Ravi Sharma (@RaviSharmaTalks) header
Ravi Sharma (@RaviSharmaTalks) profile picture
New Delhi, India
Joined October 2009
Photo by Ravi Sharma (@RaviSharmaTalks)Photo by Ravi Sharma (@RaviSharmaTalks)Photo by Ravi Sharma (@RaviSharmaTalks)Photo by Ravi Sharma (@RaviSharmaTalks)Photo by Ravi Sharma (@RaviSharmaTalks)Photo by Ravi Sharma (@RaviSharmaTalks)Photo by Ravi Sharma (@RaviSharmaTalks)Photo by Ravi Sharma (@RaviSharmaTalks)Photo by Ravi Sharma (@RaviSharmaTalks)Photo by Ravi Sharma (@RaviSharmaTalks)
This is precisely what fraternity means. When the Chief Minister of Maharashtra publicly celebrates Bihar’s first municipal bond listing on the NSE and does so by recalling how a Bihar delegation came to Mumbai and Nashik to learn from Maharashtra’s own experience. we witness something rarer and more precious than routine political courtesy. We witness states treating one another as partners in a shared destiny rather than as rivals in a zero-sum game. Devendra Fadnavis’s words and Samrat Choudhary’s gracious acknowledgment together embody the third and often neglected pillar of our constitutional vision: fraternity. For too long, the easiest politics in India has been the politics of division; amplifying every regional grievance, every caste grievance, every historical slight into a permanent wall. That era is running out of time. Not because such identities will vanish, but because the nation is beginning to discover that they can be sources of strength rather than instruments of fracture. Sub-national loyalty, perse is not the enemy of the nation, rather it is a healthy sense of responsibility toward one’s own state or region is what makes federalism work. Pride in one’s land, one’s language, one’s developmental trajectory creates the very energy that can later be shared. Maharashtra’s willingness to open its institutional knowledge to Bihar, and Bihar’s readiness to receive it, is sub-nationalism functioning at its highest pitch: rooted, confident, and outward-looking. The same logic applies to caste. Caste is not an original sin. For millions it remains a living connection to cultural memory, community support, and historical continuity. The problem begins only when that identity is treated as an end in itself, a permanent claim upon the state or a permanent grievance against others. Its proper moral use is different. To belong to a caste should mean accepting a heightened responsibility: that the community one represents will be judged, ultimately, by the quality of its contribution to the larger society. The test of any group identity is not how fiercely it protects itself, but how generously and competently it adds to the common good. In the quiet exchange between two Chief Ministers is a welcome change, one offering knowledge, the other receiving it with thanks. What we see is fraternal ethic in action. No one is asked to erase Maharashtra or Bihar, Marathi or Bhojpuri, Brahmin or Yadav or any other particular identity. They are simply asked to place those identities in the service of something larger. That is fraternity: not the erasure of difference, but the refusal to let difference become destiny. When states share institutional learning instead of hoarding it, when communities measure themselves by what they build rather than by what they demand, the old politics of division loses its oxygen. What remains is the harder, more adult task of nation-building, competitive in excellence, cooperative in purpose. That is the fraternity the Constitution envisioned, and it is heartening to see at work.
बिहार और पटना के लिए यह ऐतिहासिक उपलब्धि है। ₹199.99 करोड़ के म्युनिसिपल बॉन्ड्स का NSE पर सूचीबद्ध होना बिहार की विकास यात्रा में एक नया अध्याय है। महाराष्ट्र द्वारा अपने अनुभव और मार्गदर्शन साझा करने के लिए आपका विशेष आभार। यह ‘टीम इंडिया’ और सहकारी संघवाद की भावना का सशक्त उदाहरण है। बिहार सरकार एवं पटना नगर निगम को हार्दिक बधाई एवं शुभकामनाएं।
10
3
30
6,664
For migrant Biharis, Railways has always been the way home for Chhath. This year it felt like the Railways itself was leading the celebration, with arrangements at par with, if not better than, Mahakumbh. Clean coaches, better planning, and genuine care restored a sense of dignity. Hearing Chhath songs echo through the stations finally gave us the dignity we had long yearned for. The sense that our culture and festivals are finally being celebrated, not just accommodated. A Big Thankyou @narendramodi @AshwiniVaishnaw @indianrailway__
1
11
65
1,274
Reputation is the pillar on which public life stands. The law recognises this. It provides clear, established mechanisms in form of civil defamation actions, criminal defamation , and the right to reply. The expectation is simple: if the claim is false or reckless, you sue. You put the publisher to proof. You force the issue into the open under rules of evidence. But there is another strategy as well. Incase you know that the allegations are true and you cannot withstand that cross-examination, that the questions will not collapse the allegation but will establish its core as fact, then the rational choice is silence. You do not issue a denial. You do not file the suit. You wait for the news cycle to move on and in the evening of your life you publish a self-serving autobiography where you gloss over every uncomfortable aspect of your life. That silence is not dignity. It is risk management. It protects the speaker from further exposure under oath. It converts a potentially catastrophic legal proceeding into a manageable media controversy that can be endured, ignored, or later reframed in your autobiography. The public is left with the original publication standing unrebutted in the only forum that actually mattered; the courtroom; because the person best placed to rebut it calculated that doing so would make the damage permanent. Sonia Gandhi chose that silence. The choice itself is evidence of the interest it served. When the available legal tools are left unused by someone whose entire public standing depends on reputation, the inference is not charitable. It is the inference the law itself invites when a party with the means and motive to sue declines to do so.
