98 episodes. One review a day since STLV. And now, the end.
When Enterprise first aired, a lot of people dismissed it. Too familiar, too safe, not what they thought Star Trek should be. But looking back now, it set up the beginning of everything, the first captain, the first Enterprise, the groundwork for every journey that came after.
It aired during a dark, fearful time, and it asked us to be better anyway. To meet strangers as neighbors. To see a crowded world as an opportunity, not an obstacle. We need that even more today.
We didn't value it enough when we had it. But it's not too late.
So give it another chance. Start at the beginning. You don't need to be afraid of the wind. And then fly off into the sunset like Captain Archer.
Thank you for coming along on this ride. It means more than you know. 🖖
#StarTrek #StarTrekEnterprise #NX01 #TrekReview
"These Are the Voyages..." This is it, the series finale, and I've given myself enough space from the previous episode to hopefully be objective. When it aired on May 13, 2005, I came in on the last act of "Terra Prime," which aired an hour earlier than I expected, and rolled right into this one, assuming it was a two-part finale. Jumping from Archer giving a rousing speech to an episode where they're talking about Archer having to give a speech was disorienting, though I'm sure it wasn't written to air that way, so we must do what we can to take this episode at face value.
The cold open tells us the crew has been on the ship for 10 years and is heading to the signing of some sort of charter, a time jump that's disorienting but not unexpected. But then we see the reveal that we're watching a holographic recreation on the Enterprise-D holodeck, as Commander Riker freezes the program and walks off in his Next Generation uniform. So you won't be seeing the Enterprise characters, only holographic representations based on the historical record. We shouldn't assume any major divergences in fact, but a lot of the personal conversations are what a historian, or frankly an AI algorithm, might think these people said, which may go a long way toward explaining the anachronisms and out of character moments.
Eagle-eyed fans will deduce this takes place during The Next Generation's "The Pegasus," written by Ronald D. Moore. Much has been written about how the events don't quite align, and with 11 or 12 years between the two shoots, the actors have aged, so some fans suggested setting it on Riker's USS Titan. That said, if you squint, it's not so bad. Marina Sirtis looks excellent, and Jonathan Frakes, while a little more seasoned, is still quite the dashing figure with the same old twinkle in his eye, along with a brief cameo from his future Star Trek: Picard showrunner, Terry Matalas, who walks out of the turbolift just as Manny Coto's final screen credit appears.
We learn a lot in a hurry. Shran faked his own death after getting involved with criminals, which is nonsensical for the character, and now they've kidnapped his daughter, Talla, played by Jasmine Anthony, his child with Jhamel from "The Aenar," a relationship I don't think should have turned romantic. They're based on Rigel X, the first planet Enterprise visited in "Broken Bow." I know it's not literally true, but this finale feels as if it was written following Season 3. Archer feels he still owes Shran for the Xindi crisis seven years earlier, which ignores how they settled up in Season 4, and it's public record that Rick Berman and Brannon Braga weren't very creatively involved in Season 4.
T'Pol's hostility toward Shran, especially after losing her own child an hour ago, feels very Season 3, if not Season 1, and Archer essentially calling her racist against Andorians seems unearned after six years of some form of alliance. The characters revert to their archetypes, which we could write off as the limits of holographic recreation. Archer's line about the Vulcan Council being enlightened feels like a copy-and-paste update from the Vulcan High Command, but it's a cool idea that Vulcan is now ruled by a council, presumably with Minister T'Pau on it.
Riker puts the holodeck in objective, or fly on the wall, mode, the least interactive holodeck use we've ever seen. It's a crossover that doesn't let the casts interact, even as holograms, which feels like a missed opportunity. The most fun mechanic is Riker taking the place of Chef, a character we've heard about but never seen, so he can have scenes with most of the main cast. We also get our final Porthos moment, and it's very nice to see the captain's good beagle.
A big problem I have is the handling of Trip and T'Pol, which T'Pol tells Chef has been over for six years. As I said in my last review, nothing in that episode convinces me of that, and it's a disservice to everything we've been through with them over the last two years. We can say, based on this holographic record, that they didn't have a public relationship in the six years since "Terra Prime," but we don't have to accept that there was no relationship in private, or even a child, who perhaps could return in some future installment.
I also don't know why following orders was chosen as the episode's theme. Enterprise isn't a show that lived and died on duty and obligation, as other Star Treks have. It's a Wild West show, so a lot of that feels meaningless. And Riker freezing the program to kiss T'Pol on the cheek just seems wrong. Why would you do that? It is lovely to see the Enterprise-D sets in high definition, and we learn the NX-01 survives in a Starfleet museum, where you can see it in the background of Picard's third season, as the Drexler refit with a stardrive section the ship here doesn't have yet. And our good Glen Hambly is still working faithfully in the background of Engineering.
Then Counselor Troi reveals Trip will not be making it back. The first time through, you hoped the disservice to Trip and T'Pol was in service of reuniting them, but you've just been told that's not happening. And so the pill continues to turn bitter. You lick the ice cream cone, and it tastes less sweet with every lick. Archer takes the shuttlepods instead of the transporter after a season of getting comfortable with it, and Trip tries to convince him not to go because he's important to the signing, which is completely true. Of course, we know Trip is the one in jeopardy.
The shuttlepod scene between Trip and T'Pol is well acted but frustrating, and the lack of any discussion of the child, in an episode I'm sure was written around the same time as "Terra Prime," makes them seem like very cold, out of touch people. There's a nice moment, which I have to think came from the actors and director, when T'Pol guides Talla away, leaving Shran to his presumed fate, and puts a hand on his shoulder, belying any animosity we saw earlier. Our heroes are clearly standing on the gantry of a sound stage, firing down at criminals who pose little threat, Archer pulls Trip back from a fall, and the music by Dennis McCarthy and Kevin Kiner sounds a lot like Kiner's work on The Clone Wars only three years later.
Archer gets Shran away at warp 4, when they'd routinely hit warp 5.2 in Season 4, another weird anachronism, though props to the art department for some great aging on the ship's panels. Brent Spiner gives a nice voice cameo as Data, his last performance as Data until Picard in 2020. Riker's dilemma over whether to confide in Picard is silly, since the obvious answer is yes, and I'm not sure how these 22nd-century events inform it. He also makes pizza with Reed, something he'll do again in Picard's "Nepenthe," and we learn Trip didn't graduate college and learned engineering on boat engines, a throwaway line that discounts the weight Connor Trinneer has always given the character.
Riker's questions are all about Trip, so you wonder what situation would lead Trip to disobey orders, and none of that's paid off. Phlox recalls the neuro-pressure sessions, so much more effectively remembered in "The Aenar" as the start of a rich relationship, and here it's played as a joke. It was that or become addicted to sedatives. Maybe sedatives would have been smarter, Doctor. The romance gets lip service, as if from a note, but it serves no purpose, not a new relationship, not even regret that there wasn't one. It's insignificant, and so disrespectful to the characters.
Then Trip and Archer share a private conversation in the captain's mess, over whiskey Zefram Cochrane gave Archer's father, a scene that shouldn't be in the historical record, so I think we can discount it. I don't think you can retcon Trip's death, but I don't think these are the actual events that led to it. In my mind, it's part of a cover-up tied to a war and a race conspicuous by its absence, connected to the founding of the Federation. Nameless buffoons get aboard past security, with no MACOs and no alarms, and that can only be because it's a historical forgery. The novels, starting with "The Good That Men Do," kept Trip alive as an agent behind Romulan lines, but I think Trip should be dead, just in a way we can feel better about.
It feels like another attempt at shooting Captain Kirk in the back, and it fails just as spectacularly. Trip gets manic, in an unmotivated performance, and gets Archer knocked out, then lures the intruders into a corridor to blow them all up. We're never told Archer's survival is key to the Federation, and these men are friends who together could beat some buffoons. There are enemies worth Trip's life, Romulans, Klingons, Borg, Suliban, and these gangsters aren't. Killing a main character can work when they have agency and their choice is the only one that can save everyone. That's not the case here.
