Disputing Sunnah (@DisputingSunnah) header
Disputing Sunnah (@DisputingSunnah) profile picture

Rebuking 'Sunnah' with Sunnah. Enjoyer of Islamic History and Discussions.

Joined November 2022
Photo by Disputing Sunnah (@DisputingSunnah)Photo by Disputing Sunnah (@DisputingSunnah)Photo by Disputing Sunnah (@DisputingSunnah)Photo by Disputing Sunnah (@DisputingSunnah)Photo by Disputing Sunnah (@DisputingSunnah)Photo by Disputing Sunnah (@DisputingSunnah)Photo by Disputing Sunnah (@DisputingSunnah)Photo by Disputing Sunnah (@DisputingSunnah)Photo by Disputing Sunnah (@DisputingSunnah)Photo by Disputing Sunnah (@DisputingSunnah)
Disputing Sunnah retweeted
Bismillah al-Rahman al-Rahim I am pleased to announce the publication of my first podcast on YouTube, titled “Syrian War, Iraqi Insurgency, Abu Musab al-Zarqawi & The Reasons Behind Iran’s Intervention.” In this podcast, I draw on material from my book to examine Iran’s intervention in Syria, the Syrian insurgency’s ideological ties to Iraqi Zarqawism, and the historical roots of the war’s sectarian dimension. I also analyze the political rationale behind Iran’s intervention through the lens of neorealism. Drawing on a range of historical sources and data, I explore the ideological foundations of the early Syrian insurgency and construct a historical timeline to shed light on the origins and development of the conflict’s sectarian dimension. For privacy reasons, I have used audio-engineering techniques to alter my voice in this episode and will continue to do so in my podcasts over the next five months. Unfortunately, this has somewhat affected the audio quality and distorted the pronunciation of certain words. I apologize for these shortcomings and appreciate your understanding. After this five-month period, I intend to reveal my identity and record podcasts using my natural voice. You can see the video by using this link: youtube.com/watch?v=U4Q1QGi-…
I am going to record my first podcast about the Iranian intervention in Syria, its political rationale through the neorealism lens, the Syrian insurgency’s ideological ties to Iraqi Zarqawism, and the roots of the sectarian dimension of the war. Before that, I must add a few points. Iran’s relationship with Assad was purely political, and Iranian intervention in Syria was necessary to prevent Israeli hegemony. Otherwise, as I previously posted in one American report, Assad even bombed Hezbollah during the 1980s, had no interest in seeing a Shia theocracy in Lebanon, Iranian official political discourse until a few decades ago used to call them the “Baathist regime,” and most importantly, Imam Khomeini never let Hafez set foot in Iran because of his anti-Islamist policies and the Hamas massacre. However, politics doesn’t operate based on idealism; it’s almost always a pick between the lesser evil. We had and have no love for Baathist ideology, but Assad was the Berlin Wall of this region, and when it fell the whole region fell and the Palestinian cause died with it. In this scenario, the intervention was not just necessary but even Islamically justified, given there is nothing more evil than Israel and its hegemony. When the enemy started chanting against Iran and Hezbollah from the second week of the protests unprovoked, something that came from the Zarqawism of Iran and that I listed the evidence for in chapter 7 of my book, we were left with no option but to support the Berlin Wall against the demons of Zionism. No one thought Bashar was an angel, but given that “Dr” Rahmeh says “Alhamdullah” Assad is gone, she is supporting the Israeli project without any concerns for the subsequent Israeli imperialism. That is the issue. Else, I agree with brother Ahmad (propaganda & Co.) here.
26
49
3
186
8,011
Disputing Sunnah retweeted
Imam ʿAlī said something very similar ages ago: "Indeed, the beasts are preoccupied with their bellies; the predatory animals are preoccupied with aggression against others; and women are preoccupied with the adornments of worldly life and corruption therein. Indeed, the believers are humble; indeed, the believers are compassionate and apprehensive; indeed, the believers are fearful." اعْقِلْ ذَلِكَ فَإِنَّ الْمَثَلَ دَلِيلٌ عَلَى شِبْهِهِ. إِنَّ الْبَهَائِمَ هَمُّهَا بُطُونُهَا، وَإِنَّ السِّبَاعَ هَمُّهَا الْعُدْوَانُ عَلَى غَيْرِهَا، وَإِنَّ النِّسَاءَ هَمُّهُنَّ زِينَةُ الْحَيَاةِ الدُّنْيَا وَالْفَسَادُ فِيهَا. إِنَّ الْمُؤْمِنِينَ مُسْتَكِينُونَ، إِنَّ الْمُؤْمِنِينَ مُشْفِقُونَ، إِنَّ الْمُؤْمِنِينَ خَائِفُونَ.
