Stop Mandated Shunning (@SMShunning) header
Stop Mandated Shunning (@SMShunning) profile picture

Join our global campaign to set legal precedents against mandated shunning as a violation of human rights #stopmandatedshunning

Global
Joined August 2023
Photo by Stop Mandated Shunning (@SMShunning)Photo by Stop Mandated Shunning (@SMShunning)Photo by Stop Mandated Shunning (@SMShunning)Photo by Stop Mandated Shunning (@SMShunning)Photo by Stop Mandated Shunning (@SMShunning)
Stop Mandated Shunning retweeted
Support for those leaving high-control religion is a continuing need. Research indicates that religious shunning can result in suicide. Let’s work together to make shunning recognized as a destructive tactic of coercive religions and cults. #exjw #ShunningKills #StopTheShunning
2
3
232
Stop Mandated Shunning retweeted
🚨 Were you shunned after leaving a high-control religious group? @SavinBapirTardy and I are conducting a study on mandated shunning and want to hear your experience! Your voice matters! Please reach out via DM. @RoehamptonUni #mandatedshunning #mentalhealthawareness #abuse
2
1
93
Stop Mandated Shunning retweeted
If you cannot leave your religion without harm coming to you, or without your dignity in tact, then that group is harming you. There is no freedom of religion if you are not free to leave it.
3
20
2
52
1,782
Stop Mandated Shunning retweeted
Article from Denmark regarding the new JW shunning rules No paywall, translate in your browser. ekstrabladet.dk/nyheder/samf…
3
12
1
44
2,329
Stop Mandated Shunning retweeted
Read Monica Velin Rodriguez's review of the 2024 ICSA conference in Barcelona. 👉 stopmandatedshunning.org/rev… #stopmandatedshunning #icsa
1
114
Stop Mandated Shunning retweeted
Your support of our new research project will help us push for significant change and make mandated shunning a recognized violation of human rights. lttr.ai/AUn9i #roehamptonuniversity #stopmandatedshunning #openmindsfoundation #research
3
7
496
Stop Mandated Shunning retweeted
There is a big push happening with a massive research project into the scope and detrimental affects of mandated shunning, not just within JW but other faith groups. The data gathered will be used to support court cases in multiple countries. Check out the website and survey
Check out our updated website where you can tell your mandated shunning story, take the survey, or donate to our campaign to make mandated shunning a violation of human rights. stopmandatedshunning.org #stopmandatedshunning #shunning #mandatedshunning
4
12
441
Stop Mandated Shunning retweeted
Another Norwegian #exjw story. Meet Ashley and read her strong story. A story of our time, where both people in a JW marriage wake up and go different paths, as friends. Please read and share this one. No paywall, translate with your browser. kk.no/livet/frykten-var-lamm…
1
12
2
56
6,994
Stop Mandated Shunning retweeted
Our helpline is open today (Fri) 08:00 - 11:00 Whether you left religion many years ago, recently, or are planning an exit, we are here to listen and support. 0800 448 0748
1
3
9
444
Stop Mandated Shunning retweeted
HUGE news: A Norwegian court on Monday upheld a decision to punish the Jehovah's Witnesses because of their cult-like behavior. The ruling prevents the JWs from receiving taxpayer-funded subsidies and performing legal marriages. friendlyatheist.com/p/norweg…
22
154
16
681
29,524
Stop Mandated Shunning retweeted
Read this! Read this! It's what we all have been saying.
1
1
18
553
Stop Mandated Shunning retweeted
#exjw around the world. You know what to do.
Replying to @jfnilsen
CHILDREN MUST BE PROTECTED AGAINST THE EFFECT OF THE EXLUSIONAIRY PRACTICE
14
73
4,132
Stop Mandated Shunning retweeted
Breaking News! In the case Jehovah's Witnesses vs the State of Norway we have a verdict! Jehovah's Witnesses lost! The State won. More to come, stay tuned! vg.no/nyheter/innenriks/i/2B…
47
87
25
425
73,020
Stop Mandated Shunning retweeted
Jehovah's Witnesses Will not get their state support back!