The sickbay scene gives false hope, and I remember hoping they'd pull out of it. Bakula and Trinneer are excellent as Archer lies that everything will be all right, and then Trip winks on his way into the hyperbaric chamber. What is that signifying? Did you kill the series' most popular character out of spite because we didn't show up enough to keep the show on the air? T'Pol packs his things and smells his uniform, after six years without a relationship. None of it makes sense. But here the episode gives me something to hang on to, as Archer tells T'Pol he used to see himself as an explorer, and now Trip is dead and he's trying to figure it all out.
After episodes about building institutions that last, this one asks about the personal, and that's why I don't think you can rob the show of Trip's death. It was handled horribly, but the aftermath has real weight, moderating Archer as he builds the Federation, shaping how T'Pol opens herself to others, and how she'll raise the child I deeply believe she and Trip had, hidden from the history books. When Archer says he believed something noble would be beyond the next star, you can almost hear the writer asking, now that it's over, what was it all for? It's a little nihilistic. And Trip's final scene with Chef gives Riker his answer to trust his captain, the sin of handing the episode's agency to Riker, criticized by fans and the Enterprise cast and crew alike.
The charter signing takes place in the auditorium from "Azati Prime," a much bigger gathering than "Terra Prime," presumably delayed by the Earth-Romulan War, and we won't see the signing, because it's not an episode of Young Indiana Jones. Our supporting cast and members of Letter Decks fill the bleachers, with Admiral Manny Coto looking wistful and then disappointed, as if he's watching the same finale we are. Phlox says goodbye, and T'Pol calls Archer "heroic," a much better choice than the script's "handsome," in an uncomfortable hug that's probably the only one they'll ever share. Troi says this alliance will give birth to the Federation, another misnomer, since it is the Federation we are seeing, and Riker ends the program, which many fans felt reduced the series to a hologram.
Then we transition into something quite beautiful, a montage with voiceovers from Picard, Kirk, and Archer, the three captains of the Enterprise, ending on Archer's ship flying into the sunset. A last-minute idea from Mike Sussman, replacing the Enterprise-D as the final shot, it's quite the save, and it moved me in 2005. But it was the only Star Trek finale people hated, unless you count "Turnabout Intruder," and time has upheld that reputation. My out is that this is a historical recreation, in some ways what happened, but perhaps not how, and any sequel should clarify the great lie told to bring this alliance together.
That final shot of the NX-01, the only real thing in the episode, speaks to the show's unfinished promise. By Season 4, Enterprise had come into its own, and its classicism, avoiding the shaky cam of its day and shot cinematically in 16:9, has helped it stand the test of time. Television was worse for losing it, and so were we. I've rated episodes 0 before, but piling on feels unnecessary, so this gets a big fat N/A. Thank you all for reading these. It's been 25 years since Enterprise launched. If you haven't given it a shot, use these reviews as a guide. Live long and prosper.
Written by Rick Berman and Brannon Braga, directed by Allan Kroeker. Rating: N/A.
1
888
"Terra Prime." This is actually a better episode than the previous one. It's faster paced, introduces real jeopardy and stakes, lets the characters really grow, and delivers a fitting end to the story of the series. It is littered with references to experiences the characters had in the past, as a series finale typically would be. We see Hoshi in command, with some acknowledgment of her origins as the nervous Nelly of the crew, and now she's steely, very effectively quoting regulations and giving the right commands to keep control of the ship at a critical moment. What struck me thematically in the conclusion of the arc that began in the last episode was the coldness, the closed-mindedness, the ruthlessness, the nihilistic, zero-sum thinking exhibited by the villains.
That thinking seems so familiar to me in this moment and truly disturbs me how well they predicted what humanity was going to go through in the 21st century. As Enterprise is fired upon by the array and has to withdraw, Paxton gives a speech about how he doesn't hate diversity, as long as all aliens leave the system. They should go back to their countries, excuse me, their planets. The delegates, including Ambassador Soval, who arrives in this episode in his final appearance on the series, and an Andorian ambassador, not Shran, assisted by Glen Hambly, explain that protests are forming around the Vulcan compound and the Andorian embassy, and disturbed by Paxton's following on Earth, they discuss ending the conference.
Samuels goes aboard Enterprise and orders Archer to destroy the array, despite that destroying it will also destroy a large portion of the colony on Mars, killing many innocent people. The politician says it's more important to act and show other systems that Earth can control its people, and offers to assign another ship if Archer doesn't want to be the one to do it. Archer convinces him to let him take a small assault team to try to intervene, and if they're not in time, they'll fire. I'm not sure if it's budgetary or story, but the MACOs don't appear in this episode, and it feels like a really good episode for MACOs. So it's going to be Archer, Reed, Travis, and Phlox, and there's a great moment when they explain their plan to Samuels to piggyback on a comet.
Travis says he has experience with comets, as we know from the first season's "Breaking the Ice," and Reed says compared to Xindi defenses, this will be a walk in the park, a reference to, of course, all of Season 3. Reed is also able to get some intelligence from Harris and Section 31 that will enable them to carry out the mission. Harris says if Archer's coalition happens, he'll be busier than ever. Travis's girlfriend claims she is working for Starfleet Intelligence and warns him there's a spy on Enterprise for Terra Prime. Meanwhile, on Mars, Trip is being pressured into calibrating their weapons system, and he refuses, gets locked up, and starts working his own way out.
Meanwhile, T'Pol is with the child and concerned for her health, and she discovers Paxton has been using alien gene therapy, anathema to his followers. She threatens to expose him, and like any good demagogue, Paxton dismisses her concern, basically saying he could go out into New York City and shoot somebody on the street, and they'd still follow him. It's not exactly what he said, but it's very similar. The landing party survives sabotage to the shuttle and launches its assault, while Trip has heroically already freed himself, so they converge on Paxton's control center for the action climax. Because the time is up, Samuels orders Hoshi to fire, and she refuses, using her authority to silence communications so she can't be relieved of command. Good for Hoshi.
Archer's team arrives at the center in time to call off the strike, but not before a fight, and Archer and Paxton have a final back and forth as the glass viewscreen shatters, threatening to expose them to the thin atmosphere of Mars. Trip, however, is in time to make sure the array fires harmlessly into San Francisco Bay. The imagery in this sequence, by the way, is nearly identical to the drill sequence in J.J. Abrams's 2009 Star Trek movie. There's a wonderful conversation between Archer and Paxton. Paxton says his father went up to the moon and turned a small mining colony into a self-sufficient world, and that's how we need to go out into space, taking the worlds we need and settling them.
What he's describing is Manifest Destiny, the philosophy that led American expansionists into the West, resulting in them driving out or subjugating the native populations, in some cases massacring them. For many, many years, the idea that we went out and settled an empty land was an essential part of the American myth, and it's an idea you'll find in other parts of the world as justification for colonial expansion, and a lot of people are raised to value it and see it as strength. Archer in this scene represents the alternate view, that space is crowded, a lot more crowded than we thought, and he calls it an opportunity, not an obstacle. We don't have to subjugate them. We can work with them, be with them, live with them, and help each other.
That is, at its core, the final message of the series, which you could describe with the Vulcan statement, infinite diversity in infinite combinations. Of course, Paxton isn't swayed and has to be knocked out, because he's evil and a madman, though they do keep him alive and in custody, and if we'd gone to a Season 5, I'm sure he'd have been back. He had also confirmed earlier that they have operatives on Enterprise who got the genetic material that allowed them to create a clone using Trip and T'Pol's DNA. That's something the show hadn't dealt with, that there was a human on Enterprise who knew there was something going on between Trip and T'Pol and was offended by it, as someone might have been offended by an interracial relationship in the early 20th century.
Travis confirms there is a spy when they examine the shuttle. I was wrong earlier, this episode is actually the final appearance of Commander Kelby, one last time as the suspected patsy. But it was Ensign Masaro, someone we only saw earlier in the episode, though his name has been mentioned offhand throughout the series. Masaro comes for the captain, tells Archer he's sorry, he believed in the cause, he didn't think they were going to hurt anybody, asks him to apologize to his parents, and turns the gun on himself. It's a very troubling scene. When they're looking for Masaro in the mess hall, we do see Duncan K. Fraser as Ensign Walsh, in his final appearance? We'll find out tomorrow.
