Pinned Tweet
Check out my current published series if you're interested. No, it's not that type of Infernal, I promise. However, this series is NOT for kids.
a.co/d/08AdfpkU
6
806
Roman Catholicism is a mission field. It is, by far, the largest false gospel in existence.
What I find sad about it is that Rome offers no peace. In Roman Catholicism, you have to earn your salvation. Of course, Rome doesn’t say it that way. There are a lot of words they use that they have changed the definitions of to better suit their teachings.
Such as “condign merit.” Which is, essentially, their way of trying to say that merit doesn’t actually mean merit even though it means merit.
Confusing? Yeah, I thought so too. It is, because nonsensical things tend to be confusing. “For by grace you have been saved through faith. And this is not your own doing; it is the gift of God, not a result of works, so that no one may boast” (Ephesians 2:8-9). “And to the one who does not work but believes in him who justifies the ungodly, his faith is counted as righteousness” (Romans 4:5).
The absolute best a Roman Catholic can hope for is Purgatory, which is them being cleansed by the literal fires of hell for some indeterminate amount of time that changes every so often. “When he had made purification for sins, he sat down at the right hand of the Majesty on high” (Hebrews 1:3). “But when Christ had offered for all time a single sacrifice for sins, he sat down at the right hand of God” (Hebrews 10:12). “For by a single offering he has perfected for all time those who are being sanctified” (Hebrews 10:14).
You have some Catholic apologists who will claim Purgatory is instant now, as an attempt to try and convert more Protestants who understandably recoil from the doctrine.
Think about that for a moment, though.
If you’re Roman Catholic, you cannot know if you have peace with God. Your absolute best hope is a short time burning in the fires of hell before you can then see God. “I write these things to you who believe in the name of the Son of God, that you may know that you have eternal life” (1 John 5:13).
Which is essentially telling Jesus “Sorry, but you’re not enough. You’re not enough to save me.” “It is finished” (John 19:30).
I recognize that Catholicism doesn’t see it that way. To a Roman Catholic, they are following Jesus by engaging in and believing this.
And my post here isn’t really trying to change that.
It’s a lament.
Because I do have peace with God. It’s not pride, it’s not a boast, I just have it and I know I have it because God tells me so through His word. “Therefore, since we have been justified by faith, we have peace with God through our Lord Jesus Christ” (Romans 5:1). “There is therefore now no condemnation for those who are in Christ Jesus” (Romans 8:1).
I pray you end up having it too.
1
63
I've personally stayed silent on the Samuel Sey situation for several reasons. One, I don't know him. I know he's a brother in Christ and I have no reason to doubt that, but I don't know him. Second, when you don't have a lot of information, it's generally a good idea to remain silent until you do. "Even a fool who keeps silent is considered wise; when he closes his lips, he is deemed intelligent" (Proverbs 17:28). I've never regretted keeping my mouth shut about a situation when I didn't think I knew enough to comment.
Third, I'm a small account. Hardly anyone will see it anyway, and that's fine. I don't crave followers, this isn't my career, and I don't make money from this. I don't care about numbers. I care about scripture, about God's word which is the foundational truth of all things.
So, with all of that being said, let me make one thing clear. I support deportations. Deportations should and need to happen. You cannot just ignore the laws of a country and waltz on in. "Let every person be subject to the governing authorities. For there is no authority except from God, and those that exist have been instituted by God" (Romans 13:1). Consistent with that, knowingly or unknowingly, Samuel was breaking the law and thus deserved his deportation.
Does that mean I don't have empathy for him and his wife and kids? No. I do. I have empathy for those in similar situations as well. But empathy is not the same thing as giving a pass to people. We have laws. We must obey them as Christians, and from what I've seen Samuel say, he would agree with me. "Be subject for the Lord's sake to every human institution" (1 Peter 2:13). His actions match this. He complied with all actions ICE took against him. He fought it where he was supposed to fight it and continues to do so.
Now, did Samuel knowingly commit fraud? Should he fight it? I don't know. I don't think there is necessarily enough information to determine this. I don't want to think he did, because I don't want to think that of my brothers and sisters in Christ. But the truth is, we are sinners. "For all have sinned and fall short of the glory of God" (Romans 3:23). Being Christian doesn't change the fact that we have flesh that we fight daily. We stumble. We lie. We fall to sexual sin, wrath, pride, envy, and more besides. We lose control of our tongues. "If we say we have no sin, we deceive ourselves, and the truth is not in us" (1 John 1:8).
This happens. That is reality. Samuel Sey isn't immune to that. Neither am I. Neither is anyone reading this. So while I may not want to admit that he could have knowingly done this, it is certainly possible that he did, and I won't blind myself to that. That's as far as I'll take it, though, because I just don't know enough. I cannot see Samuel's inner thoughts. God knows. I leave it with Him.
So, I do pray for Sam and his family. Just as I pray for everyone. Even those I don't want to pray for and even those who I know hate me. "But I say to you, Love your enemies and pray for those who persecute you" (Matthew 5:44). It's what we should do. God will take care of this in His way, and I trust that.
3
176
Let go of the need to be right.
The truth is, I still struggle with this. I struggle with it in my personal life, my work life, and just life in general.
Heck, my need to be right, ironically, drove me to Jesus. I went looking for information on whether or not God was real so I could be informed and be right. Just a little aside on how God uses things for His ends in so many ways.
The desire to be right isn’t wrong in every sense. But especially when it comes to being wronged, I think we as Christians should be more aware of it. Jesus said, “If anyone would come after me, let him deny himself and take up his cross and follow me” (Matthew 16:24). That includes the part of us that wants to win every argument and nurse every slight.
Yes, if we are the wronged party, you’re going to be right. And so what? You’re right about how bad you feel? So now you feel good about your misery? Congrats, I guess. Paul wrote, “Do not be overcome by evil, but overcome evil with good” (Romans 12:21). Holding on to being right usually just leaves you overcome.
And I say that to myself as well, because how often have I sat in righteous anger about something? Some things do deserve that anger, but at the end of the day, I ultimately have to leave it with God. “Vengeance is mine, I will repay, says the Lord” (Romans 12:19).
If we cannot extend a hand of forgiveness and love where we reasonably can and in reasonable ways (I’m not advocating for releasing every murderer, for example), mostly by letting go of the anger and bitterness in our hearts, then why should God do so with us? Jesus was clear: “For if you forgive others their trespasses, your heavenly Father will also forgive you, but if you do not forgive others their trespasses, neither will your Father forgive your trespasses” (Matthew 6:14-15).
Our sin nailed Jesus to that cross. We deserved hell. That’s what we deserved. “For the wages of sin is death, but the free gift of God is eternal life in Christ Jesus our Lord” (Romans 6:23). Jesus gave us something we didn’t deserve. Grace.
All of that is to say that because we have something we do not deserve, and can never earn, we should portray that in our lives toward others. We should extend that toward others. “Be kind to one another, tenderhearted, forgiving one another, as God in Christ forgave you” (Ephesians 4:32).
Let the other person be right. Who cares? Someone treating you poorly? Treat them with kindness. Someone insults you? Agree with them. Who cares! “If your enemy is hungry, feed him; if he is thirsty, give him something to drink” (Romans 12:20).
I’m not saying abandon all discourse. I’m saying that we shouldn’t allow our attitudes to be dictated by anyone else. “Do not be conformed to this world, but be transformed by the renewal of your mind” (Romans 12:2).
We choose how we approach every day, and I want to keep trying to approach it while walking with Jesus, despite how much I stumble every single day.
59
Lee Monroe retweeted
I just listened to these two Calvinists defending @gui_bignon_theo against @DineshDSouza. Here is a summary of their answer and my rebuttal:
youtube.com/live/4IsHtJd5XGc…
1) Their answer to “Does God make you do it” (regarding sin):
No. God does not coerce or force you to sin against your will. You do the sinful act because you want to, according to your own desires. God determines the desires, brain states, circumstances, and the act itself, but because you willingly act on those desires, the act is yours and you remain fully responsible. God has righteous intent behind what He determines, so He is not the moral author of the sin. The distinction is between ultimate determination (with good purposes) and proximate willing of the evil (by the creature).
I believe that is a fair representation of their answer. Tell me if you disagree. 🤷♂️
2) Why this answer is insufficient within the compatibilistic framework:
Compatibilism reduces “freedom” to acting according to one’s strongest desires without external coercion. Once God exhaustively determines the desires themselves (the internal states that produce the choice), the “I wanted to” is fully determined by God’s decree. There are no alternative possibillities; the outcome could not have been otherwise and the source of the evil desire is the divine decree.
The distinction between “God makes you do it” and “God determines your desires so that you freely do it” collapses into a verbal distinction. It’s semantics. God still originates the sinful inclination and ensures the act by controlling the very will that “chooses” it. This leaves the creature as the proximate instrument of a predetermined outcome rather than the true origin of the sin, which fails to preserve genuine secondary causation or the force of texts such as 1 John 2:16 and James 1:13–14 that locate the source of temptation and sin in the world or the creature’s own desires, not in a divine causal decree. The framework therefore does not escape the implication that God is the ultimate source of the sinful act it seeks to avoid.
Lee Monroe retweeted
It wasn’t private equity that killed BioWare. It wasn’t capitalism. “Dragon Age: The Veilguard” lost about $200 million.
There is no economic system and no conceivable owner who keeps a video game studio that loses that much money operating.
Why private equity acquisitions like the one that just claimed BioWare are so dreaded pcgamer.com/gaming-industry/…
Lee Monroe retweeted
In the time of the Reformation it was a known practice of the Catholic priests to deny the people the cup during communion.
They would give them the bread but not allow them to drink of the cup. The logic was that these people might accidentally spill a drop and dishonor the blood of Christ. So, people routinely went forward for communion and were disallowed full participation and obedience to Christ, who instituted both bread and cup in remembrance of his sacrifice and in anticipation of his return.
