Kevin (@Kevkevmichael) header
Kevin (@Kevkevmichael) profile picture

Supporter of the Sub Postmasters' fight. Hater of injustice.

Joined August 2013
Photo by Kevin (@Kevkevmichael)Photo by Kevin (@Kevkevmichael)Photo by Kevin (@Kevkevmichael)Photo by Kevin (@Kevkevmichael)Photo by Kevin (@Kevkevmichael)Photo by Kevin (@Kevkevmichael)Photo by Kevin (@Kevkevmichael)Photo by Kevin (@Kevkevmichael)Photo by Kevin (@Kevkevmichael)Photo by Kevin (@Kevkevmichael)
Put them all in jail.
21
214
11
561
12,021
To read the witness statements of wrongly prosecuted Subpostmasters is to discover the most appalling and heartbreaking stories of how institutions can destroy a person. As MPs begin an inquiry into compensation delays, this morning I read the story of Carol Riddell. 1/7
11
76
8
192
25,237
£163million for what though. Passing papers back and forth to delay payments and reduce payments. Just wonderful.
This Post is from an account that no longer exists. Learn more
13
45
4
159
8,466
#PostOfficeScandal Arise.... Sir Alan Bates🎖️ A Huge Congratulations🙂 There cannot be a more deserving person in the country of this award. For over two decades Alan has led the JFSA (Justice for Sub Postmasters Alliance) in a constant David vs Goliath battle against the @PostOffice and their shareholder the government. Against all odds as both the Post Office and the Department for Business threw everything at the High Court GLO (as well as over £100m over taxpayer cash) and then attempting to recuse Justice Fraser for apparent bias, two landmark Judgements were handed down. These are known as the Common Issues Judgement and the Horizon Issues Judgement. @BBCEmmaSimpson reporting for @BBCNews wrote :- Bates learned of knighthood at Post Office inquiry‼️ The campaigner and former sub-postmaster, Alan Bates, was at the public inquiry into the Post Office scandal when he received the news that he was to be knighted in the King's Birthday Honours. He had travelled from his home in Llandudno to hear former Post Office CEO Paula Vennells give evidence, breaking her near-decade long silence. “It was all a bit of a surprise,” Sir Alan, as he is now known, told the BBC. He was told that he had to let the Honours Committee know by the end of the day whether he would accept. For the last 15 years, Sir Alan has campaigned for justice for hundreds of sub-postmasters who were wrongfully prosecuted for theft and false accounting, when faulty software called Horizon made it look like money was missing from their accounts. He had already rejected the offer of an OBE last year, telling the Honours Committee that it would be inappropriate to accept it whilst Ms Vennells kept hold of her CBE for services to the Post Office and many victims continued to suffer. Ms Vennells handed back her CBE earlier this year amid mounting pressure in the aftermath of the ITV drama in January which sparked national outrage over the scandal. “I went and had a confidential talk with somebody who knows what’s gone on over the years and they said to me, 'well you’ve done the heavy lifting, others are doing the rest now.' And on reflection, I knew so many people who were keen for me to actually receive something, I felt I would be insulting them as much as anyone else if I refused it at this time," Sir Alan said. He insisted the honour was not just for him but also for his group, the Justice for Sub-Postmasters Alliance, which he started in 2009. “I think it’s another string to my bow to try and drive the rest of the campaign home. We have got to get funding for everybody. And that’s been my priority now for some time. And if it helps there, then great. It’s wonderful.” Sir Alan said his work was far from finished, adding that he would pursue court action, if necessary, to get financial redress for the victims who took part in the original High Court action that helped expose the Horizon IT scandal. “I think the nation will support us if we have to go ahead with another case,” he said. The former sub-postmaster's dogged pursuit of the truth began after refusing to accept losses at his own post office which he took over in 1998. Had he ever thought about giving up and letting it go? “I could never do that. We’ve all seen the horror stories, and there are so many. I keep hearing from so many more these days who are coming out of the woodwork and stories that have never been told. I mean, they’re absolutely diabolical. What’s happened to people is very sad but at least they’re now starting to see some light at the end of the tunnel for themselves.” He described his work as the best unpaid job he’d ever had and said he was looking forward to having a holiday this summer. Read the piece here⏬ bbc.com/news/articles/c722kz… #MrBatesVsThePostOffice #MrBates #MrBatesVsPostOffice #MrBatesPBS #PostOfficeInquiry #SirAlanBates
36
170
13
782
33,673
I just hope that whom ever she represents now, doesn’t in the future need her assistance with another inquiry/criminal investigation. Clearly she thought this wouldn’t catchup with her. Even down-under is very well aware of this scandal.