And even though the threat is resolved, the delegates still feel it might be wise to end the conference, because clearly they feel Earth is not ready. T'Pol names the child Elizabeth, after Trip's sister, which is incredibly moving, and again a callback, since it was the death of Trip's sister that brought her together with Trip. This Elizabeth is also dying, and Phlox confirms it's a genetic issue with the human and Vulcan DNA. Phlox tells Archer that when he joined the crew, he expected it to be for a few months, a welcome respite from the complications of family, and he didn't expect to get a new family as a result. Losing her hurts the same as if it was his own child. It's really moving, and he asks Archer to make something good come from this.
So they go down to the conference, Samuels turns the floor over to Archer, and he gives a wonderful speech, both in universe and to us. It's more for us. He starts by talking about how in the past, humans asked if we were alone in the universe, and our generation is privileged to know the answer. Well, thousands of years ago on Earth, a tribesman, or someone living in a village, certainly had no knowledge of most of the world and the different kinds of people in it. Our generation in the 21st century is privileged to live in a world where we know the whole world, where people are, the different cultures, languages, food, and customs.
We can read about it, we can live among them, they can live among us, and this is a privilege and an opportunity granted only to those of us who have lived in the last 100 or so years. It is not something to be feared, as some would have us feel. It is not an obstacle to progress. When he says our greatest lessons are not what lies beyond the next star, I like to think it's a comment on the end of The Next Generation, when Q tells Picard his next journey is charting the unknown possibilities of existence. I like to think this is saying the real questions are not what's out there, but what's in us. And when he talks about the threads that bind us together, he's talking about us, our world.
The Vulcans, the Andorians, the Coridanites, the Tellarites, they're just stand-ins for the different types of people you and I will meet in our lives. It's always been the case since 1966, it's just very easy to lose sight of in the storytelling and the fiction. But as the show, and Star Trek itself, came to an end, with nothing else to tell us, this was to be the final message. All of you still here, all of you, must embrace and explore the privilege of being together on this planet. That's the final theme of Jonathan Archer in this series, and with a holo-Archer coming next time, the final scene of Scott Bakula playing him in the flesh. It's a wonderful curtain call.
Then comes the scene where I honestly did start crying as I watched it this time, because of the simplicity and commitment of the performances between Connor Trinneer and Jolene Blalock. We open on Jolene cradling the Vulcan IDIC medallion to her face, and I mentioned earlier infinite diversity in infinite combinations. This posture of embracing diversity as hope is what T'Pol seems to be desperately doing in this moment. As we'll learn in a moment, her child is dead, partly as the result of meddling by some very intolerant, evil people, but T'Pol's beliefs don't allow her to resent or decry the existence of anyone, and I like to think that's what's meant by her cradling the IDIC.
Trip enters, and it's so efficiently written. We know Elizabeth has died because he tells us the delegates at the conference were asking about the service because they'd like to attend, and we understand very quickly that this child has become a symbol of the promise of unity. He also tells her he spoke to Phlox, and that the problem with Elizabeth was the fault of the scientist who cloned her, and that it would be possible for a human and a Vulcan to choose to have a child. He's weeping as he says it, and he tells her there's some comfort in that, and she desperately grabs his hand and clings to it, the final shot of the two of them until we see the ship fly away.
Obviously, Star Trek has always had Spock, half human and half Vulcan, the culmination of the setup here, but what they've done with this emotional throughline over two years of Trip and T'Pol's relationship is make this child a symbol not only of diversity, but of unification. I'm going to talk about the next episode in a separate review, but as far as I'm concerned, any suggestion that these two didn't have a profoundly deep and connected relationship after this, one that produced at least one child, I absolutely reject.
That, to me, is clearly the path these characters are on, and the only hope for them after all they've been through. The loss they've felt together is one of the most profound in Star Trek, and deserves to be numbered among the greatest losses of a child on television. Like Archer's speech, this feels like a moment of crossing over, of Manny and his team telling us, okay, we're done, we're giving this back to you, and leaving us in that place, saying it's time for you to go out into the world, time for you to have a child, time for you to embrace your neighbors and those who live far away from you, and to build a world we can all live in, in harmony and peace.
Star Trek signing off. It's absolutely wonderful, and a perfect culmination to the story of Earth's first ship of interstellar exploration. Unfortunately, it's not my final review. I want to say a special thank you to Manny Coto, may he rest in peace, Mike Sussman, André Bormanis, and Judith and Garfield Reeves-Stevens for bringing us this season of Star Trek, one of its best, and for leaving us with such a wonderful message, regardless of what came next. And this last thanks I give to more than them, to the writers, producers, cast and crew of the whole series, Brannon, Rick, and everyone, for giving us the Star Trek we needed in the early 2000s. We'll talk more about that tomorrow. Thank you, Captains.
Teleplay by Judith and Garfield Reeves-Stevens and Manny Coto, story by Judith and Garfield Reeves-Stevens and André Bormanis, directed by Marvin V. Rush. Rating: 11/10. Next up: "These Are the Voyages..."
"Demons." The final arc of Star Trek: Enterprise before the standalone finale was clearly mostly written before the series' cancellation. It's not that it isn't a fitting ending, it certainly is, but it brings with it so much promise about what might be to come that it's frustrating, and teasing. We open with a teaser of the great Peter Weller looking at a baby, and if we look closely, we can deduce it's a human-Vulcan hybrid, with Vulcan ears but human eyebrows.
After the credits, we learn we're at a conference to charter a new organization called the Coalition of Planets, led by an Earth diplomat, Nathan Samuels, played by Harry Groener, who's not only important in this episode but feels like he's being set up to continue along the series in an important way. We see many of the races the ship has encountered, the Andorians, the Tellarites, and Coridanites, though I have to wonder if the producers forgot we saw Coridan in the first season, where the aliens were much more traditionally humanoid, which has led fan sites to say Coridan is a multi-species planet.
It does, however, establish in a way why Coridan didn't join the Federation, as we know from the original episode "Journey to Babel." The conference is interrupted when a woman brings T'Pol a strand of hair with a cryptic message about someone in danger, and with Phlox's help, it's determined that the person in danger is the child of Trip and T'Pol, to everyone's shock.
This briefly drives a wedge between them, as Trip wonders if she kept something very important from him. She says she didn't, Phlox backs that up, and they have a wonderful scene together, as Trip confides in Phlox and Phlox chides him a bit for doubting T'Pol. There's a great moment in that scene where Trip says, "My father always wanted a granddaughter. He used to bug my sister about it constantly," and Phlox says, looks like he got his wish. The subtext, of course, is that his sister is dead, and he likely assumed there would be no more Tuckers.
Another thing about this episode that feels like growth for Star Trek is its very mature subject matter. The topic of an unplanned pregnancy is handled very maturely, and the characters behave maturely, in a way even some earlier Star Trek shows probably would have struggled with. We learn of a group called Terra Prime, which has been around for some time, and Reed says it made noise when Enterprise was first launched. It's an isolationist sect on Earth that doesn't think humans should explore space, or that there should be any aliens on Earth, so that humans can remain isolated and control their own destiny.
They believe there may be a hotbed of this activity on the moon, which necessitates a covert mission, as Trip and T'Pol infiltrate a mining colony on the moon, which we see was established in 2090. We don't know what they're mining, but it's quite a robust operation, and it's really cool to see an episode centered in Earth orbit for the first time. Reed solicits help from Mr. Harris of Section 31, bringing that plotline back into the show, which we wouldn't have expected, and Harris agrees, but basically says you owe me, and Reed doesn't deny it. Again, more setup for a future that never came.
Travis also gets a big plotline, as an old girlfriend comes aboard, and I have to say, Mr. Coto, it worked with the Orions, but not every love interest can be this super eager, forward woman. I don't know if there have just been some changes in our culture, but that element reads less believable to me than pretty much anything else. We get to spend some time on the moon with Peter Weller's character, named Paxton (interestingly enough), who is essentially whatever a neo-Nazi would be if it were about aliens. The dialogue is incredibly well written, and the points of view he espouses could have been taken from X today, with an alien twist.