8
18
7
130
6,310
Stop Mandated Shunning retweeted
#JWvsNorway Ex-witness: - For us, this is an incredibly great relief OSLO DISTRICT COURT: The verdict in the Jehovah's Witnesses trial was not surprising, says former Jehovah's Witness, Jan Frode Nilsen. He is relieved to be believed by the district court. From Vårt Land (machine translated by Google) (RELIEF: Ex-member Jan Frode Nilsen is relieved that the state has been acquitted in the Jehovah's Witnesses case.) The state is acquitted by the Oslo District Court in the Jehovah's Witnesses case. It became known on Monday afternoon. - For us, this is an incredibly big relief. There has been an extreme amount of emotion connected to the case for those of us involved in it, says an emotional Jan Frode Nilsen to Vårt Land. He is a former member of Jehovah's Witnesses, and was one of several who testified in the Oslo district court about how he was excluded from his former religious community. He is not surprised by the district court's verdict. - It is as expected. This stands firm, legally speaking, and has been solid all along. Nilsen believes there was very little to indicate that Jehovah's Witnesses should have won the trial. - In that case, the court would have to disregard all literature from the religious community. But that will be disregarding the evidence. So I had no doubt that this was an obvious case. Nilsen is relieved by the recent news, and says that he will take some time to let the joy and relief sink in. - Being believed in by the judges, in the same way as we were believed in by the ministries and the state administrator, is very important. Nilsen says that it has been tough to appear in court. - That we are now believed, and that we don't have to wait until the autumn and the appeal case to be believed, is a great relief. No free cancellation In court, the state has claimed that the practice of Jehovah's Witnesses prevents free expression. They have argued that members who opt out are no longer allowed to have contact with family and friends in the congregation. Thus, they may feel pressured to remain in the religious community. Jehovah's Witnesses have now been ordered to pay court costs of over NOK 1.1 million. ($108,000 USD)
2
13
2
73
7,722
Stop Mandated Shunning retweeted
#JWvsNorway "Done in court: - Jehovah's Witnesses want to frame this as a case of religious persecution" From Vårt Land (Machine translated by Google) Standing on opposite sides - this is how they experienced the trial CONCLUSION: On Friday, the parties went their separate ways in the Oslo District Court, after the two-week dispute between the state and Jehovah's Witnesses. Ben Elder and Jan Frode Nilsen have followed the case from different sides. (HAS FOLLOWED THE CASE: Ben Elder is legal counsel for Jehovah's Witnesses. Jan Frode Nilsen is a former member of the organisation, and was himself summoned as a witness for the state.) By Jor Hjulstad Tvedt Published: 19/01/2024 15:57 On Friday, the parties made their closing statements in the trial between Jehovah's Witnesses and the state in the Oslo district court. The court has now withdrawn and the case has been taken up for judgment. Vårt Land has spoken to two of those who have followed the case closely this week - from different sides. Jan Frode Nilsen is a former member of the organisation, and was himself summoned as a witness for the state. Ben Elder is legal advisor at the European Association of Jehovah's Witnesses for the Protection of Religious Freedom, an organization that works against the judiciary and public authorities to defend the interests of the religious community. Jan Frode Nilsen says that it has been difficult to follow Jehovah's Witnesses' procedures in recent days. - It is presented as if everything you have experienced and the history you carry with you is only inside your own head, he says. He says that he is primarily surprised at how far Jehovah's Witnesses go in denying that there is a set doctrine on how the excluded should be treated. At the same time, he feels that the religious community's lawyers waver on the question. - In one moment they admit that there is a practice, in the next they say they don't. Actually, I think there should be no doubt about what is the fact, and that the interesting question is the legal one. (EX-WITNESS: Jan Frode Nilsen has been one of the state's witnesses in court) International attention Regardless of the outcome, Nilsen believes that there is much to be learned from this case. That is why it is also followed very closely by ex-witnesses all over the world, he says. By claiming that there is no correct practice, and that it is up to each individual member to decide how to deal with excluded members , Nilsen believes that Jehovah's Witnesses have made statements that will have international significance. (linked to this story nitter.gq/Ron_POMO/status/174584…) - They have squeezed the toothpaste out of the tube, and they will never be able to put it back. And there is nothing we want more than that. He also says that what emerges in court runs completely counter to what