Gareth (@ErfinderRotwang) header
Gareth (@ErfinderRotwang) profile picture

And into the forest I go, to lose my mind & find my soul

Heading steadily North
Joined July 2014
Photo by Gareth (@ErfinderRotwang)Photo by Gareth (@ErfinderRotwang)Photo by Gareth (@ErfinderRotwang)Photo by Gareth (@ErfinderRotwang)Photo by Gareth (@ErfinderRotwang)Photo by Gareth (@ErfinderRotwang)Photo by Gareth (@ErfinderRotwang)Photo by Gareth (@ErfinderRotwang)Photo by Gareth (@ErfinderRotwang)Photo by Gareth (@ErfinderRotwang)
Gareth retweeted
15 months for criminal damage? Here’s the logic and why it appears a bit steep. He was convicted of criminal damage. Nobody disputes that. But you’re confusing the offence with how a sentence is determined. Thomas slashed a vessel eight times with a knife while a French rescue worker was aboard, deliberately disrupting a maritime operation involving Border Force, the Coastguard and RNLI. He had five previous convictions, including kidnapping, and committed this offence whilst already on bail. Those are relevant sentencing considerations, not irrelevant historical footnotes. And here’s another detail. Thomas initially pleaded not guilty and exercised his right to elect trial by jury at the Crown Court. He subsequently changed his plea to guilty, avoiding a full trial and qualifying for a reduction in his sentence. The right to trial by jury wasn’t held against him. His guilty plea actually benefited him. But what might have happened had he remained in the Magistrates’ Court? This is where things become particularly interesting. Ordinarily, magistrates can impose up to 12 months’ imprisonment for a single either-way offence. They can also refer sufficiently serious cases to the Crown Court for sentencing. However, criminal damage has specific provisions concerning the value of the damage. Where the damage does not exceed £5,000, the offence is ordinarily dealt with summarily, with a maximum of three months’ imprisonment and/or a fine. In Thomas’s case, the judge explicitly acknowledged that the value of the damage could not be established. Under section 22 of the Magistrates’ Courts Act 1980, where that value is uncertain, a defendant can consent to summary trial. Section 33 then limits imprisonment for that criminal damage offence to three months. That means Thomas potentially had a route to proceedings in the Magistrates’ Court where the sentencing ceiling for this offence would have been considerably lower. Instead, he elected Crown Court trial by jury, exposing himself to the wider sentencing powers available there. He was entirely entitled to make that decision. But it was his decision, not evidence that he was denied justice. Had he admitted the offence at the earliest opportunity, he could also have qualified for the maximum one-third guilty plea reduction, subject to the applicable sentencing rules. Instead, he initially denied the charge, elected jury trial and subsequently pleaded guilty. So we have a repeat offender, already on bail, who filmed himself committing an offence, initially denied it and subsequently admitted it. He received 15 months after the Crown Court considered the circumstances, his criminal history, the aggravating factors and his guilty plea. You’re entitled to question the proportionality of that sentence. But reducing the entire case to “15 months for criminal damage” whilst disregarding the sentencing framework isn’t a serious legal argument. Nor is it evidence of political persecution when a defendant exercises his legal rights and receives a sentence within the powers of the court he chose. Context doesn’t cease to exist simply because it’s inconvenient. Sources: Court proceedings and judicial remarks: portsmouth.co.uk/news/crime/… Original plea and election: aol.co.uk/articles/danny-tom… Magistrates’ Courts Act 1980, section 22: legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/198… Section 33, sentencing limits: legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/198… Sentencing Council, guilty plea reductions: sentencingcouncil.org.uk/gui… Sentencing Council, criminal damage: sentencingcouncil.org.uk/gui…
As much as you list his previous convictions. It seems he received 15 months for criminal damage.
29
107
22
281
12,186
Gareth retweeted
“Once, when sitting as an unelected member who helps makes laws and can’t be removed by public vote, I went on social media to complain about unelected members who help make laws but can’t be removed by public vote”
I do not want our laws set by this woman. I did not elect her. We cannot remove her by voting! I want a Westminster government that British people can remove if they decide they want to. Not a weak PM who defers to Brussels
23
646
6
3,341
47,177
He’s bang on.