There's even discussion of Colonel Green, a character referenced in the original series, seen here in a historical recording, with Steve Rankin taking over the role, and I've heard rumors that additional material was shot with him. We learn that in the aftermath of the Third World War, Green killed people affected by radiation sickness specifically to prevent them from passing genetic mutations to their offspring. Paxton defends this, as does Daniel Greaves, played by the great Peter Mensah of Spartacus and many other projects. Daniel, good name, but I regret the side they put him on. They're both completely sold out to their ideology and believe they're doing what's in the best interest of humanity.
Weller gets a number of great speeches, and as Trip and T'Pol infiltrate the moon, Trip goes to an Earth First rally, where we hear a different point of view on a lot of the experiences we've had in the series, some of which certainly have some logic to them. Josiah, and they all seem to have biblical names, complains that the Xindi killed 7 million people. Did they ever apologize? Did we ask for an apology? Did they provide reparations? And that's true. We felt very good at the end of Season 3 that we'd made peace with our enemy, but 7 million people died, families were destroyed, whole family lines may have been wiped out, and a lot of people would not be happy that we simply made peace.
They reference the bombing of the Earth Embassy on Vulcan and correctly say the Vulcans killed 45 humans and nothing's come of it. We felt the satisfaction, with Archer, that the High Command was shut down and that T'Pau and Kuvak are running the government, but to someone on Earth, that's really not that significant. As with a lot of these things, it's not that the criticisms don't have merit, it's that the underlying premise is wrong, the idea that it's inevitably bad to associate with those who are different. We've seen that on the show, as Phlox is a great addition to the crew who brings a special experience, and T'Pol is invaluable.
As much as Paxton has contempt for Trip and T'Pol's relationship when he confronts them, we know it's something very special. We'll learn about the creation of the child in the next episode, but Paxton does seem to have knowledge of their relationship, which doesn't seem to have been publicized, so it implies there's a spy on Enterprise, probably a member of Terra Prime from back when the ship launched, keeping close watch on this mission and sending back information that would allow them to carry out this plan.
Archer and Hoshi determine that Travis's girlfriend is a spy, presumably for Terra Prime, and they arrest her, and Archer is able to blackmail Samuels into helping get them information, learning that Samuels was a member of Terra Prime in his youth, though he does seem to be on the level now. Finally, Paxton launches his ship to Mars, the first time we've been on the surface of Mars, as well as the moon, in Star Trek, and takes over a comet-diverting array, which he uses to fire on the moon. He says he'll fire on any ship in the system unless all the aliens leave, that it's a new day for Earth, and that's the cliffhanger we're left on.
Again, what strikes me about this episode is how much new ground it sets up. Travis is considering staying on Earth, Reed is obviously open to working with Section 31, and Trip and T'Pol are confronting their bond, the idea that they're connected, as T'Pol says she knows Trip is worried she's lying to him, because she can tell. It's this beautiful story they're building with these characters, and there's even Archer's growing frustration with Earth politics. It's also LeVar Burton's last Star Trek directing job.
There's a great moment when they've got the reporter girlfriend and she asks for a lawyer, and you can see on Bakula's face that he's used to being out in deep space where he's in charge, and here he's subject to a legal system, as he should be. As he operates more around Earth, he's not an explorer anymore, and he's going to be more subject to a real legal system, whether Earth's or this Coalition of Planets'. It's no longer the Wild West.
So much is being set up here, some of which gets paid off in the next episode, but watching this, you're really not ready for the series to end. These speeches from evil characters make for such an intellectually challenging idea, with so many great lines about what will happen to humans if we keep interbreeding with aliens, and how Starfleet keeps being told how dangerous it is to reveal our existence to other species, which is true, since the Borg, the Klingons, and the Romulans all happened because Earth went out into space. It's very challenging and interesting, a fantastic part one to this great saga, and 10 out of 10, for sure.
Written by Manny Coto, directed by LeVar Burton. Rating: 10/10. Next up: "Terra Prime."
1
419
"In a Mirror, Darkly, Part II." This is where the fun really begins. They packed enough plot for at least two episodes into the one hour they knew they'd have on these beautiful sets. We see the bridge, a good section of the corridors, the conference room, and the captain's quarters, all constructed so much to spec with the original series that the little changes made because it's supposed to be a different ship really stand out.
They also reconstruct the Jefferies tube, the crawl space from the original series, and add new spaces I really love, a great mix of '90s-era Star Trek sensibilities using the look and feel of the '60s. I imagine those were largely built because they couldn't afford to build the engine room, so we never see engineering, but we see these spaces where critical power components are. They get the Defiant up and running and blow away the Tholians, and one of the joys is seeing the weapons from the original series be completely devastating in this period, as if you'd gone back to the Civil War with an Uzi.
The writer, Mike Sussman, also made sure to justify getting the characters into original series uniforms, albeit with a different insignia patch, since the crew of the Defiant had a different patch in that original episode, and Majel Barrett voices the Defiant's computer, just as she voiced the original Enterprise's. Archer is bound and determined to use this ship to end the war with the rebels, who are of course alien factions, over T'Pol's objections, but before they can get to the battle, they're sabotaged by a reptilian creature, a Gorn.
The Gorn, from the original series episode "Arena," was an iconic Star Trek alien that had never really been depicted since, and it's represented here as a CGI creature in a way I think is quite effective. The design is quite similar, with slight alterations, even down to the clothing, but being CGI lets it move faster and be a more realistic physical threat to Archer than the original could. It's not as dramatic a redesign as Strange New Worlds, where the Gorn mostly don't even seem able to communicate, whereas here it speaks through the universal translator, so it's quite faithful, and thrilling to have Archer hunting it through the bowels of the ship.
Reed is critically injured, but Archer outwits the Gorn and kills it. He's also been digging into the library computers and learned the history of our prime universe, and now he's seeing hallucinations of Prime Archer taunting him, because this Archer is incredibly insecure. He continues his relationship with Hoshi, who looks up her historical record and his. Fun fact, that historical record serves as the basis for the proposed future of the character, since it establishes that Archer became President of the Federation, an on-screen canon event we hope to see followed up on while the good Mr. Bakula is still acting.
Once the Gorn threat is eliminated, which I'd consider episode one of this series of plotlines, they engage the rebel fleet and save the NX-09 Avenger, which has aboard Soval, an ambassador we know, who, just like Leonard Nimoy in "Mirror, Mirror," has a Vulcan goatee. It's commanded by Admiral Black, played by great character actor Gregory Itzin at the same time he was beginning his most famous character, President Logan on 24. Admiral Black is someone we've never seen before, and it would've been interesting, had the show continued, if he'd returned in the prime universe.
Archer kills Admiral Black when he won't give him command of the ship, letting us see the great disintegration effect of the phaser for the first time on Enterprise, and in the battle, over T'Pol's objection, Archer destroys a Vulcan ship while letting an Andorian ship go, which speaks to the little bias Archer may have toward Andorians in all universes. It was so cool at the time to see the Constitution class in modern VFX and with modern warp effects. The original series has since been remastered with similar effects, making it less novel, but at the time it was a revelation. So there's episode number two.
Now, episode number three. Archer intends to go to Earth and take command of the Empire, now with a little fleet of two ships, and T'Pol, Soval, and Phlox conspire to destroy the Defiant. In the final act, Archer outwits them with Trip's help, destroying the NX-09, with a wonderfully campy performance from Soval screaming as the ship blows up, and we see Glen Hambly as an Andorian and an Orion woman among his crew, all killed. Archer celebrates his victory by lying back in bed with Hoshi, but unfortunately for him, she's drugged him and begun a relationship with his guard, Travis, and the episode ends with her proclaiming herself Empress.
Other fun cameos include Duncan K. Fraser walking by in the corridor as Phlox goes to sabotage the ship, and Commander Kelby dying at the hands of the Gorn, which I believe is Kelby's last appearance on Enterprise. It's fun that in this universe Trip also hates Kelby and yells at him, because that's what he likes to do. We also get a great fight between T'Pol and Hoshi, hurling insults at each other while slicing each other with knives, and it's always good to see green blood on a Vulcan.