The former top Post Office lawyer who will NOT be appearing at the inquiry has been tracked down. Jane MacLeod is in Australia. The @PostOffInquiry even offered to cover transport and hotel costs. Still no. No comment to us. Very short walk for her dog. bbc.co.uk/news/articles/czdd…
19
79
4
209
10,143
Mirror tracks down former Post Office IT chief Horizon inquiry insisted couldn't be found. Ex Post Office IT chief Mike Young insisted it wld hv bn easy for inquiry to find him & said he wld give evidence as accused Paula Vennells of trying to shift blame mirror.co.uk/news/uk-news/mi…
7
149
5
222
9,015
Post Office scandal: Police to deploy 80 detectives for criminal inquiry. Horizon Inquiry to report in 2025. Then police will investigate. CPS may levy charges in 2026. Legal wranglings will follow. Miscreants will escape. Why no criminal charges now? theguardian.com/business/art…
22
214
3
501
15,812
#PostOfficeScandal Latest piece for @SkyNews by @SkyNewsAdele & @SkyNewsEmilyJ Arriving in by cab and flanked once more by MET police officers Vennell’s was asked if she was ‘lying’‼️ Day 1 was tough but day 2 quietly worse. She then got into all the things she didn’t do (X is not long enough to list all those). “I never once withheld information” “I was not trying to close anything down” “I would not cover anything up” And it went on time and time again all day long❗️ Accused of putting the brand first above investigating miscarriages of justice. Asked if she had taken the advice of her PR guy who she appeared to rely on so heavily, Mark Davies (@markdavies67 ), of course she could not remember. I’m sure she remembers writing him an email saying that she attributed getting her CBE partly to him as he got the business through ‘very stormy waters’ and he ‘always got the big calls right’‼️ Then an email devastating to Vennell’s where she wrote about the mediation scheme from back in 2013 was that she hoped to ‘avoid or minimise compensation’‼️ Even though she wrote it herself or maybe it was her computer malfunctioning like Horizon writing things without her input ⌨️💻 , she would probably call it an ‘exception or an anomaly’ thanks to the IT expertise of her husband, she denied it meant what it said. There was a good exchange with Jason Beer KC about it. Watch the clip below👇 #MrBatesVsThePostOffice #MrBates #MrBatesVsPostOffice #MrBatesPBS #PostOfficeInquiry
25
74
3
244
64,679
#PostOfficeInquiry Tomorrow the real interrogation (with all due respect to Mr Beer who offers up his questioning in a more circumspect manner). I can't see PV handling confrontational inquisitiveness all too well Not best suited to ones who try to defend their mistakes
17
23
2
184
15,156
#PostOfficeScandal Yesterday @MarinaHyde from the @guardian was at @PostOffInquiry and she wrote up a piece on Paula Vennell's first day of testimony. Rev Vennells wept but couldn’t remember much about sending innocent subpostmasters to jail. All so long ago‼️ The former Post Office CEO Paula Vennells would like the victims of the most widespread miscarriage of justice in British legal history to know that she hasn’t actually done anything deliberately wrong, and that she honestly doesn’t understand how all this has happened. I guess she’s asking all the jailed and wrongly convicted subpostmasters to try to imagine being swept up in a Kafkaesque nightmare of undue blame. So … please add the murder of irony to her notional future charge sheet. The former @PostOffice CEO Paula Vennells would like the victims of the most widespread miscarriage of justice in British legal history to know that she hasn’t actually done anything deliberately wrong, and that she honestly doesn’t understand how all this has happened. I guess she’s asking all the jailed and wrongly convicted subpostmasters to try to imagine being swept up in a Kafkaesque nightmare of undue blame. So … please add the murder of irony to her notional future charge sheet. To Aldwych House in London, then, where Paula produced tears in time for the lunchtime bulletins and reprised them for the section in which her emails seemingly found her on a fishing expedition for other “contributory factors” that might have caused an appallingly persecuted subpostmaster to take his own life. Pressed early by the inquiry’s Jason Beer KC