Replying to @CarlPaulus
Cows are herd animals, Wolves are pack animals, but humans are the one and only societal animals. Therefore, societies are biologically in conflict with each other and compete. Women (and to a lesser extent, men), therefore, must contain an underlying biological imperative to destroy any society that does not prioritize their reproduction, as reproduction, for the vast majority of human existence, is the only metric for societal success.
1
1
18
1,021
Disputing Sunnah retweeted
JUST IN: CLASHES ERUPT IN BAHRAIN OVER ARRESTS OF SHIITE RELIGIOUS FIGURES
12
264
3
1,268
27,953
Disputing Sunnah retweeted
📜 Rational Necessity and Textual Endorsement: The Rational and Narrational Proofs on Taqlid Full document: drive.google.com/file/d/1CnY… Abridged version: drive.google.com/file/d/1lXq…
1
4
6
254
Disputing Sunnah retweeted
I am happy to report that I have successfully developed an AI-assisted (largely) accurate ICMA workflow that can now do majority of the work. That mean, using it, we can now find out the true CLs of any particular Hadith. The workflow can generate such diagrams:
24
32
7
226
10,721
Disputing Sunnah retweeted
Some animals have more humanity than the people claiming to speak for God.
8
32
2
193
8,844
Disputing Sunnah retweeted
I’ve seen a lot in my days as a war observer but Houthi fighters free soloing a cliff to ambush PLC fighters is wild.
321
1,948
193
11,899
837,891
Disputing Sunnah retweeted
Shia Lebanese man poetry at the sight of Israeli shelling: "A day will come when we will see our Mahdi, Leaning against the wall of the Ka'aba Roaring with his Haydari voice, 'O people of the world! I am the Imam Al Qa'im (the one who stands up) O people of the world! I am the avenging sword` O you who seek vengence for the blood of the slain one at Karbala, O knight of the Hijaz! O Remnant of God, come to our aid! Here I am at your service, O Mahdi"
13
160
2
930
15,520
Disputing Sunnah retweeted
Every accusation is a confession. This map shows Sunni suicide bombings targeting Shias in Baghdad alone between 2004 and 2009.
Iran's military and its proxy militias have a long, documented history of horrific sectarian crimes against Sunni Muslims. Their crimes include massacres, ethnic cleansing, and attacking, firebombing, and destroying thousands of mosques- primarily Sunni places of worship. • In Iraq, Iranian-trained proxies operated with near-total state impunity across two massive waves of violence, destroying an estimated 200 to 300 Sunni mosques. 2006: The bombing of more than 90 Sunni mosques by Shia militias in a matter of days in Iraq. 2007: The bombing and levelling of 2 major Sunni mosques by Shia militiamen in Basra, Iraq. 2014: Musab bin Umair mosque massacre by Iran-linked Shia militias who massacred 73 worshippers and rigged secondary explosives in Diyala, Iraq. 2016: Iran-backed militias firebombed 9 Sunni mosques in Muqdadiya, Iraq. • In Syria, Iran-backed Shia militias shelled, bulldozed, and burned hundreds of Sunni mosques • In Afghanistan, Iran's Quds Force is accused of carrying out covert false-flag bombings of dozens of mosques to instigate a sectarian civil war and recruit Afghan Shia men into its militias. • In Yemen, the Houthi militias have targeted, vandalised, and destroyed between 300 and 750 Sunni mosques since capturing Sana'a in 2014. Yemeni human rights reports document over 4,800 total violations targeting places of worship. • In Iran, they are accused of false flag operations to justify brutal domestic crackdowns and inflame anti-Sunni sentiment such as the 1994 Mashhad mosque bombing operation that killed 26. This list is not exhaustive. Haqiqatjou, who once called out Iran for massacring Sunnis, has become a shameless liar. Rewriting history will never bring unity. Dodging accountability and honesty will only cement division.