emerges in the Watchtower, the Jehovah's Witnesses' own magazine. - That is why they want to shield Jehovah's Witnesses' publications from the presentation of evidence, and say that they are "sacred texts" that the state cannot interpret. It is because they know what is written there. Self-therapeutic For him and the other ex-witnesses, it is not primarily about winning in court, says Nilsen. According to him, whether Jehovah's Witnesses lose state support is a trivial matter. Many of those who have testified in court have never told their story in that way before, he says that this in itself has had great significance. He also says that he and the other ex-Witnesses have found it strange to hear how Jehovah's Witnesses present themselves as a vulnerable minority. - Because on an individual level, we are the ones who have been the minority. Individuals in the face of a worldwide organization that has billions on its books and millions of members. Nilsen also says that he thinks the government lawyers have done a good job. According to him, they have remained calm, and resisted what he sees as a strategy of obfuscating and confusing by highlighting irrelevant points and examples: - Jehovah's Witnesses want to angle this as a matter of religious persecution. There I feel that the lawyers have been good at saying: "Relax, it's not about that, it's about a state support scheme". Not aware of other cases Ben Elder has been a witness for Jehovah's Witnesses, and says that the organization he represents is often a third party in European court cases. They also work to spread understanding of the challenges Jehovah's Witnesses face among public actors and human rights actors. They have followed the case between the state and Jehovah's Witnesses in Norway since it started in 2022. - Is the case unique in a European context? - Yes and no, similar accusations have been made in the past. What is unique, however, is how far it has gone, and that the registration as a religious community has already been withdrawn. I don't think that has happened in any other European country so far. It is new waters for us, and to be honest we were very surprised by the State Administrator and the ministry's decision. According to Elder, the organization sees increasing activity among so-called "anti-cult" organizations in Europe. According to Elder, these are organizations that have been created with the purpose of attacking religious minorities, by claiming that they are second-rate religions and harmful to society. - The same rhetoric is repeated in every country, with exactly the same wording. (Assessor: Ben Elder is legal adviser for the European Association of Jehovah's Witnesses for the Protection of Religious Freedom, and has followed the case in court together with Jehovah's Witnesses' lawyers.) Believes the state has weak evidence When asked if he is confident that the court will take their side, Elder replies that he is confident that the case is based on solid legal arguments. But when it comes to the outcome, everything depends on what the judge chooses to emphasize, he says. - Do the stories that have come out in the ex-witnesses' statements make an impression on you? - Yes, of course, when people have bad experiences and are mentally ill - it's a terrible situation to be in. But to say that this is due to our religion... That's where we struggle a bit. He also says that the state has not produced evidence for one of its main arguments, namely that the organization excludes minors, and in that way exercises psychological violence against children. - The only evidence the state has presented that minors are excluded was one case nearly 30 years ago. If that's all, then it's too little to say it's a big problem. Integrated into society - But even if you vouch for the fact that these are individual stories, and that legally there is nothing to complain about. Do you think that you could still do something about how you treat former members, so that fewer had bad experiences? - It's a good question, and I feel it was answered by the religious community when the State Administrator said that Jehovah's Witnesses must change their practice in order to get support. We can't, because it's based on our understanding of the Bible, and our strong conviction about what it says, Elder replies. He adds that the organization will "naturally" comply with national legislation, but that he is confident that the current legislation is on their side. - You are often called a closed religious community. What do you think about it? - Personally, I think it's ridiculous, but we often hear that, yes. We do not live in isolation, we have TV, internet and participate in community life. Compared to many other religious communities, Elder believes that Jehovah's Witnesses are very integrated into society. - We send our children to the same schools as everyone else, we are your neighbors and your colleagues. We even stand on your doormat, and on Saturday mornings we stand on street corners, he says with a smile. The verdict is expected to be ready in about two weeks.
