
5
228
Dick Janssen retweeted
The Crimean Bridge connecting Russian-occupied Crimea to Russia has collapsed after a Ukrainian Flamingo missile strike overnight on 17/11/26.’ kyivindependent.com/ukrainia… (also Ukraine strikes Crimean Bridge in record drone attack, Financial Times, 16/11/26 archive.ph/SJ30W#selection-1…)
3
1
1
152
De Kerch brug voor autoverkeer is verwoest door Oekraïense aanvallen. Auto's kunnen er niet meer overheen en schepen niet onderdoor. Een tactisch succes voor Oekraïne, maar is het strategisch hoopvol?? De Russische regering komt in spoedberaad bijeen, beweert de NOS. Als het klopt, wat zal het resultaat zijn voor de Russische aanpak? 1. Inbinden met hun maximalistische eisen? Toegeven aan een deel van de Oekraïense eisen? Aansturen op een compromis en een vredesakkoord? Of: 2. Brug repareren en verder escaleren. Verheviging van bombardementen op civiele doelen in Kiev en West-Oekraïne? Alle bruggen over de Dnjepr vernietigen? Treinverbindingen met Polen definitief verwoesten? Regeringscentrum in Kiev bombarderen? Bevolkingscentra aanvallen? Het kan allemaal nog veel erger worden. Gezien het grote strategische belang van de Krim voor Rusland en zijn militaire escalatiedominantie is 2 het meest waarschijnlijk. Dan zal opnieuw blijken dat militaire druk en escalatie Oekraïne niet kunnen redden en dat alleen een vredesakkoord met Rusland een uitweg biedt.
30
3
24
3,249
Arnaud Bertrand (een Fransman die naar China emigreerde en auteur is van talloze uitstekende berichten op X) over het sanctioneren van individuele burgers door de EU. Bankrekeningen van gesanctioneerde personen worden geblokkeerd (!), ze mogen niet reizen en het is anderen verboden hen betaald werk te laten doen. Dat is regelrecht in strijd met individuele vrijheden die in EU-regels en -besluiten zijn vastgelegd. Het sanctioneren verloopt zonder aanklacht, zonder enige vorm van proces, en dus zonder mogelijkheid van verweer. Het is een 21ste eeuwse vorm van middeleeuwse verbanning. De bewijslast wordt bij de gesanctioneerde persoon gelegd, die achteraf moet procederen. Je bent dus schuldig tenzij je er in geslaagd bent je onschuld in een Europese beroepsprocedure te bewijzen. Beroep bij de nationale rechter is onmogelijk. Arnaud besluit met de vraag: wil je dat Europa de erfgenaam is van Spinoza, of van Voltaire, of van Galileo, of van degenen die hen vervolgden? Dit optreden van de Brusselse bureaucratie, dat nota bene politiek gedekt wordt, is onverenigbaar met de democratische rechtsstaat, en is eerder aan de kaak gesteld door Europarlementariër Michael von der Schulenburg. michael-von-der-schulenburg.… Hieronder conclusies uit een kritisch rapport over de juridische aspecten van het EU sanctieregime. Prof. Ninon Colneric is voormalig rechter bij het Hof van Justitie van de Europese Unie.