17
171
6
1,178
22,028
Disputing Sunnah retweeted
According to al-Bāqillānī, the extremist Fāris ibn Ḥātim believed in the doctrine of the Twelve Imams. Fāris died during the lifetime of al-ʿAskarī (as). This demonstrates that the doctrine of the Twelve was held during al-ʿAskarī’s lifetime.
4
12
49
2,450
⚠️ Sensitive Content Warning The video shows Syrian Arab Army soldier Shadi Hamada, from the al-Midan neighborhood of Damascus, being held captive by a group affiliated with the organization in the village of al-Jafrah, in the eastern Deir ez-Zor countryside. Based on their accents, the individuals in the video appear to come from different Arab countries, particularly Egypt, Morocco, and Libya. The group humiliated the soldier, forcing him to kiss their feet under the pretext that they were “mujahideen” (fighters engaged in jihad). They also referred to him as a “Nusayri,” a sectarian term referring to Alawites. Hamada, however, was Sunni. This reflects the sectarian assumptions apparently held by the group's members, particularly the belief that all Syrian Arab Army personnel belonged to the Alawite community. Despite Hamada's pleas for mercy and his insistence that he had not fired a single shot at the fighters, his appeals were to no avail, and members of the organization executed him. The Syrian Archive publishes this footage as part of a documentary series highlighting the involvement of foreign fighters who came to Syria from abroad in operations targeting Syrian Arab Army personnel, as well as the takfiri rhetoric and sectarian incitement accompanying these operations. The series aims to preserve these materials as historical sources and make them available for research and documentation. #Syrian_Archive #Syrian_Arab_Army #Syria
تحذير: محتوى حساس ⚠️ يُظهر هذا الفيديو قيام مجموعة تابعة للتنظيم بأسر الجندي في الجيش العربي السوري، شادي حمادة، المنحدر من حي الميدان في مدينة دمشق، وذلك أثناء وجوده أسيرًا لدى التنظيم في قرية الجفرة الواقعة في ريف دير الزور الشرقي. ومن خلال الاستماع إلى لهجات الأشخاص الظاهرين في الفيديو، يبدو أنهم ينحدرون من جنسيات عربية مختلفة، أبرزها المصرية والمغربية والليبية. أقدمت المجموعة على إذلال الجندي وإجباره على تقبيل أقدام أفرادها، بحجة أنهم «مجاهدون»، واصفين إياه بأنه «نصيري» (في إشارة إلى الطائفة العلوية). إلا أن الجندي سني، وهذا ما يعكس التصورات الطائفية التي يبدو أن أفراد التنظيم يتبنونها، والمتمثلة في الاعتقاد بأن جميع أفراد الجيش العربي السوري ينتمون إلى الطائفة العلوية. ورغم محاولات الجندي شادي حمادة استجداء الرحمة، وتأكيده أنه لم يُطلق رصاصة واحدة على المقاتلين، فإن تلك المحاولات لم تُجدِ نفعًا، إذ أقدم أفراد التنظيم على اعدا_مه. وتأتي هذه المادة ضمن سلسلة توثيقية تسلط الضوء على مشاركة عناصر أجنبية، قدمت من خارج سوريا، في عمليات استهدفت السوريين من أفراد الجيش العربي السوري، وعلى الخطاب التكفيري والتحريضي الذي رافق تلك العمليات، وذلك في إطار الحفظ التاريخي للمصادر وإتاحتها للأغراض البحثية والتوثيقية. #الأرشيف_السوري #الجيش_العربي_السوري #سوريا
17
12
2
213
128,127
Disputing Sunnah retweeted
في فاجعه هزت مشاعر ووجدان شيعه اهل البيت عليهم السلام بعد اقدام السلطات الكويتيه مساء الاثنين على اعدام فضيله الشيخ حسين المعتوق مع عدد من المؤمنين بتهمه حضور جنازه الوليه الفقيه السيد علي الخامنئي في كربلاء والنجف انا لله وانا اليه راجعون #الكويت بأي ذنب قُتل يا أحفاد يزيد
106
30
1
195
181,111
Disputing Sunnah retweeted
بسند صحيح قال رسول الله صلى الله عليه وآله ملعون ملعون من يظلم بعدي فاطمة ابنتي ويغصبها حقها ويقتلها
4
5
2
38
2,646
Disputing Sunnah retweeted
The Rabbi at this Syria event, Asher Lopatin, called Israels slaughter in Gaza, "a legitimate war" that they fought "morally-more than any other country in any other war before in an urban setting" and denied it was a genocide. When Peter Beinart told him Israel didn't have the right to blow up hospitals, Rabbi Lopatin shrugged it off as justified.
