Pinned Tweet
Don't let the chatter distract from the hard evidence on the Karen Read case. There is no viable discussion to be had on this case, absent that evidence.
Murder Recap retweeted
According to Voss interview & Karen Read's own words, Karen invented most, if not all of the narrative that will later take hold in the public. It seems, these ideas weren't triggered by evidence. It's also telling that Karen never mentions Scanlon as a source. Only her attys do.
Replying to @MBeachlover
Exactly. Once the history of this is carefully documented, what is evident is that the theory that this was anything other than a vehicular homicide doesn't emerge until the 2nd arrest. Also, Karen Read admits to Voss that she invented almost the entire narrative. On her own.
According to Voss interview & Karen Read's own words, Karen invented most, if not all of the narrative that will later take hold in the public. It seems, these ideas weren't triggered by evidence. It's also telling that Karen never mentions Scanlon as a source. Only her attys do.
Replying to @MBeachlover
Exactly. Once the history of this is carefully documented, what is evident is that the theory that this was anything other than a vehicular homicide doesn't emerge until the 2nd arrest. Also, Karen Read admits to Voss that she invented almost the entire narrative. On her own.
Chloe (German Sheppard) could have bit an entire boy scout troop, but if her DNA was not found on John O'Keefe & injuries to his arm do not comport in trajectory to a a dog attack, she didn't bite John O'Keefe. Coincidence is interesting, but it's not evidence.
2
19
The easiest way to distort reliable information is to distract viewers with shiny-data that is meaningless. But that elicits emotion, especially if it elicits anger. Don't be distracted from the evidence on the Karen Read case by emails. The evidence is ALL that matters.
3
35
Murder Recap retweeted
If @DoctorTurtleboy wants to claim he's a journalist, he needs to do what is required of journalists-verification of the facts he relies on. Can't do that if one doesn't examine all the evidence & one is also able to explain why one analysis was deemed more reliable than another.
Replying to @hungus14
Except if @DoctorTurtleboy claims he's a journalist, a critical part to journalism is VERIFYING facts. Which means he can't just blindly agree with Richard Green's analysis, he must explain why he ruled out all the other experts who differed with Green. Facts must be verified.
If @DoctorTurtleboy wants to claim he's a journalist, he needs to do what is required of journalists-verification of the facts he relies on. Can't do that if one doesn't examine all the evidence & one is also able to explain why one analysis was deemed more reliable than another.
Replying to @hungus14
Except if @DoctorTurtleboy claims he's a journalist, a critical part to journalism is VERIFYING facts. Which means he can't just blindly agree with Richard Green's analysis, he must explain why he ruled out all the other experts who differed with Green. Facts must be verified.
This is an aspect of 3rd party culp theory presented by Karen Read's defense that never made any sense to me. If John's death had actually been the result of falling during a fight-the easiest way to hide this is to place him on in a street. No reason to put on a major production
Riddle me this: Why if John O'Keefe fell during a fight, would his killer need to frame anyone? Why not place John somewhere consistent with him falling while walking? There would have been no way to know at 12:32 am that Karen Read would show up with a damaged taillight at 6 am.
13
Riddle me this: Why if John O'Keefe fell during a fight, would his killer need to frame anyone? Why not place John somewhere consistent with him falling while walking? There would have been no way to know at 12:32 am that Karen Read would show up with a damaged taillight at 6 am.
Murder Recap retweeted
nypost.com/2026/11/20/us-new… Here's the quote: "Jackson is among Hollywood’s most sought-after defense attorneys, having helped Karen Read BEAT murder charges in two separate trials."
"beat charges" not "prove her innocence".
Fraser Bohm case just got more interesting.
nypost.com/2026/11/20/us-new… Here's the quote: "Jackson is among Hollywood’s most sought-after defense attorneys, having helped Karen Read BEAT murder charges in two separate trials."
"beat charges" not "prove her innocence".
Fraser Bohm case just got more interesting.
From the start EVERYONE, including Karen Read, agreed-this was a vehicle homicide case. This is evidenced in who Karen consulted with the night of John's death. Karen phones attys who specialize in drunk driving. No reason to do that, if she didn't think she hit John O'Keefe.
Murder Recap retweeted
Karen Read claims in recent deposition that she watched John O'Keefe SKIP up the Albert drive with drink in hand. Question: WHEN did this happen, as we know that at 12:24 there was an F-150 at the bottom of that drive. & Julie Nagel walked down & back up the drive-never saw John?
Murder Recap retweeted
Cult of personality wars won't solve the Karen Read case. Only evidence can do this.
Karen Read claims in recent deposition that she watched John O'Keefe SKIP up the Albert drive with drink in hand. Question: WHEN did this happen, as we know that at 12:24 there was an F-150 at the bottom of that drive. & Julie Nagel walked down & back up the drive-never saw John?
Murder Recap retweeted
The evidence is what matters on the Karen Read case. As this is a circumstantial evidence case, the only way to understand the evidence is to view each piece of evidence within the context of ALL the other evidence.
In the early days of the Karen Read case Karen fully admitted she must have "HIT SOMETHING" & that this case was a motor vehicle homicide. Even @BostonDefender acknowledges this. (No reason to call an atty who specializes in drunk driving if Karen didn't think she'd hit John.)
The evidence is what matters on the Karen Read case. As this is a circumstantial evidence case, the only way to understand the evidence is to view each piece of evidence within the context of ALL the other evidence.
In the early days of the Karen Read case Karen fully admitted she must have "HIT SOMETHING" & that this case was a motor vehicle homicide. Even @BostonDefender acknowledges this. (No reason to call an atty who specializes in drunk driving if Karen didn't think she'd hit John.)
In the early days of the Karen Read case Karen fully admitted she must have "HIT SOMETHING" & that this case was a motor vehicle homicide. Even @BostonDefender acknowledges this. (No reason to call an atty who specializes in drunk driving if Karen didn't think she'd hit John.)
Murder Recap retweeted
Don't let innuendo & emails distract from the evidence on any criminal case. Especially Karen Read's. Doesn't matter when Chloe was rehomed, or that someone got a time wrong-including Karen. What matters is hard evidence-and that is ALL that matters. Conjecture is NOT evidence.



