Chad🗽 (@Puff_Chady) header
Chad🗽 (@Puff_Chady) profile picture

Recommended by 4 out of 5 people that recommend things.

Joined November 2014
A piece of my childhood died today. 💔 Sir Patrick Stewart wasn't just Captain Jean-Luc Picard. He was a symbol of wisdom, courage, and hope for an entire generation. The captain may be gone, but his legacy will live among the stars forever. 🖖 Rest in peace, Sir Patrick Stewart (1940–2026). The final frontier will never be the same. #StarTrek #PatrickStewart
1
378
Sure. NYC values an $18.5 million condo at $1.1 million for property tax. That's not paying their share, that's a discount.
1
17
Theft would be using city services without paying for them. Oh wait.
14
Why do you think the apartment is worth $10 million? Because the city works. Guess who pays for that? Not them.
11
Says the account that thought a property surcharge was an income tax an hour ago. Made up stuff is your specialty.
14
Glad you're laughing. The bills already went out. The city's collecting either way.
1
14
It's not an income tax. It's a property surcharge. It's literally billed with property taxes. Difficult for you to comprehend, I know.
1
25
Tourists already pay hotel tax and sales tax every visit. You just made the case that second home owners were getting off easier than tourists.
1
21
We will. That's how it works. If he doesn't deliver, voters will decide in four years. So far it's been W after W. Approval's up 9 points in a month. New Yorkers are seeing it.
1
13
Agreed. Not owing anything to the old establishment is a big part of why people voted for him.
10
"Your mayor." Right, ours. And 69% of us view him favorably, per Siena last month. Your embarrassment isn't showing up in the numbers.
2
17
So you'd rather every homeowner in the city pay more than a few thousand second home owners. Got it.
1
10
It was excessive, and it got dropped. The surcharge is what replaced it. Sounds like you prefer the surcharge.
5
Fair, property tax brings in more overall. Which is why this matters. The city was going to raise property taxes 9.5% on everyone. The pied a terre surcharge replaced that. Would you rather everyone pay?
2
14
You went from "they pay their regular taxes" to "the whole city is embarrassing." Out of arguments already? The city income tax has been around since 1966. NYC is still the most expensive city in the country to buy into. People clearly aren't embarrassed.
2
12
Heads, the city collects $500 million. Tails, a full time New Yorker moves in and pays city tax. Pick one.
17
Because their "regular taxes" skip the biggest one New Yorkers pay. City income tax. I pay it every paycheck. They don't. The surcharge closes part of that gap.
2
1
20
"I own a 2nd home in NYC." Well, that explains everything you've posted in this thread. Is it worth over $5 million? If not, why are you so worried?
7
Chase people out of a city they don't live in? That's the whole point. They're already out. And if they sell, and someone who actually lives here moves in and pays city tax. That's not a downside. "Minimal use"? The FDNY still shows up if their building catches fire, and the NYPD still patrols their block. Their property gets protected year round, occupied or not.
3
44
Says the guy defending people who use NYC services and skip NYC income tax. Someone else pays for their things. Literally.
1
12