In response to the Protestant complaint that this practice violates Jesus’ commands, the Catholic Church addressed it at the Council of Trent. This is an ecumenical council and is infallible (as far as they are concerned). The council decided that it would be official Catholic teaching that laity who eat only the bread and are refused the cup have done enough. They don’t need the cup.
A small but important moment demonstrating how false teaching gets enshrined and how Catholics are bound by their magisterium in ways that can keep them from obeying Jesus.
Countless Catholics will go to Mass this Sunday and be given only the bread, being denied the cup. Though they do make some exceptions for special feast days. Jesus and the apostles did one thing and the Roman Catholic authority does another.
I'm not surprised BioWare went under. Not at all. Look, I stand by the fact that an artist can make whatever art they want. You want to shove an ideology into your games? Feel free.
However, there isn't any obligation for people to buy said art.
If you choose to make art that deliberately alienates a large portion of the people who would potentially buy your games, don't be shocked when it fails.
BioWare hollowed out their company. They were woke, and supremely proud of being so.
It would have been one thing if they just included the wokeness as possible choices a player could make.
But they didn't do that with some of their games. They shoved it in your face.
That's why a game like BG3 works. The player doesn't have to engage in any same-sex relationships if they don't want to.
They can make whatever character they want and ignore every companion if they want.
That's the difference.
So, yeah, make what art you want, but remember that no one is obligated to buy it.
1
81
Lee Monroe retweeted
Of course everything said here is a lie. They didnt "include an lgbtq character", they made Leftist ideology central to every element of the story across multiple games while simultaneously treating straight males as pariahs to be demeaned whenever possible.
They chose orthodoxy over story, over fans, over everything.
And now the ideologues want to blame everything and everyone but themselves when it all fails like we told them it would.
As always, all they do is lie.
The replies to this are a cesspool of fake gamers saying BioWare deserves this for including lgbtq character in dragon age, except the last dragon age game was by all accounts good—they just don’t actually want good games
Readers added context they thought people might want to know
Dragon Age: The Veilguard received mixed reception: critics averaged 82-84/100, but user scores hit 4.0/10 on Metacritic with widespread complaints on writing, combat, and design. It missed EA sales targets, contributing to BioWare's closure.
polygon.com/analysis/52029…
eurogamer.net/bioware-closin…
Part of me wishes I'd never looked into Calvinism. Before, I was somewhat ignorant of what deterministic Calvinists actually believe.
Now that I'm not, I find it very hard to take a lot of what they say seriously.
Not because I'm casting them out of the kingdom. On the contrary, they are brothers and sisters and I love them.
No, it's the logic. If you're holding to determinism, then there's very little reason to bother disagreeing with anyone or speaking out about anything.
Whatever a person believes, they believe it because God determined they would. And if that's the case, then it is right that they believe it, because God decided before the foundation of the world that this is what they would hold. Why argue with a conclusion God Himself fixed?
The same problem shows up with actions.
A woman who gets an abortion did what God determined she would do. Abortion is obviously a sin, and yet under determinism God determined that abortion for His good ends. So on that view it's good that she did it, because it leads to the good God had already planned. That doesn't make any sense to me.
This is why I struggle to take some of it seriously. Why speak out against anything? Why try to convince anyone of anything? If God determined both the belief and the act, then the outcome is already what He wanted.
Saying "God determined the means" doesn't solve it for me either. The means are still determined. The person still couldn't have believed or acted otherwise.
Either way, you can't really say someone is wrong without also saying God determined them to be wrong. And that just collapses. I don't see how you hold both.
21
I'm not usually on board with mockery or anything, but man, I have to agree this is a pretty big slip up.
1
26
Lee Monroe retweeted
I must admit, the opening criticism made me smile. Apparently, going back to the Old Testament passages from which Paul draws his Potter, clay, Jacob, Esau and Pharaoh language is “not actually exegeting Romans 9.” Then, within a few paragraphs, you take us to Genesis, Exodus 33, Exodus 4, Exodus 5, even bring in John Piper, and return to Romans 9 carrying conclusions gathered from all of them. 😂 Sir, apparently leaving Romans 9 is permissible after all. The only question seems to be which direction one is allowed to travel.
And I have absolutely no problem with your going to Genesis and Exodus. You should go there. Paul quotes them. My problem is with calling it “distraction” when someone follows Paul's imagery back into Israel's Scriptures, but calling it “exegesis” when you do precisely the same thing. Even more strangely, you accuse me of refusing to stay with Paul's argument while stopping your theological conclusion before Paul has finished explaining the very problem Romans 9 introduced.
So let us stay with Paul. Really stay with him.
You correctly identify the question haunting Romans 9. Paul has just celebrated God's saving work in Romans 8, yet so many of his fellow Israelites remain outside Christ. Has God's word failed? Paul says no: “For they are not all Israel, which are of Israel” (Romans 9:6). Physical descent from Abraham does not, by itself, make someone a child of promise. On that much we agree.
But you then move from that proposition to something considerably larger: that God eternally and unconditionally selected particular individuals to receive the grace that infallibly produces faith, while passing over the remainder, so that their unbelief and destruction are the inevitable result of His decision. The problem is that Paul has not said that yet. That is the very proposition requiring demonstration.
And this is where allowing Paul to finish his own argument becomes rather inconvenient.
At the end of Romans 9, Paul asks why Israel did not attain what it pursued. He actually uses the word “Wherefore?” Why, Paul? Here is the perfect place to answer, “Because before they were born God determined not to grant them the grace by which alone they could believe.”
But Paul doesn't say that.
He says Israel failed “because they sought it not by faith, but as it were by the works of the law” (Romans 9:32). Meanwhile the Gentiles attained righteousness, “even the righteousness which is of faith” (9:30). That explanation is not something I imported from Jeremiah, Ezekiel, or some other framework. It is how Romans 9 ends.
And Paul isn't finished. Chapter numbers were not inserted into his original letter, and I'm sure you know that. Romans 10 begins with the same Israel and the same salvation problem: “Brethren, my heart's desire and prayer to God for Israel is, that they might be saved.” Paul says they are ignorant of God's righteousness and “have not submitted themselves unto the righteousness of God” (10:1–3). He speaks of confessing, believing, calling, preaching and hearing, and then says, “they have not all obeyed the gospel” (10:16).
Then Paul asks the question himself: “But I say, Have they not heard?” His answer is yes (10:18). And the chapter closes with God's own description of these people: “All day long I have stretched forth my hands unto a disobedient and gainsaying people” (10:21).
Please notice what has happened. The people whose condition supposedly proves an unconditional divine decision not to grant them saving faith are described by Paul as people who did not pursue righteousness by faith, did not submit to God's righteousness, did not obey the Gospel, heard God's message, and remained disobedient while God stretched out His hands to them.
Then Romans 11 becomes even harder for your reading. Paul explains why the natural branches were broken off: “Because of unbelief they were broken off, and thou standest by faith.” (Romans 11:20)
Paul could hardly have chosen more unfortunate words if his purpose were to teach that faith and unbelief have nothing meaningful to do with the distinction he has been discussing. And notice what he immediately tells the Gentile believer: “Be not highminded, but fear.” Standing “by faith” apparently does not create the boasting problem your argument says it must create. Paul can say in the same sentence that Israel was broken off because of unbelief, that the Gentile stands by faith, and therefore that the Gentile must not boast.
Then comes the sentence I simply cannot reconcile with the idea that these people constitute an eternally immutable class created for destruction: “And they also, if they abide not still in unbelief, shall be graffed in: for God is able to graff them in again.” (Romans 11:23)
Read that slowly sir. These are broken-off natural branches. Their present condition is unbelief. Yet Paul contemplates their not continuing in that unbelief and says God will graft them in again. He even describes Israel's hardening as “in part” and “until” the fullness of the Gentiles comes in (11:25). Whatever Romans 9 means, Romans 11 will not permit us to turn every hardened Israelite into an individual whom God unconditionally created for inevitable eternal destruction.
This is why I find your “pots are pots!” argument particularly revealing. You write that there cannot be another possibility in which the pots respond because, “pots don't have such a capacity! Pots are pots!”
But sir, literal pots don't sin either. Literal pots don't disbelieve. They don't hear the Gospel. They don't reject Christ. They don't harden their hearts. They don't repent. They don't answer back to God. And literal olive branches don't believe either. Yet Paul says branches were broken off because of unbelief and others stand by faith.
You cannot literalize the helplessness of pottery when it serves determinism and then suddenly remember that Paul is speaking metaphorically when every other property of pottery becomes inconvenient. The Potter/clay imagery establishes God's authority over His creatures. It does not follow that every physical incapacity of clay becomes a theological statement about the human will.
And remarkably, Paul himself proves this.
Elsewhere he uses almost the same vessel categories: “some to honour, and some to dishonour.” Then Paul immediately says, “If a man therefore purge himself from these, he shall be a vessel unto honour, sanctified, and meet for the master's use.” (2 Timothy 2:20–21).
No, I am not claiming 2 Timothy 2 is the exegetical context of Romans 9. Please don't answer an argument I haven't made. I am addressing your particular inference that the vessel metaphor itself rules out responsive agency because “pots are pots.” Paul uses vessel imagery and explicitly speaks of a person's response in connection with becoming a vessel unto honour. So that inference cannot simply be extracted from the metaphor.
And now perhaps we can stop pretending Jeremiah 18 is some desperate excursion taken to escape Romans 9.
God tells Jeremiah to go “to the potter's house.” Jeremiah sees a vessel, clay, a potter, and the vessel being made and remade. Then God Himself interprets the scene: “O house of Israel, cannot I do with you as this potter?... as the clay is in the potter's hand, so are ye in mine hand.” (Jeremiah 18:6).
And what does the Potter Himself say next?
