Pinned Tweet
The Constitution of Ireland begins not with government, but with the Nation—with the People themselves. That is not symbolism. That is authority.
It is from the People that all power flows, and it is by our collective will that we established the Constitution as the supreme law of this State. Within it, we gave ourselves courts—not as instruments of control, but as guardians of liberty. Under Article 34, we vested those courts with a solemn duty: to protect and vindicate our personal rights.
Those personal rights are not abstract ideas. They are expressly recognised and protected across the Constitution—beginning in Article 40, and extending through Articles 41, 42, 42A, 43, and 44. Together, they safeguard what it means to live freely and with dignity in Ireland:
our personal liberty,
our families,
our children,
our right to educate according to conscience,
our private property,
and our freedom of religion.
These rights do not exist at the pleasure of the State. They do not depend on policy, preference, or administrative convenience. They are fundamental, and they are inalienable.
What we are witnessing at this moment is something profoundly serious. A member of the Government—holding office as a Minister of State, an office that exists only by statute—has purported, through a statutory instrument, to prevent the People of Ireland from exercising their constitutional rights in their own courts.
That cannot stand.
No statutory instrument can override the Constitution.
No minister, junior or otherwise, can suspend fundamental rights.
No act of secondary legislation can lawfully obstruct access to the courts where those rights are vindicated.
To suggest otherwise is not merely mistaken—it is constitutionally impossible.
The courts do not belong to the executive.
They do not belong to departments.
They belong to the People, because the Constitution says so.
And so, this is where the line is drawn.
The Constitution is not optional.
Fundamental rights are not negotiable.
Access to justice is not a privilege to be rationed.
Tomorrow, the law will be laid plainly before the Minister for Justice—not in defiance, but in fidelity to the Constitution; not in anger, but in duty to the People; not for personal grievance, but for the protection of all.
Because if fundamental rights can be restrained today, they can be extinguished tomorrow.
And if we do not stand now, we leave our children standing alone later.
This is not about power.
It is about principle.
It is about ensuring that the Constitution lives—not on paper, but in practice.
And it is about the furtherance of our fundamental rights, so that we may protect ourselves, our families, our children, the way we educate our children, our private property, and our religion—today, and for generations to come.
#NoFeeOnGuarantee – at Ireland
Patrick McGreal retweeted
Poor wee SF health spokesman David Cullinane is confused. He just does not see "where is the controversy" with the new SF guidance on responding to the vexed question of "what is a woman?"
But surely, if anyone appreciates the controversy, it is David who, in April 2025 published a Tweet welcoming the UK Supeme Court decision restoring the primacy of biological sex, but, within 24 hours was forced to issue an Tweet apology.
And a fortnight later, David was accompanied by his boss and party leader Mary Lou McDonald (in my mind "accompanied" is David being dragged along by the ear lugs by Mary Lou holding a wooden spoon in the other hand) to a meeting with NGOs like TENI and BelongTo, after which he proclaimed "Trans women are women" (and presumably "a trans woman is a woman"). Since then, David has been muted on the subject, and in fact, he later denied that he met with NGOs.
So when yesterday, the SF HQ guidance was published in the Irish Daily Mail beginning with "a woman is an adult female", it must surely be controversial for David especially, because that is at odds with his "a trans woman is a woman", because otherwise, the SF positition is "a trans woman is an adult female (a woman is an adult female)"
Just for the fun of it, someone should ask David about this illogicality, but be careful he might accuse you of othering him!
Come back Padraig MacLochlainn, all is forgiven!
SF HQ new advice on what their reps should say to the vexed question of 'what is a woman?' ...
"Like most people, I see a woman as an adult female. There are also trans women. A trans woman is someone who was recorded as male at birth but who identifies and lives as a woman. ~ [where a Gender Recognition Certificate has been issued, ‘a person is legally recognised in their preferred gender’]"
In April 2025, SF TD for Donegal and party chief whip Padraig MacLochlainn told his local radio station that a woman was an adult female (before passionately expounding agreed party policy on supports for gender dysphoria). He's been in the doghouse since, with SF HQ putting him forward just twice in 1.5 years for national political panel debate shows (previously he was on 3-5 a year).
But where does it leave SF health spokesman David Cullinane who was hauled by Mary Lou McDonald to a meeting of "trans" NGOs to be re-educated, emerging to proclaim "Trans women are women"? That wording is not in the above SF HQ advice David!