#JWvsNorway Day 4 & 5 From Vårt Land: vl.no/religion/2024/01/12/st… Jehovah's Witness board member about cutting contact: - Up to the individual family COURT: Kåre Sæterhaug, board member for Jehovah's Witnesses, explained himself to the court on Thursday and Friday. Here he claimed that the religious community has no rules for contact with expelled family members - completely contrary to the state's claim. (BOARD MEMBER: Kåre Sæterhaug (in the back of the picture) explained himself on Thursday and Friday.) ByJor Hjulstad Tvedt Published: 12/01/2024 11:53 - How contact with excluded members is practiced is up to the individual and the individual family, depending on how they interpret the Bible's principles. Kåre Sæterhaug, board member of Jehovah's Witnesses, explained this to the court on Thursday. The background for the statement is that the state has asked Sæterhaug to submit a party statement in the ongoing dispute case in the Oslo district court. This means that Sæterhaug must take a seat in the witness box and spontaneously answer questions from the judge and both parties' lawyers. The questioning started on Thursday afternoon, when it was the Jehovah's Witnesses' own lawyer who asked the questions. On Friday morning, the party's statement will continue, as it is planned that the state and the judge will ask their questions. The statement is almost directly at odds with what the state has previously claimed. Provide evidence On Tuesday this week, the state gave its opening statement to the court. Here, government lawyer Kristin Hallsjø Aarvik presented what the state believes is evidence for a strict set of regulations regarding how excluded members and people who have left the religious community should be "shunned" by the congregation. This means that you must distance yourself from former members, to the extent that you must not even greet them in the street. The state claims that the regulations also mean that members must cut all unnecessary contact with former members of the immediate family, if they no longer belong to the same household. If members do not comply with the regulations, the state believes that this will be met with sanctions, and in the worst case, have consequences for their own membership. The state believes that the practice of avoiding former members prevents free withdrawal, because members who want to leave the religious community may feel forced to stay, in order not to lose contact with family. They also believe that it involves negative social control and psychological violence against children, because baptized minors can be excluded and sanctioned in the same way as adults. To substantiate the claim, the state referred to several articles in Jehovah's Witnesses' journals, handbooks, informational videos and independent research literature. Up to each individual In court, Sæterhaug claims that this is not true. In front of the court, he explained that the religious community's practice of excluding members who practice serious sins is founded on biblical principles. At the same time, he pointed to other scriptures, which express other principles, including the responsibility one has to take care of one's family. According to Sæterhaug, it is up to the individual to weigh these principles against each other, and assess how the principles should be applied in the individual situation. - If a minor is excluded, you of course have an obligation to still be mother and father. It continues if you move away from home. Much will be different from family to family. Do they want contact? There are many factors that are up to the individual's conscience. Don't want to risk being excluded When asked by the judge whether members can be sanctioned for maintaining contact with excluded or deregistered members of their own family, Sæterhaug replied that this is not something the congregation intends to do. - How can I go in and say how much contact someone should have and what is necessary in a family? This is about their own relationship with God. The judge then asked: - Does that mean that there are no sanctions against those who have a more liberal attitude towards the excluded? To this, Sæterhaug replied that the way in which contact is practiced afterwards will be different, and that sanctions will only occur if someone says that they fundamentally disagree with the scheme. The judge then asked what will happen if a mother continues to have the same contact with her child, even if the child joins another religious community. - It is up to her conscience. She does not want to risk being excluded, said Sæterhaug. No great part of the exercise of faith Sæterhaug also said that he does not feel that the court fully understands their way of thinking. Furthermore, he pointed