Jennifer Welch and Angie Sullivan apologized for only one thing: Laughing at a joke.
They haven't backtracked at ALL on:
- hurting people directly affected by Kirk's public murder, including his family
- lying about the alignments and motives of Kirk's confessed murderer
- saying horrible things and enjoying violent rhetoric long before last week's incident
- putting the reputation of their advertisers in jeopardy
These women live for and make a living on their self-voiced hatred for other people. There is no depth or nuance in their thinking. Expect more of the same wretched, sinister talk - as long as they can find an audience for it.
38
Hey, sane and thoughtful progressives (I know you're out there) - Genuinely curious:
How does a Jennifer Welch train wreck happen?
I know there must be some of you who are disgusted and embarrassed by the ugliness on the "I've Had It" podcast with Jennifer Welch and Angie Sullivan - and also with so-called 'progressives' who immediately cheered Charlie Kirk's murder, tore down Israeli hostage posters, suggest murder as a response to pro-life effforts (Jane Fonda on the View), and in so many other ways celebrate, advocate for, or commit violence.
But no one on the left is talking. The left's cozy relationship with violence is not covered in the media. Yet it's there, and ever-present, and right out of leftists' own mouths.
For those of you who are not okay with this, what are you saying and hearing in your private conversations with other progressives? Why is there so little pushback against the culture of violence? Are people afraid to speak up? Do progressive besties talk and joke of violent behavior even more off-camera and away from social media? How do they square traditionally left-wing non-violent, pacifist ideals with calls for the blood of people like Charlie Kirk and Donald Trump to grassroots conservatives, Christians, and Jews?
I'm seriously trying to do the math on this, and it isn't adding up. Behavior and rhetoric like Welch's and Sullivans used to be shunned, on both sides of the aisle. Now, it's commonplace in left-oriented social media, college campus culture, and elsewhere. Is this a generational thing? Is there any sense of panic, disgust, or feeling that the culture of violence is getting way out-of-hand? In your most private conversations, do progressives care? Is there ANY anger at Welch and Sullivan? If so, why aren't we hearing more of it?
I'm particularly interested in the thoughts of progressives who work in media.
Conservatives, please let liberals do most of the talking on this post.
1
48
Jennifer Welch has said nothing publicly yet, 2 days after having a laugh at Charlie Kirk's murder.
After losing multiple advertisers, an apology may or may not be coming. But I expect she will eventually try to make herself the victim in this.
1
99
Good Dog Otto retweeted
Jenner Welch and Angie Sullivan, this is repulsive. Regardless of anyone’s political position, the mirth you express about the brutal murder of another human being is repugnant. It is a disgusting display of a complete lack of empathy, respect for human life, compassion, maturity, and personal morals. There is no personal standard being upheld by either of you. @Hanover_Square Press, @YouTube @ApplePodcasts
Podcasters Jennifer Welch and Angie Sullivan can't stop laughing at the thought of digging up Charlie Kirk's corpse and "doing it" again to him.
After laughing for 30 seconds straight, the women falsely claimed that Tyler Robinson was a 'MAGA person.'
They will celebrate your death, laugh uncontrollably, and still be fully convinced they're the "good guys."
Yes, Jennifer Welch and Angie Sullivan have the right to speak their mind, and they shouldn't be silenced for doing so.
That doesn't mean that every decent person in the world shouldn't vocally condemn their joking about their cold-blooded murder of Charlie Kirk, tune them out, and leave them utterly, bitterly, completely alone to exercise their freedom of speech for no one but each other while getting paid absolutely nothing for it.
1
46
It was just DAYS ago that Katie Couric, an accomplished journalist and former network anchor at NBC and CBS, shared a fawning, gushing, smiling interview with Jennifer Welch.
Now, Welch is a) openly enjoying a fantasy redo of Charlie Kirk's murder, and b) blatantly lying about the beliefs and motives of Kirk's killer.
@katiecouric , will you end your your warm association with Welch? I hope you take this perfect opportunity to distance yourself from a vicious and fundamentally dishonest woman, no matter how much you may like her politics. If you don't, you are no better than the Trumpers and MAGA people you enthusiastically criticize.
You have rightly criticized Donald Trump's crass behavior. Now, will you have the character and the guts to point out the ugly rot on the left? Or is decency relative?
Podcasters Jennifer Welch and Angie Sullivan can't stop laughing at the thought of digging up Charlie Kirk's corpse and "doing it" again to him.
After laughing for 30 seconds straight, the women falsely claimed that Tyler Robinson was a 'MAGA person.'
They will celebrate your death, laugh uncontrollably, and still be fully convinced they're the "good guys."