I don't know if I spoke to the costumes last time, but in the original mirror universe, the women had midriff-baring uniforms, and that's maintained here using the Enterprise-style uniforms, which are certainly quite effective. And of course, the real pleasure from a uniform perspective is seeing our main cast in the traditional gold, blue, and red, I believe the last Star Trek cast to do so, since any future version using those colors would use a retrofitted design.
So this episode is full of lasts in a number of important ways. It's the last depiction of the original version of the Constitution-class starship in Star Trek, the uniforms, and the props, since all subsequent versions would revise these things, even when depicting this era. It really is a finale of sorts to a whole era of Star Trek built on iteration, and a real testament to the work all the craftspeople pulled off, from the designers to the builders to the prop masters.
Director Marvin Rush, typically the series' cinematographer, steps in and does some really fun stuff with lighting, like a scene of Archer and Hoshi talking and making out in the bedroom, all in a single shot in silhouette, a very difficult thing to pull off, but quite effective. I think the digital cameras really help make these sets look futuristic even while they're simple, with a simplicity to the interfaces that implies a sophistication we don't see on the usual NX ships.
From a storytelling perspective, this is much more of a fun romp than the first part, which I think has some real thematic things to say. This one is incredibly over the top, and Bakula is having a wonderful time giving speeches and chewing the scenery. All the actors get great moments, Phlox, T'Pol, and Hoshi for sure, the MVP of this two-parter. I didn't note this last episode, but Archer has a Porthos, a big dog like a Doberman or a Rottweiler, and we have to assume that dog died when the Enterprise was destroyed, which is very sad.
It's a great two-parter, and Mike Sussman's final script for the series. We're really at the point where we're getting a lot of lasts. During the filming of this episode, they learned the show was canceled, which is quite sad, with only three episodes left. Since the finale is very much a series finale, I assume it was only at this moment that decisions about it were made, and I don't know if "Demons" and "Terra Prime" were originally intended as a three-parter, so perhaps someone reading this can speak to that. What we know is that it became a two-parter, and "These Are the Voyages" became the finale, and I have some speculation I'll save for that review.
This is certainly an incredibly high note for Mike to go out on, and a great tribute to the original Star Trek. I'm sure there are references I missed, and it's a wonderful watch. I'm sure you've seen it if you're reading this, but if you haven't, check it out. It absolutely gets a 10 out of 10.
Story by Manny Coto, teleplay by Mike Sussman, directed by Marvin V. Rush. Rating: 10/10. Next up: "Demons."
129
"In a Mirror, Darkly." Most polls of Star Trek fans will list this as the best episode of Enterprise, and that's because a majority of Star Trek fans have not watched Enterprise, but they have watched this episode. It's famous for two reasons. It's Enterprise's only visit to the mirror universe, a concept established in the original series' "Mirror, Mirror" and continued in Deep Space Nine, and it's the return of the bridge of the 1966 Enterprise.
Technically, it's not the Enterprise in the episode, but the Defiant, from "The Tholian Web," which aired in November 1968, where the set was simply a distressed version of the Enterprise bridge, so the construction here is identical. This was highly promoted at the time and a pretty big deal, because no full physical recreation of that set had ever been done. In The Next Generation, they built a small portion of it and extended it digitally, and Deep Space Nine did something similar, if more robust, using a lot of digital technology to composite their cast into footage of "The Trouble with Tribbles."
The episode itself is a big swing that hits across all sectors. The mirror universe in the original was probably not too unusual for '60s television, our characters going to an alternate version of their reality where everything is darker, more evil, and quite fascist. There's no Federation, it's an empire, the mirror Kirk has committed atrocities and war crimes, and there's cutthroat drama within the crew, akin perhaps to the darkest periods of ancient Rome, or even the Nazi Reich. Enterprise takes this concept and does a prequel, setting the entire episode in the mirror universe.
It opens with a scene from Star Trek: First Contact, humanity's first contact with aliens, but in this version, the humans turn weapons on the Vulcans, kill them, and take their technology. The title sequence has been modified as if we're watching an episode of the show from the evil universe, showing the progression of human weapons and instruments of death, and what's really fascinating is that this is also part of human history. In so many ways, the dark version of our future the episode shows us is a little too recognizable for comfort, especially if you spend any time today on the platform known as X.
All the characters we've come to love are here, including the formerly deceased Admiral Forrest, who in this world is captain of the Enterprise, with Archer as his first officer, and Letter Decker Evan English is at the helm. The plot is dense and the mythology and world building are vast, but what's important is that each character gets a very believable and consistent version of themselves that's completely morally bankrupt and self-interested. And while in some ways the technology is superior to what we're used to in the 22nd century, the characters' fates are worse off.
Archer isn't a captain, he's a first officer, and the system these people live in, which theoretically promotes advancement, has actually left them in worse condition than we're used to. Trip is visibly scarred because there are no safety protocols for warp engines, Travis is a stooge who Archer has to tell not to kiss up too much, and Hoshi is the captain's mistress, a role somewhat formalized in the original "Mirror, Mirror." T'Pol has to proclaim she's not a slave, and Archer has to remind her, you're Vulcan, don't forget that. The aliens have been subjugated, with Tellarites and Vulcans aboard in subservient roles.
Phlox is a sadistic torturer, who we see experimenting on little dogs and aliens, and who tortures a captured Tholian by lowering its body temperature, while Reed is the inventor of the agony booth, the device we saw in "Mirror, Mirror." There's casual racism throughout, as when Reed asks, aren't all Tellarites guilty of something? It's an incredibly dark depiction of a completely Randian society, where the only rule is advancement and success, not unlike perhaps Wall Street or some other value systems we're familiar with.
So I contest Manny Coto's claim in the documentary about these episodes that the episode has no message. I completely disagree. I think it has a message by demonstration, by analogy, showing us what an alternate reality fueled by the worst impulses of humanity would look like, from shifting loyalties to all kinds of manipulation, sexual and political.
The setup for how we get to the original Enterprise sets is that this Archer has intelligence that the Tholians have what he knows to be a futuristic ship, so he commits a mutiny, with shades of "The Menagerie," taking over the ship from Captain Forrest, who he imprisons. He takes Forrest's girlfriend/mistress, Hoshi, who apparently was Archer's ex in this reality as well, since she was climbing the ladder. And T'Pol, who is formidable in this universe, sexually manipulates Commander Tucker into sabotaging the ship.
It made me realize that while last episode is, as I recall, Trip and T'Pol's last kiss in the prime universe, they actually kiss here, so Jolene and Connor weren't necessarily done kissing, and maybe I'll see the next few episodes and realize I was mistaken. T'Pol breaks Captain Forrest out of the brig with the aid of her Vulcan compatriots, played by Letter Deckers Glen Hambly and Scott Hill, but it's too late, as Archer has locked navigation and convinced Starfleet Command to back his plan to take what he believes to be a much more powerful ship.
They assault the facility and board the ship, and we get a beautiful shot of them coming onto this bridge Star Trek fans are so familiar with, and then Trip powers on the lights for a beautiful pan across the ship. But the Tholians have caught the Enterprise in the famous Tholian web, depicted here as a full three-dimensional structure that can contract and presumably crush a ship when completed. Forrest commits somewhat of an act of nobility, sacrificing himself to allow others to escape, including Hoshi, and at the end the Enterprise is destroyed, with Archer and his boarding party on the Defiant, still trapped in the Tholian facility.
The episode is a complete guilty pleasure, and perhaps the most faithful sequel to "Mirror, Mirror" in its depiction of the mirror universe. More recent Star Trek series have explored the mirror universe quite a lot, and done some serious damage to the mythology in things like the Section 31 film, which really didn't line up with anything we'd seen before. Even in more interesting depictions, like Discovery's first season, they removed a lot of elements, and it became darker and more sadistic, but not as fun, or as sexy.
The mirror universe in the original, in this, and even in Deep Space Nine is campy, over the top, and entertaining. We see people behaving badly, but there's a little bit of wish fulfillment in the way people dress and the pure testosterone the men exhibit. As I said, it's an example of the worst impulses of humanity, but these are our impulses, and we do experience them, so to see them dramatized this way is enjoyable while also serving as something of a cautionary tale.