🚨Roy Keane on Elliot Anderson’s controversial red card after his foul on Lamine Yamal during England vs Spain: 🗣️ “I think everyone is going to look at this from another angle, but that’s not where I’m looking at it. I’m looking at what happened before the red card. Jarell Quansah has the ball. He’s trying to play out, and the next thing I see is Lamine Yamal going in hard on him. And I’m not saying he went in hard as if that’s some excuse — he actually fouled him. The referee sees it and does nothing. That matters. England are already three goals ahead. They’re putting in an outstanding performance, they’re controlling the game, and then an important decision goes against them right in front of the referee. Spain win the ball from that situation. Yamal gets it, and now Elliot Anderson is back covering. And suddenly everyone wants to focus on Anderson. ‘Oh, he’s holding Yamal.’ Yes. ‘He’s the last defender.’ Yes. ‘He committed a foul.’ Yes. I’m not going to sit here and tell you Anderson did the right thing. He didn’t. If you’re the last defender, you have to understand the consequences of grabbing a player like Yamal. But let’s use our brains for a second. It’s the 65th minute. England are winning 3-0. If Yamal gets through and scores, it’s 3-1. You still have a two-goal lead. Is conceding one goal frustrating? Of course. But getting yourself sent off and leaving your teammates with ten men for the final twenty-five minutes is potentially far worse. So no, Anderson shouldn’t have grabbed him. He made a poor decision. But that is not the biggest issue for me. The biggest issue is what happened to Quansah. Was that a foul? Yes. Did the referee see it? Yes. Was anything done about it? No. Did VAR go back and properly examine the incident that started the entire sequence? Apparently not. Instead, the entire focus becomes the red card. That’s where football becomes confusing. We have all these rules. We have VAR. We have referees, assistants, technology, replays from ten different angles. And yet sometimes it feels like the officials decide which part of the sequence they want to investigate. If Yamal fouls Quansah, stop the play there. England keep possession. There is no counterattack. There is no situation where Anderson is forced to defend Yamal running through. And there is no red card. So yes, Anderson made a mistake. But England were also denied an important decision before that mistake ever happened. And I’m tired of football pretending those two things cannot be true at the same time. You can criticise the player for the red card and still criticise the referee for missing the foul that created the situation. That’s not making excuses. That’s looking at the whole incident. Because if we only punish the final mistake and ignore what caused it, then what exactly is VAR there for? The rules are supposed to make football clearer. Sometimes the way they’re applied just makes the whole thing more confusing.”
38
Just watched Arrival (again) Just gets better and better with every watch. Discover something new each time. Actually gasped at one point. “That’s how!!” Incredible. So clever, thoughtful and brilliant.
22
Tarkowski on Ndoye.
One of the most badass plays in NBA history. No remorse, no trying to smooth things over; Jokic got a cheap shot and then he cheap shotted back. So epic.
214
So they start to investigate knowing that usually triggers the investigated driver to give up the position. Lewis duly does that. Then they say they weren’t going to penalise him anyway. Ridiculous.
🤣🤣🤣🤣 Goodnight ✋🏼
71
Idiots. Everywhere.
31
Absolutely loving Glasner sprinting down the touchline to celebrate Delap’s second #NFFC
174
É a primeira vez que eu vejo uma música eletrônica analógica
1,107
12,739
2,036
84,347
5,110,349
10% medical training 90% staying fucking calm
Una pareja manejaba a exceso de velocidad porque su hijo no respiraba, los paró un policía y al ver la situación les sacó el pibe y le desatascó lo que tenía en la garganta. Tipazo y muy calmado.
98
MGW in the form of his life and best performer in the premier league - not selected for England MGW not playing up to his usual standards, struggling to create - named in the England squad Make it make sense @forestfocuspod
1
1
6
898
The 90s were so special and nobody knew it at the time..
62
295
38
2,085
169,835
To me this isn’t a tackle. Neither player is in possession of the ball so they’re both trying to get to it. An unfortunate collision, never a red.
The referee gave Jacob Ramsey red card for this tackle but couldn’t give Nyoni a Red card after his tackle on Odegaard at Anfield? The inconsistencies in Premier League are actually funny nitter.gq/Eli_Sam_/status/211737…
1
77
You have to wonder why some people are posting this shite 12 years on.
Now you know why their mps get off scot free and judges are handpicked for others.
32
F1: Max has broken the rules Also F1: it’s OK, no penalty needed.
38
Incredible. We’ve been damned unlucky.
We’ve allowed five shots on target in the past three games and four of them have gone in - three deflecting in. #NFFC
1
55
When I saw this at normal speed my first instinct was that the little nudge in the back was enough to put him off.
53' LA TÊTE DE RYAN YATES S'ENVOLE, C'EST PAS POSSIBLE !!! 😩 La passe de Morgan Gibbs-White était parfaite… 🐝 1⃣-0⃣ 🌳 #NFFC #PremierLeague
2
139
Just watching the Sky highlights. Frustrating again, especially as Brentford got two really lucky deflections. We had the chances, could’ve won it 4-3 #NFFC
1
302
Wow! Incredible crowds out for Halloween. At one point so many people outside the house I thought a coach party had turned up. We bought *a ton* of sweets and were all out about 15 minutes ago. Lots of compliments about the house and so many polite, friendly kids (& parents)
1
91