Whichever Court Answers, the Right to Place Sworn Facts Before a Judge Moves Forward
Today in the High Court, before Mr Justice Brian Cregan, Senior Counsel for the Courts Service, Eoghan Cole SC, told the court that the Courts Service would not be moving to have my posts removed, recognising that such a step could engage my constitutional rights. I welcome that. The right of the citizen to express freely his convictions and opinions is guaranteed by Article 40.6.1° of the Constitution, and it is right that it was acknowledged in open court.
Mr Justice Cregan also adjourned my ex parte motion so that it can be heard on notice, and the Courts Service will now reply to it. The matter is back before the High Court on 9 December 2026. A question about the reach of a court order affects the rights of every person who might one day stand where I stand, so it deserves to be answered with every side heard.
The question is simple. Can a member of the public lay sworn information before a judge of the District Court under the Petty Sessions (Ireland) Act 1851, as the law has allowed since that Act was passed? I have asked the court to say so plainly, and I am content to wait for the answer.
I would be glad to bring my information before my own local District Court, a court of local and limited jurisdiction established under Article 34 of the Constitution. But there is real value in the High Court answering the question first. Under the doctrine of stare decisis, a determination of the High Court binds the Circuit Court and the District Court throughout the State. Whatever the High Court decides about a citizen's right to place sworn facts before a judge will not be confined to my case. It will guide every court of first instance in the country, and every person who comes after me.
So I don't see this as time lost. I see it as the question moving to where it can be settled for everyone. Either way the law moves forward, and either way I will keep exercising my rights calmly, in good faith and on the record.
#FundamentalRightsMatter #NoFeeOnStateGuarantee #OpenJustice #RuleOfLaw
Complaint Against Supermac's Ireland Limited Received by Mullingar District Court
Judge Bernadette Owens has received my complaint against Supermac's Ireland Limited at Mullingar District Court, under section 32 of the Waste Management Act 1996, about the company's derelict land in the town. The matter has been adjourned to 16 December 2026 at Mullingar District Court, when I will give my sworn information to the court.
I have also sent Supermac's Ireland Limited a letter by registered post to its registered office in Galway. It gives formal notice of the complaint, encloses the correspondence the company has so far left unanswered, and includes a copy of the written information.
The company still has the chance to restore the gate, repair the fencing and clear the waste before the court sits. If it does, I will tell the court. If it does not, the court will hear the facts.
Read the letter and its attachments here:
drive.google.com/file/d/1p8I…
#FundamentalRightsMatter #NoFeeOnStateGuarantee #OpenJustice
Supermac's Ireland Limited Now Faces a Private Prosecution in Mullingar District Court
I gave Supermac's Ireland Limited 24 hours to confirm it would restore the missing gate, repair the collapsed fencing and remove the waste on its derelict land in Mullingar. I followed up in writing, copied Westmeath County Council, and gave written notice of enforcement action. No reply.
So I am now laying an information before Mullingar District Court under section 32 of the Waste Management Act 1996, on two counts: facilitating the dumping of waste, and holding waste in a manner likely to cause environmental pollution. Under S.I. No. 164 of 1998, any member of the public may bring these proceedings.
This is about a gate, a fence and litter beside a road where children walk to school. A company earning tens of millions a year could have fixed it with one phone call. It chose silence, so now the court will hear the facts.