It reestablishes character dynamics in this universe in such great detail and with such great success that fans were very much hoping for a subseries set in the mirror universe, and perhaps, if there were a future Star Trek show with Scott Bakula, that dream could live. We open on the mirror universe and a jail cell, and there is the former Captain Archer, imprisoned... but I'm getting ahead of myself. Let's not spoil part two.
I don't think it's fair to say this is the best episode of Enterprise, because it's not a typical episode of Enterprise, but I also can't knock it whatsoever. It's certainly a 10 out of 10 episode and an all-timer, and I can't wait for part two.
Written by Mike Sussman, directed by James L. Conway. Rating: 10/10. Next up: "In a Mirror, Darkly, Part II."
1
296
"Bound." An unnecessarily controversial episode that one might describe as a guilty pleasure, all about deep cuts into original series lore and attempting to update them for a modern audience. It opens with a wonderful joke, a reference to Spock's line in "This Side of Paradise" about seeing a dragon on Berengaria VII, as Enterprise heads there to establish the first of something called starbases, an important part of Star Trek world building we'd not heard of until now. In the original series they were usually on planets, like Starbase 11 in "Court Martial" and "The Menagerie," and by TNG they were space stations.
Before they get there, an Orion ship approaches, and we meet the most interesting male Orion I think we've ever met in Star Trek, Harrad-Sar, played by William Lucking. He comes across like a Harkonnen in the new Dune movies, and whereas the slave traders in "Borderland," with Big Show, seemed strong but not altogether clever, Harrad-Sar is immediately formidable, a character I'm sure would have returned had the series continued. Meanwhile, Kelby struggles under his unexpected new boss, Trip, T'Pol asks Trip about their shared visions so obtusely that he takes advantage, to our amusement, and Manny Coto slips in a reference to the Gorn Hegemony, walking the steps Akiva Goldsman would walk after him.
Harrad-Sar wines and dines Archer and Reed, and we get the first Orion dance sequence since the original series' "Whom Gods Destroy," originating in "The Cage," an elaborate and exciting number with three Orion women walking in the footsteps of Bobbi Sue Luther, Cyia Batten as Navaar, Crystal Allen as D'Nesh, and Menina Fortunato as Maras. Harrad-Sar points out that Archer is wanted by the Klingon Empire and the Orion Syndicate, quite a roguish reputation, and says women like these come with troubles of their own, and Archer finds that funny, which is entertaining, because of all the Starfleet captains, Archer's fairly reserved in his pursuit of women.
He and Reed are very enamored, so one might wonder if there's something more at play. The Orion dancing girl of the original pilot was clearly meant to represent a male fantasy ideal, and the characters speaking to Pike use rather dated language to suggest Orion women are natural nymphomaniacs, though nothing suggests they're reliable narrators, and Susan Oliver's raw sexuality was an illusion in Pike's head anyway. Yvonne Craig, arguably the only real Orion woman in the original series, is more coquettish, and while she does try to seduce Kirk, it's not with the overt sexuality we saw in "The Cage," or here.
Harrad-Sar is obviously trying to seduce the captain in his own way, and in a very humorous scene, Archer tells T'Pol he's already agreed to a 10% share in exchange for the coordinates of a planet rich in resources for warp reactors, so why ask her? Because Harrad-Sar insists he accept a gift, and he doesn't know what to do about it. The gift is three green ladies. There's some "Rajiin" here, but it's more an homage to "Mudd's Women," as they comically overwhelm the senses of the men. T'Pol makes the obvious mistake of asking Archer to speak to them, though I think she enjoys that they believe they're his property and wants him to deal with it.
Travis and Reed work off some steam in the gym, with a reference to the Deltans from The Motion Picture, another Gene Roddenberry creation along with the Orion women, and Gene would probably love this episode. One Orion cozies up to Kelby, who nobody likes except her, and it's no coincidence he's the chief engineer. Hoshi and other women come to Phlox with headaches, a plot point that's been criticized, and I never understood why. The idea is a biochemical love potion, irresistible to men, that's harmful to women, presumably to reduce competition. Perhaps audiences wanted it to be more pansexual, as later Trek has played with, but this race appears to have evolved this particular power, and it's all make believe.
Phlox collapses, so something is wrong. Trip seems unaffected, though he still calls Kelby, a commander in the previous episodes and with commander rank still on his uniform, lieutenant, which may just mean Trip doesn't like him either. Respect the man's rank, sir. When Kelby refuses to ask the Orion woman to leave engineering, Trip confines him to quarters, not what I'd expect from someone just helping out, so perhaps it's like The Motion Picture, when Decker got a temporary grade reduction. Whatever Trip says, he's commandeered engineering, playing right into the hands of our green friends.
Archer tells Navaar she's not a slave, and while she seems relieved, she still puts the moves on our good captain. Archer generally isn't one for the ladies, but he makes an exception, and maybe the show was developing the idea that he has a heart for alien women, since in "E²" he marries a woman of another species. T'Pol interrupts his little high school makeout session, but given his open shirt and disheveled, sweaty appearance on the bridge, I think it's safe to assume Captain Archer went where no (hu)man had gone before. When T'Pol asks if he's all right, he says, I'm fine, in a way none of us believe. We also learn Hoshi is the protocol officer.
At the planet, an alien ship with low-powered weapons fires on them, posing no threat, but Archer, with testosterone flooding his system, orders it destroyed anyway. T'Pol objects that they can just withdraw, and to his credit, Reed refuses, a really strong character moment, especially after his last episode in the brig. Meanwhile, another Orion tells Kelby he's better than Tucker and should be in charge, and that she's used to men who take what they want, so get rid of Tucker or no more of this company. She has complete power over him, and when she asks what he'd do to keep her forever, he says, anything.
When alarms go off in engineering and Trip sees Kelby at a console, he immediately screams, Kelby! Nobody likes this guy, and everyone assumes any problem is his fault, so he's not wrong that he's unfairly treated. Phlox finds a potent pheromone increasing aggression in the men and causing headaches in the women, which doesn't contradict the original series, since we never saw women around the Orions. John Billingsley has perfect comic timing, timing a stimulant injection to his neck with his line. Only Trip and T'Pol are unaffected, and Phlox doesn't know why. We know why, or we think we do, it's their true love.
Archer confines the Orion women to decon, still in their slight attire despite all that talk of getting them clothes, and almost releases them until T'Pol's voice wakes him up, and Navaar delivers a wonderful line, I'm obviously not the only woman with power over you. Foolishly, they leave a male MACO guarding them, when it would've been the perfect time for a female MACO. Trip recalls the pilot, the sort of thing you do when you think a show's ending, and two crewmen start fighting, one being Duncan K. Fraser, credited as Crewman #2 rather than Ensign Walsh, a union designation, as this was a speaking role, and Trip yells him down, since Trip likes to yell at the crew.
T'Pol explains there's a long-held belief that Vulcans who mate share a psychic bond, and I wonder whether that comes from Surak's teachings or folk belief. It's hard to imagine a race that banned mind melds believing this as fact, and she does seem to speak of it more as mythology than lived practice. Again, it must require true love. I love Trip's response, we didn't mate, and she makes a face, getting him to admit he's been having the same dreams. She believes her physiology is making him immune, and there's both hokiness and romance in the idea.
I wish they'd kept it in Strange New Worlds, where they turned Spock into a raging slut, because it'd be nice if there were consequences. Then Harrad-Sar takes Enterprise in tow and delivers the line people struggle with, it's the men who are the slaves, not the women. It's a fascinating idea, though we saw a woman sold in "Borderland," perhaps a ruse to a non-Orion "owner," the women used as a control mechanism to turn households into vassals.
Lower Decks and Discovery would maintain that Orions are matriarchal but largely ignore the sexual side, I feel because they were afraid to deal with it, and modern Star Trek, outside of making Spock a horndog, is largely sexless. People felt this was making a comment about women as a whole, and I don't know if that's fair. And as far as Orion culture, if it evolved from a primitive society into an imperialistic one through female dominance and this pheromone-empowered competition, the play-acted slavery could linger, and still evolve out over the 200 years before Lower Decks, especially if it was due to growing Federation influence and prohibitions on actual slavery. There's a story there.