By my own count, if one includes these latest sanctions, the EU has now sanctioned 8 European citizens for speech: - 3 German citizens: Alina Lipp, Thomas Röper and Hüseyin Doğru - 3 French citizens: Xavier Moreau, Adrien Bocquet and Sylvain Afoua (aka Egountchi Behanzin) - 1 Lithuanian citizen: Ernest Mackevičius - 1 Irish citizen: Chay Bowes The sanctions include freezing these people's assets and making it a crime for anyone in the EU to pay them, hire them or even lend them a single euro. They also include a travel ban, which leads to some absurd situations: Doğru - based in Germany - was invited by some members of the EU parliament to Brussels to plead his case but he couldn't go due to the travel ban. As one of the MEPs who invited him - and made 40 phone calls to try, unsuccessfully, to get him cleared to come - put it: "It really was like something out of a Kafka novel" (berliner-zeitung.de/article/…). And, probably worst of all, all of this was decided without any charge, trial or court ruling - simply as a unilateral decision of government ministers. Yesterday's sanctions, for instance, were decided at the Foreign Affairs Council meeting of EU Foreign Ministers and were simply signed by Kaja Kallas alone on behalf of the Council (eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-cont…). Put it all together, and this violates at least half a dozen of what the EU keeps saying are the fundamental values and principles it supposedly fights for: 1) Separation of powers: here we have government ministers - members of the executive branch of their countries - acting as prosecutor, judge and jury 2) Presumption of innocence (Article 48 of the EU’s own Charter of Fundamental Rights): they’re punished without guilt ever being established, and without being given a chance to plead their case before the decision 3) Right to a fair trial (Article 47): there was no trial at all, let alone a fair one 4) Freedom of expression and of the media (Article 11): they were sanctioned - explicitly so - for what they said and published. For instance, in these latest sanctions, Chay Bowes was sanctioned for, among other things, the speech crime of "participat[ing] in the spreading of anti-Western and anti-Ukraine disinformation at the UN Security Council" (eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-cont…). Sanctioned in part for a speech at the UN, a forum that exists precisely so that clashing views on international matters can be heard, quite the message to send from the EU... 5) Freedom of movement (Article 45): they're under a travel ban 6) Right to work and to property (Articles 15 and 17): their assets are frozen and nobody may employ or pay them You can think whatever you want about these 8 people. But ask yourself this: even if you are pro-Ukraine, pro-EU, anti-Russia and you view these people as malignant Russian operatives... what is the EU fighting for here, exactly? This is more profound than you may think: we're speaking about the very foundation of modern European civilization, built on the very idea that political power alone cannot decide what is true. I'm not exaggerating. What we’re witnessing is a return to the pre-Enlightenment playbook, when monarchic or religious authorities defined the truth, deviations from it were called heresy, and heretics were excommunicated - cut off from the community, so that no one could trade with them, employ them or help them. In Europe's darkest times, heretics were even famously burned at the stake - like Joan of Arc or Giordano Bruno. It took literal centuries of religious wars and debates, and the likes of Voltaire, Kant and Mill, to replace it with a basic idea: that no single power, however legitimate, gets to be the final judge of what is true, and that you answer for your words only before a court, under laws written via a process separate from the power that does the accusation. You can find countless works of European literature on this very matter. Take Spinoza, excommunicated in 1656 by the Portuguese-Jewish community of Amsterdam, with a decree ordering that "no one should communicate with him" nor "accord him any favor". He went on to write the Theological-Political Treatise, one of the founding texts of the Enlightenment, with an entire chapter arguing that "in a free state every man may think what he likes, and say what he thinks." Or Mill, two centuries later in On Liberty, Chapter 2: "All silencing of discussion is an assumption of infallibility." Or Kafka’s The Trial, the story of a man accused by an authority nobody can quite locate, of something nobody will explain. How is what Europe is presently doing anything other than going back to that very system, under new appellations? The authority: government ministers. The heresy: "disinformation". The excommunication: assets frozen, banned from travelling and nobody may pay them, hire them or lend them a single euro. It’s basically Spinoza’s excommunication decree on EU letterhead, with a bit of Kafka sprinkled in given that the man invited to the European Parliament to contest his punishment couldn’t attend because of the very punishment he wanted to contest. You don’t have to like these 8 people, or even care about them, to see the problem. Heck, this system was developed precisely for the people nobody likes: consensual ideas never needed protecting. No, the real question here is this: do you want Europe to be the heir of Spinoza - or of Voltaire, or of Galileo, or of any of the countless Europeans who suffered or even died for thinking differently - or of their persecutors?
13
205
15
489
15,048
De EU voert steeds hardere censuur-politiek tegen intellectuelen en journalisten, een standaard-kenmerk van een autoritair regime. Zij kunnen - itt de principes van een rechtsstaat - niet naar de rechter om deze kneveling door de overheid. Hier een kleine, niet complete lijst:
Today the authoritarian EU sanctioned me, no recourse to defend myself, no hearing, no evidence. They want to bully me into silence, they want to deny you your God-given right to hear dissenting opinions, they want to kill freedom of speech. Their allegations against me are utterly baseless, their insinuations are false, they are terrified of the Truth I will fight this assault on our right to dissent with every fibre of my being, I will not be silenced, I will not take the knee for the enemies of free thought, reason and Democracy
29
75
8
161
7,302
Dick Janssen retweeted
Aanstaande donderdag spreek ik samen met Gerrie Elfrink van de SP over oorlog, vrede en militarisering op het Vredescafe Velp. Zie poster voor meer details. Tot donderdag! Ewald
1
4
16
1,718
Hoogleraar Nollkaemper: vanuit Internationaal Recht gezien zou EU/Kallas zich minder star moeten opstellen, bv ook Russische veiligheidsbelangen moeten bespreekbaar zijn. Vasthouden aan "niet-onderhandelbare standpunten" maakt de EU medeverantwoordelijk voor nieuwe oorlogsdoden.