If God announces destruction against a nation and “that nation...turn from their evil,” God says He will relent concerning the judgment pronounced against it. If He announces blessing and that nation does evil and refuses His voice, the announced good is withheld. Then God turns directly to Judah and says, “return ye now every one from his evil way.” Their response? “We will walk after our own devices.” (Jeremiah 18:7–12).
So when I went to Jeremiah, I wasn't running away from the Potter. I went looking for Him.
And there, when God Himself explains His Potter-and-clay imagery concerning Israel, divine sovereignty and meaningful human response are sitting in the same passage without the slightest embarrassment. The Potter has absolute authority over the clay, yet the Potter Himself tells the clay to turn and explicitly describes a changed response as followed by a changed judicial outcome.
That does not mean Jeremiah 18 automatically settles every question in Romans 9. It does mean that your assertion that bringing Jeremiah's Potter into a discussion of Paul's Potter is illegitimate “context importing” is extraordinarily difficult to maintain. Paul is reasoning about Israel using Israel's Scriptures and Israel's prophetic imagery. Biblical theology does not become bad exegesis merely because the broader biblical context makes a theological system uncomfortable.
Now consider Jacob and Esau. You emphasize, correctly, that God's declaration occurred before they had done good or evil. I affirm the text exactly as written. God's election is not payment for works.
But what did God actually announce before their birth?
Genesis 25:23 says, “Two nations are in thy womb, and two manner of people shall be separated from thy bowels...and the elder shall serve the younger.” Paul quotes the latter part. Then “Jacob have I loved, but Esau have I hated” comes not from Genesis but Malachi 1, where Jacob and Esau are being discussed in connection with Israel and Edom.
That doesn't prove individual salvation is absent from Romans 9. It plainly isn't absent from Romans 9–11. But it does mean you cannot simply replace the Old Testament referents with “Jacob individually elected to eternal salvation before birth; Esau individually passed over for eternal damnation before birth” and then announce that Paul has said it. God's freedom in choosing the line through which His covenant purpose proceeds is explicit. The additional soteriological construction must still be demonstrated.
Then we arrive at Pharaoh.
I affirm without qualification: God hardened Pharaoh. Romans 9:18 says so. Exodus says so. I also affirm Exodus 4:21, where God announces beforehand that He will harden Pharaoh. God's sovereign purpose in the Exodus is not something I need to explain away.
But why does your reading seem to need half of Exodus to disappear?
Before Exodus first says, “the LORD hardened the heart of Pharaoh” in Exodus 9:12, we have already watched Pharaoh resist God's command repeatedly. Exodus 8:15 says Pharaoh “hardened his heart.” Exodus 8:32 says “Pharaoh hardened his heart at this time also.” Later Pharaoh admits, “I have sinned this time: the LORD is righteous, and I and my people are wicked” (9:27), yet 9:34 says “he sinned yet more, and hardened his heart.” Exodus nevertheless also says God hardened him. I believe all of those sentences.
The question, therefore, is not whether God hardens. He does. The question is whether “God hardens” means “God unconditionally determined Pharaoh's unbelief from eternity by withholding the only grace by which he could possibly respond, and then punished him for the unbelief that was thereby unavoidable.”
Where does Exodus say that? Where does Romans 9 say that?
That is the theological machinery your conclusion requires, but repeating “He hardens whom He wills” does not establish your definition of hardening. God's judicial act of hardening a rebel and God's causally determining the rebellion for which He hardens him are not the same proposition.
In fact, Scripture gives us a recognizable pattern of judicial hardening. Romans 1 says people suppress truth, exchange God's truth for a lie, and then repeatedly says, “God gave them up” (Romans 1:18–28). Second Thessalonians 2 speaks of people who “received not the love of the truth, that they might be saved,” and then says, “for this cause God shall send them strong delusion” (2 Thessalonians 2:10–11). Human rebellion and divine judicial action are not enemies. Scripture can affirm both.
And Paul has already given us another extraordinary piece of information before we ever reach Romans 9. He speaks of God's “goodness and forbearance and longsuffering” leading a person toward repentance, but says that “after thy hardness and impenitent heart” that person “treasurest up unto thyself wrath.” (Romans 2:4–5).
Keep those words in mind when Romans 9:22 appears: God “endured with much longsuffering the vessels of wrath fitted to destruction.”
Paul's language is fascinatingly asymmetrical. The vessels of wrath are katērtismena eis apōleian, fitted/prepared for destruction. Then verse 23 speaks of vessels of mercy “which he had afore prepared unto glory.” With the vessels of mercy, Paul explicitly identifies God as the one who prepared them beforehand. He does not use that same construction concerning the vessels of wrath.
I am not going to commit the opposite error and insist the grammar proves “they prepared themselves.” It doesn't settle that by itself. But neither are you entitled to silently rewrite verse 22 as “vessels whom God created and unconditionally prepared beforehand for destruction.” Paul knew how to say that kind of thing. In the very next verse he explicitly says God “afore prepared” the vessels of mercy.
Your statement, therefore, “They are said to have been specifically ‘prepared for destruction.’ That is their purpose,” contains the very problem I have been pointing out. “Prepared for destruction” is Paul's language. “That is their purpose” is yours. And when you proceed to say there “must be vessels prepared for destruction” so that God's mercy can be displayed to the elect, you have gone beyond even that. Paul says God demonstrates wrath and makes His power known while enduring vessels of wrath with much longsuffering. He does not say God needed to create a class of human beings for inevitable damnation so another class could appreciate grace.
That distinction becomes enormous once Romans 2:4–5 is allowed to remain in Paul's letter. Paul has already connected God's longsuffering with repentance and the sinner's own hardness with accumulating wrath. So when the same apostle later speaks of God enduring vessels of wrath “with much longsuffering,” I am not prepared to empty “longsuffering” of the moral texture Paul himself has already given it merely because a theological framework requires these people never to have had any possibility except destruction.
There is another leap in your treatment of Romans 9:16. Paul says, “So then it is not of him that willeth, nor of him that runneth, but of God that sheweth mercy.” Amen. Mercy originates in God. Man does not earn it, initiate it, compel it or place God under obligation.
But then you make Paul's statement answer another question. You take “mercy does not originate in human willing or running” and make it mean “faith therefore cannot be a genuine condition of receiving mercy unless God first irresistibly causes faith in selected individuals.” Paul doesn't say that.
Indeed, Romans has already distinguished believing from working: “But to him that worketh not, but believeth...” (Romans 4:5). Paul can simultaneously deny that salvation is of works and insist that justification is through faith. Faith therefore does not become meritorious merely because one person believes while another refuses to believe. Otherwise Paul's entire contrast between faith and works collapses.
And Romans 11 makes this almost impossible to miss. Paul says, “because of unbelief they were broken off, and thou standest by faith,” and immediately warns, “Be not highminded.” Apparently Paul did not share the fear that acknowledging faith as the distinguishing condition automatically gives the believer grounds for boasting. The believer contributes no atonement, no righteousness, no grace, no Christ, no resurrection and no merit. Receiving a gift does not make the recipient the benefactor.
This is why I don't accept the false choice your response keeps presenting. Either Calvinistic unconditional individual election is true, or salvation ultimately rests upon autonomous human will. Either God determines which individual believes, or man is sovereign. Either God prepares some people for glory and others for destruction, or “the pots prepare themselves.”
Those are not the only biblical possibilities.
God can initiate. God can reveal. God can call. God can convict. God can draw. God can show mercy. God can warn. God can endure with longsuffering. God can judge. God can judicially harden. God can accomplish His purposes even through rebels. And the human being can still be genuinely responsible for believing or refusing the truth God places before him. Scripture repeatedly holds those truths together without asking permission from either determinism or autonomous-human-will theology.
So I am happy to accept your challenge: let us exegete Romans 9. But then let us really exegete it.
Let us not stop at “Jacob have I loved” without asking where Paul obtained the quotation. Let us not stop at Pharaoh being hardened while deleting the narrative in which Pharaoh repeatedly hardens himself. Let us not turn “not of him that willeth” into “therefore faith is irresistibly caused” when Paul never writes those words. Let us not change “fitted to destruction” into “God unconditionally prepared them beforehand for destruction” when Paul explicitly supplies that agency and “beforehand” language only in the next verse concerning vessels of mercy.
And above all, let Paul finish speaking.
Let him reach Romans 9:32 and tell us Israel failed “because they sought it not by faith.” Let him reach Romans 10 and describe God stretching out His hands to a disobedient people. Let him reach Romans 11:20 and tell us plainly, “because of unbelief they were broken off.” Then let him reach verse 23 and tell those broken-off people that “if they abide not still in unbelief, shall be graffed in.”
If your interpretation of Romans 9 requires Paul's explanation in Romans 11 to become an embarrassing complication, perhaps the problem isn't that everybody else refuses to exegete Romans 9. Perhaps we stopped Paul too soon.
I have no desire to rescue human pride from Romans 9. Let Romans 9 demolish it. God owes mercy to nobody. The Potter remains Potter. The creature never becomes Creator. Salvation remains entirely of grace, Christ remains the only ground of our salvation, and nobody will stand before God boasting that his works purchased eternal life.
But neither will I protect a theological framework by making Paul's metaphors say things Paul never says, turning judicial hardening into divine causation of unbelief without demonstration, or freezing people into immutable categories when Paul himself says the broken-off can be grafted in again if they do not continue in unbelief.
The Potter is sovereign enough to judge rebellious clay without first having to create the rebellion for which He judges it.
And when the Potter Himself says, “Return ye now every one from his evil way,” I intend to believe that He means what He says.
Replying to @YinKysmileS
Since posting small books is the thing these days (this one is 2,800+ words), here is my response (3,400 words). No, not a direct response to the "don't actually exegete Romans 9...try to distract from it by going to other texts and importing contexts Paul never brings in, and which would, in fact, destroy his argument, but hope nobody notices since the natural man detests what Romans 9 is saying anyway" argument. Instead, here is my exegesis from TPF. Just compare how the two sides approach the issue: one, straight to the text itself. The other...everywhere else first, then, make application to the text, not from exegesis, but from conclusions drawn from other contexts. It's pretty clear.
