A few more words
Fanon taught us that the colonial subject has no ontological resistance when it comes to colonial projections. I return to this so often when thinking about anti-Blackness. It still causes me some discomfort, not sure I full agree or disagree. I agree with one major caveat… I think, I may return to it.
This statement firstly speaks to the reality that material inequality for Fanon at least, fuels projections of inferiority, such that it is not possible to resist colonial projections without transforming the material conditions that lead to supremacism.
It speaks to power asymmetry since it is much harder to resist projections that originate from positions of power.
It also means that the projections of intellectual inferiority in anti-Black racism have consequential institutional enactments which actively interferes with the conditions necessary for the secure development and expression of optimal Black intellectual capacities.
So you’re not only resisting the fantasy of particulars social actors, the fantasy starts to organise structural reality so you’re also fighting structures to try to free yourself from the original projection…
And as physiological beings, our very biology can become restricted, conditioned, fixed, as Fanon might say, to reproduce the very outcome or fantasy under curated conditions, I would argue, including particular forms of testing. So the projection becomes productive of the very disturbance it subsequently claims to just observe.
I also want to be clear that what I am not saying is that hatred and anti-Black racism produce less intelligent Black people.
Rather, they can create the conditions under which Black people cannot function cognitively at their optimal capacity.
And again, that is not to say that I value this particular faculty as being the defining measure of human intelligence or human worth.
I wrote The World Does Not Need More Intelligent Men for that very reason.
And I take us back to Kongolese metaphysical traditions that see the heart as the centre of human intelligence, and human intelligence as inseparable from morality, ethics and community welfare...
A few thoughts of Eugenics, the Cofnas debacle
I have been rather quiet and observed events as they enfolded. I am ready to share a few thoughts.
The moment you give sadistic people and systems access to a tender spot, they will keep kicking you there, irrespective of whether they themselves created the wound in the first place. I need all of us to come to grip with this troubling reality.
There has been much reactivity from many of us in response to the discussions around race, intelligence and eugenics led by Cofnas.
I understand that when people are targeted, they react, so I am not judging that process. It is largely physiological.
What I am saying is that we need to remind ourselves that, if we are dealing with systemic, sadistic anti-Blackness in the way that we are, as demonstrated by the gleeful hounding of Professor Jason Arday to death, then the more we react, the more we potentially make ourselves vulnerable.
These Antiblack discourses around intelligence are potent poison, particularly for the more vulnerable among us, those who are less equipped to resist their internalisation.
If we say that psychic structures and social structures are so deeply intertwined that they may, for all intents and purposes, be one and the same, then we need to recast the reactive protests we have witnessed.
If the evocation of a misconceived claim creates so much disturbance and agitation externally — no matter how racist it may be, we must consider what disturbance and mess it may already have created internally, particularly in those targeted.
My concern, as always, is primarily community welfare.
So, how might we protect ourselves and each other? How do we detach ourselves from what is designed to harm us? How do we become less vulnerable to its noxious effects? These are the questions that interest me, because this is how we begin to take away some of the potency of the poison and therefore the social power of bad faith actors who farm on it.
I continue to say that anti-Blackness is an attack on the cerebral system.
It is an attack on the Black brain. It is an attack on our capacity to think, on the ability of our cerebral system to experience safety, to develop as intended and to reach its optimal potential.
All traumatogenic agents have the capacity to interfere with these processes, so imagine those that are specifically loaded with that intention.
Of course, the formations of anti-Blackness that construct Black people as intellectually deficient or dysfunctional are designed to assault the very function they critique!
This is akin to an observer who cannot understand that he is implicated in shaping the very phenomenon he claims merely to observe.
Racist eugenic discourses are part of creating the conditions that can then affect the faculty they claim is defective. Need to be defective for narcissistic reasons.
That this irony cannot be seen by those who consider themselves at the peak of human intelligence makes it all the more funny to me.
The Black brain is affected as it reacts. The more it reacts, the more it can be affected. As it takes in, as it introjects, it responds to the toxic demands placed on it, and in responding, it risks becoming increasingly defined by the very discourses directed against it.
And that is what I want to leave you with.
Not necessarily whether people should be allowed to debate hate, protest or agitate against eugenicist nonsense, or whether we should censor it. This is not the direction of this conversation. Usual considerations?
What interests me primarily is how, as a community, we protect ourselves, particularly our children, against the harm which is injected onto their brain.
1
23
A few thoughts of Eugenics, the Cofnas debacle
I have been rather quiet and observed events as they enfolded. I am ready to share a few thoughts.