The women escape onto the bridge, and the men completely melt, with Archer ordering Reed to take a supposedly jealous T'Pol to the brig. It's funny, it's sad, it's great. Trip stuns every man on the bridge, and the Orions look truly perturbed they have no effect on him, as it should be. It ends with a great original series homage, the crew telling jokes in sickbay, as T'Pol, referring to the knowledge that the women are in charge on Orion, says even the most disagreeable species have positive attributes, and Archer says she's picking up Trip's bad habits. In the coda, Trip gets T'Pol to admit she wants him to come back, says he'll think about it, and when she kisses him, he admits he'd already told Hernandez he wasn't coming back. I think it's their last on-screen kiss.
This is a really fun episode, I don't care what anybody says, probably their best attempt at comedy, with relaxed actors playing for laughs. It's sexy, and the Orion women revived a cosplay tradition seen at conventions ever since. Because Bobbi Sue did not get to speak in "Borderland," we're able to get a fuller picture of Orion women here, and these three portray exactly what you'd imagine Orion women would be, dangerous, cunning, a real threat. In a franchise that can struggle with new alien races, it builds out one that was established but never really seen.
It's sort of the final word on this era of Orions. We've seen them in modern Trek, with Lieutenant (jg) Tendi in Lower Decks a very popular example, the one in Discovery's third season a bit forgettable, and some pretty good Orions in Mike McMahan's Short Treks episode "The Escape Artist," with Rainn Wilson as Harry Mudd. Jolene and Connor make their relationship fun, it's a great setup for where we go after next time's detour into the mirror universe, and it gets a 9 out of 10.
Written by Manny Coto, directed by Allan Kroeker. Rating: 9/10. Next up: "In a Mirror, Darkly."
1
903
"Divergence," part two of this mini Klingon arc. Fun fact, it's directed by David Barrett, who's had a long career but was relatively young in it at the time, and he'd go on to direct two episodes of Star Trek: Discovery, including the best episode of Discovery, which is, of course, "Magic to Make the Sanest Man Go Mad," written by Aron Eli Coleite and Jesse Alexander. I read an interview with him around that episode's release where he talked about how no one was really paying attention to the rules of directing Star Trek by the time he came onto Enterprise, so he tried to put in as much unusual camera work as he could.
He masterfully directs the opening sequence, where Columbia must merge with Enterprise's warp bubble so Trip can transfer from one ship to the other by rope, solving last week's cliffhanger. It's a thrilling, very well directed sequence, and Archer lets Reed out of the brig to help facilitate the transfer, which is successful, and then Reed goes back in the brig. Once that action completes, the episode slows down compared to part one, and we get to spend a little more time with Phlox on the Klingon colony.
He's been tortured and doesn't want to do anything to help the Klingons create augments, but Dr. Antaak convinces him there's a way to cure the plague without solving the augment problem, and that they can hide this from the general, so they conspire together. Meanwhile, Archer is discovering the mysterious figure, Harris, and trying to piece together his relationship to Reed, and convinces Reed to tell the truth, now that he can see Harris was willing to destroy Enterprise, and to reach out to him, so Harris and Archer have a conversation.
We discover Harris is a shady operator, and he references part of the Starfleet Charter, Article 14, Section 31, a reference to a shadowy group introduced in Deep Space Nine as Section 31. In that show, it was represented by a singular man named Sloan, played by William Sadler, who recruited Dr. Julian Bashir as an agent. This episode maintains that structure, since it's clear Reed was operating as an agent while having other duties, and Section 31 doesn't have uniformed officers, but like the CIA, recruits assets who serve the division.
It's a great canon extension of that idea, which was drastically changed in more modern Star Trek interpretations, but this is fairly faithful, and it suggests the group goes all the way back to the origins of Starfleet, which is quite interesting. One might suspect that knowledge of the events of Star Trek: First Contact, or other strange incursions, might have prompted the founders of Starfleet, who we still don't know anything about, to incorporate this into their charter, and that it was maintained even into the era of the Federation.
It's quite clear Harris is attempting a sort of realpolitik manipulation, working with a Klingon admiral, Krell, who I love, played by Wayne Grace. I think he's one of the best Klingons we've seen in a long time, with a perfect voice, perfect makeup, and a buck tooth sticking out of his mouth. Of course, Krell double crosses him, intending to destroy both Enterprise and Columbia and sterilize the colony. Reed tells Archer he doesn't know where Phlox is, but Starfleet Intelligence believes the Klingons have a genetic research facility on the Qu'Vat colony.
He should have added, and that's where we destroyed the augment ship, so it would make sense. I don't know why they forgot that was Qu'Vat colony, so I guess Reed's just not very bright. In any case, Archer beams down to the Klingon planet with the general's son, who is their prisoner, and there's a great beat earlier where the Klingon augment soldiers are dying of the virus and their commander, Laneth, played by Kristin Bauer, talks about how she felt fear and cowardice.
I think this is an allusion to the fan perception that Klingons in the original series were cowardly, swarthy, conniving, and not honorable. I disagree with that. Kor is honorable, and Kang is very honorable in those episodes, Koloth is comic relief, the guy in "Friday's Child" is weird, and we don't really get much with the guy in "A Private Little War," who, funnily enough, is also named Krell. I guess Kahless in "The Savage Curtain," where we meet Surak, is kind of cowardly, but that's not the real Kahless, so I never found that fan comment accurate, and I don't think it needed to be serviced, but nonetheless, it's serviced here.
Archer learns Phlox is trying to cure the virus and wants to help, and there are a number of things in the episode where Phlox says, if I do this, I can do this faster. The first is that if he infects three Klingons and gives each a version of the cure, they'll know faster which cure is real, so the Klingons all do that, and there's a great moment with James Avery asking if bloodwine would hurt the process, and Phlox says no, and he says, then we shall drink. That's always great.
It turns out James Avery's character does have the cure, so Phlox wants to rush to cure his friend Dr. Antaak, and when Archer arrives, he says he could do this faster with a human host. So we get a wild sequence where Archer is strapped down to a chair and injected, and for reasons I still don't understand, develops Klingon head ridges. That means in the course of this season alone, Archer has had the katra of Surak, can now apparently instruct a Vulcan on how to mind meld and does Vulcan neck pinches, and has had Klingon ridges and a craving for gagh, which he mentions at the end of the episode. We're getting a little wild with Jonathan Archer experiencing alien sensations.
They're able to get the cure, while Enterprise and Columbia try to fight off the Klingon fleet, but the Klingons are too powerful and are going to destroy the colony. So Phlox beams the virus aboard the Klingon ship and says, if you let us live, we'll give you the cure, which is dark from our good Dr. Phlox, that dark edge coming out, a little bit of mad scientist. He wanted to make sure he had the cure first, so he's got principles, but he's dark, and he's able to get the Klingons to surrender.
Hernandez says she's got to take Columbia and do some exploring, since we haven't done any this season, and this is the last time we'll see her on the series, which is a shame, because she's a great character and Columbia is a great ship. Trip, however, is going to stay for a little while at Archer's request to help with repairs, and I have to ask, if Trip's staying and she's going to explore, presumably at top speed in one of the fastest ships, how's Trip going to get back? As you know if you watch the show, they never have to do this, and I think it's funny that for all the drama, Trip basically spends one episode off Enterprise. Good for Trip.
I love seeing T'Pol uncomfortable with it and out of her element, and the episode ends with Reed telling Harris, don't call me again, I don't work for you anymore, and Harris saying you don't get out that easy before Reed hangs up on him, so we're not done with that plotline. We get a really clear shot of Cricket Yee of Letter Decks in sickbay, who was also Hoshi's stand-in, but here appears to be a nurse of some sort. Then we get a scene with Phlox and Dr. Antaak, who now has no Klingon head ridges, a side effect of the cure, and he explains it's going to cause a lot of problems for the Klingon Empire. Maybe he'll get into cranial reconstruction.
