Commonwealth and Comparative Politics (@FCCPolitics) profile picture

Commonwealth & Comparative Politics is a quarterly journal of Comparative Politics, esp in the Commonwealth. It is published by Taylor & Francis @tandfonline

Articles & content ➡️
Joined January 2021
Photo by Commonwealth and Comparative Politics (@FCCPolitics)Photo by Commonwealth and Comparative Politics (@FCCPolitics)
Commonwealth and Comparative Politics retweeted
📢📢PUBLICATION ALERT In this paper for @FCCPolitics, I examine the populist performance of international summitry in the context of 🇮🇳’s G20 presidency in 2023. Using the theoretical frameworks of populism as style (@bjmoffitt) & populism as ...(1/3) tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.…
1
3
1
5
2,447
Commonwealth and Comparative Politics retweeted
Pleased to have my latest article published in @FCCPolitics. It demonstrates the sense of powerlessness that people can feel as council population sizes grow, particularly as a result of amalgamation. This compromises LG's role as a school for democracy: doi.org/10.1080/14662043.202…
1
3
6
196
Commonwealth and Comparative Politics retweeted
We would like to draw your attention to a book review on "Race & Diplomacy in Zimbabwe: The Cold War and Decolonization, 1960–1984" by Timothy Lewis Scarnecchia, reviewed by Ryan Shaffer in @FCCPolitics. Read: doi.org/10.1080/14662043.202… @tandfonline @CambridgeUP #globalsixties
3
5
472
Commonwealth and Comparative Politics retweeted
Seeing reviews of Land Politics from scholars whose work I greatly admire has been an unexpected treat. Thanks to Prof. Dominika Koter for this one in @FCCPolitics. And thanks to @CUP_PoliSci for releasing it last month in paperback! tandfonline.com/doi/pdf/10.1…
3
16
1,068
Commonwealth and Comparative Politics retweeted
My review of @IsmayMilford's carefully crafted 'African Activists in a Decolonising World' is now out @FCCPolitics. 50 free downloads are available at: tandfonline.com/eprint/GFKZ3…
3
29
67
3,700
Commonwealth and Comparative Politics retweeted
Congratulations and thanks for introducing me to this book.
1
3
68
Commonwealth and Comparative Politics retweeted
This may be a little late for #ZimDecides2023 but yesterday the @FCCPo journal published my article on ZANU-PF's Bigwig Rallies as Performative Politics. I am sharing it as my outro to the #ElectionsZW discussion for now. It partially answers questions around why authoritarian-nationalist parties like ZANU-PF bother to campaign through rallies. It attempts to show the framing and communication intentions of the rally, and argues that at bigwig rallies what is communicated is more than what is actually said, to include what is projected, shown, demonstrated and or performed. In this way, the article defines, describes and explains the how and why of ZANU-PF’s rallies, and is part of a special edition on Campaign rallies and political meaning-making, edited by @pandaget @NixiiB  & @GabrielleLynch6. You can find the intro to the special edition at tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.…. An earlier companion piece for this edition by @hannahwaddilove on rallies and performance and elite alliance building can be found at tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.…. My paper can be found at Below is the paper's opening, & the full arrticle can be found at tandfonline.com/eprint/PVGTF… Introduction: ZANU-PF’s bigwig rallies as performative politics during Zimbabwe’s 2008 and 2013 elections The Zimbabwe African National Union–Patriotic Front’s (ZANU-PF), authoritarian tendencies and illicit means of power capture and retention through violence, rigging, and chicanery are well documented in the literature. While essential to understanding the party and politics in Zimbabwe, this dogged focus on the illicit often neglects how, in typical electoral authoritar- ian fashion, ZANU-PF makes differential use of coercive clientelist and persuasive clientelist mobilisation across constituencies and elections. In this complex matrix, ZANU-PF pursues legitimacy-seeking rallies and persuasive appeals side-by-side with electoral manipulation, violence, and intimidation. While acknowledging the latter, this paper focuses on the under recognised persuasive power-seeking methods by exploring ZANU-PF’s use and abuse of the party rally. A rally is a public event at which speakers address an audience face-to-face for the ostensible purpose of politically