Lowell Karr 🟦🟧 retweeted
So now Alabama's best wins of the season are against a 4-loss Kentucky and 5-loss LSU. How can anyone justify ranking a 2-loss Alabama ahead of 1-loss Notre Dame or 1-loss Miami or 2-loss Texas (beat Ohio State when they were No. 1 and had their QB) or 2-loss Tennessee (which beat Alabama by 16). And Alabama is 8 - 8?1? - spots ahead of a Wake Forest team which lost only to UM and is blowing out everyone? What a joke.
I'm expecting committee to reward Alabama for its 47-0 win over Chattanooga by saying they showed the world how to ace the trap game - or overcame longer than usual wait for tables at the Tuscaloosa Applebys - or some other cockamamie reason. (I still can't believe they're ranked 3rd with 2 losses and best wins vs. Kentucky/LSU).
Lowell Karr 🟦🟧 retweeted
Despite losing at Washington, Indiana has that quality non-conference schedule & shouldn't drop in the CFP rankings. At all
Lowell Karr 🟦🟧 retweeted
Can’t wait for South Carolina to slide further for losing to UGA than Arkansas.
Lowell Karr 🟦🟧 retweeted
Miami has a harder challenge playing in the ACC.
That is Correct
A conference loss or two usually derails their chance at a playoff birth
The sec you can actually lose multiple times to a 6-4 team and suddenly the conference that screams it just means more….. well…. It actually means less
One team needs to be perfect. The other team just needs to be close to good
Lowell Karr 🟦🟧 retweeted
The thing that's so frustrating about how the committee is utilizing strength of schedule is that it's already baked into other metrics. SoR includes SoS. AvgWP includes SoS. We don't need SoS & SoC. It's already in there! It's got a multiplier effect now.
Lowell Karr 🟦🟧 retweeted
The CFP selection committee docked Ohio State for losing to USC and Oregon without Julian Sayin, but gave South Carolina the benefit of the doubt after a 28-point loss to Arkansas without LaNorris Sellers.
It's the lack of consistency that really bothers me.
Lowell Karr 🟦🟧 retweeted
This might be a good time to remind everyone that 9 of the 13 CFP committee members have @SEC ties.
@CFBPlayoff wants no part of equal representation. There’s an agenda to be had.
CFP top 12 rankings should be:
Georgia
Utah
ND
Miami
UCLA
Indiana
Texas
Tennessee
Alabama
Wake Forest
BYU
Texas Tech
Boise G6 team.
31
Lowell Karr 🟦🟧 retweeted
Don't care what anyone says about the Alabama-Tennessee pod situation. If two teams in the same conference have the same record and the lower-ranked team beat the crap out of the higher-ranked team, they are comparable.
Lowell Karr 🟦🟧 retweeted
Texas’ quarterback threw three interceptions in a last-second win over LSU, who is now unranked (miraculously).
Gets bumped over Notre Dame, who has a road loss to No. 10 BYU, and over Miami who lost by a hair without its star player on 2 days notice against the Irish.
Lowell Karr 🟦🟧 retweeted
Wait what?
Conference strength through LEAGUE GAMES ONLY?
How are you measuring the strength of a conference if you’re not using the nonconference games in which that conference plays other conferences??????
Lowell Karr 🟦🟧 retweeted
The committee has no shame ranking all those 4 loss SEC teams at the bottom so everyone still has ranked wins.
Lowell Karr 🟦🟧 retweeted
What a coincidence that Texas' two bad losses are "ranked" as 4-loss teams this week?
Lowell Karr 🟦🟧 retweeted
The only thing I'm interested to see in tonight's rankings: Last week, Indiana fell 5 spots on a bye because every team they had a win against lost.
This week, Alabama had a 21-6 win over Vandy while every P4 team they had a win against lost their game.
Does Alabama receive the same treatment Indiana did?
And if it does, are they finally in the same pod as Tennessee?
Lowell Karr 🟦🟧 retweeted
You are using SEC logic on the conf champ game scenario. They are keeping SMU and Duke from being ranked which then denies improving our SoS., while keeping very avg 3-loss SEC teams in the rankings. It’s a self fulfilling prophesy. Too bad the ACC leadership doesn’t squeal publicly about this and make membership in the conference mean something.
I think an 11-1 regular season and a loss in the ACC CG, especially to a team they beat earlier in the season in Wake, gets Miami in.
If UM wins out in the regular season, they likely are in the top 5 entering conference championship weekend. The committee has typically dropped conference title-game losers one or two spots, so UM should be safe.
A 10-3 Miami that loses two-regular season games and the conference title game is probably out, in my opinion.
Lowell Karr 🟦🟧 retweeted
The systemic institutional bias against ACC, and in favor of SEC, will never change. ACC needed 24 teams in field to even get 2nd team in. Miami kicking SEC butt in postseason last year changed nothing. Hard to overcome systemic bias
Lowell Karr 🟦🟧 retweeted
Let me explain the bias I'm referring to: The committee -without seeing anything head to head - automatically assumes that the 3rd, 4th, 5th SEC teams are better than the No. 2 ACC team. (This was reflected yet again in these rankings.) Might Kentucky and all these SEC teams be better than Wake? Perhaps. But how would they or anybody know? When you always assume a 2-loss SEC team is better than a 1-loss ACC team without any evidence that would hold up in court, that's bias.
Lowell Karr 🟦🟧 retweeted
Tonight I was told UCLA is better than Miami cause they won at 5-4 Minnesota while Miami, without its best player, lost by a TD @ No. 5 ND. Bruins deserve credit for no loss. But a 6 spot drop?
Not shocked, but you can’t tell me you watch ball & agree. Even the metrics call BS.

