This portion of Paul’s reasoned, organized argument regarding the nature of salvation comes after the announcement of the tremendous blessings of eternal salvation found in chapter 8. Immediately the Apostle must face a crucial issue: what of the Jews? Surely Paul had heard this many times in his public ministry: “If this gospel message you proclaim, Paul, is so wonderful, why is it that only a small number of Jews embrace it, while the majority of the covenant people reject it? Are not your main opponents the Jews, to whom the promises were made? Are you not just a renegade Jew who has left the faith?” Such accusations must have been common place in the public disputations with the Jews. And upon speaking of God’s work of predestining, calling, justifying, and glorifying, one can just hear these objections growing in volume. “Oh come now, Paul, if God is so sovereign and powerful, then why do His very people, the Jews, by and large reject Christ?” It is to this issue that Paul now turns.
In Romans 9:1-5, Paul lays out his heart’s desire along with the true privileges granted to physical Israel:
I am telling the truth in Christ, I am not lying, my conscience testifies with me in the Holy Spirit, that I have great sorrow and unceasing grief in my heart. For I could wish that I myself were accursed, separated from Christ for the sake of my brethren, my kinsmen according to the flesh, who are Israelites, to whom belongs the adoption as sons, and the glory and the covenants and the giving of the Law and the temple service and the promises, whose are the fathers, and from whom is the Christ according to the flesh, who is over all, God blessed forever. Amen.
Paul has not forgotten the Jews. Strong emotion fills his words as he swears that he has sorrow and unceasing grief in his heart over the hard-heartedness of the Jewish people. He even goes so far as to say that he would be willing to be cut off from Christ if this would only bring his brethren to salvation. It should be noted that this immediately raises an important point: Paul is speaking of individual salvation. It makes no sense to say “I could wish myself were accursed for the sake of the nation of Israel so that it might be returned to a position of receiving national privileges and favor.”
The next verse is vitally important and provides the key to one of the great controversies in interpretation of the rest of the chapter:
But it is not as though the word of God has failed. For they are not all Israel who are descended from Israel. (Romans 9:6)
We can surely understand Paul’s concern: his ministry had often been charged with teaching a doctrine that made it appear as if the word of God (found in the promises to Israel) had failed due to the rejection of Christ by the Jews. But Paul is quick to reject this errant assertion. His response must be understood. “For they are not all Israel who are descended from Israel.” Why has the word of God not failed? Because the accusation is based upon a false premise. Just because a person is a physical descendant of Israel does not mean this person is truly an Israelite. The rejection of those who are only physically Jews but not spiritually so is not a valid basis upon which to say the promises have been made void. Paul expands upon this point:
Nor are they all children because they are Abraham’s descendants, but: “THROUGH ISAAC YOUR DESCENDANTS WILL BE NAMED.” That is, it is not the children of the flesh who are children of God, but the children of the promise are regarded as descendants. For this is the word of promise: “AT THIS TIME I WILL COME, AND SARAH WILL HAVE A SON.” (Romans 9:7-9)
The promises remain valid since they were only the possession of the “children of promise” from the beginning. Two truths immediately come to our attention: first, God determined who was, and who was not, a child of promise. This is all God’s work. Secondly, Paul is speaking of the salvation of individuals. When he says that not all who are descended from Israel are truly children of promise, who is he referring to? Is he not speaking of persons within the body of the nation of Israel? Who are these children of promise if not people? Remember the accusation to which he responds: “Look, Paul! Your gospel teaches that these Jewish opponents of yours who oppose Christ and His gospel will be accursed! You nullify the word of God!” But Paul’s response is, “No, I do not, for simply being a physical descendant of Israel does not make you a true Israelite. God has always had an elect people that He chooses and it is not an external matter, based upon race or nationality.” And it is this last point that Paul takes up beginning in verse 9. But the key is this: Paul is not talking about nations and he is talking about God’s sovereign election in salvation, for it was God’s right and freedom to limit His promises to the children of promise, and not to anyone else.
God has always worked this way, Paul teaches. Salvation has always been under His control. God has never been forced to act upon the dictates of human choice or decision. He demonstrates this from Israel’s own history:
And not only this, but there was Rebekah also, when she had conceived twins by one man, our father Isaac; for though the twins were not yet born and had not done anything good or bad, so that God’s purpose according to His choice would stand, not because of works but because of Him who calls, it was said to her, “THE OLDER WILL SERVE THE YOUNGER.” Just as it is written, “JACOB I LOVED, BUT ESAU I HATED.” (Romans 9:10-13)
The declaration of “God’s purpose according to His choice” (or “election”) is the keystone of this section. Everything points to this one assertion. The pronouncement by God that the older would serve the younger was made on the basis of a choice by God (dare we say a “free choice”?) that was made before their birth and before they could “do” anything good or bad. Paul’s emphasis is upon the independence and freedom of God’s choice. There was nothing in the twins that determined the choice (which is the point of stating that the pronouncement was made before the twins had done “anything good or bad”). Just so that this would not be missed, Paul clarifies and emphasizes his concern: “not because of works but because of Him who calls.” Literally the text reads “from works…from the One calling,” again making the same point: the ground of choice, the source of election, is solely in God, not in man. John Piper gave excellent insight into this passage when he wrote,
First, with the use of the preposition ἐξ Paul makes explicit that God’s decision to treat Esau and Jacob differently is not merely prior to their good or evil deeds but is also completely independent of them. God’s electing purpose (Rom 9:11c) and his concrete prediction (9:12c) are in no way based on the distinctives Esau and Jacob have by birth or by action. This rules out the notion of the early Greek and Latin commentators that election is based on God’s foreknowledge of men’s good works. Second, Rom 9:12b enlarges on 9:11b by going beyond the negation of human distinctives as the ground for God’s predestining of Esau and Jacob. It makes the positive affirmation that the true ground of this election is God himself, “the one who calls.” The intended force of the phrase “not from works but from the one who calls” is felt most strongly when one contrasts it with the similar Pauline phrase “not from works but from faith.” In Paul’s thinking the latter phrase describes the event of justification (Rom 9:32; Gal 2:16), never the event of election or predestination. Paul never grounds the “electing purpose of God” in man’s faith. The counterpart to works in conjunction with election (as opposed to justification) is always God’s own call (Rom 9:12b) or his own grace (Rom 11:6). The predestination and call of God precede justification (Rom 8:29f) and have no ground in any human act, not even faith. This is why Paul explicitly says in Rom 9:16 that God’s bestowal of mercy on whomever he wills is based neither on human willing (which would include faith) nor on human running (which would include all activity).
This is likewise the implication of verse 13, where God speaks of His choice of Jacob over Esau. Much is made of the terms “loved” and “hated” here, and we will see how these terms are to be applied when responding to CBF’s commentary.
The immediate response that is offered to the assertion of the Potter’s freedom to do with His creation as He sees fit is, “But, doesn’t that make God unjust?” Paul had “heard it all before” and was ready with a response:
What shall we say then? There is no injustice with God, is there? May it never be! For He says to Moses, “I WILL HAVE MERCY ON WHOM I HAVE MERCY, AND I WILL HAVE COMPASSION ON WHOM I HAVE COMPASSION.” So then it does not depend on the man who wills or the man who runs, but on God who has mercy. (Romans 9:14-16)
Paul is ready with an Old Testament example to buttress his arguments: Exodus 33. This tremendous passage contains themes that find their full expression only in the New Testament’s full revelation of the doctrines of God’s free and sovereign grace. God showed mercy and compassion to Moses, choosing to reveal His glory as an act of grace. We must understand, in light of the prevailing attitude of the world around us, that God’s mercy, if it is to be mercy at all, must be free. Literally the text speaks of “mercying” and “compassioning,” again verbs of action that find their subject in God and their object in those chosen by His decision. It does not say, “I will have mercy on those who fulfill the conditions I have laid down as the prerequisite of my plan of salvation.” Both the “source” of compassion and mercy and the individual application find their ultimate ground only in the free choice of God, not of man.
This divine truth, so offensive to the natural man, could not find a clearer proclamation than Romans 9:16. We truly must ask, if this passage does not deny to the will of man the all-powerful position of final say in whether the entire work of the Triune God in salvation will succeed or fail, what passage possibly could? What stronger terms could be employed? The verse begins, “so then,” drawing from the assertion of God that mercy and compassion are His to freely give. Next comes the negative particle, “not,” which negates everything that follows in the clause. Two human activities are listed: willing and literally “running,” or striving. Human choice and human action. Paul puts it bluntly: it is not “of the one willing” nor is it “of the one running.” Paul uses two singular present active participles. The fact that they are singular shows us again the personal nature of the passage. The interpretation that attempts to limit Romans 9 to “nations” cannot begin to explain how nations “will” or “run.” In contrast to these Paul uses a present active participle to describe God’s act of “mercying,” showing mercy. Man may strive through his will and his endeavors, but God must show mercy.