The moment you give sadistic people and systems access to a tender spot, they will keep kicking you there, irrespective of whether they themselves created the wound in the first place. I need all of us to come to grip with this troubling reality.
There has been much reactivity from many of us in response to the discussions around race, intelligence and eugenics led by Cofnas.
I understand that when people are targeted, they react, so I am not judging that process. It is largely physiological.
What I am saying is that we need to remind ourselves that, if we are dealing with systemic, sadistic anti-Blackness in the way that we are, as demonstrated by the gleeful hounding of Professor Jason Arday to death, then the more we react, the more we potentially make ourselves vulnerable.
These Antiblack discourses around intelligence are potent poison, particularly for the more vulnerable among us, those who are less equipped to resist their internalisation.
If we say that psychic structures and social structures are so deeply intertwined that they may, for all intents and purposes, be one and the same, then we need to recast the reactive protests we have witnessed.
If the evocation of a misconceived claim creates so much disturbance and agitation externally — no matter how racist it may be, we must consider what disturbance and mess it may already have created internally, particularly in those targeted.
My concern, as always, is primarily community welfare.
So, how might we protect ourselves and each other? How do we detach ourselves from what is designed to harm us? How do we become less vulnerable to its noxious effects? These are the questions that interest me, because this is how we begin to take away some of the potency of the poison and therefore the social power of bad faith actors who farm on it.
I continue to say that anti-Blackness is an attack on the cerebral system.
It is an attack on the Black brain. It is an attack on our capacity to think, on the ability of our cerebral system to experience safety, to develop as intended and to reach its optimal potential.
All traumatogenic agents have the capacity to interfere with these processes, so imagine those that are specifically loaded with that intention.
Of course, the formations of anti-Blackness that construct Black people as intellectually deficient or dysfunctional are designed to assault the very function they critique!
This is akin to an observer who cannot understand that he is implicated in shaping the very phenomenon he claims merely to observe.
Racist eugenic discourses are part of creating the conditions that can then affect the faculty they claim is defective. Need to be defective for narcissistic reasons.
That this irony cannot be seen by those who consider themselves at the peak of human intelligence makes it all the more funny to me.
The Black brain is affected as it reacts. The more it reacts, the more it can be affected. As it takes in, as it introjects, it responds to the toxic demands placed on it, and in responding, it risks becoming increasingly defined by the very discourses directed against it.
And that is what I want to leave you with.
Not necessarily whether people should be allowed to debate hate, protest or agitate against eugenicist nonsense, or whether we should censor it. This is not the direction of this conversation. Usual considerations?
What interests me primarily is how, as a community, we protect ourselves, particularly our children, against the harm which is injected onto their brain.
Race Reflections retweeted
Ep 115 of @RaceReflections AT WORK came out in October.
In that episode @SimoneKolysh reflected on hiring algorithms and their inherent racism.
Listen here or wherever you get your podcasts: podfollow.com/race-reflectio…
BIG NEWS
Are you considering hopping onto the Certificate in Working with Racial Trauma and/or the Reflective (decolonial) Group on Racial Trauma but have found the fees out of reach?
I have fantastic news!
We are piloting a Decolonial Membership which in addition to our community, archives and monthly articles, provides access to the Decolonial Group on Racial Trauma and, for those who choose to apply, access to the Certificate in Working with Racial Trauma for the flat fee of £500 + VAT
Please note the membership window is 30 days which means we will close doors after this and may close earlier subject to capacity.
Places are limited and applications must be received this month.
Already a member: I am going to write to you individually…bear with me.
racereflections.co.uk/regist…
Public announcement —
Following on my thoughts on genealogical severance and extraction…no one is entitled to any scholar’s platform, or account. Sometimes I remove connections I feel are problematic, exploitative or voyeuristic or simply because I want to feel safe and secure in reflecting publicly. I know how it may be read and I know some take this personally which is part of the same problematics, but I am too old to care much.
Given how much of my inner world I choose to make public, the least I can do, is to reserve as much as is within my control, the right to deny access, without any explanation.
Yes, I am a public scholar but I as an embodied, structurally positioned entity am not public property.
I am grateful to those who understand this need and who respect these boundaries without launching into full imaginary or fantasy mode, but then again it is their prerogative to do as they wish.
Thank you to those who who engage, share and value access to my thinking. I appreciate all of you.
Reflections on Black womanhood and intellectual extraction
Lately, I have been thinking quite a lot about the ways Black women are excluded from the domain of knowledge production. The ways in which the domain of theory is gatekept, policed, and made difficult to access for certain groups of people. And of course, I am thinking here about my own position as a Black woman.
