Replying to @theIslampill
It does. The accusation of “selectively exempting the Christian framework by appealing to progressive revelation” and saying that we are “smuggling in human centered moral epistemology” above God’s wisdom is only going to apply on a DCT model.
If a virtue ethicist framework is in view and we have something like Webb’s hermeneutics in the background, there is no replacement of God’s wisdom or sovereignty.
A source if confusion here may be that for us- we can accept this progressive trajectory ethic. If islam did too, and was willing to say child is bad. Then there’s no problem
1
1
175
I don’t know how @Deenresponds gets away with being this dumb and this dishonest. You were given my model. You ever engaged it. You were corrected by people you tried to use as your witness. And you still lie publicly on a recent stream. Is this dawah?
Here is what the Dawah guys see from this.
The fact that Muslims clipped this part of the debate reveals a lot more than they realize. Here's a breakdown.
First, Libyano asks Mike his *personal opinion* whether the Son of Man is the most glorified. Mike asks for verses, Libyano says cumulative case. Mike agrees (again, his personal opinion).
Second, Libyano switches from Mike's personal opinion and asks whether a *certain arbitrary selection of scholars* think that the Son of Man was distinct from Jesus. Mike says according to those scholars, but not to Mark. Also note, that same arbitrary selection of scholars don't agree with Mike's personal opinion that the Son of Man is the "most glorified human figure." This is a major disconnect. More on that later.
Third, Libyano asks Mike what 'Ahmed' means in Arabic. Mike gets it right when he says "most praised one." That's what the term means in Arabic (look it up). Libyano then tries to correct him and says it means most glorified human figure (it does not). Praise and glory are not synonymous.
Fourth, Libyano claims victory and says Mike agrees that Jesus prophesied Muhammed according to scholarship.
None of this follows. None of it.
(1) Mike's personal opinion is that the Son of Man is the most glorified human figure.
(2) Certain scholars think the Son of Man is distinct from Jesus.
(3) 'Ahmed' means most praised one.
From (1), (2), and (3), it does not follow that Jesus prophesied Muhammed according to scholarship. It's a blatant non-sequitur.
-Libyano needs those same scholars to all agree that the Son of Man is the most glorified human figure. They do not.
-Libyano needs 'Ahmed' to mean most glorified human figure. It does not.
-Libyano needs those scholars to think that Jesus was prophesying a figure like Muhammed to fulfill this role several centuries later. They do not.
-Even if Libyano had everything he needed (he doesn't), it doesn't follow that Jesus actually prophesied Muhammed. All that would follow is that a group of scholars believe this. But scholars believe all sorts of dumb things. This is clearly why Libyano didn't want to discuss what Mike actually believed, he wanted to focus on what certain scholars say.
In short, several key premises are missing to get the conclusion that Libyano wants, yet he still saw fit to claim victory. Other Muslims, like Deen saw fit to clip this and post on X. But this is not serious thinking. Anyone can make a string of confused and confusing statements and claim victory.
Muslims, do better.
Replying to @Deenresponds
@Deenresponds : THAN COMMITTED HERESY. Then refuses to dig into the philosophy, listen to my clarifications, or the testimony of many people who know my position.
Also Deen when defending himself: “you can’t judge someone’s intentions especially when they’re telling you their intentions are not that”
Replying to @Acts17David
@Acts17David wanna join me in responding to this?
youtu.be/8BcbLzoajkk?si=0u-S…
1
1
108
come watch this tonight. Part 1 of my new argument for high Christology in Mark’s gospel.
youtu.be/LZ76TRyjCoc?si=oHiW…
Sneak leak of next video coming out. @theistrational_
Live tomorrow at 1pm central. Come hang out 🙂
youtu.be/TbF-ef_gQvc






