Pierre (@PHfloor) header
Pierre (@PHfloor) profile picture

Development planning expert | Decades in the uncomfortable trenches of demography, sociology, macroeconomics, housing policy & sustainable development | Charts

Joined June 2020
Photo by Pierre (@PHfloor)Photo by Pierre (@PHfloor)Photo by Pierre (@PHfloor)Photo by Pierre (@PHfloor)Photo by Pierre (@PHfloor)Photo by Pierre (@PHfloor)Photo by Pierre (@PHfloor)Photo by Pierre (@PHfloor)Photo by Pierre (@PHfloor)Photo by Pierre (@PHfloor)
Housing starts swing wildly. Annoying I know. Linear trend always “up,” polynomial shows the cycle (better fit with data). Can we get to the mythical supply-sider green line where volatility is suppressed + more supply + more empty units...which presumably drives price⬇️?
3
4
1
15
37,655
To be honest, the aggregate national data is a bit meaningless anyway. Have a look at the chart for your city. rbc.com/en/economics/wp-cont…
I don’t know about you all, but it looks to me like condo and single family homes move in lockstep
102
I'm pretty sure this drawdown from previous ATH will not be remembered--unless, of course, it drops much more.
To put the $7.4 trillion figure in perspective: The US lost $10.5 trillion in value between 2007 and 2009 during the Great Financial Crash. The US market lost $7.4 trillion in value THIS WEEK alone. This was a bloodbath
73
No it does not, but when RE does take a hit, the fact that it is leveraged, it hurts more financially and takes much longer to recover. But at least you get to live in it.
Real estate doesn’t collapse like this in a day, week, month, etc etc
1
2
234
Roughly the equivalent of 18.2% of the federal debt...in a week. Damn.
ABOUT $7.4 TRILLION WIPED OUT OF THE U.S. STOCK MARKET THIS WEEK
103
Presumably you buy when this indicator gets around this low...correct?
1
1
99
NDX drawdowns from previous ATHs. We are flirting with "bear" market territory here. It's been worse... Hope all the data/advice you got from being on here helped you avoid these.
1
78
SPX keeps getting pummeled over and over. How bad does this one get? Does it hold here?
1
2
314
Yes, this issue has been flagged for a while now. See Bloomberg piece published in Feb 2024: bloomberg.com/news/articles/…
I’ve been flagging this for years. It’s been a known problem associated with the disastrous Trudeau era temp resident debacle. It seems that @MarkJCarney and @LenaMetlegeDiab want to permanently embed this into our demographics
1
136
Qatar's population is very skewed to males. Why? Temporary foreign workers. While men who contribute to the skew are not the same men over time due a constant churn of workers, the persistent condition of a society of mostly men is not particularly healthy.
51
Swaraj is correct. Few understand what the impacts of eliminating a t-com carrier will mean for prices and service.
few understand this
1
1
154
Anything city council can do to prevent further drops in rental rates at turnover would be welcome.
This is a nuclear bomb for the multi-family industry. Record purpose-built rental completing into soft rents and possibly vacancy controls freezing turnover rents.
190
Good prices...
Calgary’s condo market shifting as supply outpaces demand. "A two-bedroom, two-bathroom condo initially listed in the low three-hundred-thousands is now selling for $230,900. A one-bedroom, one-bathroom in the same building dropped $55,000 to $194,900." cbc.ca/news/canada/calgary/s…
287
Jack is correct. There is "economic theory" that supports smaller oligopolies. Anyone know if Canada's t-com "market structure" would be better off with fewer operators? Or is "market structure" the same across all t-com markets where the optimal no. of competitors is known?
Carney is correct. In markets with high fixed costs and economies of scale, the relationship between firm # and product $ is not necessarily monotonically decreasing.
153
No, but hoteliers should seek housing arrangements suitable for their workforce. Also, hotel accommodation is highly segmented offering different prices ranges across product types and within individual properties. The same is true of housing (remember filtering?)
Should hotels have to sell 20% of their rooms at affordable rates for low-income tourists?
1
186
Pretty sure this guy means that the PM doesn't need to apologize. Could of said these kinds of mergers are evaluated by government who test them against the public interest. Market structure? Lol...way to invite an apology you didn't need to.
Terrible indictment of our world the sheer amount of qualifying and apologizing he has to do before saying something unintuitive but true.
1
209
Pretend Canadian cities are neighborhoods within a big city. In the chart below, the neighborhoods grow fairly consistently with population (how can it be otherwise?). And there are neighborhoods people are willing to pay more for to live in. So what's the problem?
Article in today's Vancouver Tyee on the housing crisis and solutions in plain sight: "Vancouver’s own record — more infill units relative to its base than any other North American centre city, paired with the continent’s highest price-to-income ratios — remains the clearest demonstration that “supply, supply, supply” is not a sufficient policy." thetyee.ca/Opinion/2026/11/1…
1
145
The phrase, "location, location, location" is long-standing, well-understood by almost everyone, and it is no secret that Vancouver clearing prices for homes is higher than in other Canadian cities...like forever (wonder why?). And somehow Vancouver keeps growing, thriving.
79
It’s true. RBC just bumped its population growth forecasts up by 0.1% for the next two years--now expecting 0.4% in 2026 (up from 0.3%) and 0.6% in 2027 (up from 0.5%). Honestly...it could be zero and we’d still be just fine.
1
241
Folks, if you want supply, you gotta buy the homes.
1
158
Correct, nothing like the GFC. US households in aggregate are in good shape and mortgage delinquencies are in check.
I'm hearing a lot of "this is just like 2006-2007, sales crashed right before home prices crashed." But existing home sales hit an ALL-TIME HIGH in 2005 at ~7.1M units. In 2006 they fell to about 6.5M sales, which is still the 3rd-highest year on record. And in 2007, 5.65M, the 6th strongest year ever. Over the past few years, home sales have been at 30-year lows and are now on pace to hit the lowest point since the mid-1990s. Existing home sales in 2023 rank #29 all time, while 2024 and 2025 are tied for #30. The year 2026 is on pace to be the weakest year since 1995, ranked #32. With population growth since then up nearly 40%... Think about this. Home sales PEAKED in the prior cycle when we had the worst mortgages imaginable, the worst underwriting, the shoddiest appraisals. New, unqualified home buyers were arriving in droves while existing homeowners tapped their equity to 100%. When housing affordability tanked this cycle, home sales plummeted, which is a HEALTHY response. It's what you want (and expect) to happen. In addition, the bulk of the entire outstanding mortgage universe today was originated in 2020-21 when mortgage rates hit record lows. Home prices have also risen 50-60% nationally since 2020. So your typical homeowner today has an LTV of 50% or less and a 2-4% 30-year fixed mortgage, which was fully underwritten as well. In 2006, they had zero equity and an adjustable-rate mortgage they qualified for via stated income or no doc underwriting backed by an appraisal that was handpicked by the originator. I understand the temptation to compare the two periods, and there are aspects that "rhyme," but it's far more different than it is the same.
111