Jove Is Watching (@JoveIsWatching) header
Jove Is Watching (@JoveIsWatching) profile picture
Joined November 2019
Photo by Jove Is Watching (@JoveIsWatching)Photo by Jove Is Watching (@JoveIsWatching)Photo by Jove Is Watching (@JoveIsWatching)Photo by Jove Is Watching (@JoveIsWatching)Photo by Jove Is Watching (@JoveIsWatching)Photo by Jove Is Watching (@JoveIsWatching)Photo by Jove Is Watching (@JoveIsWatching)Photo by Jove Is Watching (@JoveIsWatching)Photo by Jove Is Watching (@JoveIsWatching)Photo by Jove Is Watching (@JoveIsWatching)
Jove Is Watching retweeted
I offer this response in the spirit of Platonic dialogue, not out of hostility. The author of this passage is a thoughtful and sincere thinker, and I appreciate his effort to explain Platonic metaphysics. However, I feel compelled to push back against what has increasingly become a kind of assumed orthodoxy in some circles: namely, the idea that Proclus' theory of Henads is not just part of Platonism, but its true foundation. This is not only historically inaccurate but metaphysically incoherent when examined closely. 1. "Platonism is not monism." This is a fair and accurate statement. Platonism is neither monism nor dualism in any strict modern sense. These are modern categories, and while useful to a point, they do not fully capture the richness of Platonic thought. The Platonists did not describe themselves in these terms. They held that all things proceed from a single ineffable source, but that does not make them monists in the modern philosophical sense. The author correctly points out that the One is not a numerical unit or a discrete object, and that the term “One” is symbolic of absolute unity, not arithmetic priority. This is consistent with Plotinus and the wider Platonic tradition. 2. "What defines the One is that nothing can define it." This paragraph rightly affirms the apophatic nature of the One. The One is not a being, not a mind, and not a god in the conventional sense. However, Platonists have long referred to the One as "God," especially when speaking poetically or in a religious tone. Plotinus does so frequently, and Middle Platonists often equate the One with the Father, with Nous, and even with the Demiurge, depending on the context. So while it is true that the One is not a god among gods, it is also not incorrect to call the One "God" in the absolute sense, especially when contrasted with the gods who belong to the order of Being. That said, the author is right to say the One is not mind, being, or substance. The One is beyond all such categories, and even the name “the One” is something of a placeholder, a necessary fiction to allow us to speak of that which is unspeakable. 3. "From this ineffable Unity proceed the Henads..." This is where the system breaks down. After affirming the One’s absolute simplicity and transcendence of all attributes, the author introduces the proclean idea of a plurality of Henads, each of them described as unparticipated, divine, causative, and beyond Being. This undercuts the very apophatic principles just established. If the One is beyond Being, and if, as Parmenides said, thinking and being are the same, then anything that can be identified, even as a “Henad,” must already fall within the realm of Being. One cannot assign divine causes or identity to something that is genuinely beyond Being, because those are determinations, and determination belongs to Intellect. To posit many “ones” or “gods” beyond Being is to collapse the ineffable into the intelligible, and thus undermine its simplicity. I’ve already addressed these issues at length in this post, so I won’t flesh out all the contradictions again. blog.romanistsociety.org/p/o… 4. "They are not parts of the One, but distinct causal powers..." Here we run into another issue. If these Henads are not parts of the One, nor products of Nous, and yet they are distinct and causative and somehow exist beyond Being, then the system must be introducing a new metaphysical layer not present in classical Platonism. This effectively creates a new hypostasis between the One and Nous. But such a move is entirely absent from Plotinus, Numenius, the Middle Platonists, or Plato himself. It emerges only in Proclus. If we are to accept this system, we must also accept that Platonism only truly began in the fifth century with Proclus. That is clearly absurd. What we have here is not the foundation of Platonism, but a theological innovation that departs from the core metaphysical principles of the earlier tradition. 5. Historical and Logical Considerations The term Henad is not used by any Platonist before Proclus. Plotinus, who is extremely careful in preserving the simplicity of the One, explicitly rejects the idea that anything can exist alongside or within the One at that level. He makes it clear that the One produces all things without being multiplied or divided. The many arise only at the level of Nous, where thought and being begin. To speak of multiple unities beyond Being is to import multiplicity into the ineffable source itself, which is precisely what Plotinus warns against. The system described as “Henological Polytheism” is not the metaphysical foundation of Platonism. It is a late elaboration, brilliant in its own way, but riddled with contradictions when read alongside earlier teachings. A truly Platonic metaphysics must preserve the radical simplicity of the One and admit multiplicity only at the level of Being, where differentiation becomes possible. To introduce multiple gods at the level of the ineffable is to abandon apophasis in favor of theological ornamentation. It may be inspiring, but it is in no way the foundation of Platonism, but rather an interesting but flawed elaboration of classical Platonism.
Platonism is not monism—because its source is not ‘One’ in number, identity, or being. The term ‘One’ (τὸ Ἕν) is symbolic, not numeric. It does not mean “the first item in a sequence,” nor does it mean “the only thing that truly exists.” Rather, it refers to absolute, ineffable Unity—prior to number, Being, and principle. You could call it “ten,” “zero,” “nothing,” or “infinity”—and Nothing would change. For what defines the One is precisely that nothing can define it. It is not a God, not a mind, not a being, not even a substance—it is the precondition of all identity, order, and existence. The One does not act, will, or think—it overflows by necessity, in superabundant stillness, just as light radiates from the sun—not by choice, but by its very nature. From this ineffable Unity proceed the Henads—eternal, unparticipated, causative divine unities beyond Being, each a true God. They are not parts of the One, but distinct causal powers, rooted in unity without division. Monism = all is one thing—one being, one substance, one God. Henology = all proceeds from absolute Unity—ineffable, indivisible, and beyond Being—yet the many are real, eternal, and causally distinct. This is not monism. This is Henological Polytheism—the true metaphysical foundation of Platonism.
4
4
1
35
4,172
Hello everyone, I've just released a new print of the Pythagorean Golden Verses and Hierocles' Commentary on them Thank you to @VirtueCultivate for the wonderful cover design 🔽
3
7
55
Why does Zeus have so many lovers? What do they all mean, and do they say anything about greek morality?
8
29
10
169