I have spoken before about some of the difficulties I encountered when I started engaging with philosophy, particularly the philosophy of knowledge, and with psychoanalytic theories in psychology. And some time ago, I also shared that I had been contemplating my engagement in public scholarship because of questions of extraction and lack of acknowledgement.
Now, of course, it is always challenging to address this topic, particularly as a Black woman, because of all the connotations of pettiness, grandiosity, and all the ways in which Black women who attempt to claim the fruits of their intellectual labour can be interpreted through very particular lenses.
All the same today, I want to revis extraction.
Over the past decade or so, I have been engaging in public scholarship of an increasingly conceptual nature. And I have probably written something like 250,000–300,000 words on Race Reflections and on this account. This is substantial.
And one of the things I have noticed firstly, is that people will often read the work without necessarily sharing it. Now, I know that people read because I have the stats on the site!
And I often know where people read from, sometimes as precisely as which institution.
So that is already noteworthy. People are quite willing to engage with the work privately, but not necessarily prepared to share it publicly, so that it might reach a broader audience, and perhaps also so that the source of the thinking might be identified.
But I have noticed something else, that I will write about a particular concept, or use a term/idea that might have fallen out of use or fashion, or that is not necessarily in common use, particularly outside specialist fields — and then, all of a sudden, I start seeing that term in use within particular communities and networks I am a part of, usually among people who, as far as I can tell, do not ordinarily engage with that theoretical vocabulary and who I know read and follow my work.
And … there is zero acknowledgement of my contribution.
Now, I want to be careful, because I know how these conversations can quickly go…
I am not claiming this is always done intentionally or even consciously. But the pattern is evident.
I am not claiming to have always invented the concepts I see being reiterated after I use them. And this is where the difficulty lies.
I might though have made particular connections, for example, putting Klein in conversation with Fanon or African metaphysics in conversation with analytic ideas, or thinking in particular ways about space and the psyche, adding new winds to their relevance on Social Media.
As a relevant aside, one of my strengths, actually, is my capacity to make connections between things that might appear unrelated. I also think I am quite conceptually productive. I generate a lot of ideas. I spend a lot of my time thinking.
I have plenty of weaknesses, for sure. Spelling is one of them. The structural presentation/organisation of my ideas can be another and increasingly their density. But when it comes to producing concepts, to making unusual connections and to thinking in theoretical terms, I’d say I have a fairly unusual capacity.
The expectation that I should disavow these talents is part of this conversation.
Returning to intellectual extraction: I think there is something happening in the way people engage with my work that we don’t necessarily have a very good language for. And a dismissal of this phenomenon by phrases such as:
“You’re not the only person who has written about that.”
“You’re not the first person to use that word.”
1/2
That is true. But equally, many were not using that term or engaging with particular ideas before coming across my work but choose to discard or erase that link in their own contributions, often returning to the originator, therefore breaking the genealogical link and erasing my labour yet clearly having benefited from it, this is where I see the issue.
Extraction is not only about originality. It can also be in operation in the severing of people’s connections and roles in how ideas come to become available or accessible for engagement— in how they may become more ‘fashionable’ or acceptable — and in whose intellectual labour or contribution becomes visible, or erased, in the process.
Let me give you an example.
I have written about neurosis and envy, drawing on Kleinian theory to think about race, racism. Suddenly I saw, neurotic this, neurotic that — very specifically about whiteness and envy, in the way I linked those terms.
Now, of course, neurosis is hardly a concept I invented. I did not formulate envy as psychoanalytic term. Or linked envy to racism first. Still I did put those concepts in close conversation and more importantly, to the point here, I brought attention to them.
So what interests me is that people who would not ordinarily engage with that particular conceptual vocabulary start doing so without ever citing my article Neurosis of Whiteness, Racialised Violence and White Envy.
There are plenty of other examples I could use, and likely back up by doing a search for terms after I wrote an article.
This raises a question about the ways particular conceptual engagements can begin to happen within a community, while the work that may have contributed to bringing those connections into the conversation remains unacknowledged.
And I think being a Black woman (of Congolese ancestry, as I have previously noted) makes that process of extraction and erasure even more troubling to me, when my work can be consumed, engaged with, even drawn upon, while I remain absent from the conversations or thinking that my work may have helped to shaped this again disappeared from the genealogy in the same way the Kongo had been disappeared from the genealogy of analytic thinking.
And I want to be clear once more that I am not necessarily talking about plagiarism.
In fact, that is precisely why I think this conversation is challenging.
Because we have a language for plagiarism, we have avenues for redress in a way that we do not when intellectual contributions — as inspiration, as influence — can be mined without anybody technically stealing anything.