30
17
2
40
7,915
Een effective manier waarop neocon VS en incompetent Europa er voor kunnen zorgen dat de oorlog in Oekraïne voorlopig doorgaat is te eisen dat de Russen eerst instemmen met een staakt-het-vuren en pas daarna bereid te zijn tot onderhandelingen over een vredesakkoord. Bovendien: een veiligheidsorde die beter is dan afschrikking door een zich onbeperkt uitbreidende NAVO is dringend nodig. De oorlog in Oekraïne met honderdduizenden doden laat zien dat die orde niet werkt.
This sequence by @kajakallas is absolutely right: (1) ceasefire, (2) peace agreement, (3) broader European security architecture. If Putin can't even get No. 1 done, no one should believe he can negotiate sincerely on No. 3.
2
5
497
Dick Janssen retweeted
Replying to @djbelgrado
De dioxinevergiftiging van Joesjtsjenko vond plaats in 2004. Maar het gevecht tussen de VS en Rusland om Oekraïne begon al veel eerder. Vanaf 1949 was de CIA in Oekraïne actief met Project Aerodynamic. Het doel was in Oekraïne een gewapende strijd tegen de Sovjet Unie (later Rusland) aan te moedigen. Lees "Boiling Point" van voormalig oorlogsverslaggever Stephen Kinzer.
2
1
5
245
Mr. Merz, Germany was wrong about mass migration, it was wrong about nuclear energy, and now you are wrong again about financing the war!
1,790
8,306
509
31,782
528,317
This viral thread is highly selective. Mr Daalder correctly cites the (1990 Charter of Paris) right of European states to choose their own alliances, but neglects the equally explicit 1999 OSCE Charter for European Security principle that no country should strengthen its security at another's expense. Russia was included in a number of European security discussions, but NATO retained exclusive control over its expansion and military decisions (Moscow was offered consultation, but not meaningful influence). Presenting the collapse of Europe's post-Cold War security order as entirely Moscow's doing is a rather convenient rewriting of history, particularly from a former US ambassador to NATO, who one assumes knows all of the above.
Thank you, Mr. Kushner. Those five principles are important. However, Moscow subscribed to these principles in documents signed in 1975 (Helsinki Final Act) and 1990 (Charter of Paris). The problem isn't agreeing to principles, but Moscow's failure to abide by them. 🧵 /1
16
10
83
4,213
Dick Janssen retweeted
Those who claim Russia wants to “destroy the West” are the people most likely to incite WW3 and destroy Europe for a third time. For some insane reason, they want to turn a proxy war between Moscow and Washington for control of Ukraine’s people and resources into a continental conflict. By driving all countries on Russia’s western border to join the US nuclear threat, one is kicking the bear, and at some point, the bear lashes out. The list of renowned western scholars of history and geopolitics who have warned about this in the past is extensive. There is no surprise here. Russia’s reaction in Ukraine was expected and the circumstances were created for that reaction to materialise. Estonia, Latvia and Lithuanian joined in 2004, and then Finland (2023) and Sweden (2024), but that wasn’t enough. They also want Ukraine—a country where half the people speak Russian and have traditionally voted for Moscow-aligned candidates. While sitting far away in the safety of your London townhouse or Washington mansion, you can work for peace in Europe, encourage trade, fund scientific exchange and organise sporting events with Russia. Or you can do the evil and immoral opposite: incite ethnic hatred in faraway lands, encourage discrimination based on what language one learnt as a child, arm and embolden neo-nazis, actively work to make sure peace negotiations fail in order to endlessly funnel billions of deadly weapons into a fragile region, ensuring that cities are blown to dust, families and businesses are eradicated, public infrastructure is destroyed, and millions of children across Eastern Europe can never again be held and protected by their fathers. This monstrous strategy—no doubt dreamt up by fools drinking bourbon by a log fire in a Vermont lodge—identified Ukraine as the next country to flip, and be under no illusions, they don’t care how many people die, or how much money is stolen by corrupt officials, or how many billions of their own taxpayers’ money is diverted to the war lobby, away from much-needed investments in infrastructure, eduction, or healthcare in Cleveland, Baltimore or Detroit. Remember what Victoria Nuland said as she started moving her chess pieces around the board at the start of this diabolical shitshow? “Fuck the EU”. That’s 500 millions lives she was talking about. This is what being dangerously drunk on power sounds