I will in the coming days tweet each one of the 22 articles I wrote then in the New Indian Express (which had the guts to carry them) to bring back to the public domain today the true and uncomfortable facts which will reveal the real Sonia which her book is calculated to conceal. Her book is only about what she wants to tell about her. But the truth she wouldn't tell but which the Indian public and the present gen must know will come out in my tweets My ariticles were written when Sonia was at the peak of her power and authority. She neither challenged it personally nor did the congress
1
6
367
He built the organisational backbone of the BJP brick by brick. That party is now India’s dominant electoral force. He set the gold standard for integrity and probity in public life; a rare example in politics. A lifetime of service. A century of inspiration. 🙏 #LKAdvani #HappyBirthdayAdvaniJi
1
2
218
Lobbying is legal in US; receiving foreign money to fuel protest within India is not. You wont get it.
2
262
Ambedkar also said so; chomu.
Wow. Wow. Wow! Constitutional courts making us very, very proud! BIG CLAPS! 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼
4
51
1,101
I made the following post day before; it was premised on @SauravDassss ‘s own tweet made in 2023 and his subsequent conduct, including his bon homie with Justice Sanjay Kishan Kaul as evident from the 2025 Diwali Party photos. While the last post, pertained to one such instances but their exists credible chain of circumstances to suggest that Saurav Das is indeed a hit man. If you want any case to be taken out of a judge’s court, you can hire his services for a consideration. Immediately he will issue a tweet, rattling the judge. We all saw this recently, when he published and article on the eve of hearing of liqour scam cases before the Delhi High Court, relying on which Arvind Kejriwal sought recusal of Justice Swarnkanta Sharma. Can you believe that this 25 years old novice sent a letter to the 65 years old then Chief Justice of India telling him that he was assigned the task of writing a piece about his tenure as CJI and that since he wanted an interview which may last for about 2 hours, he was fine with a meeting over dinner or lunch. His game-plan was simple yet sinister : if the meeting materialises, he could gather information about other judges. If the CJI did not agree for a meeting, he will be at liberty to write all non sense and add that CJI refused to respond. He will be the victor either way. The govt must probe this man thoroughly and bring him to account before law and courts. @sgurumurthy
Replying to @SauravDassss
@SauravDassss , stop the gaslighting. In July 2023 you yourself published this thread: nitter.gq/SauravDassss/status/16… You alleged, citing “sources within the administration,” then a sitting Supreme Court judge and collegium member (rumour has it was Justice Kaul) was behind the transfer of Justice Gaurang Kanth out of the Delhi High Court and the “punishment posting” of Justice Siddharth Mridul as Chief Justice of the five-judge Manipur High Court. You claimed these moves were driven by personal issues, denied “favours,” and vendetta. You called the collegium resolutions opaque cover for exactly. That was a specific charge that a sitting judge was using his position to settle scores inside the Delhi High Court. Who was the collegium member, you were referring to? Was is Justice Kaul? If yes, then its rather strange that now you are defending the same Justice Kaul’s private “taper it down” advice as the harmless, kindly counsel of a retired judge at a Diwali function in your house. So answer this directly: Was that advice given in the context of the very reporting in which you accused him of meddling in Delhi High Court transfers? Did you subsequently drop, soften, or kill follow-up on those claims after he spoke to you? And was that the consideration that produced the warm home visit and the current public defence of the man you once implied was weaponising the collegium? You cannot have it both ways. Either the 2023 allegations were reckless and false (in which case you owe an explanation for publishing them under the cover of “sources”), or they were true and you later chose silence after private counsel from the person you had implicated. The Diwali photo and the sudden warmth do not exist in a vacuum. Until you address that sequence, the “private function / private citizen / everyone tells me to taper it down” defence is not principle. It is selective amnesia and a post-facto clean-up. If its the same judge you once suggested was capturing the system is now your source of moral clarity on the judiciary. That is not journalism. That is a transaction.