When you try to raise this as a Black woman, you can very quickly find yourself positioned as being petty, uppity, territorial, grandiose, etc… but if you keep silent you accept the violence of extraction and you are forcefully rendered absent. Though I want to be clear the extraction is not primarily from white people!
But if you say something, you risk being accused of claiming ownership over ideas, or thinking too highly of yourself.
Charges that echo Black women’s constructions as unreasonable, excessive, difficult, somehow unable to assess our own contributions rationally or with sufficient modesty, thus unable to think rationally.
On balance, public scholarship is still worth engaging in.
As much as I give, I gain. This is the reality.
I become a stronger thinker. And of course, I create opportunities for myself. For example, my honorary doctorate was clearly based on the fact that I have thought aloud…as I say and openly shared analytic ideas about race for over a decade. Peers say I should protect my ideas by putting them in academic journals, I am resistant to use this mode of dissemination as my main channel.
I do not also forget that the influence of my work in noted elsewhere and I am grateful.
This was a long one! Thank you for bearing with me. As always thoughts welcome.
I have just remembered 5-6 years ago, I did do a Twitter survey on people experience’s of scapegoating.
I was interested in the link between people saying they had a propensity to be entrusted with secrets, had repeated experiences of strangers confiding in them and scapegoating.
And it was a reasonably large sample N > 150, to my recollection and it seems, as expected, there was a statistically significant correlation.
Not a robust study of course a hand that appears to support the same axis sensitivity-disturbance and also holding in some sense.
I will try to dig this, because perhaps I made sense of this differently, I cannot remember the questions I asked, it was well before my current scholarship
The metaphisics of sensitivity
My good people, I have accepted an invite to speak at the Tavistock again, on the Doctoral Programme in social work/care this February — I will share details as soon as I can.
Today I have been thinking about sharing some Afroanalytic thoughts on intuition, before I got the invite actually so I think I’ll turn the thoughts below onto that talk.
Here is the direction of the possible abstract.
What if sensitivity were not simply a quality or disposition inherent to the subject, but a communal resource, designated and bestowed upon particular members, and through which collective life is organised?
What if it were through sensitivity that a group’s knowing and unknowing are structured, that the memory of the unsaid and the unsayable is sustained? That discarded knowledge or knowledge at risk of being discarded is transmitted across time and space? What if sensitivity allowed for contested understandings of reality to be
preserved?
Those links above would imply those most likely to become sites of communal archives are also perceptively gifted. And those who are perceptively gifted are also most likely to become the location of disturbance as it is understood in groups.
This is an Afroanalytic line of interrogation and thinking, I have shared through various angles.
It mlinks sensitivity to inheritance, memory-bearing, and storytelling. It seeks to deprivatise and deindividualise sensitivity by emphasising its communal functions and its relationship to the immaterial.
Drawing on African metaphysics, this approach to sensitivity expands our understanding of disturbance, embodiment, and the relationship between groups, knowing and memory.
Although this formulation appears to be opposed to classic analytic understanding of disturbance, it is like much of Afroanalytic ideas, which push and expend the boundaries of the conceptually legitimate beyond so called scientific realism, and used alternative exploitations for phenomena both scholarly orientations note.
I think I will make this the focus on my talk… what do you think? sensitivity as a collective, historical, metaphysical and epistemic resource, basically.
I wanted to share another slip I made live. When I wrote…´Today I have been thinking about sharing some Afroanalytic thoughts on intuition’ I meant ‘Today I have been thinking about sharing some Afroanalytic thoughts on sensitivity’
Isn’t it the most useful of slips, like heart and art I shared last month, the slip is forcing to me to explore the relationship between sensitivity and intuition and although I do not think the two constructs are interchangeable at all, and can exist independently I think they often overlap?There is an interesting question from an Afroanalytic perspective;
Could sensitivity, understood as astute attunement to phenomena, dynamics, patterns, and experience that do not easily reach the threshold of perception for most,
be one of the ways through which forms of knowing become which are discarded/disavowed or repressed become available to intuitive understanding?
The metaphisics of sensitivity
My good people, I have accepted an invite to speak at the Tavistock again, on the Doctoral Programme in social work/care this February — I will share details as soon as I can.
Today I have been thinking about sharing some Afroanalytic thoughts on intuition, before I got the invite actually so I think I’ll turn the thoughts below onto that talk.
Here is the direction of the possible abstract.
What if sensitivity were not simply a quality or disposition inherent to the subject, but a communal resource, designated and bestowed upon particular members, and through which collective life is organised?