Lest someone think, “Well, yes, God shows mercy and initiates salvation, and only then does the will of man freely embrace it,” as is argued constantly in CBF, Paul closes the door by giving as his own interpretation of his argument the example of Pharaoh:
For the Scripture says to Pharaoh, “FOR THIS VERY PURPOSE I RAISED YOU UP, TO DEMONSTRATE MY POWER IN YOU, AND THAT MY NAME MIGHT BE PROCLAIMED THROUGHOUT THE WHOLE EARTH.” So then He has mercy on whom He desires, and He hardens whom He desires. (Romans 9:17-18)
The example of Pharaoh was well known to any person familiar with the Old Testament. God destroyed the Egyptian nation by plagues so as to demonstrate His might and power in the earth, and key to this demonstration was the hardening of Pharaoh’s heart. Before Moses had met with Pharaoh the first time God told him:
When you go back to Egypt see that you perform before Pharaoh all the wonders which I have put in your power; but I will harden his heart so that he will not let the people go. (Exodus 4:21)
It was God’s intention to bring His wrath upon the Egyptians. God’s actions were not “forced” by the stubborn will of the Egyptian leader. God said He would harden Pharaoh’s heart, and He did. Listen to the impudent response of this pagan idolater to the command of Moses:
And afterward Moses and Aaron came and said to Pharaoh, “Thus says the LORD, the God of Israel, ‘Let My people go that they may celebrate a feast to Me in the wilderness.’” But Pharaoh said, “Who is the LORD that I should obey His voice to let Israel go? I do not know the LORD, and besides, I will not let Israel go.” (Exodus 5:1-2)
Is this not what God said He would do? Will someone suggest that Pharaoh’s heart is “soft” here? No indeed, and Moses well knew that God was behind this for when the Pharaoh then increased the work load of the Israelites, Moses complained to God in Exodus 5:22. Why complain to God if, in fact, God had nothing to do with it and it was all just a matter of the Pharaoh’s “free will choice”?
This provides the background of Paul’s citation of Exodus 9:16. The portion of truth that here stings the pride of man is this: it is more important that God’s name be magnified and His power made known than it is any single man get to “do his own thing.” Pharaoh was surely never forced to do anything sinful (indeed, God probably kept him from committing many a sinful deed). He acted on the desires of his wicked heart at all times. But he is but a pot, a creature, not the Potter. He was formed and made and brought into existence to serve the Potter’s purposes, not his own. He is but a servant, one chosen, in fact, for destruction. His destruction, and the process that led up to it (including all the plagues upon Egypt), were part of God’s plan. There is simply no other way to understand these words.
Paul then combines the fact that God showed undeserved compassion and mercy to Moses (Exodus 33) with God’s hardening of Pharaoh’s heart (Exodus 5) and concludes that whether one is “mercied” or “hardened” is completely, inalterably, and utterly up to God. The verbs here are active: God performs these actions. He “mercies” whom He wills and He hardens whom He wills. The parallel between “mercy” and “hardening” is inarguable. We may like the “mercying” part more than the hardening, but they are both equally a part of the same truth. Reject one and you reject them both. There is no such thing as preaching God’s mercy without preaching God’s judgment, at least according to Scripture.
The passage reaches a crescendo in these final verses:
You will say to me then, “Why does He still find fault? For who resists His will?” On the contrary, who are you, O man, who answers back to God? The thing molded will not say to the molder, “Why did you make me like this,” will it? (Romans 9:19-20)
Paul well knew the objections man presents to the words he had just penned. If God has mercy solely based upon His good pleasure, and if God hardens Pharaoh on the same basis, all to His own glory and honor, how can God hold men accountable for their actions, for who resists His will? Paul’s response is swift and devastating: Yes indeed God holds man accountable, and He can do so because He is the Potter, the one who molds and creates, while man is but the “thing molded.” For a pot to question the Potter is absurd: for man to answer back to God is equally absurd. These words cannot be understood separately from the fundamental understanding of the freedom of the Sovereign Creator and the ontological creatureliness of man that removes from him any ground of complaint against God. Though already devastatingly clear, Paul makes sure there is no doubt left as to his point:
Or does not the potter have a right over the clay, to make from the same lump one vessel for honorable use and another for common use? What if God, although willing to demonstrate His wrath and to make His power known, endured with much patience vessels of wrath prepared for destruction? And He did so to make known the riches of His glory upon vessels of mercy, which He prepared beforehand for glory, even us, whom He also called, not from among Jews only, but also from among Gentiles. (Romans 9:21-24)
The Potter’s freedom pulses through these words, flowing inexorably into the sea of sovereignty, rushing any would-be proponent of free will out of its path. God has the perfect right to do with His creation (including men) as He wishes, just as the Potter has utter sovereignty over the clay. Just as God had demonstrated His wrath and power by wasting idolatrous Egypt, so too He demonstrates His wrath upon “vessels of wrath prepared for destruction.” Are these nations? Classes? No, these are sinners upon whom God’s wrath comes. They are said to have been specifically “prepared for destruction.” That is their purpose.
Why are there vessels prepared for destruction? Because God is free. Think about it: there are only three logical possibilities here. Either 1) all “vessels” are prepared for glory (universalism); 2) all “vessels” are prepared for destruction; or 3) some vessels are prepared for glory and some are prepared for destruction and it is the Potter who decides which are which. Why is there no fourth option, one in which the pots prepare themselves based upon their own choice? Because pots don’t have such a capacity! Pots are pots! Since God wishes to make known the “riches of His grace” to His elect people (the vessels prepared of mercy), there must be vessels prepared for destruction. There is no demonstration of mercy and grace where there is no justice.
The vessels of wrath, remember, like being vessels of wrath, would never choose to be anything else, and they detest the vessels that receive mercy. Indeed, during the writing of this book I encountered an unbeliever who, upon hearing me mention the wrath of God, mocked and said, “Ah, yes, the wrath of God! I LIKE IT!” This is the attitude of the vessel of wrath prepared for destruction.
God’s wonderful grace will be praised throughout eternity because of the great contrast between the vessels of wrath and the vessels of mercy. Why? Because the only difference between the vessels of wrath and the vessels of mercy is the sovereign grace of God that changes the heart of the rebel sinner and turns him from being a God-hater into a God-lover. This is why there is no basis for man’s boasting, ever.
I keep asking Catholics, Orthodox, and any church that claims to be Christ’s one true Church a simple question. How do you know you are that church without using the private judgment you say we can’t use with Scripture?
I’ve asked it in countless comments. I’ve posted it in debate groups. I’ve posted it here before.
I have never gotten a logically coherent answer. Some try to split hairs and say private judgment and private interpretation are somehow different. Most dodge it and try to flip the conversation to something else.
A huge reason I am a Christian is that I think this is the most logically coherent view of the world. I became a Christian because of logic and evidence. It makes the most sense that Christ is real, and if He is, then what Scripture says about me, and about all of us, is true. It also means He loves me. He died for me.
So if your view can’t even answer a basic question about its own rules, that’s a gigantic indicator to me that it isn’t true.
Biblical Christianity makes sense. It answers most questions consistently. I don’t have contradictions I have to protect. I don’t have to dodge, hide, or spin the question around. I can face it head on.
When a basic question makes you do the opposite, it’s time to reconsider the worldview.
33
Lee Monroe retweeted
Well, it seems my post on Paul’s sermon at Athens has touched some nerves. What I found particularly interesting, though, is that very few of those critical of my explanation actually stayed with Paul’s language long enough to show me where his “all men everywhere” suddenly became a small, hidden section of humanity.
Instead of showing from Paul’s own argument where my reading went wrong, the conversation quickly moved elsewhere. Verses such as “I lay down my life for the sheep” and “He shall save his people from their sins” were pulled in from other contexts, as though saying Christ died for His sheep somehow proves that He therefore died only for His sheep. But that little word “only” is precisely what still needs to be demonstrated from the text, not quietly added to it.
So instead of chasing proof texts from one end of Scripture to the other, I want to push the original question deeper. If we really want to know the scope of Christ's redemptive provision, there is hardly a better place to go than Romans 5, where Paul deliberately places Adam and Christ face to face.
Paul begins, “By one man sin entered into the world, and death by sin; and so death passed upon ALL MEN” (Romans 5:12). Whatever else Christians debate about original sin, the scope of Adam's catastrophe is not difficult to see. Paul says elsewhere, “ALL have sinned” (Romans 3:23), and, “in Adam ALL die” (1 Corinthians 15:22). Adam's side of the story concerns humanity.
Now pay very close attention to what Paul does with ALL and MANY, because this is where the argument becomes fascinating. In Romans 5:12, death passes upon “all men.” Yet only three verses later Paul says, “through the offence of one MANY be dead” (vs 15). Then in vs 18 he returns to “all men” under condemnation, before saying in vs 19 that by one man's disobedience “MANY were made sinners.”
Did Paul's population keep changing? Obviously not. The MANY who died in vs 15 are the ALL MEN upon whom death passed in vs 12. The MANY made sinners in vs 19 correspond to the ALL MEN under Adam's condemnation in vs 18.
That matters because I keep hearing “Christ died for MANY” presented as though the word many itself means “not all.” It doesn't. “Many” can certainly refer to less than everybody in some contexts, just as “all” can be restricted in some contexts. Context determines both. Romans 5 itself proves that “the many” can describe the very population Paul elsewhere in the same argument calls “all.”
And this is not some convenient linguistic trick invented to escape limited atonement. The Old Testament already gives us this kind of language.
Isaiah 53 begins the Servant's suffering with this confession: “ALL WE like sheep have gone astray; we have turned EVERY ONE to his own way; and the LORD hath laid on him the iniquity of us ALL” (vs 6). Yet a few verses later the same Servant “shall justify MANY” and “bare the sin of MANY” (vs 11–12). The movement from all/every one/all to many does not by itself announce a smaller population.
That becomes even more significant when Jesus says He came “to give his life a ransom for MANY” (Mark 10:45), while Paul says Christ “gave himself a ransom for ALL” (1 Timothy 2:6). Those statements need not fight each other. The Servant-language background already gives us the category of the one standing over against the many, the multitude.
Now return to Romans 5 and watch Paul turn from Adam to Christ. “For if through the offence of ONE MANY be dead, MUCH MORE the grace of God, and the gift by grace, which is by ONE MAN, Jesus Christ, hath abounded unto MANY” (vs 15). There are the many on both sides of Paul's sentence.
If Adam's “many” are the humanity affected through Adam, what in Paul's sentence tells us that Christ's “many” suddenly becomes a smaller, secretly selected population? Paul doesn't say that. The limitation has to be supplied from somewhere else and then carried into the verse.