6
270
4
456
41,926
This is Article 19(1)(a) read with Art. 19(2) and Article 19(1)(b) read with Art.19(3). Constitution, being the grundnorm. It didn’t require much jurisprudence. Did you not study about grundnorm, while preparing of CLAT.
Wonderful jurisprudence! Stellar stuff! Big claps! 👏🏼 👏🏼 👏🏼
10
491
I find it funny. Bihar Museum tops. Bihar becomes Rugby Capital. Bihar also has news like Jamui crime. Before these, it was Vaibhav Suryavanshi, railway violence in Bihar, civic sense criticism, Bihari man as AI minister of UK. "We are relevant because we are the future"
#PlainSpeak | India’s Bihar Museum Makes Global Top 10, Ranks Ahead Of Paris’s Louvre And New York’s The Met Bihar Museum In Focus: Global Ranking Puts Patna’s History, Art And Heritage In The Spotlight #BreakingNews #BiharMuseum #BiharMuseumPatna #Patna #Bihar #WorldsBestMuseums | @ShivaniGupta_5
4
39
317
6,650
Told by whom, SKK himself.
Am told there’s a hit job coming on Justice Sanjay Kishan Kaul following the damning expose wrt ex-CJI DY Chandrachud in his book.
7
498
That something, is the biggest fraud on humanity.
All exit polls indicating Netanyahu is coming to power again. Btw, whoever comes to power in Israel, they will keep hunting Islamist terrorists. So it doesn’t make any difference 😄
218
Ravi Sharma retweeted
My take on the recent revelations by Justice Sanjay Kishan Kaul and its impact on the institutional integrity of the Supreme court of India. Do read :) aankhighosh.substack.com/p/t…
3
11
1
20
2,578
Judicial independence is a constitutional principle, Justice Kaul. It ill behoves a retired Supreme Court judge to assert that he was an independent judge in his memoirs; that verdict ought to be left for posterity to decide, based on his judgements. Unless the judge is riven with doubts about his independence! Most certainly, anecdotal evidence about wrangling in the collegium are an extremely poor foundation for self-assertions about one's 'independence' as a judge. The timing of the release of Justice Kaul’s memoirs are as ominous as it’s content. It comes on the eve of a Supreme Court hearing and decision on the issue of alleged dissensions within the ECI and the legality of some measures introduced by it. Now let's dissect what's happening: the cockroaches are intent on pressuring the judiciary as the SIR process has weeded out bogus voters which has clearly raised the hackles of the entire unhinged Left/radical Islamists combine (that also includes the INC and some I.N.D.I. allies). On the heels of the eyebrow raising visit of Justice Kaul to Saurav Das’ Diwali party last year followed a scathing personal attack on Justice Suryakant around the time he became CJI in November of that year in one of the combine’s favourite mouthpieces - Caravan. The article was a republication of a 2019 article in the magazine published when CJI. Suryakant was elevated to the Supreme Court that year. Along with his proclaimed fierce independence while serving on the Bench - a claim which needs more analysis than his own self-serving assertion; and his denigration of former CJI Chandrachud as too deferential to the executive is a clarion call to sitting judges to oppose the executive if they wanted to earn the latter’s respect. In the light of his unexplained association with Saurav Das - the vaunted cockroach of the anti-SIR & anti-CEC agitation - the timing and the publicised thrust of his memoirs raise a grave question. ▶ Is he calling upon members of the judiciary to decide the validity of SIR , the related issue of CEC internal divisions and the legality of its processes against the executive and in favour of the protesting anarchists? ▶ Is a former Supreme Court judge using his considerable heft to influence the direction of a most important pending verdict of the Apex Court?