What if it were through sensitivity that a group’s knowing and unknowing are structured, that the memory of the unsaid and the unsayable is sustained? That discarded knowledge or knowledge at risk of being discarded is transmitted across time and space? What if sensitivity allowed for contested understandings of reality to be
preserved?
Those links above would imply those most likely to become sites of communal archives are also perceptively gifted. And those who are perceptively gifted are also most likely to become the location of disturbance as it is understood in groups.
This is an Afroanalytic line of interrogation and thinking, I have shared through various angles.
It mlinks sensitivity to inheritance, memory-bearing, and storytelling. It seeks to deprivatise and deindividualise sensitivity by emphasising its communal functions and its relationship to the immaterial.
Drawing on African metaphysics, this approach to sensitivity expands our understanding of disturbance, embodiment, and the relationship between groups, knowing and memory.
Although this formulation appears to be opposed to classic analytic understanding of disturbance, it is like much of Afroanalytic ideas, which push and expend the boundaries of the conceptually legitimate beyond so called scientific realism, and used alternative exploitations for phenomena both scholarly orientations note.
I think I will make this the focus on my talk… what do you think? sensitivity as a collective, historical, metaphysical and epistemic resource, basically.
Race Reflections retweeted
The metaphisics of sensitivity
My good people, I have accepted an invite to speak at the Tavistock again, on the Doctoral Programme in social work/care this February — I will share details as soon as I can.
Today I have been thinking about sharing some Afroanalytic thoughts on intuition, before I got the invite actually so I think I’ll turn the thoughts below onto that talk.
Here is the direction of the possible abstract.
What if sensitivity were not simply a quality or disposition inherent to the subject, but a communal resource, designated and bestowed upon particular members, and through which collective life is organised?
What if it were through sensitivity that a group’s knowing and unknowing are structured, that the memory of the unsaid and the unsayable is sustained? That discarded knowledge or knowledge at risk of being discarded is transmitted across time and space? What if sensitivity allowed for contested understandings of reality to be
preserved?
Those links above would imply those most likely to become sites of communal archives are also perceptively gifted. And those who are perceptively gifted are also most likely to become the location of disturbance as it is understood in groups.
This is an Afroanalytic line of interrogation and thinking, I have shared through various angles.
It mlinks sensitivity to inheritance, memory-bearing, and storytelling. It seeks to deprivatise and deindividualise sensitivity by emphasising its communal functions and its relationship to the immaterial.
Drawing on African metaphysics, this approach to sensitivity expands our understanding of disturbance, embodiment, and the relationship between groups, knowing and memory.
Although this formulation appears to be opposed to classic analytic understanding of disturbance, it is like much of Afroanalytic ideas, which push and expend the boundaries of the conceptually legitimate beyond so called scientific realism, and used alternative exploitations for phenomena both scholarly orientations note.
I think I will make this the focus on my talk… what do you think? sensitivity as a collective, historical, metaphysical and epistemic resource, basically.
The metaphisics of sensitivity
My good people, I have accepted an invite to speak at the Tavistock again, on the Doctoral Programme in social work/care this February — I will share details as soon as I can.
Today I have been thinking about sharing some Afroanalytic thoughts on intuition, before I got the invite actually so I think I’ll turn the thoughts below onto that talk.
Here is the direction of the possible abstract.
What if sensitivity were not simply a quality or disposition inherent to the subject, but a communal resource, designated and bestowed upon particular members, and through which collective life is organised?
What if it were through sensitivity that a group’s knowing and unknowing are structured, that the memory of the unsaid and the unsayable is sustained? That discarded knowledge or knowledge at risk of being discarded is transmitted across time and space? What if sensitivity allowed for contested understandings of reality to be
preserved?
Those links above would imply those most likely to become sites of communal archives are also perceptively gifted. And those who are perceptively gifted are also most likely to become the location of disturbance as it is understood in groups.
This is an Afroanalytic line of interrogation and thinking, I have shared through various angles.
It mlinks sensitivity to inheritance, memory-bearing, and storytelling. It seeks to deprivatise and deindividualise sensitivity by emphasising its communal functions and its relationship to the immaterial.
Drawing on African metaphysics, this approach to sensitivity expands our understanding of disturbance, embodiment, and the relationship between groups, knowing and memory.
Although this formulation appears to be opposed to classic analytic understanding of disturbance, it is like much of Afroanalytic ideas, which push and expend the boundaries of the conceptually legitimate beyond so called scientific realism, and used alternative exploitations for phenomena both scholarly orientations note.
I think I will make this the focus on my talk… what do you think? sensitivity as a collective, historical, metaphysical and epistemic resource, basically.