Read the information here:
drive.google.com/file/d/1X42…
#FundamentalRightsMatter #NoFeeOnStateGuarantee #OpenJustice
From the Preamble to Our Front Door, the Constitution Walks With Every Family in Ireland
The Constitution begins with “We, the people”. The Nation comes before the State, and all powers of government derive from the people. The State lives under the people who created it, not the other way round. Our statutes, like the Data Protection Act, the Freedom of Information Act and the Petty Sessions Act, are the sword and shield the Constitution promised. But nobody hands them to us. We have to know them, point them out and use them. In under four years I went from not knowing what an affidavit was to using them every day, and so can you: 👇
patrickmcgreal.substack.com/…
#FundamentalRightsMatter #NoFeeOnStateGuarantee #OpenJustice #RuleOfLaw
🤖 Made with AI
This week a national newspaper printed my name beside words I never chose. It reported a judgment, and the judgment repeated sworn accounts whose records were never produced in court: no CCTV, no incident report, no Garda record. I’m lucky. My family and my community know who I am. But I think of the person who doesn’t have that support. Tomorrow I go before the High Court, still searching for facts, because the truth is found in facts: 👇
patrickmcgreal.substack.com/…
#FundamentalRightsMatter
#OpenJustice
#NoFeeOnStateGuarantee
#RuleOfLaw
When a Citizen Walks the Lawful Road, the Facts Have Nowhere Left to Hide
Affidavits sworn in my High Court case described events in October 2024, but no record of those events was ever put before the court. No CCTV, no incident report, no Garda record. I’m not saying they don’t exist. Nobody can say, because they have never been produced. So today I made ten written applications under the Data Protection Act 2018 and the Freedom of Information Act 2014, asking for the records those affidavits rest on, with answers due by law in mid-December. Tomorrow I ask the High Court how far its order reaches, so that the facts can be placed before an independent judge of the District Court. The truth is found in facts, and the law gives every citizen the means to ask for them: 👇
patrickmcgreal.substack.com/…
#FundamentalRightsMatter
#OpenJustice
#NoFeeOnStateGuarantee
#RuleOfLaw
Two Bodies Corporate, Two Very Different Deals for the People of Ireland
Supermac's Ireland Limited and the Courts Service are both bodies corporate. Neither has a life, a family or personal liberty, so neither holds the personal rights the Constitution guarantees to the people of Ireland. Both serve the public, but the difference in what each takes from us and gives back is stark.
Supermac's takes in around €314 million a year, and every cent comes from people who freely choose to walk in the door. In return they get a hot meal, served on the spot, in towns all over the country. If the service is poor, people go elsewhere and the company feels it.
Under the Appropriation Act 2025, the Courts Service received €165.8 million straight from the taxpayer, paid by every household whether or not they ever set foot in a courtroom. It was also allowed to keep a further €35 million in receipts, largely the fees we pay at the counter, bringing the total to over €200 million in one year.
So we pay twice. We fund the Courts Service through our taxes, and when we come to it to vindicate our fundamental rights, we are charged again to file our documents. Since September, even an Article 40.4 complaint is only fee-free if the person is detained at the very moment proceedings are brought.
The administration of justice is a constitutional function no fast-food company can perform, and that is exactly why the comparison matters. A company selling chips must earn every euro it takes, while a public body funded by all of us charges us again to reach the very rights it exists to protect. In my view, the people of Ireland get far more for their money at a fast-food counter than from the courts that belong to them.
#FundamentalRightsMatter #NoFeeOnStateGuarantee #OpenJustice
Supermac's Is Merely a Corporate Body and the People of Mullingar Come First
I have sent a follow-up email to Supermac's Ireland Limited about its derelict land in Mullingar, and Westmeath County Council is now engaged. The email sets out the statutory duties engaged by the missing gate, the collapsed fencing and the litter on the site, and asks the council to use its own powers to have the land made safe. The 24-hour notice I gave Supermac's this morning still stands.
It is worth being clear about who we are dealing with. Supermac's Ireland Limited is merely a corporate body: a legal entity created on paper and registered with the Companies Registration Office. It can own land and enter contracts, but it holds none of the personal rights the Constitution guarantees to people. It has no life to protect, no bodily integrity and no children walking to school. The families living around this site have all of those things, and it is their fundamental rights, and their personal liberty to move safely through their own community, that a neglected and unsecured site puts at risk.
Bringing this land back into line with the law might cost somewhere between ten and fifteen thousand euro at most, to repair the fencing, put back the gate, clear the litter and maintain it from now on. For a group earning tens of millions a year, that is a small price for regularising its position in our community. Ordinary people in Mullingar keep their homes, gardens and boundaries in order every day of the week without being told. A corporate body should be held to the same standard.
I expect Supermac's to be glad this has been brought to its attention, because an unsecured site is a real liability for the company. But it is a far greater liability for the community living beside it. Mullingar is in the Tidy Towns competition, and everyone has to pull their weight, including the largest landowners in town.
#FundamentalRightsMatter #NoFeeOnStateGuarantee #OpenJustice
A Citizen Has Written to Supermac's About Its Derelict Land in Mullingar
I have now written to Supermac's Ireland Limited, the registered owner of the derelict land in Mullingar, about its open entrance and broken boundary fence. I asked the company to confirm within 24 hours that it will put a gate back on the entrance, repair the fencing, clear the broken timber and litter, and maintain the land properly from now on.