mobilising it (Paget, 2019, p. 451). It is a dynamic, often persuasive act that engages in sense-making, sense-spread- ing, and distributing the sensible through multiple performances, including slogans, praise-singing, speeches, dances, and visual symbols (Rancière, 2006, p. 13; Gilman, 2009). Beyond theatre, spectacle, and performance, rallies are an essential mode of political communication to citizens in sub- Saharan Africa from politicians and parties. They are an integral part of the election process and retain a significant role in providing space for parties to seek legitimacy through direct contact with the electorate. Survey data puts Zimbabwe’s national rally attendance rates based on respondents admissions at between 45 and 50 per cent (measured for 2019) and over 60 per cent for the 2008 and 2013 elections (AfroBarometer, 2015; Paget, 2019). Although rally attendance in electoral authoritarian set- tings like Zimbabwe is not always voluntary (it can be coerced), attendance rates show that political parties in Zimbabwe largely see rallies as important communication platforms and stages for performative politics involving poli- ticians, parties and various audiences and constituencies (Paget, 2019, 2022). Despite the salience of rallies as a vital part of performative politics and a sub-genre during election campaigns in Zimbabwe, there is limited literature on them. Most literature explores, at length, issues around rigging, violence and coercion, and the lasting legacies of fear and their fundamentally dama- ging effects on people’s lives (Alexander & Tendi, 2008; Masunungure, 2009, 2014; Alexander & Chitofori, 2010; Zamchiya, 2013; Moore, 2014; Southall, 2013; Bratton et al., 2016). However, there have been some attempts at illu- minating what politicians and parties choose to communicate at rallies in Zimbabwe, including some work on rallies of different intensity, depth, and focus (see for example, Marongwe, 2013; Tendi, 2013; Zamchiya, 2013). Using primary data from original fieldwork, participant observation, and secondary data from document analysis, I build on the above work in two ways. First, I draw on and enrich past research. I show that in 2008 and 2013, ZANU-PF’s messages at rallies varied in the distinct contexts of each campaign. I focus on the rallies convened for the president and/or presiden- tial candidate. I show that similar rallies are also convened for other senior party figures who are considered significant enough to stand in for the pre- sident or presidential candidate, but who are not themselves presidential candidates or presidents. To show the latter, I develop a broader category of what I refer to as ‘bigwig’ rallies. Bigwig rallies take place at a scale more prominent than the ward, consti- tuency, and district administrative levels and are presided over and organised by party agents and structures from the provincial and national level. While taking place in a particular area, these rallies differ from regular/local rallies because of who addresses them, in this case, party bigwigs from the presidium, namely the party president, vice president(s), and party chairper- son. The presence of these ‘bigwigs’ makes these rallies significant national- level events. I include in the categorisation of bigwig rallies in this paper ‘star rallies’, at which the party president is the show’s star. In Zimbabwe (but perhaps elsewhere, too), the bigwig rally constitutes a distinct sub-genre of the rally that occupies a distinct place in election campaigning. I look at what ZANU-PF communicated at and through bigwig rallies in 2008 and 2013 and explore how it produced them to generate those communications. Second, I show at length that ZANU-PF used bigwig rallies to make a series of performances that communicate through what speakers explicitly state and what the rally projected and intimated in Zimbabwe’s electoral-authoritarian context. I engage with and specifically look at what ruling parties in electoral- authoritarian regimes communicate through their bigwig rallies and how they produce the rallies to generate the desired communications. In this way, the article illuminates the bigwig rally, its meanings, purpose, and func- tion in the greater scheme of the electoral campaign. Bigwig rallies are integral to ZANU-PF’s legitimacy-seeking and voter mobilisation strategies. The communicative power of the bigwig rally goes beyond what is said to include what