3
150
Oh, Paul-
Your instincts are normally correct. Kathy Griffin's are not. That second observation should have alerted you to the pitfall of pitying Kelly Clarkson.
So, Clarkson is "right" because she's ... consistent? I'll give you that, but consistency doesn't earn Clarkson a medal, or restore her formerly "nice" reputation.
This isn't about right or wrong, winner / loser. Neither party comes off smelling great here - especially after the store raised the price of the bird to $15 million. (Give me twenty bucks at Hobby Lobby and I can probably make my own.) This is about a botched opportunity for celebrity schmoozing on one hand, an unseemly twitter tantrum on the other, and two parties trying to save pride, face, and reputations - while yet losing that elusive character trait often described as "grown-up behavior."
Of COURSE, Kathy Griffin would favor the celebrity. She IS a celebrity. Of COURSE Griffin wants apologies and flowers for offended celebrities ... except Donald Trump, who should only have his head severed ... figuratively, of course.
Out of Kelly Clarkson's own mouth- she was offended because she was given the "Pretty Woman" treatment. She wasn't catered to quite enough. The store tried to 'help' her as if she were poor. The nerve.
Wise of the store? Probably not. Offensive? Only to some upper-class people like Clarkson, Kathy Griffin, and Clarkson's uber-fans. Clarkson accused the store of was classist "rudeness" because they suggested cheaper alternatives. The HORROR. But I'm one of those freak-show cheapskates that likes it when a store clerk tries to save me money. I'm just weird that way.
Clarkson, on the other hand, shamed an employee globally just 15 minutes after a five-minute interaction. She could have posted a helpfully negative Google review and left it at that, as most of us do, but she chose to go celebrity-nuclear. She called the store rep an "idiot" and "liar." And she did it with an audience of millions, hundreds of whom turned their own wrath directly on the store with scornful messages, calls, and visits. Insist that Clarkson is incredibly nice if you like ... but incredibly nice people don't normally do what Clarkson did unless they are having a very, very bad day.
So we have the store's perceived snobbery on one hand, vs. documented character assassination, a global insult, an attempted business cancellation, and an attempt to become the most aggrieved self-made martyr since Meghan Markle and Jussie Smollett. But wait ... there's more:
Kelly Clarkson charges $140 MINIMUM for a concert ticket and $3,000+ for a VIP seat. She can afford an absurdly priced bird toy because she commits a reciprocal 'crime' from the one she experienced: She treats poor people like they're rich while running their credit cards. This is far more offensive than a 'snobby' store offering a "nice" lady a better deal on a one-trick wooden bird.
But do take comfort Paul, that just this one magical time, for one "Moment Like This," (sing it, Kelly ♫), you and Kathy Griffin see eye-to-eye.
I shall take comfort that I've only paid Kelly Clarkson less than a dollar for one song on iTunes.
When both Kathy Griffin and I agree that Kelly Clarkson is the right one in the Art of Play store incident, then you really know the Brooklyn store messed up. It still feels weird to say I agree with Griffin, but it’s the truth.
Griffin said today that she’s “Team Kelly” in the Art of Play feud and called the store “petty.” She said she’s known Clarkson since the night she won American Idol, thinks Clarkson has become more real since her talk show ended, and doesn’t believe Clarkson would invent a story that could hurt a small business. I wish Griffin could be this sensible about everything.
Griffin’s take is that the store would’ve been better off saying they were embarrassed and that the employee had a bad day, then sending flowers. She thinks that would’ve helped their business instead of making them look small. That’s the same point I’ve been making. A simple apology and an invitation back would’ve ended this. The store owner playing the victim and raising the price to $15 million didn’t.
Agreeing with Griffin still feels off. She and I don’t line up on much. On this one, though, she’s right that Clarkson’s version has been consistent and that the store’s response made it worse. Treating a customer decently the first time still costs less than the cleanup.
At this point the Art of Play store co-owner is so dug in with his unfounded victimhood that I doubt he’ll ever do the right thing. At best he’ll probably just stop talking about it and pretend it never happened.
What he actually has to do after his reactions since the incident with Clarkson is apologize for the incident and also apologize for his response. Don’t make any excuses, just say his store was wrong, he was wrong, and Art of Play has taken steps to fix how they treat customers.
As for Griffin, she’s never apologized for the horrific political displays she’s made, so I won’t consider her anywhere near balanced. But when it comes to Clarkson, her take here seems right.
249
Kelly Clarkson and I have not spoken lately (well, ever), so I should not judge her. However:
Is it possible for a talk show host with a reputation for being super-nice to also come down hard on people when they are displeased?