This land sits in a built-up area where children, families and residents pass every day. An open, overgrown site behind a collapsed fence puts life and limb at risk, and that should concern everyone who lives here.
Supermac's is a big and very successful company. It has the means to put boots on the ground and fix this fence quickly. But a single citizen who knows the Constitution and the law can make bigger things happen. That is what this journey is about: showing that each of us has the power to protect our community when those responsible fail to act.
Follow the story here:
drive.google.com/file/d/1tHL…
#FundamentalRightsMatter #NoFeeOnStateGuarantee #OpenJustice
Who Owns the Derelict Land in Mullingar
I found the owner of the derelict land in Mullingar. I located it on Google Maps, checked it on OpenStreetMap, then bought folio WH37267F on landdirect.ie for €5. The full owner is Supermac's Ireland Limited. I will now write to their property contact with photographs, opening an inquiry into how this neglect affects the rights of people living nearby.
#FundamentalRightsMatter #NoFeeOnStateGuarantee #OpenJustice
I found derelict land in Mullingar with the gate taken off and fences down, unrepaired for what looks like years. It sits in a built-up area where children walk to school and families pass daily. This is a danger to life, person and our environment. I will show you step by step how we can deal with it ourselves when our local council fails in its duty.
#FundamentalRightsMatter #NoFeeOnStateGuarantee #OpenJustice
Holding Officials to Their Functions Protects Everyone's Rights
The High Court is where we vindicate, defend and protect our fundamental rights. But the District Courts in every county are open to us too, to enforce the statutory law when Irish officials step outside it. Every official exists to discharge a defined function. When one acts beyond that function, the conduct can be identified and prosecuted on its facts, or charged using the pre-approved offence code and wording. Each time an official is held to the rule of law, our fundamental rights are made stronger, not only for ourselves but for our families, our children and our communities.
#FundamentalRightsMatter #NoFeeOnStateGuarantee #OpenJustice
No office holder in Ireland, however high, has the authority to reach into the fundamental rights of a citizen or person living here. That includes the Attorney General, the Commissioner of An Garda Síochána, and corporate bodies such as the Courts Service. The Constitution gives the administration of justice to the courts alone, and no official stands between a member of the public and a judge.
Every person in Ireland has the right to swear an information before our District Court that an offence has been committed. No official can lawfully decide on the court's behalf whether your complaint will be heard. The decision to issue a summons or a warrant belongs to the judge alone.
That is why we must learn how to particularise an offence. Every statutory offence is made up of essential elements set out in the law. When you swear an information, you tell the court the time, the place, and exactly what the accused person did or failed to do, so that each element is met by the facts.
The attempts to stop me doing this have not come from the institutions of the State. They have come from individual people working within those institutions who chose not to follow the rules that bind them. That is the act of the individual, and it should be named as such.
Learn the elements of the offence. Set out the facts that meet them. Swear your information before the District Court. Our fundamental rights, including our personal liberty, are only as strong as our willingness to stand on them.
#FundamentalRightsMatter #NoFeeOnStateGuarantee #OpenJustice
How to Particularise an Alleged Offence in Plain Facts
Particulars should describe what a person did, not repeat the words of the statute. Start with the date and time, then the place, then the conduct act by act in ordinary language. Leave out legal labels such as "intentionally" or "without consent". Those are conclusions the court draws from the facts.
Every essential element must be met by a fact, and you should be able to name the section, subsection and limb each fact engages. You do not have to negative any defence or exception (Order 15, rule 9), and alternatives in the statute can be stated together (Order 15, rule 8).
Example under section 15 of the Non-Fatal Offences Against the Person Act 1997: "On the 1st of January 2020, A removed B from the front steps of a building on Main Street, brought B to a building on Church Street, kept B in that building for approximately two hours, and then let B go, and at no point did B agree to being removed, brought or kept."
A is "a person" and B is "another" under section 15(1). "Removed" and "brought" engage section 15(1)(a), "takes". "Kept" engages section 15(1)(a), "detains". "At no point did B agree" engages section 15(1), "without that other's consent". "Intentionally or recklessly" is inferred from the deliberate acts. Section 15(1)(b), "causes to be taken or detained", would apply if A directed someone else to do the acts, and section 15(1)(c), "otherwise restricts the personal liberty of", covers restrictions such as blocking a person's way.
Every element is met by a fact, with no legal conclusion. A court that refuses it has to say this conduct is not an offence.