is projected and understood by various audiences. This is because bigwig rallies are elaborate productions at which party heavyweights communicate messages and make meanings concerning these various audiences. They lay down the law and line of march for party structures, shape collectivities, and frame candidates, the electoral contest, and their opponents. They solicit votes based on various claims of representativeness and legitimacy to various audiences. As Paget et al. (Forthcoming) argue, the rally and its broadcast communicate important messages about candidates’ electoral viability (effective representation), what is at stake for the constituents (beatific or horrific futures), and what the elec- tion is actually about (framing contests). I argue that bigwig rallies are also carriers of communication aimed at pro- jecting power, authority, insurmountable strength, and confidence at the polls. Besides being a stage for the bully pulpit, the bigwig rally is also a stage for illusions and political optics and demonstrates itinerant rulership in service to electoral authoritarianism. In this instance, rallies become a mani- festation of authority where the very presence of the incumbent, even as an election candidate or ZANU-PF bigwig, makes their ‘infallibility’ and power visible and tangible (Wedeen, 1999; Jourde, 2005). In this respect, the bigwig rally is a theatre and performance, broadcasting power and framing specific definitions and conceptions of reality while gathering information about the party’s perceived and real organisational strength and organisa- tion. Seen in this way, the bigwig rally generates intimidation effects for opponents and sows doubt in the opposition’s ability to unseat the incum- bent in the eyes of casual, disinterested, and marginally interested observers. I elaborate on the preceding in the sections that follow. First, I locate the rally in electoral campaigns and outline their types in Zimbabwe, developing the concept of bigwig rallies and why they are a distinct sub-genre of the rally that occupies a distinct place in election campaigning. Second, I then engage with and add to the extant literature on rallies, highlighting bigwigs’ mess- ages to party faithful and rallygoers. In the last substantive section, I outline how the bigwig rally is both a performance and an integral part of performative politics in Zimbabwe’s electoral authoritarian environment and focus beyond what is said at bigwig rallies to what those rallies inferred, projected, suggested, demonstrated and performed. I end the paper by com- paring the performative aspects of bigwig rallies in Zimbabwe and similar rallies in other electoral authoritarian contexts in sub-Saharan Africa.
7
54
3
123
32,527
Commonwealth and Comparative Politics retweeted
Please join us for our first #BookTalkSeries on 8 Nov from 12-1.30pm GMT. We will have @knr21_cam author of ~Garments without Guilt? Global Labour Justice and Ethical Codes in Sri Lankan Apparels. @TansyHoskins will be our discussant. Link to register:bit.ly/45nzWn9
2
6
1
12
1,555
Commonwealth and Comparative Politics retweeted
Call for applications for the ICSSR’s Doctoral Fellowships for the Financial Year 2023-24 #fellowship #SocialScience icssr.org/call-applications-…
2
136
6
311
39,694
Commonwealth and Comparative Politics retweeted
It’s time to say more this new article out in @FCCPolitics doi.org/10.1080/14662043.202…
1
5
1
6
1,059
Commonwealth and Comparative Politics retweeted
📚Introducing our #BookTalkSeries. Calling all authors who have published a book on South Asia in the past couple of years or have a forthcoming book. Join us for a 30-minute discussion followed by Q&A. Express interest by August 30th🗓️ Link: bit.ly/3QV4KrH
4
5
552
Commonwealth and Comparative Politics retweeted
I have a new article out (open access) It’s unites my study of rallies and my new work on pol theory It’s based on material from my book project It’s part of a special issue in @FCCPolitics co-edited with @NixB and @GabrielleLynch6 Interested? Read on tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.…
3
10
26
1,990
Commonwealth and Comparative Politics retweeted
I have a new article out! In it, I begin with the idea that representation is always something constructed, something claimed I argue that this representative claim-making shares an affinity with the rally Find out more here @FCCPolitics Open access doi.org/10.1080/14662043.202…
2
5
380