In an interview with journalist Karan Thapar for The Wire, Justice Kaul said that former Chief Justice of India, Justice DY Chandrachud, was in the practice of discussing names proposed for judicial appointments with the Government before the Supreme Court Collegium formally deliberated on them. Now, Congress is using this statement to target the judiciary. This statement should not be taken in isolation. Let us connect it with some of the events that happened in the past: 1. Photos are circulating showing that Justice Kaul attended a Diwali party at the residence of Cockroach Saurav Das. Why would a Supreme Court judge visit the house of an unknown, unemployed person? 2. Congress Kerala’s official handle targeted the Indian judiciary a few days ago. 3. At the same time, Rahul Gandhi, along with an opposition crowd, marched to the Supreme Court premises, created chaos, and entered forcibly. 4. Students of left-liberal institutes such as TISS and NALSAR Hyderabad and NLU Bangalore opposed the CJI and observed a one-day fast in support of the same ecosystem. 5. The CJI was targeted in London by the wife of CPI-ML President Deepankar Bhattacharya. 6. Justice Chandrachud was once a favourite of the left ecosystem; now the same ecosystem is targeting the Indian judiciary by using his name. 7. When Kaul was Madras HC Chief Justice, Karnan repeatedly attacked him with serious allegations of harassment, belittlement, etc., and even tried contempt proceedings. SC later jailed Karnan for contempt The message is very clear. The left ecosystem is meticulously targeting the Indian judiciary because it knows it is likely to lose the SIR case in the Supreme Court. It is therefore trying to create a fake narrative that the Supreme Court takes permission from the Modi government before delivering judgments. A well-crafted plan to damage Indian democratic institutions is underway by the global communist-socialist ecosystem.
30
352
5
806
25,114
Ravi Sharma retweeted
I wrote ... Constitutional hypocrisy The Tiruchengode community-based who were protesting against ‘Madhorubagan’ were ordinary people — dhoti-wearing countrymen, not modern urbanites. Not like the wealthy Ambanis, who could threaten the publisher to pulp the book or politically powerful like those who could get books, like the ones on Pundit Nehru or Bal Thackeray, banned. The Tiruchengode people conducted a peace talk democratically where Perumal Murugan was invited to produce the evidence he had claimed. There was no violence. No one abused or molested him despite the issue being sensitive. Murugan apologised for his writing because he could not adduce any evidence. Yet the peace meet is regarded as kangaroo court, despite government officials initiating it. Many disputes in India are settled by informal talks — be it panchayat or community leaders’ intervention. The famous Manipal group dispute lingering for decades in High Courts and Supreme Court was finally solved by a spiritual leader — Veerendra Heggade. A sweeping generalisation is likely to undermine a valuable, cost effective social capital still functioning in many parts of India. The judiciary ought to be empathetic and issue guidelines on how peace meetings or panchayat should be held rather than ridiculing and trivialising them. In communal riots or caste wars, even police invariably resorts to peace meetings and solves issues. Are they too kangaroo courts? Despite Murugan’s provocative writing against their women, the community gathered for the peace meet, which was held without violence. They need to be patted. In Rushdie and Vishwaroopam cases, the protesters succeeded in their aim by unleashing violence. Were the Tiruchengode people wrong then in holding peace meeting? The conclusion is self- evident: A helicopter view of the cases on ban on books in most cases and selective assertion and celebration of freedom in some other cases exposes political and constitutional hypocrisy that goes on in the name of liberalism and freedom of speech. Unquote I ended my article by telling Kaul the pain a lady who got a child by praying at the temple underwent because of the rogue writers book which Kaul celebrated. Quote Evenhanded approach needed A personal account: An educated lady professional from Tiruchengode, who begot a child by undertaking the Visakam ritual, asked me what those who had read Murugan’s book would think of her and her child. I had no answer. Nor can the liberals who celebrate Murugan’s book have any. Thousands of women in Tiruchengode areas suffer this humiliation — silently. I understand their pain. Lesson: A balanced and evenhanded constitutional approach to ban or permit objectionable expression is needed. Unquote I counseled to have a balanced approach. But even a decade later after becoming SC judge he could not seem to have got that virtue even after getting out of the office and being out of the SC ecosystem of one-upmanship and mutual jealousy These judges seem to be like any ordinary politician and businessmen only at best and destroyers of the very high constitional institution which had them big -- without which they would have been nothing newindianexpress.com/opinion…
1
6
14
899
Ravi Sharma retweeted
Dear ex-justice Kaul. The people you lobbied to get considered by the collegium for the SC job and for the HC jobs are talking. They’re talking a lot actually. Moral grandstanding doesn’t behoove a brown noser. I expect several stories will be coming out shortly.