🇸🇾 🕌⛪️🕍 🇺🇸 The Syrian Mosaic Foundation was proud to host its inaugural New York event, "Syria's Mosaic Heritage," in Brooklyn. We were honored to welcome H.E. Ambassador Ibrahim Olabi (Syria's Ambassador to the UN), Mr. Jacob Fisch (Director of Jewish Heritage at the ALIPH Foundation), Dr. Suhail Zavaro, Dr. Jill Joshowitz, and Rabbi Asher Lopatin. Bringing together more than 150 Syrian Jews alongside scholars, rabbis, and community leaders, the evening centered on the history of Dura-Europos. With traditional Syrian music and kosher Syrian food, the night was a powerful celebration of the shared heritage that connects us all. Syria's heritage belongs to all of us. This event was about coming together to preserve the importance of our cultural heritage, and working to protect it for the future. Preserving Syria's Heritage. Building Its Future. ✨️🕊 #SyriaForAll #SyrianMosaic
15
125
6
357
11,707
Disputing Sunnah retweeted
Muhammad Ibn Abd al-Wahhab was an ignorant liar who said Rawdhat al-Wa'idhin was a book by Mufid (it's by Martyr Ibn al-Fattal) and that the Shi'ah unanimously agree that al-Imam al-Hasan b. Ali's descendants (ع) went extinct. Have a laugh at their so-called "Mujadid".
1
2
16
882
Disputing Sunnah retweeted
BIG | 🇮🇱🇸🇾‼️‼️ Israeli forces are reportedly establishing a military installation on Jabal al-Arab in Syria’s southern Suwayda province, potentially including advanced radar systems and surveillance equipment. A local source told Syria 360 that dozens of Israeli military helicopters had transported substantial quantities of weapons, equipment, and advanced technology to the mountainous area over the past 72 hours. According to the report, the operation is intended to support the construction of a military base near the summit. Local Druze authorities have also reportedly prohibited civilians from approaching the facilities or taking photographs. The reported deployment and construction activities have not been independently verified. A military installation on Jabal al-Arab could provide Israel with a strategically valuable position for monitoring southern Syria and detecting potential aerial threats. The mountainous terrain would offer advantages for radar coverage, surveillance, and early warning capabilities. A permanent Israeli military presence in the area, however, would also raise serious questions about Syrian sovereignty and could further complicate the already fragile security situation in southern Syria. See the latest updates with us: @visionergeo
1
15
1
55
8,720
Disputing Sunnah retweeted
>Coalition spox: ermmm we haven’t used the AH-64 yet, so Ansarallah is lying. But coincidentally we did lose an AH-6i and its crew to technical malfunction 😔 >Ansarallah publishes footage of the AH-6i getting blown to pieces.
تدعّي إسقاطها .. ستدخل الميدان قريباً.. تذكر شكلها فلا تنسى
31
222
10
1,684
108,987
Disputing Sunnah retweeted
I left Christianity and became a Shia Muslim. That’s the tweet.
459
209
80
3,052
197,465
Disputing Sunnah retweeted
I never thought I'd see this day. Saudi Wahabis defending the Shia leader of Azerbaijan with their lives. Sayed Hassan Nasrullah certainly spoke the truth.
This quoted post is unavailable.
12
192
4
1,387
46,252
Disputing Sunnah retweeted
In the name of Allah, putting the nail in this coffin once and for all. From this thread of false tales and his other posts, we will prove that this person is an ignorant buffoon, and we will waste nor more time with him. "Pay no attention to the ignorant." 7:199
Finally we see someone from their corner stepping up to the challenge. Their corner has been quiet for a while after they were dismantled one by one. I always see this initial optimism and enthusiasm only for it to slowly evaporate once we begin tearing their arguments apart
5
6
1
17
2,496