Verse 18 makes the problem even sharper: “Therefore AS by the offence of one judgment came upon ALL MEN to condemnation; EVEN SO by the righteousness of one the free gift came upon ALL MEN unto justification of life.”
Paul could hardly have constructed the parallel more deliberately. Through ONE, condemnation toward ALL MEN. Through ONE, the gift toward ALL MEN. The Greek construction is hōs... houtōs kai, “as... so also.” So if the first all men means humanity, where does Paul tell us that the second occurrence of the same expression, inside the same sentence and joined by this explicit comparison, has suddenly changed populations?
That is the exegetical question. Not, “Can I find another verse somewhere that mentions sheep or God's people?” Of course I can. The question is: Where does Romans 5 make the switch?
Then comes the predictable objection: “If the second ALL means every individual, then every individual must automatically be justified. You have universalism.”
No, because Paul has already told us something crucial in v.17: “MUCH MORE they which RECEIVE abundance of grace and of the gift of righteousness shall reign in life by one, Jesus Christ.” Paul distinguishes the scope of the gift from the reception of the gift.
That distinction did not suddenly appear in Romans 5. It has been Paul's argument throughout Romans. The Gospel is God's power unto salvation “to EVERY ONE THAT BELIEVETH” (Romans 1:16). God's righteousness is “unto all and upon all them that BELIEVE” (3:22). The ungodly is justified by believing rather than working (4:5). Having been “justified by faith,” we have peace with God (5:1).
So no, saying Christ is God's redemptive answer for the same humanity ruined in Adam does not mean every person is already justified irrespective of faith. The provision is God's; the reception is through faith. Faith does not create Calvary, enlarge Calvary, complete Calvary, or persuade God to include you retrospectively. Faith receives the gift God has provided.
Jesus Himself gives us a beautiful picture of this in John 3. He compares His being lifted up to Moses lifting up the serpent in the wilderness: “that whosoever believeth in him should not perish, but have eternal life” (John 3:14–15). God's provision preceded the Israelite's looking. Looking did not manufacture the serpent, and looking was certainly not a meritorious work. Yet the benefit of God's provided remedy was received by looking.
Then comes John 3:16: God loved the world, God gave His Son, and whosoever believeth has everlasting life. Verse 18 then distinguishes the believer from the unbeliever. Universal provision and conditional reception are not enemies. Scripture comfortably holds them together.
Paul does the same thing elsewhere in language that directly connects Christ's death with humanity's predicament: “If one died for ALL, then were ALL DEAD: And that he died for ALL...” (2 Corinthians 5:14–15).
Read Paul's reasoning carefully. ALL DEAD. ONE DIED FOR ALL. If the “all” whose death establishes Paul's premise includes humanity, why should the “all” for whom Christ died suddenly become smaller? Once again, the redemptive act is being spoken of against the backdrop of the human catastrophe.
And Scripture keeps speaking this way. Christ “by the grace of God should taste death for EVERY MAN” (Hebrews 2:9). He “gave himself a ransom for ALL” in a passage where God desires “ALL MEN to be saved” (1 Timothy 2:4–6). John says Christ is “the propitiation for our sins: and NOT FOR OURS ONLY, but also for the sins of the WHOLE WORLD” (1 John 2:2).
Can all sometimes have a contextual limitation? Absolutely. Can world have different nuances? Certainly. But that is precisely why the restriction must be demonstrated from each context rather than assumed before reading it.
And now we come to something in Romans 5 that I think is even more damaging to the idea that Christ's redemptive provision is narrower than Adam's catastrophe. Paul does not merely present Christ as Adam's equal and opposite.
Paul repeatedly says: MUCH MORE. “For if through the offence of one many be dead, MUCH MORE the grace of God...” (vs 15).
“For if by one man's offence death reigned by one; MUCH MORE they which receive abundance of grace...” (vs 17).
And finally: “Where sin abounded, grace did MUCH MORE abound” (vs 20).
We need to understand what Paul means before turning those words into a slogan. His “much more” does not mean that more people must ultimately be saved than were affected by Adam. Paul's emphasis includes the surpassing power, abundance and triumph of grace over the trespass. One offence brought condemnation, while God's gift confronts the accumulated “many offences” and brings justification (vs 16). Death reigns through Adam; those receiving God's overflowing grace reign in life through Christ.
But precisely because MUCH MORE describes Christ's surpassing answer to Adam, it is extraordinarily difficult to turn Paul's argument into this:
Adam's offence reaches every human being, but Christ's redemptive provision never concerned most human beings.
Adam's “many” means everybody, but Christ's “many” means only the elect.
Adam's “all men” means every individual, but Christ's “all men,” in the very same sentence, means only some of them.
Adam's ruin is universally relevant, but Christ's sacrifice was never provided for most of those ruined people.
And then, after making Christ's redemptive scope smaller than Adam's destructive scope, we point at Paul's words and say: MUCH MORE.
That is exactly where I have a problem. Not because I think Christ must automatically save everyone Adam affected. Paul has already excluded that conclusion by speaking of receiving the gift and by making justification consistently through faith. My problem is with making the provision itself narrower than the catastrophe it answers.
The “much more” is not mathematical proof of universal atonement by itself. But within Paul's whole Adam-Christ argument, it certainly gives us no reason to imagine Christ as God's smaller answer to Adam. Paul's point is the overwhelming superiority of the Second Adam: grace over trespass, righteousness over condemnation, life over death, abundance over ruin.
And think carefully before saying, “But Christ died for His sheep.” Of course He did. Christ died for His sheep. Christ died for His church (Ephesians 5:25). Christ saves His people from their sins (Matthew 1:21). None of those sentences contains the word only.
Paul could say Christ “loved me, and gave himself for me” (Galatians 2:20). Surely nobody concludes, “Then Christ gave Himself for Paul and nobody else.” A statement can identify a particular beneficiary without exhausting the entire class of beneficiaries.
The question is therefore not whether Christ died for His sheep. We agree that He did. The question is whether Scripture says He died only for the sheep in the sense required by limited atonement, so that no atoning provision whatsoever was made for anyone who finally perishes.
That claim has to survive texts saying ALL, EVERY MAN, WHOLE WORLD, and NOT FOR OURS ONLY. It has to survive Paul's Adam-Christ parallel. It has to explain why Adam's “many” are allowed to mean the all while Christ's “many” must suddenly become fewer. And it has to do all of that without simply inserting the limitation into the text beforehand. This is why Romans 5 matters so much.
Paul's story is not that an ordinary creature somehow achieved a wider human reach in destruction than the incarnate Son of God achieved in redemptive provision. But neither should we argue that Christ's deity means everyone must therefore be saved; that would confuse the sufficiency and scope of God's provision with its saving application. Christ's superiority is displayed in the nature, abundance and triumph of His gift, while Paul explicitly identifies those who receive that gift as reigning in life.
Adam is not sovereign. Adam does not get the final word over humanity. Sin does not get the widest horizon while grace hides in a corner. The Second Adam enters the very human catastrophe created through the first and answers it with something infinitely greater.
That is why Paul's vocabulary keeps exploding rather than shrinking: grace, gift, abundance, much more, justification, righteousness and life. And finally: “WHERE SIN ABOUNDED, GRACE DID MUCH MORE ABOUND.”
So my question remains very simple. If Adam's MANY are the ALL, and Paul's own as... so also construction places ALL MEN on both sides of Adam and Christ, show me from Paul's argument where Christ's redemptive provision becomes smaller than the humanity Adam's transgression affected.
Don't just give me “sheep” and quietly add “only” or “His people” and quietly add “and nobody else” or “many” as though Scripture itself never uses “many” for the multitude elsewhere called “all.” Show me the restriction in the text. Because I can see where Paul distinguishes those who receive the gift from those who do not. What I cannot see is where Paul says the gift was never provided for the others at all.
And until somebody can show me that from the text, I am going to let Paul's contrast stand at its full force: The first Adam brought humanity sin, condemnation and death. The Second Adam brought humanity God's redemptive answer of grace, righteousness and life, received through faith.
Adam did not out-reach Jesus Christ; sin does not get the bigger victory, and Paul's words over the triumph of Christ are not MUCH LESS. They are MUCH MORE.
If you have ever been persuaded by an impressively woven theological system, built through selective texts and carefully constructed definitions, that Jesus Christ could not possibly have died for ALL, for EVERY SINGLE INDIVIDUAL in the world, follow Paul to Athens with me. Because once you carefully follow the progression Paul deliberately builds, from creation to providence to repentance to the risen Christ and finally to righteous judgment, you cannot simply unsee it.
And the further Paul goes, the harder it becomes to make his “ALL” mean a secretly selected few. To slip that restriction into Paul’s “ALL” is not exegesis; it is theological bias overriding the text. Paul NEVER put the limitation there.
Paul begins:
“God that made the WORLD and ALL THINGS THEREIN, seeing that he is Lord of heaven and earth, dwelleth not in temples made with hands; Neither is worshipped with men's hands, as though he needed any thing, seeing HE GIVETH TO ALL LIFE, AND BREATH, AND ALL THINGS; And hath made of ONE BLOOD ALL NATIONS OF MEN FOR TO DWELL ON ALL THE FACE OF THE EARTH, and hath determined the times before appointed, and the bounds of their habitation.” Acts 17:24–26
Before anybody tells me what “all men” means in verse 30, I want Paul to tell me who these people are.
God made THE WORLD AND ALL THINGS THEREIN. He gives ALL life and breath. He made ALL NATIONS OF MEN from one blood. He placed them upon ALL THE FACE OF THE EARTH.
Who receives that life and breath? Only believers? Obviously not. The idolater breathes. The unbeliever eats. The wicked man wakes beneath God's sun. Jesus Himself said God “maketh his sun to rise on the evil and on the good, and sendeth rain on the just and on the unjust” (Matthew 5:45).
