Jonathan Barth (@Professor_Barth) header
Jonathan Barth (@Professor_Barth) profile picture

Christian, husband, father, historian, associate prof at ASU. Views expressed are mine alone.

Phoenix metro area, AZ
Joined July 2016
Photo by Jonathan Barth (@Professor_Barth)Photo by Jonathan Barth (@Professor_Barth)Photo by Jonathan Barth (@Professor_Barth)Photo by Jonathan Barth (@Professor_Barth)Photo by Jonathan Barth (@Professor_Barth)Photo by Jonathan Barth (@Professor_Barth)Photo by Jonathan Barth (@Professor_Barth)Photo by Jonathan Barth (@Professor_Barth)Photo by Jonathan Barth (@Professor_Barth)Photo by Jonathan Barth (@Professor_Barth)
Fear God, not man
8
12
3
77
14,662
No, it is not the Vice President's "job" "to support the President of the United States." The Vice President is an independent officer within the executive branch. Unlike the Secretary of State and other Cabinet officials, he does not serve at the pleasure of the President.
JD Vance responds to question whether going to war with Iran was worth it, and Trump’s face tells it all “The president said he would do it again. My view is that my goal and my job is to support the president of the United States.” Trump doesn’t look stoked by JD’s answer
1
70
Jonathan Barth retweeted
The reason everything sucks and is exploding in cost, including public schools but not at all limited to them, is that everyone must pay for an army of white-collar rent-seekers who do omnicausal activism and surveil the dwindling remnant of those who do the actual thing for signs that they believe criminals should be incarcerated or that men cannot be women
The Boston Symphony used to run on 100 musicians and 6 administrators. According to Heather Mac Donald, it now has about 100 of each. She says that's the real story behind the fight over what an orchestra is for. Mac Donald: "Feeding and keeping occupied all of these human resources consultants and whatnot costs a fortune, which results in ticket prices going up." Her fix is the part I keep coming back to. Mac Donald: "If you want a diverse audience, how about you lower your ticket prices? How about even making it free to schoolchildren?" Instead, she says, the staff needed something to do, so they started shaping the programming. This summer, one of Tanglewood's closing humanities programs was about mass incarceration and systemic racism. Mac Donald: "Classical music is seen simply as a jumping-off point to get to what really matters." On the other side is conductor Andris Nelsons, who wanted the orchestra's plan to name the core repertoire and the orchestra's own sound as its mission. That's the irony. The cheapest way to bring new people to Tchaikovsky is to let them hear Tchaikovsky. A free ticket for a 12-year-old does more for the audience of the future than another panel discussion. When the people running the music outnumber the people playing it, the music stops being the point.
58
369
18
3,233
120,885
Mamdani's lost his earlier magic. He's gaining weight; the mustache makes him look like Saddam Hussein. He can't answer a basic question about city-owned grocery stores without relying on banal slogans that don't meaningfully address the core concerns in the question.
Zohran Mamdani finally got confronted on his city-owned grocery store grift and his response is pure slop. "This is an industry that has typically a margin between 1% and 4% and your plan is to sell products at a 30% discount..."
232
357
20
4,731
225,456
Jonathan Barth retweeted
So we are importing foreigners at a rate seven times faster than our own population is growing? I don’t know, seems fair to me to call that replacement….
Between 2021 and 2025, the foreign-born population grew nearly 7 times faster (11.4%) than the U.S.-born population (1.7%). Over the longer period from 2010 to 2025, the foreign-born population grew more than three times faster than the U.S.-born population — 26.2% vs. 8.2%. The largest percentage increases in immigrants in the U.S. from 2010 to 2025 were for Venezuela, up 471%; Afghanistan, up 390%; Nepal, up 256%; Bangladesh, up 141%; Nigeria, up 119%; Kenya, up 113 %; Ghana, up 110%; Burma, up 108%; and Brazil, up 106%. Read more: cis.org/Camarota/Growth-Immi…
68
324
9
1,426
18,142
Jonathan Barth retweeted
Why is the history of slavery in the Islamic world so rarely discussed? Historian Justin Marozzi writes that the enslavement of millions of Africans across the Middle East and North Africa – a trade that lasted for centuries – has been largely absent from public debate in the region ⬇️ telegraph.co.uk/news/2025/11…
564
2,618
284
10,886
409,054
Jonathan Barth retweeted
35% of President Trump’s 2024 voters stayed home during the 2026 midterms, while 52% voted Republican and 8% switched to Democrats. Among Trump voters aged 18–29, 16% defected to Democrats, while lower Republican turnout accounted for roughly two-thirds of the overall Democratic swing. Follow: @AFpost
37
121
20
865
36,403
people often post this stuff to imply that moral panics about the technologies of the past were quaint. But the past is full of reminders that we are on a long, slow march away from embodied experience, and that we’ve lost more of it than we can even remember
Daily Mirror, September 14, 1938
212
3,320
194
34,890
1,331,269
Gee, why are Trump and the Republicans so unpopular in 2026 after winning so decisively in 2024? 🤔
Vote the pro-peace ticket. Vote Trump-Vance 🇺🇸
2
211
Jonathan Barth retweeted
This is mind blowing
569
2,921
368
16,867
2,845,719
Incredible.