#FundamentalRightsMatter #NoFeeOnStateGuarantee #OpenJustice
Finding an Irish Official's Address for a Private Prosecution
1. Set out the conduct. Write down what the Irish official did, when and where, as plain facts. Match each fact to an element of the offence in the statute. You don't have to negative any exception or defence (Order 15, rule 9).
2. Write to the body that holds their records. Ask its head, such as a Commissioner, Secretary General or Chief Executive, to attend the District Court voluntarily on a set date, or to send someone from the office, to identify the official and produce the record of their address. Set a deadline and keep proof of sending.
3. Let the deadline pass. A refusal or no reply shows the evidence won't be given voluntarily, which section 13 of the Petty Sessions (Ireland) Act 1851 requires.
4. Lay your information before a District Court Judge, on oath and in writing (Form 15.3). Set out the facts and what you know of the official's identity, state that the address is unknown, and exhibit your letter and any reply.
5. Ask for a witness summons in the same application. Under section 13(1) and Order 21, rule 1, ask the Judge to summon the head of the body to produce the identifying records, and to adjourn your summons application to that date.
6. Serve the witness summons at least three clear days before the return date (Order 21, rule 1(3)).
7. Attend on the return date. Once the records are produced, the Judge can issue the summons with the address included (Order 15, rule 3(1)). If the witness fails to attend without just excuse, prove service and ask for a warrant.
8. Serve the summons on the official for the hearing date it fixes.
#FundamentalRightsMatter #NoFeeOnStateGuarantee #OpenJustice
It's up to everyone in Ireland to hold Irish officials accountable to our laws and courts. Nobody is above the law. Have sworn facts? Your local District Court is open to you. That's how our rights are protected and vindicated.
#NobodyAboveTheLaw #OpenJustice #FundamentalRightsMatter #NoFeeOnStateGuarantee
Nobody Is Exempt Because of Where They Work
The Oireachtas wrote offences that apply to Garda members and Courts Service staff exactly as they apply to everyone else, and it gave every person a route to put the facts before a District Court Judge. I traced that law from 1851 to today, and the chain never breaks: 👇
patrickmcgreal.substack.com/…
#FundamentalRightsMatter
#OpenJustice
#NoFeeOnStateGuarantee
#RuleOfLaw
I will ask the High Court whether its restriction order stops me laying sworn information's before a District Court Judge, a right every citizen has had for 175 years. I’m publishing the motion, affidavit and submissions in full so everyone can see how access to justice works: 👇
patrickmcgreal.substack.com/…
#FundamentalRightsMatter
#OpenJustice
#NoFeeOnStateGuarantee
#RuleOfLaw
These are the words viewers heard in the video. Every label in them comes from three charge sheets, and none of those sheets states any act. One recites the wording of section 6 of the Criminal Justice (Public Order) Act 1994. One says only that I "assaulted" a named person. One cites "Section 19" with no subsection and says I "did resist/wilfully obstruct" a Garda member. Statutory wording like that tells the public nothing about what happened, but it lets anyone who repeats it paint whatever picture the words suggest. Whoever writes the charge sheet controls the narrative long before any court hears a word of evidence.
The rules of the District Court provide a different picture. Order 17, rule 1(1) requires the particulars of the offence alleged to be set out on the charge sheet. In my notice of motion before the Dublin Metropolitan District Court, which I have already shared with you, I asked the court to amend the three charge sheets to do exactly that. The particulars I proposed are taken from the prosecution's own witness statements. Drafted that way, the charges would allege that I did shout the words "arrest" and "commissioner"; that I did grab the right forearm of Mr John Hiney with a strong grip and said I was arresting him; and that I did grab onto a bench and try to resist being removed from the courtroom by Garda Michael McGrath, using the carpet as a grip to further impede him.
Look at the picture, then read those words from my notice of motion. The same allegations, two very different stories. The first is built from labels that only a judge may apply after a trial. The second is what is actually alleged, which you, a reporter and the court can weigh for yourselves.
As my notice of motion makes clear, those particulars are the prosecution's account, not mine, and I do not admit their accuracy. I reserve my right to answer the truth of each complaint once the charge sheets state the conduct alleged, as the law requires. When the Garda members who draft charge sheets and the officers who prosecute in the Director's name follow the rules of court, the facts tell the story. When they don't, the labels do.
#FundamentalRightsMatter #OpenJustice #NoFeeOnStateGuarantee

