So Paul's “all” has not begun as “all kinds of elect people.” He is talking about the human race.
Then Paul tells us something even more remarkable about why God ordered humanity's existence: “That THEY SHOULD SEEK THE LORD, if haply they might feel after him, AND FIND HIM, though HE BE NOT FAR FROM EVERY ONE OF US: For in him WE LIVE, AND MOVE, AND HAVE OUR BEING.” Acts 17:27–28
Watch the movement carefully. The “all nations of men” are the “they” who should seek the Lord. And God is “not far from EVERY ONE OF US.”
Paul is saying this while standing among pagan Athenians surrounded by idols.
Then comes the command: “And the times of this ignorance God winked at; but now COMMANDETH ALL MEN EVERY WHERE TO REPENT.” Acts 17:30
Now tell me: who are “ALL MEN EVERYWHERE”?
We have just been told.
They belong to the world God made. They are among those to whom God gives life and breath. They comprise all nations of men. They inhabit all the face of the earth. They are among those who should seek the Lord. God is not far from every one of them.
And now God commands:
ALL MEN. EVERYWHERE. REPENT.
If “all men” suddenly means only certain individuals unconditionally selected from humanity, show me where Paul changed populations.
Where is the restriction?
Where did “all nations of men” become “some individuals from all nations”?
Where did “every one of us” become “only those selected for salvation”?
It isn't there.
But Paul is still not finished. The next word is “BECAUSE.”
“BECAUSE he hath appointed a day, in the which HE WILL JUDGE THE WORLD IN RIGHTEOUSNESS BY THAT MAN WHOM HE HATH ORDAINED; whereof HE HATH GIVEN ASSURANCE UNTO ALL MEN, in that HE HATH RAISED HIM FROM THE DEAD.” Acts 17:31
Read that again slowly.
God commands ALL MEN EVERYWHERE to repent BECAUSE He will JUDGE THE WORLD IN RIGHTEOUSNESS through Jesus Christ, and He has given ASSURANCE UNTO ALL MEN by raising Christ from the dead.
Paul has now surrounded his command with universal language:
ALL NATIONS OF MEN.
ALL THE FACE OF THE EARTH.
EVERY ONE OF US.
ALL MEN.
EVERYWHERE.
THE WORLD.
ALL MEN.
At what point exactly are we supposed to insert “only the elect”?
If “all men everywhere” means only a selected subset, should “judge the world” also mean God will judge only a selected subset of the world?
Nobody believes that.
Jesus says: “When the Son of man shall come in his glory, and all the holy angels with him, then shall he sit upon the throne of his glory: And BEFORE HIM SHALL BE GATHERED ALL NATIONS: and he shall separate them one from another, as a shepherd divideth his sheep from the goats.” Matthew 25:31–32
The world that God created is the world accountable to Him. The humanity receiving life and breath is the humanity commanded to repent. And the humanity commanded to repent is the humanity warned that it will meet the risen Christ.
But here is where the argument becomes even more profound.
Why can God command every sinner everywhere to repent? Why is the risen Christ God's assurance to all men? And why can the coming judgment of that world be called judgment “IN RIGHTEOUSNESS”?
Acts 17 itself explicitly gives us Christ's resurrection, not a complete doctrine of the extent of His atonement. So we follow the risen Christ through the rest of the New Testament, and Scripture tells us what happened before that resurrection.
“For the love of Christ constraineth us; because we thus judge, that if ONE DIED FOR ALL, then were all dead: And that HE DIED FOR ALL, that they which live should not henceforth live unto themselves, but unto him WHICH DIED FOR THEM, AND ROSE AGAIN.” 2 Corinthians 5:14–15
There it is again: death and resurrection.
And notice Paul's reasoning. ONE DIED FOR ALL, because ALL WERE DEAD. The scope of human ruin and the language describing Christ's provision stand together.
Hebrews says: “But we see Jesus, who was made a little lower than the angels for the suffering of death, crowned with glory and honour; THAT HE BY THE GRACE OF GOD SHOULD TASTE DEATH FOR EVERY MAN.” Hebrews 2:9
John says: “And he is the propitiation for our sins: and NOT FOR OURS ONLY, BUT ALSO FOR THE SINS OF THE WHOLE WORLD.” 1 John 2:2
Paul says: “For this is good and acceptable in the sight of GOD OUR SAVIOUR; WHO WILL HAVE ALL MEN TO BE SAVED, AND TO COME UNTO THE KNOWLEDGE OF THE TRUTH. For there is one God, and one mediator between God and men, the man Christ Jesus; WHO GAVE HIMSELF A RANSOM FOR ALL, to be testified in due time.” 1 Timothy 2:3–6
And Jesus says: “For God so loved THE WORLD, that he gave his only begotten Son, that WHOSOEVER BELIEVETH IN HIM should not perish, but have everlasting life. For God sent not his Son into THE WORLD to condemn THE WORLD; but that THE WORLD THROUGH HIM MIGHT BE SAVED.” John 3:16–17
Now the picture is coming together beautifully.
The God who gives humanity life and breath did not stop giving when humanity reached its greatest need.
He gave His Son.
The Creator's generosity toward humanity does not end with sunshine, rain, food and oxygen while salvation suddenly becomes a provision with no reference whatsoever to most of the people He commands to repent.
When Scripture finally speaks of God's supreme Gift, its language remains astonishingly broad:
THE WORLD.
WHOSOEVER.
ALL.
EVERY MAN.
THE WHOLE WORLD.
A RANSOM FOR ALL.
And now go back to Paul's word: RIGHTEOUSNESS.
“He will JUDGE THE WORLD IN RIGHTEOUSNESS...”
God is not judging merely for the sake of judging. The Gospel announces something God has actually done in Christ and summons sinners to respond to it. Christ died. Christ rose. God commands repentance and faith. And persistent rejection meets righteous judgment.
Jesus explains that judgment: “He that believeth on him is not condemned: but HE THAT BELIEVETH NOT IS CONDEMNED ALREADY, because HE HATH NOT BELIEVED in the name of the only begotten Son of God. And this is the condemnation, that LIGHT IS COME INTO THE WORLD, and MEN LOVED DARKNESS RATHER THAN LIGHT, because their deeds were evil.” John 3:18–19
That is breathtaking. The Light came. The problem was not that there was no Light for them. They loved darkness.
Jesus says elsewhere: “And ye WILL NOT COME TO ME, that ye might have life.” John 5:40
There is life in Christ. Yet they refuse to come.
This is why universal provision must never be confused with universal salvation. Scripture does not say everybody is automatically saved because Christ died for all. It says: “Therefore being JUSTIFIED BY FAITH, we have peace with God through our Lord Jesus Christ.” Romans 5:1
And faith contributes no merit to Calvary:
“Now to him that WORKETH is the reward not reckoned of grace, but of debt. But to him that WORKETH NOT, BUT BELIEVETH ON HIM that justifieth the ungodly, his faith is counted for righteousness.” Romans 4:4–5
The sinner who believes did not provide the Lamb.
God Himself provided the Lamb. Faith simply receives what grace has provided.
And this is why God's disposition toward those who reject Him matters so much. Listen to God Himself:
“As I live, saith the Lord GOD, I HAVE NO PLEASURE IN THE DEATH OF THE WICKED; BUT THAT THE WICKED TURN FROM HIS WAY AND LIVE: TURN YE, TURN YE from your evil ways; FOR WHY WILL YE DIE, O house of Israel?” Ezekiel 33:11
Notice how naturally that fits Acts 17.
“ALL MEN EVERY WHERE... REPENT.”
“TURN YE, TURN YE... WHY WILL YE DIE?”
This is not a God delighting in sinners remaining unrepentant so that He can destroy them. He is a righteous Judge, yes, but He explicitly tells us that He takes “NO PLEASURE IN THE DEATH OF THE WICKED.”
Then look at Christ: “O Jerusalem, Jerusalem... HOW OFTEN WOULD I HAVE GATHERED THY CHILDREN TOGETHER, even as a hen gathereth her chickens under her wings, AND YE WOULD NOT!” Matthew 23:37
“I WOULD.” “YE WOULD NOT.”
And when judgment approaches Jerusalem: “And when he was come near, HE BEHELD THE CITY, AND WEPT OVER IT.” Luke 19:41
The Judge weeps over those approaching judgment.
That should stop us from constructing a theology in which the destruction of the wicked becomes something God secretly delights in while publicly pleading with them to turn.
Now return one final time to Athens.
Paul's argument begins with the world God created, moves to all humanity sustained by His goodness, tells us humanity should seek Him, declares Him not far from every one of us, commands all men everywhere to repent, announces the risen Christ to all men, and warns that the world will be judged in righteousness through Him.
Then the rest of Scripture tells us why Christ can be proclaimed to that world:
“ONE DIED FOR ALL.”
“TASTE DEATH FOR EVERY MAN.”
“NOT FOR OURS ONLY... THE WHOLE WORLD.”
“A RANSOM FOR ALL.”
“GOD SO LOVED THE WORLD.”
And Scripture tells us why some nevertheless perish:
“HE HATH NOT BELIEVED.”
“MEN LOVED DARKNESS RATHER THAN LIGHT.”
“YE WILL NOT COME TO ME, THAT YE MIGHT HAVE LIFE.”
That is what makes the coming judgment so solemnly righteous. The Judge is not indifferent. God has acted in Christ. The Gospel announces that act to sinners. God commands repentance. Christ is offered as the object of faith. Yet the Light can be rejected, the outstretched hands resisted, and the Savior refused.