like. They make some people very rich, while their power and status grants them the right to play board games with millions of people’s lives, and when things go very badly wrong—as they have done in Ukraine—and and they usually do—they have an army of “experts” and “journalists” who flood the airwaves and newspapers to defend their evil and incompetent efforts and instead tell us that it is Russia that is trying “to destroy the West”. They are sadly working from a position of such military, intelligence, funding and propaganda superiority that no another narrative gets much light in Western counties like Britain. The debate is neutered, while they march the European continent back towards World War. And one thing you can be certain of, they’ll be on the first plane out with their families when the tanks start rolling across the Flemish or polish flatlands again, or swarms of thousands of drones race across the channel on their way to London. Deescalation is what is needed. The war profiteers must be sidelined. As must be the Nulands of this world who want to “win” the “board game” they have laid out on their big desk in the pentagon. They have all the most deadly toys at their disposal, and they’re desperate to use them. They’ll claim it was for a higher ideal, but it’s all about ego and power—the worst of our human cruches—and in their eyes, be damned the millions of casualties.
“Russia wants to destroy the West.” Matthew Syed of the Sunday Times warns we’re “tilting towards war” because of Russian hybrid warfare efforts in Europe. #Newsnight
44
114
5
323
10,230
Remarkable statements on Dutch TV by NATO Secretary General Mark Rutte about the war in Ukraine: 1. Rutte stated that it is unlikely that Ukraine will retake all its lost territory, and that a future peace agreement will probably be a compromise. It is up to Zelensky and his government to decide whether that is acceptable. → The conclusion that a compromise - and thus concessions - cannot be avoided if a peace agreement is to be reached should have been accepted and communicated much earlier. This could have prevented many of the 2 million casualties. A "just" peace is now unrealistic, since a defeat of the Russian military is highly unlikely.
59
82
12
185
36,186
2. Rutte also stated that if the war in Ukraine ends, the risk of a Russian attack on European countries increases, while Europe's defenses are still being built up. → This is a bizarre statement, since the current increasingly hostile and dangerous situation between EU and NATO countries, including hybrid warfare, is due to the war over Ukraine. The statement suggests an unwillingness to normalize relations with Russia after a peace agreement is reached. If the current US policy is continued, it could imply that the US and Russia develop profitable economic relations, while Europe continues to have a conflict with Russia. In practice, it could even mean that Russian Nord Stream gas is delivered to Europe via the US.
5
14
36
2,093
Topics not discussed: → The origins of the war and their consequences for the elements of a possible peace agreement → If and how the current NATO strategy promotes a scenario that leads to peace in Ukraine. As always, Rutte was in a good mood, smiled a lot, and stated that he will get drunk with Zelensky on the top of a mountain once the war is over.
6
6
21
1,465
Dick Janssen retweeted
No, I'm not suggesting limits on anyone's sovereignty. Countries have a right to decide which alliances they would like to join & alliance members have a right to decide which countries they can/should accept & how they should allocate resources to best prevent war & protect national interests. In any case, even NATO membership does not entitle any country to deployment of foreign forces or NATO assets.
All Central and Eastern European and Nordic countries joined NATO because of the threat coming from Russia. Not the other way round. Kavanagh is suggesting limiting independent countries’ sovereignty to appease Russia.
13
8
44
3,535
Dick Janssen retweeted
37 bodies have been recovered, 59 people are still missing, and up to 38 may remain trapped under the rubble following the Russian airstrike on Komyshuvakha, Zaporizhzhia region. These numbers are unbearable. The video shows people walking down into the shelter while they are still alive, moments before Russian forces deliberately targeted it with massive three-ton aerial bombs. Every Monday, this underground shelter became the center of this small town. People went there for humanitarian aid, food, documents, and basic assistance. It is located just 20 km from the front line. This bloodshed must end. Real negotiations are the only way to stop the killing of civilians.
55
38
7
181
18,970