35
1,008
6
4,227
112,431
Ravi Sharma retweeted
Any judge who speaks about the inside issues of the judiciary outside after retirement needs to answer the question why he didn't resign if he felt the issue affected Judicial independence and why opted to be part of the consensus to do the wrong going. The general view about the collegium is that each member was party to wrong things in return for wrong things he got done for himself. But they only speak about the wrong things others did but not about the wrong things they got done in return for supporting the wrongs of others indianexpress.com/article/le…
113
758
25
1,899
27,783
Please do. #arattai hain na.
This quoted post is unavailable.
3
239
Not elected. Not chosen. Not followed in any number that has ever survived a real test. Yet they have anointed themselves the keepers of India’s conscience; permanent judges of what the ordinary Indian is allowed to want, believe, or vote for. When the people disagree, it is never the circle that is wrong. It is always the people who are insufficiently educated, insufficiently enlightened, or simply not intelligent enough to know their own interest. This is no civil society. It is just small group with an inherent contempt for collective Indian Intelligence. They appear at the front of every protest not because they represent a living constituency, but because protest is their business model and their only remaining claim to relevance. They speak of “the people” while treating the actual people as a problem to be managed, corrected, or overridden. Their moral authority is self-issued. Their following is a handful of the same networks that already agree with them. Their privilege is the assumption that their judgment sits above the judgment of everyone who lives outside their circle and does not share their priors. The country is not short of intelligence. It is short of people who will stop pretending that a small, unelected, self-satisfied Delhi layer speaks for it. The ordinary Indian does not require their approval to understand his own life, his own trade-offs, or his own vote. The more insistently these circles claim otherwise, the more clearly they reveal what they actually are: a class that has confused its own sense of superiority with the right to rule without consent.
Those who fear the word "Civil Society" were those for whom once the role of this "Civil Society" was essential for the survival of Nation. Ladies and Gentlemen, Arun Jaitley on "Role of Civil Society" in a Democracy.. - Rajya Sabha, 27 August 2011 (during the Lokpal debate amid the Anna Hazare movement) As LoP- “We have to respond to each one of these questions which have been raised, not merely by the "civil society" but by the people at large today. We must not unnecessarily get into a position that there is the situation of Parliament versus "civil society". Sir, there are two basic principles that we have to keep in mind when we legislate. In any developing society, in any mature society, there will be a role for "civil society" . They are hard realities; they will exist. Some of them may take positions which seem a little excessive which may not be implementable. But then we must realize that their role is one of being a campaigner or a crusader or a flag-bearer on several issues. They rise, try and compel the decision-makers to change their views and come on track with their kind of opinion. We have the option of agreeing with them; we have the option of not agreeing with them. … What we must not do is to engineer a kind of confrontation either between Parliament and civil society or Government and civil society. The maturity of Indian polity is that we must not allow ourselves to get provoked and, therefore, we must still keep all rationality in mind and, therefore, legislate accordingly as far as these principles are concerned.” - Rajya Sabha, 29 December 2011 (during the Lokpal Bill debate) Criticising provisions of the government’s draft: “And, you want to use that Lokpal, whose credibility will be vulnerable to intrude into every area of "civil society" from temples to mosques, from gurudwaras to schools to rotary clubs to civil society, and you want us to support this Bill. This, according to you, is a strong law.” He also said of one provision (in the same debate): “I have not the least doubt that this provision has been introduced to teach the "Civil Society" a lesson. It is a revenge provision…” - Rajya Sabha, 24 November 2009 (climate-change/negotiations discussion) “We are an open society. We are a democratic society. We have a media that is holding us accountable. We have a "civil society" that holds us accountable. We do not need monitoring, reporting and verification with some international body. Any Government in India goes through this monitoring, reporting and verification every day in Parliament, in civil society and in the media.” Outside Parliament -Jamnalal Bajaj Awards, Mumbai, 28 October 2017 Speaking on poverty alleviation: “You require social activism of the "civil society" to continue to flag the plight of the poor, to continue to work in those areas, to knock at policymakers and bring the poor to the forefront and then after years and decades, we can pull them from their present condition of destitution.” A closely matching version reported the same day: “There has to be social activism of "civil society" to continue to flag the plight of the poor, to knock at policymakers and bring the poor to the forefront and remove them from their present condition of destitution. Whether it is the government, or "civil society", we will have to resolve to work together to remove poverty.” - Comment on the NJAC judgment (Facebook post / public statement, October 2015) Referring to arguments made in the judgment: “Civil society in India is not strong and, therefore, you need an independent judiciary.” (He was summarising and criticising one of the judicial opinions.) #BJP #Congress #CivilSociety #ArunJaitley #IndianDemocracy #FreedomOfExpression #RightToDissent #PeoplePower #Lokpal #AnnaHazare #Parliament #PublicDiscourse #CivilLiberties #ConstitutionalDemocracy #SaveDemocracy @BJP4India @INCIndia @JPNadda @RahulGandhi @AmitShah @kharge
4
272
Ravi Sharma retweeted
It is 4 days since I challenged Prashant Bhushan to sue me if what I have tweeted is not true. I am giving him two more days.