And so the Bible ends exactly where this theology would lead us to expect: “And the Spirit and the bride say, COME. And let him that heareth say, COME. And let him that is athirst COME. And WHOSOEVER WILL, LET HIM TAKE THE WATER OF LIFE FREELY.” Revelation 22:17
From Athens to Calvary, from the empty tomb to the final judgment, the picture holds together:
The God who gave all humanity breath did not withhold humanity's greatest provision. He gave His Son. The Christ who died for all rose again. The risen Christ is proclaimed to all. God commands all men everywhere to repent. Whosoever believes receives life. Those who reject the Light remain accountable. And the same Christ whom humanity is commanded to receive will one day judge that world “IN RIGHTEOUSNESS.”
That is not a Gospel searching for a tiny, hidden group of specially selected sinners. That is a Gospel for the world, purchased by Christ, proclaimed to all, received by faith, and rejected only at the sinner’s peril. So preach it exactly as God gave it: TO EVERY CREATURE UNDER HEAVEN. Do not make Calvary smaller than Scripture makes it.
I have talked before about lens. I think that is the real divide in these discussions. We talk past each other because we are not starting with the same standard, and we all assume ours is the right one.
That is why this has gone on so long, and why it will keep going. There will not be much understanding while the standards stay this far apart.
I can quote Scripture all day to a Catholic or an Orthodox Christian and it often will not matter. We are not looking at the text with the same lens, because our authority is different.
I call myself a biblical Christian. Scripture is my ultimate authority. I think you interpret it by careful exegesis, with the right context and the right cotext.
Will that wipe out all error? No. We are fallible. We will get things wrong. That is not a problem with the text. That is a problem with us. God’s word is not the issue. We are.
Rome and Orthodoxy say only the Church can properly interpret the text. Whether they admit it or not, that puts the Church over Scripture in practice. They will say the two are equal. In real life, if the Church tells you verse x means y, you believe y. The verse gets made to fit.
Take Mary’s sinlessness. Scripture is not unclear that no one is righteous except God, and that Mary herself said she needed a Savior. “None is righteous, no, not one” (Romans 3:10). “For all have sinned and fall short of the glory of God” (Romans 3:23). “And my spirit rejoices in God my Savior” (Luke 1:47). It does not matter, because Rome has declared her sinless, so the text gets bent around that. Needing a Savior becomes “God saved her by making her sinless.” No one is righteous, except Mary. Gabriel calling her favored in Luke 1:28 gets loaded with a whole doctrine the rest of Scripture will not carry.
The Church said it, so it is so.
I am not only saying this as a shot at Rome, though some will take it that way. I am pointing at the problem. Two different standards.
How do we get past that? I do not fully know. I do know the argument that matters is which standard is right. Is Scripture our ultimate authority, or a church?
If it is a church, how do you pick it? Rome says she is Christ’s one true church. Orthodoxy says the same. Mormonism says the same. A lot of groups do. Most of them also say you cannot trust your own interpretation of Scripture. So how am I allowed to use that same judgment when I decide which church is Christ’s?
I am at a loss. Someone has to be wrong. There cannot be two “one true churches.”
People tell me to read history. Orthodoxy says history is theirs. Rome says history is theirs. And how do I read history without using my own judgment, the thing both of them say I should not use? My judgment is good enough for history, but not for Scripture?
So the standard gets hard to pin down. On some level I have to trust something, and on some level I have to use my own mind. Then why can I not use that same mind, with pastors, elders, and careful study, when I open the Bible? Why is my pastor’s reading automatically wrong, and Rome’s automatically right? Why is Orthodoxy right and Rome wrong, and how do I know that without judging?
That is why I think my standard is the right one. Scripture, handled carefully. God’s word does not change. It is His breath, so it carries His truth in a way no committee of men does. “All Scripture is breathed out by God and profitable for teaching, for reproof, for correction, and for training in righteousness, that the man of God may be complete, equipped for every good work” (2 Timothy 3:16-17).
Yes, we will still get things wrong. You cannot erase human error by naming a group a magisterium. You pray. You study. You try to come to the text with an open heart, and you let God’s word shape your conclusions. You do not start with the conclusion and make the word fit.
1
67
If your first move in a disagreement is “you’re misrepresenting me,” or “that’s a lie,” or “that’s a grift,” and you never show how, that is a strong sign the argument is weak.
Show the error. Quote the thing that was actually said. Answer that. “The one who states his case first seems right, until the other comes and examines him” (Proverbs 18:17).
A label is not a rebuttal.
1
33
A fundamental truth of the gospel is that we're filthy rags before a holy God and we deserve hell. Isaiah 64:6 says “We have all become like one who is unclean, and all our righteous deeds are like a polluted garment. We all fade like a leaf, and our iniquities, like the wind, take us away.” That’s every single one of us. Me included.
A lot of people say they understand this. I’m not sure they really do.
When you call out something evil someone else did, go for it. It needs to be said. But get this: God sees us as deserving hell too. Maybe you never did that particular thing. I didn’t either. Still, we’ve sinned, and that brings the full sentence.
Romans 3:23 “for all have sinned and fall short of the glory of God.”
Romans 6:23 “For the wages of sin is death.”
Not some sins. Sin.
James 2:10 “For whoever keeps the whole law but fails in one point has become guilty of all of it.”
There are different levels of sin. Scripture says so. A drug dealer isn’t as bad as a pedophile in our eyes, and God will judge accordingly. But both still end up in the same place without Christ. So do I. So do you. None of us are good before God. We all deserve hell.
Picture two guys drowning. One’s in ten feet of water. The other one’s in a hundred. Different depths. Same outcome. Both die if nobody pulls them out. That’s us. Some sins are worse than others. All of them still sink us.
Only God is good. Jesus said in Mark 10:18 “Why do you call me good? No one is good except God alone.”
Romans 3:10-12 “as it is written: ‘None is righteous, no, not one; no one understands; no one seeks for God. All have turned aside; together they have become worthless; no one does good, not even one.’”
This keeps me humble. All the glory belongs to God. It kills the pride when I start feeling better than the people I’m calling out.
Ephesians 2:1-3 “And you were dead in the trespasses and sins in which you once walked, following the course of this world, following the prince of the power of the air, the spirit that is now at work in the sons of disobedience—among whom we all once lived in the passions of our flesh, carrying out the desires of the body and the mind, and were by nature children of wrath, like the rest of mankind.”
I was a child of wrath. You were too. The only difference between any of us and the worst person we can name is the mercy of God.
Call out evil. Just don’t forget to look for it in yourself. 1 John 1:8 “If we say we have no sin, we deceive ourselves, and the truth is not in us.”
The gospel isn’t that some of us were mostly fine and just needed a little help. We were all filthy, condemned, and headed for hell. Christ alone is the righteousness that saves.
90
Lee Monroe retweeted
Replying to @Sachinettiyil
Notice, not “his conversion to Christ,” like we see in the Bible with people turning to the Lord (2 Cor 3:16), but “his conversion to Catholicism.”
Salvation isn’t by joining an institution.
Some of my fellow Christian brothers and sisters have been saying we shouldn't have voted for this man. Well. Look at how God used this man, and look at what my vote for this man was used by God? Stop trashing Christians for voting for him.
1
48
Lee Monroe retweeted
Mormons: We’re Christian
Me: No. You’re not.
Mormons: We are highly offended by that! How dare you say we aren’t Christian when we believe in Jesus.
Me: You use the name Jesus but reject core Christian beliefs about Jesus. You reject core Christian beliefs about a bunch of essential things. You tend to use the same vocabulary as us but with different definitions.
Mormons: Of course we reject your core beliefs. They are an abomination! This is why Joseph Smith said God told him did all your creeds are in abomination and that he couldn’t join any Christian group in the United States. It’s because you guys don’t know the truth about God and Joseph Smith had to restore the true gospel, fix the teachings you have from your corrupt Bible, and give us a host of new Scriptures.
Me: See, this is why I say you aren’t Christians. It’s not personal. It’s the foundation of Mormonism that you reject core Christian teachings about Jesus, salvation, God, the Bible, exaltation, and more. Joseph Smith made this clear. Brigham young said all Christians were apostates and it was only more recently you guys were told by your leaders to co-opt the name Christian. But it’s like a man trying to say he’s a woman. No, he’s not. That’s silly. He can be offended but it’s not rational and it’s actually harmful to pretend he’s a woman just to appease him.
Mormons: Mike, we believe in the Bible, Jesus, God the Father, salvation by faith, and all the stuff you believe. We just have a few more things you don’t know about yet. We have your beliefs and extra, because we are like complete Christians.
Me: You believe the Bible is corrupt in whatever ways it may challenge your theology. You believe Jesus wasn’t always God and that he’s the brother of Satan. You believe God wasn’t always God and that he became a God in the same way that you can become a God if you are considered worthy of it when you die. You believe in grace plus works which invalidates grace (Romans 11:6) and triggers Galatians 1’s anathema, saying that “we are saved by grace after all that we can DO.” You may not have realized it but your religion teaches you the same words as Christians but defines them in ways that actually reject our core beliefs.
Mormons: You don’t understand us. We believe what we believe and it’s Christian.
Me: I know some more modern Mormons will say they actually don’t hold to some of those things I mentioned but I have to treat Mormonism based on its Scriptures, apostles, and prophets, not its online apologists. Based on those things, it’s not Christian.
Mormon (version 1): Your ignorance and attitude are offensive and harmful. We are Christians.
Mormon (version 2): We are the true Christians and you are apostate. You and most Christians throughout history were not real Christians. Joseph Smith restored true Christianity after it fell away shortly after Jesus rose.
Me: Jesus, the real Jesus, paid the full price for your sins on the cross. You can be saved and forgiven and live eternally with God, the one and only God, by trusting in Christ’s works and not your own. Joseph was a modern false prophet. Run from him to Jesus.
Lee Monroe retweeted
Replying to @CatholicDrip___
You have just articulated the heart of sola fide.
We are saved by grace alone, through faith alone, in Christ alone. But the faith that saves is never alone; it produces the works of love and charity for which Christ created us.
That is the beauty of Ephesians 2:8–10: we are not saved by good works, but we are saved for good works.