how on earth she hadn’t known what was going on, Paula explained: “I was too trusting.” Barely a quarter of an hour later this humblebrag had done a complete 180, as she said: “I was sometimes criticised at team development events for being too curious.” Was she? At one stage Vennells had even been unaware that her organisation employed a team of about 100 enforcers driving private prosecutions. Today they were hearing the testimony of an absolutely key figure in the Post Office scandal – who hasn’t uttered a word in public on it for almost 10 years, much to the anguish of the many subpostmasters packing the room to finally get a bit more clarity on how their lives were, y’know, ruined by the organisation she ran. Memorable exchanges were also available in the evidence. Take the texts between Paula and the former Royal Mail CEO Moya Greene from only earlier this year, which were projected excruciatingly on the big screen, and read like dialogue in a bad daytime detective drama. “I think you knew,” Greene typed to Vennells. “How could you not have known? … I can’t support you now after what I have learned.” Paula explained to the inquiry that her obliviousness was something to do with the lack of “corporate memory” about the birth of the Horizon system. Alas, Beer – and forgive the slide into legalese – simply didn’t have time for this shit, replying: “How come we’ve been able to find it out just by asking for the documents?” Watching Vennells today, I found her a wholly inadequate holy inadequate, and kept wondering what was really going on beneath the mandated contrition. Maybe she still hangs on to the secret conviction that subpostmasters were actually on the take, or being led into temptation, as one of her emails put it in a weirdo echo of the Lord’s prayer. Read the full piece here👇theguardian.com/commentisfre… #MrBatesVsThePostOffice #MrBates #MrBatesVsPostOffice #MrBatesPBS #PostOfficeInquiry #Vennells #PaulaVennells
9
58
1
121
3,464
This is hardcore.
#PostOfficeScandal At the end of todays @PostOffInquiry hearing I was outside with @alextomo from @Channel4News when Alwen Lyons left Alwydch House! He asked, “Your organisation sent innocent people to prison. Are you prepared for prison yourself⁉️” Pushed aside by her legal representatives, and responding I am doing my job. He then asks, “Will you be sending back your OBE? Paula Vennell’s sent back her award. Paula Vennell’s sent back her OBE, are you prepared to do the same❓” Tune in tonight for more at 7pm by @alextomo and @NanettevdLaan #MrBatesVsThePostOffice #MrBates #MrBatesVsPostOffice #MrBatesPBS #PostOfficeInquiry
18
46
2
181
24,621
#PostOfficeScandal Today is a landmark day for this scandal & for the @PostOffInquiry Former @PostOffice Network Director and then more importantly the CEO between 2012 and 2019 where we now know the organisation were made aware on many occaaions of problems with the Horizon system. Nobody seems to know why they were copied into emails, others didn’t read emails, many didn’t read the attachments to emails (supposedly) and even when they did the information was tightly controlled usually using legal privilege - which in many cases should not have applied. We have seen more emails and secret recordings in the last 24 hours to again suggest there has been a monumental cover-up of issues with Horizon in order to maintain the Post Office’s reputation and shield individuals from blame. Anyone want to guess how many ‘I do not recall or I do not remember’ we will hear today❓ Watch live on youtube from 09:45 to hear for the first time in public what she has got to say. Will she tell the truth, the whole truth and nothing but the truth⁉️ Or will she try to save her own skin❗️ Youtube link :- youtube.com/@postofficehoriz… #MrBatesVsThePostOffice #MrBates #MrBatesVsPostOffice #MrBatesPBS #PostOfficeInquiry
24
59
4
147
9,131