to chapter 22 of the Gospel of Matthew, where Jesus is asked what was the most important commandment in the law. According to the Gospel, Jesus replied that "You shall love the Lord your God with all your heart and with all your soul and with all your mind" and "You shall love your neighbor as yourself". This is also the basic attitude of Jehovah's Witnesses, Sæterhaug explained. - The witness statements we have heard show that members have slightly different views on how to deal with excluded people. We think that the elders should not be police, but shepherds and helpers. Sæterhaug also said that the trial may create the impression that exclusions play a large role in the religious community, but that in reality it is a very small part of the Jehovah's Witnesses' practice of faith. - Extremely rare Towards the end of Ryssdal's questioning, the board member was asked if there were many exclusions, to which Sæterhaug replied that, according to him, "there were relatively few". Ryssdal then followed up with an issue that has previously been raised by the state, namely the situation of excluded minors: - Is it a question of a large group of minors who "shit out" and are excluded? asked the lawyer. - No, I think it is important to talk about realities. I am not aware of any cases of minors being excluded today. It is extremely rare, answered Sæterhaug. He also said that children of excluded people are not denied contact with grandparents. His impression, however, was that it is sometimes those who stand in the middle - i.e. the parents - who stand in the way of contact. Was pressured by the government lawyers On Friday, it was the state's lawyers' turn to ask questions. They were keen to confront Sæterhaug with the Jehovah's Witnesses' own publications, and what role these play in the religious community. Sæterhaug was asked, among other things, what role the Vakttårnet magazine plays in the congregations. Sæterhaug explained that one of the two weekly parish meetings usually involves discussing a study article in the magazine. The state also took up examples from the handbooks Be shepherds of God's flock and Keep yourselves in God's love . All publications are published by the Supreme Council of Jehovah's Witnesses, and are the same for the whole world. Here are several examples of situations that lead to exclusion, and how the congregation should deal with excluded people, The government lawyers asked Sæterhug whether this was not to be considered rules, and whether there was room for local assessments. To this, Søterhaug replied that the doctrine of exclusion, and that excluded members should as a general rule be "avoided", is an established doctrine. (THEIR TURN: Government attorney Kristin Hallsjø Aarvik (left) and state prosecutor Liv Inger Gjone Gabrielsen were in charge of the questioning of Søterhaug on Friday) According to Sæterhaug, there is no room for local adaptations, but that there is room for personal assessments. This is because each individual must assess how the principles are to be applied in their own life. - It is not a rule book, but it is a guide for those who want to have a clear conscience towards Jehovah. Acknowledged that contact may lead to exclusion Time and again, Sæterhaug was pressed on whether there is no "correct course of action", and whether continuing to maintain contact with excluded family members does not entail consequences. In the end, Sæterhaug admitted that there could be consequences if one repeatedly defied guidance from elders in the congregation. But as "the elders do not function as any kind of police", such a contact, as it becomes widely known, must also express a "rude and disrespectful attitude". Sæterhaug assured equally that there "will never be a sentencing committee set up for contact that takes place within a family". (NOT MERCIFUL: Former elder Rolf Furuli was very critical of Sæterhaug's diploma) Harsh criticism The next witness was former elder Rolf Furuli, who has been excluded for criticizing the current leadership of the religious community. He used harsh words to describe Sæterhaug's diploma: - To use a language: It's pure rubbish! There is no individual decision, everyone follows it as the Supreme Council has decided. What they decide is followed to the letter, said Furuli. When asked by the judge, Furuli answered affirmatively that he himself had helped to exclude members in order to have contact with excluded family members. Correction, 12.1 at 1.30 p.m.: In an earlier version of the case, it was stated that Sæterhaug said that "children of excluded persons are denied contact with grandparents". The correct thing is that Sæterhaug said that "children of excluded people are not denied contact with grandparents".
7
7
4
50
9,930