If Prashant Bushan disputes what I say I challenge him to sue me. Just reminding him what happened when I challenged P Chidambaram and Dayanidhi to sue me. They both ran away 😁😁😁 P Chidambaram threatened to sue me in the Vasan Eye Care fraud. I challenged him to sue me. He ran away (see the AI recall 1) Dayanidhi Maran threatened to sue me in the BSNL fraudulent phone lines case. I welcomed him. He ran away (see AI recall 2) 1. AI recall 1 • The Legal Threats: Following the publication, P. Chidambaram strongly denied all accusations, calling them completely false, malicious, and politically motivated. He initially threatened legal action for defamation against the publication and the authors involved. • The Challenge: Gurumurthy publicly countered Chidambaram’s statements, standing firmly by his reporting and challenging the former minister to proceed with a defamation lawsuit to let the facts be scrutinized in court 2. AI recall 2 • The Threat to Sue: Denying the allegations, Maran publicly maintained that he only had a single authorized phone line and threatened to sue the newspaper for Rs 10 crore in damages. • The Paper's Response: In response to the legal threat, TNIE famously ran a follow-up piece standing by their investigation, explicitly stating, "Welcome, Mr. Maran." Following the newspaper's open challenge to take the matter to court, Maran did not follow through with the defamation lawsuit
45
434
7
1,489
25,532
Marco Rubio is in Mumbai. But history may be waiting in Jamnagar. And some warnings never appear on a diplomat's itinerary. October 20, 2026. America's Secretary of State will meet India's Foreign Minister. Then comes Jamnagar. Mukesh Ambani. Reliance Industries. Why is America's top diplomat personally visiting an Indian refinery? There is a Texas connection. Reliance invested in a US refinery venture. Donald Trump Jr. owns a stake in the same company. Interesting coincidence? You decide. But American history has a dark habit. It leaves warnings in declassified files. Let me take you back. 1953. Iran. Prime Minister Mosaddegh nationalised oil. It challenged Britain's oil Company named BP. Britain's MI6 and America's CIA helped overthrow his government. 1954. Guatemala. United Fruit, the top company of that time, opposed land reforms. The CIA launched Operation PBSUCCESS. An elected president was overthrown. Corporate interests and geopolitics had crossed paths. 1963. Guyana. The CIA secretly supplied $435,000 to sustain a 79-day general strike. The money travelled under American labour-union cover. The objective? Pressure an elected government. 1970. Chile. The owner of El Mercurio, a powerful media empire, met America's intelligence leadership. In 1971, CIA funding followed. In 1973, a military coup overthrew President Salvador Allende. 1970. Switzerland. A company called Crypto AG sold encryption machines worldwide. Its secret owners? The CIA and West German intelligence. Foreign governments bought security. Their communications became vulnerable to the very people behind the company. Different countries. Different operations. Different disguises. One disturbing historical lesson. Foreign influence can enter through a nation's own institutions. Now return to Jamnagar. I am not saying Reliance is compromised. But America has a documented history of using commercial relationships to pursue geopolitical objectives. And Marco Rubio is no ordinary businessman. He represents American state power. A warning to New Delhi. A warning to Indian intelligence. Watch the contracts. Watch the concessions. Watch the political commitments. Most importantly, watch what happens after Rubio leaves.
77
435
29
1,542
212,080