#PostOfficeScandal This is one of, if not the most abhorrent thing to come out of this scandal. What people did in the village of Horspath is appalling, that is not a strong enough word!! @VipinAPatel1 and his son @VarchasPatel are two of the kindest people you could meet and would go above and beyond to help anyone. What they have been subjected to as a family because of the actions of @PostOffice is a disgrace‼️ Under Paula Vennell’s watch the organisation doubled down against Postmasters which has denied justice for another decade. The @PostOffInquiry is still piecing together everything that happened, but all those responsible must be held to account. On Friday we heard from CFO Alisdair Cameron who in a ‘What went wrong’ document described the Post Office as having a culture that was “self-absorbed and defensive, it stopped us from dealing with Postmasters in a straightforward and acceptable way.” The worst part about this is the Post Office is an organisation owned by US the taxpayer and their actions were allowed to continue and encouraged by the sole shareholder, ‘the government’, via UKGI & BEIS (now @biztradegovuk ). Thoughts are with Vipin, his wife Jayshree & son Varchas ❤️ #MrBatesVsThePostOffice #MrBates #MrBatesVsPostOffice #MrBatesPBS #PostOfficeInquiry
In 2011, villagers wanted my father dead by publishing “wanted dead or alive posters” - in 2016 this 👇 Paula Vennells & Co during their tenure at Post Office need to be held accountable for the catastrophic harm on my father. #PostOfficeScandal #PostOfficeInquiry
14
106
4
299
28,425
Jane McLeod refusing to come back to the UK to appear at the inquiry next month. Why would anyone refuse, if they had done no wrong? Perhaps it's "privileged information"?
Today at the Post Office Inquiry a top lawyer for Post Office didn't bother to turn up to defend herself, she lives in another country so an Inquiry has no power over her. RT if it's time for Alan Bates to launch a criminal inquiry and have INTERPOL drag her here if necessary.
1
6
293
#PostOfficeScandal EXCLUSIVE by @SkyNewsAdele & @SkyNewsEmilyJ for @SkyNews Having worked with Sky on this investigation we can now reveal :- Sky News has seen documents that suggest failures by @DWP investigators - including that of a sub-postmaster who decided to plead not guilty and was acquitted of stealing by a jury. Prosecutions of sub postmasters by the Department for Work and Pensions could be "tainted" as Sky News reveals officials worked with now discredited @PostOffice investigators to secure convictions. Around 100 prosecutions of Post Office staff were led by the Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) between 2001 and 2006. A Sky News investigation, however, has discovered that information was shared between Post Office investigation teams and the DWP. Chair of the Justice Select Committee @CommonsJustice , Sir Robert Neill KC @neill_bob , said as a result DWP convictions "need to be looked at". "I hadn't been aware of that, for example, there may have been material in the DWP case as a result of joint investigations - which suggests a disclosure failure," he added. "I think that's the area they need to look at if we are saying their approach was tainted from the beginning - in the way the investigators adopted things - then joint operations I suspect would be just as tainted arguably as something where it has been the Post Office on its own." There is also a letter, from the then post affairs minister Stephen Timms @stephenctimms , which references the case of Roger Allen, a sub-postmaster from Norwich. Despite the Criminal Cases Review Commission deciding Mr Allen had grounds to appeal against his conviction - it was upheld by the Court of Appeal in 2021. Keren Simpson @KerenSimps606 , Roger's daughter, has vowed to fight to clear his name posthumously. DWP prosecutions are not covered in upcoming government legislation that will overturn Post Office convictions. This is despite us having seen more evidence that suggests the investigations by the DWP were flawed in some cases and failed to obtain the necessary transaction logs, and when they did they failed to properly examine them. You are supposed to follow all lines of inquiry both that points towards and away from the suspect, from the documents in one case it appears clear they did not do this. She describes her father as a "proud" and "honest" man who "couldn't face or deal" with the fact his conviction would not be overturned. She says "in the end he obviously gave up" and there is "very little surviving evidence" because of the passage of time. Sky News has also seen documents that suggest failures by DWP investigators in a different case in the 2000s. In one