California community college profs rake in up to $800K a year teaching dozens of online classes at once trib.al/r7MW2bU
38
32
13
768
90,020
It's a massive problem and it's contributed to the collapse of public trust in U.S. higher education. On top of that, the administrators and faculty are completely incapable of reforming themselves on this issue.
Not only have conservatives become vanishingly rare in academia, so have centrists. That’s how complete the left’s dominance is: Even moderates are now a fringe group in academia. stevestewartwilliams.com/p/a…
2
3
203
Jonathan Barth retweeted
One thing that is hard to convey to people who didn't experience it is the subtle, happy energy there was in just being around a lot of people who were all having a good time in a hyped-up atmosphere.
POV: you went back to Christmas in the 90s.
240
1,243
37
16,716
208,885
Jonathan Barth retweeted
I think the reason we so often depict the medieval era through fantasy is that depicting it realistically gives modern audiences an uncanny valley feeling. Its institutions, cultures, and religion are immediately recognizable to us. What’s harder for modern people to accept is how seriously medieval people took their beliefs in the supernatural. Modern audiences can easily understand a ruthless, politically calculating king using religion to justify his actions. What we struggle to comprehend is that the same king might genuinely fear for his immortal soul. To communicate how real the supernatural was to medieval people, authors make it physically manifest through dragons, wizards, etc. Fantasy can make the medieval worldview more comprehensible than realism.
Modern people are shocked to learn how different we are from the Romans and how similar we are to the medievals.
20
145
5
1,822
68,859
Jonathan Barth retweeted
Wow, a pretty damning article with diverse lines of evidence.
Most people do not realize just how easy the AP exams have gotten. They are not college level. Why/how have they become so easy? What's going on? This might shock you... A brutal new piece in Education Next just dropped, saying the decline in rigor of the AP in the last two decades is, in large part, because the content has been GUTTED. For example: — AP Biology cut 40% of its material — Required lines from the Aeneid in AP Latin halved — Spanish Lit reading list cut from 56 works to 38 Then the questions themselves have become absurdly easier. Readability measures show English passages have fallen multiple grade levels, and some now include footnotes defining basic words... A 2025 AP English prompt included footnote definitions for words like "optimism" and "pessimism." At the same time, scoring was recalibrated so that more students pass: guessing penalties disappeared, rubrics grew more generous, readers were told to give students the benefit of the doubt, etc. — "no one at College Board had any incentive to maintain rigor." College professors are now seeing students arrive with AP credit who lack basic content knowledge and writing ability. The College Board insists the exams have not become easier, but everybody familiar with them knows they've become an absolute joke. Advanced Placement is no longer advanced. This is not college level. It must be replaced.
165
826
350
15,011
1,807,954
Jonathan Barth retweeted
If you’re a millennial, you’ve spent your entire adult life watching the United States engage in action after action in the Middle East without any lasting success, without even a definition of success - and no apparent strategy. It just goes on and on and on and on.
184
430
39
5,388
81,447
Jonathan Barth retweeted
Trump got regime change in Texas before Iran
630
25,232
1,151
222,191
3,631,773
Jonathan Barth retweeted
The Republican congress did nothing. Achieved nothing. Took the mandate they were given and did precisely zero with it. Feckless losers who are relieved to no longer be in the majority. The only thing Republicans do with power is bide their time until they can relinquish it.
2,972
11,477
696
98,867
1,188,885
Jonathan Barth retweeted
tenho muitas críticas ao mel gibson mas essa cena em específico é negócio de doido. os caras passam o filme todo se lacando, gente morrendo, apanhando, sendo caçada, bglh pesadissímo, mas nenhuma cena arrepia tanto a espinha de medo quanto essa, é o começo do fim
I don’t think I will ever understand this particular scene…
383
4,597
78
83,231
2,575,749
Jonathan Barth retweeted
Because it's Pat Buchanan's birthday....
Richard Nixon talking about Pat Buchanan in 1992. He called it about right:
24
145
6
1,609
63,084
A nurse tries to trap Matt Walsh on abortion, demanding to know why he’d force a 13-year-old to give birth to her rapist’s child. Then Walsh asks him one medical question, and the nurse wants to run away. NURSE: “Why do you believe that a 13-year-old should be forced to give birth to their rapist’s child?” WALSH: “I don’t think that it is ever okay to kill a child.” Then he flips it. WALSH: “You’re the medical expert. The unborn child, is that a human being or not?” NURSE: “That is a religious question.” WALSH: “It’s not a religious question. It’s a medical question. What is it if it’s not a human being?” NURSE: “Medically speaking, we don’t consider it a full-fledged human being.” WALSH: “What do you mean full-fledged?” Instead of answering, the nurse pivots: why don’t we have “conception certificates”? Or “a heartbeat certificate”? Walsh even agrees to the heartbeat certificate. But he keeps coming back to the one question. “Is the unborn child a human being or not?” Eventually, the nurse tries to bail. NURSE: “I appreciate your time.” WALSH: “No, no, no. Come back. Come back here.” “You’re the medical expert, and you won’t even tell us what a human being is. I’m starting to get concerned.” [crowd laughs] Then Walsh sums it up: “You have one side that can answer directly. It’s never okay to directly and intentionally kill a human child. That was my answer. I think I gave it probably 15, 20 times. “And then you have the other side that has no answer at all to this question. What is a human child? Can’t even answer it.” The nurse knew the answer. That’s why he left.
867
4,644
83
34,289
1,230,853