Hmmmmm ... You tell me.🤔
A classic example of the classic disingenuousness of trans ideologists:
"Calling something an ideology doesn’t make the science behind it disappear. It just saves you the trouble of engaging with it."
Calling something an ideology isn't a slur. Conservatism and liberalism are ideologies. I even agree with one of those. Identifying an ideology makes it easier to describe and identify a commonly observed mode of thinking.
What actually makes it harder to engage with ideas and assertions? Being blocked by someone ... as X explains the original poster and Mir poster did to me ... as Mir accused ME me of not engaging.
Mir also employs tactics common to those who advance the trans ideology: Make a passing reference to "science" while appealing to so-called "experts" and authority instead of actual, observed and reviewed/challenged facts and data ... then silencing dissent as much as possible and walking away from the debate.
You’re unable to view this Post because this account owner limits who can view their Posts. Learn more
Is Kelly Clarkson right? Or is the store?
It doesn't matter. When one os famous, successful, and incredibly rich, one doesn't win by shaming a small business on the world stage. She could have, and should have, walked away - writing off an unpleasant interaction that didn't go the way she had hoped - because that's what most of us do when they're out of our size, they are closing for the day, they don't accept our coupon, or they forget to put the fries in our order.
Kelly's mistake: She portrayed herself as a victim. She wasn't denied lifesaving care- She had her pride hurt. When one is in Kelly's position, and can buy so many things ... almost anything one wants ... it is pretty hard for the rest of us 'normal people' to feel sorry about it. We have much bigger concerns than being denied the sale of such a ridiculous extravagance.
Kelly Clarkson is probably a genuinely nice person, or so I've heard. But she made the mistake of making a public scrap over a first world problem. And this is why people think so many celebs are so insufferable - even if they are in the right. Most of us have learned to pick our battles, and this is one where Clarkson should have just walked away, and maybe just found another business to put in a positive spotlight.
50
What "Miffy" fails to mention: "Trans" access to women's spaces opened the door to this.
What Jo Rowling has consistently mentioned: NO male, 'trans' or otherwise, should be in women's and girls' spaces ... and the insistence of so-called "trans women" that they are entitled has permitted access for people like the offender here - because once you base access on "feelings" ... no one can be denied access.
Trans-advocate, who argues with reality on a daily basis, thinks he (?) is a superior debtor to J.K. Rowling, who has not only revealed trans extremist assertions to be inconsistent, contradictory and irrational ... she has done it with ease and style.
"Miffy" doesn't have to hold her breath for half a second: Rowling already condemned Neil Gaiman, a straight man, for his alleged abusive behavior towards women, comparing him to predator Harvey Weinstein and questioning why the literary community was so hesitant to voice disapproval of Gaiman's behavior.
Perhaps the silence results from Gaiman's vocal support of 'trans rights.'
Anyway, "Miffy" must be miffed that Rowling's "silence" on abuse isn't actually a thing, and one of the most vocal and prominent voices of trans advocacy turned out to be one of the abusers.
Can’t wait to see Rowling and the rightwing commentariat take a minute of time away from their anti-trans obsessions and condemn predatory male-presenting straight men like this.
But I won’t hold my breath.
11
241
The pro-trans solution for those who want to be an ally AND watch Harry Potter on HBO: Theft. Show your niceness, love, and integrity by taking what isn't yours, because you feel entitled. Steal from J.K. Rowling and all the people working on the series who aren't JKR because you have a 'right' to enjoy new Potter content. You aren't obligated to pay- you disagree with JKR's view on what a woman is, so it's free to you. Have the mouth to speak your mind, but the backbone to actually give-up a favorite fandom isn't required. Just help yourself to whatever (a TV series, a women's restroom, a womens' sports tournament) because you declare it's yours too ... just because you want it.
It all tracks. The entire trans movement is built on dishonesty, bullying, manipulation, taking things that aren't yours, and feeling righteous about it.
What they believe about women and men makes them deluded. How they treat other people makes them sociopathic.
True, there are some anti-JKR activists who say they will not watch the series, and encourage others to do the same. But most of them won't hold out for long: They'll watch the series covertly, because they can't deny themselves anything they want.
unavailable
1
1
138
The number of posts I have read calling J.K. Rowling a hateful bigot because she is not on board with everything 'trans' activists demand must number in the hundreds.
The number of posts I have read referencing J.K. Rowling's actual hateful and bigoted statements:
Zero.
72
Have looked over hundreds of tweets, trying to find examples of how @jk_rowling has behaved meanly to "transgender" people, and I'm coming up entirely empty-handed.
Such a disappointment when one gives internet trolls the benefit of the doubt, only to have the rug yanked away.
44