extract it says a "senior investigating officer" was "willing to admit in open court that (they) had been neglectful in (their) duty in securing evidence". Another document appears to show a failure to review transaction logs used as evidence against the sub-postmaster. Some logs appear to show that the accused did not cash the "dockets", used to collect pension payments. Other transaction logs indicate the sub-postmaster was not present at a particular branch when the theft was alleged to have occurred. Chris Head, former sub-postmaster and a campaigner for others, has also seen the documents and says they point to a "deeply flawed" DWP investigation. "They failed to obtain all transaction logs for the entirety of this case, but the ones that they have, they have they clearly haven't looked at." He believes there are "more cases out there" which could be "part of a miscarriage of justice". A Department for Work and Pensions spokesperson said: "We do not recognise these claims. Meanwhile, Lord Sikka @premnsikka has tabled an amendment in the House of Lords to the Post Office (Horizon System) Offences Bill to include all DWP convictions. Read the full piece here👇 news.sky.com/story/about-100… #MrBatesVsThePostOffice #MrBates #MrBatesVsPostOffice #MrBatesPBS #PostOfficeInquiry
10
86
5
150
21,981
#PostOfficeScandal Today at @PostOffInquiry we heard from former Chief Information Officer at @PostOffice Lesley Sewell. Some of the first words to come out of her mouth were.....see if you can guess....... 'I do not recall', surprise surprise‼️ She was at a very early stage in tears and visibly upset, make of that what you will, I don't think she ever understood the gravity of what she was involved in. Could or should, more have been done, I will leave that for you to judge. One of the most revealing lines in todays evidence was that she felt that she had to block the number of ex CEO Paula Vennell's for contacting her more than 5 years after she had left the Post Office, as she sought help to avoid an independent inquiry into the scandal. Sewell said in her witness statement that Vennell's contacted her four times in 2020 and 2021 by email, phone call and text message. She said she eventually blocked her after the forth time as "I did not feel comfortable with her contacting me." Sewell said that Vennell's had sent her an email which the inquiry is in possession of that she had been asked at short notice to appear before a BEIS Select Committee @CommonsBTC on all things Horizon/Sparrow and need to plug some memory gaps! My hope is this might help avoid an independent inquiry but to do so, I need to be well prepared.' What was feared about an inquiry? Is this more about an attempted cover-up? We will have to see🍿 I think from now on everyone needs to be asked did Vennell's contact you after she left the business. These would have been from private email accounts‼️ She was also directly contacted by the chief Horizon Architect 'Gareth Jenkins' at one stage, which Sewell describes as unusual. Lesley appears to be one of those people who was not qualified for the roles she held and had no real grasp on the true gravity of what was going on, lacked critical thinking to ask more searching questions or the authority to challenge on issues. Doesn't excuse her part but it says more about the people that appointed her in my view, completely out of her depth. Failings have been made those failings have to be lived with whatever consequences, if any that may follow, as they say ignorance is not an excuse. It is vital at a time when we are seeing scandal after scandal, to do the right thing. This leads to a wider discussion on the protection needed for those that speak out. Watch the full session of Lesley Sewell and I have included a short snippet below👇 Lesley Sewell AM : youtu.be/cA4SCjne_S0?si=2qX4… Lesley Sewell PM : youtu.be/-ysQCiR8nCQ?si=CtBs… #MrBatesVsThePostOffice #MrBates #MrBatesVsPostOffice #MrBatesPBS #PostOfficeInquiry
18
48
1
135
11,757
The story of The Great Post Office Scandal was told in a much talked about TV series, Mr Bates vs The Post Office and now The Bath Festival is hosting a fresh event on the case, with some of the key people in this long-running real-life drama. bathfestivals.org.uk/the-bat… @nickwallis
2
16
20
2,153