That allows for the idea that some of the Klingons we see later may have had cosmetic surgery, which actually answers how the Klingons in Deep Space Nine who played characters from the original series didn't have head ridges then and had them later. And since we know Klingons carry on house names, like the variety of Duras's we've seen, we can presume the Krell of "A Private Little War" is a descendant of Admiral Krell, and that, as predicted, the mutation was passed down through his children.
Again, this is all Deep Space Nine's fault for making it in universe. They didn't have to do that, they thought they were being clever, so blame them, don't blame the Enterprise writers. Blame Ronald D. Moore, that's whose fault it is that we had to explain this, because it could just as easily have been that they always had ridges and we just didn't see them because we didn't have the makeup budget.
Looking at the dates, it hasn't been that much time since they returned from the Xindi crisis, and maybe Starfleet doesn't want to send them back out into deep space so quickly, since they've gotten quite good at problem solving, there's probably a morale benefit to having them around, and we don't want to lose them so soon. I imagine had the show gone on, there'd have been some plot with them going back out. I also still have a lot of questions about the world around Earth. We only made first contact with the Klingons four years ago, so how was Harris able to make connections with a Klingon general that quickly, without another Warp 5 ship?
It's kind of like Dr. Soong earlier in the season, did he steal an alien ship? It begs the question of whether Starfleet has had access to alien ships with faster propulsion than ours, how spacefaring a race humans were, and how fast other ships were, since we saw the development of the Warp 2 engine only 10 years before the series. It feels like it's not quite built out, and unfortunately, we'll never really get an answer. But it's a great episode in a great, vastly underrated pair of episodes with great continuity. Not quite as good as part one, since it's a little slower, but a lot of fun, and I give it a 9 out of 10. Next episode will be a personal favorite.
Written by Judith and Garfield Reeves-Stevens, directed by David Barrett. Rating: 9/10. Next up: "Bound."
1
352
"Affliction." Wow. The premise of this episode should be the silliest thing ever, and I remember hearing about it and thinking, that's going to be silly. Who would have thought it would result in some of the strongest episodes of the season? I know that's a provocative statement, and I've already given out a lot of 10 out of 10s this year, so you're all just going to have to measure for yourselves the difference between a 10.1 and a 10.5, the way you can tell the difference between Warp 5 and Warp 5.2.
It has character drama, as Trip leaves the ship for Columbia and Reed betrays Archer and ends up in the brig. It's fast paced and everyone has something to do. We get to see Starfleet security on Earth and Madame Chang's restaurant, Klingons behaving very Klingony, and some beautifully ridgeless Klingons, kind of like the original series, but much more gorgeous, since they had much better hair stylists. We also get the return of the augment DNA and embryos from earlier in the season, a reference to Brent Spiner's Dr. Soong, and a fantastic cliffhanger to boot.
I think I've discovered on this watch that Archer's real catchphrase is, do what you can. It's what he says whenever there's a problem he doesn't know how to solve and he trusts his people, T'Pol, Reed, Trip, and it basically means, do whatever it takes to fix this, I've got your back. Bakula is really strong in this episode, and the show is really dialed in to the digital cinematography by this point, with everything, including the visual effects, looking really crisp, from Columbia launching on its maiden voyage to Enterprise under strain at warp at the end.
All right, the crazy premise. At the very beginning, we see a very impressive CGI targ on a handheld shot in a Klingon laboratory, where Klingons, we assume scientists, inject a prisoner with something that causes him a lot of pain and makes his head ridges start to melt. If you're a long-term fan, you understand what's going on, because in the original series of the '60s, Klingons had no head ridges. They were simply swarthy-looking humanoids from another planet who spoke Klingonese.
Then in Star Trek: The Motion Picture, they got new makeup, which they maintained through the films, and of course Worf on The Next Generation, the uber Klingon, had it as well. The difference was never addressed in the show, since we all understood they had more money and wanted to do something cool, and they did. Until Deep Space Nine, when, as part of a joke, they go back in time to Station K-7 and "The Trouble with Tribbles," and the other characters are shocked to see what Klingons looked like in this period. They ask Worf, and he says, they are Klingons, and it is a long story.
If you talked to a Gen X fan, they never wanted to hear any more about it, except it actually created the problem Enterprise had to deal with. Had it never been addressed, had the DS9 characters simply understood those Klingons to be Klingons with no visual difference from Worf, since it's really a production difference the characters shouldn't be aware of, there'd be no issue. But DS9 established in universe that the characters can see the difference, without giving a reason. They didn't know there would be a prequel, but there was, and that left the producers in a real pickle when it came time to make "Broken Bow," which heavily features the Klingons.
Do you depict them as across the films, TNG, DS9, and Voyager, or as in the original series, which you might expect, since this is before it? Enterprise chose the recognizable film makeup, I assume because they felt it was the obvious choice, and in some ways it is. But it does leave you with the question, if they had head ridges before and after the original series, why not in the middle, and what happened to them? These two episodes answer that in detail, and while a lot of it is resolved in part two, in part one we learn the augment embryos were recovered by the Klingons at the colony where Enterprise destroyed the augment ship.
The existence of genetically enhanced human soldiers was so troubling to them that they decided to do it themselves, using the augment genome to create super Klingon soldiers, but because the DNA was human, it gives them a more human appearance, and it all went wrong. After all, Cold Station 12 is Wuhan. It merged with a Klingon virus and is now killing huge portions of the Klingon Empire, and they desperately need a cure. The only person aside from Dr. Soong, who's too heavily guarded, with any experience in this is our friend, Dr. Phlox.
So when Enterprise returns to Earth, both to see the launch of Columbia and to facilitate Trip's transfer, Phlox and Hoshi come out of Madame Chang's, which looks like a clever redress of the Paramount lot, are accosted by thugs, and Phlox is abducted. That leads to the Starfleet security scene, like a CSI episode. Hoshi's a witness but was semiconscious, so Archer suggests T'Pol use a mind meld to access Hoshi's memories. She rightfully says she's never done one and isn't trained, and he makes the most ridiculous claim that's also really awesome, that he can walk her through it, since having Surak in his head for four days left him with some knowledge.
Hell of a time to bring this up, Captain. You mean this whole time, you've had all these Vulcan memories informing your strategy? Cool, and what a cool thing for the future development of that character. He does guide T'Pol through the meld, which gets them some evidence, but he encourages her to lower her emotional resistance a little, which perhaps leads to what happens next, as she somehow shares a mind space with Trip, though neither knows it's real until Hoshi asks T'Pol if it's normal to have romantic dreams about Commander Tucker after a mind meld, because she never thought of him that way, and T'Pol freaks out.
Meanwhile, on Columbia, Trip is in a bad mood, doesn't like anybody, and is being mean. Seth MacFarlane's there, and apologies to all of you, because I missed his cameo in Season 3's "The Forgotten." What's funny is that Trip forgets as well. In both episodes, he's named Rivers, yet Trip acts like they didn't go to the Expanse together and Rivers has no deep space experience, which means Trip "merely" forgot Rivers, so in his head at the time that he doesn't remember the guy he was yelling at when he wasn't sleeping, and he yells at him again, because Trip does not like Seth MacFarlane. He thinks he's a bad engineer.
Captain Hernandez, Archer's lover, tells Trip to cool it and be nice to these people, and we get some insight from her into what life in Starfleet might have been like if you're not on the Warp 5 ship heading out into deep space. There's definitely some sort of comic book or expanded universe story around that we've still never gotten. We also meet Commander Kelby, played by Derek Magyar, the new chief engineer, who it's very obvious from the beginning nobody likes. Poor guy, I don't know why he took the job, and you'd think there's somebody out there they might like, but there doesn't seem to be.
Meanwhile, Reed is approached by a shady figure, Harris, played by Eric Pierpoint, who claims some hold over him from the past and gets him to sabotage Enterprise's mission to find Phlox. Enterprise finds the remains of the ship that took Phlox, destroyed with its crew killed, and its black box reveals sabotage. They're attacked by human-looking people in a Klingon Bird of Prey and take one prisoner, who turns out to be Klingon, their first hint something's going on. Archer and T'Pol discover Reed's betrayal, and Archer gives him a chance to come clean, but he doesn't.
Archer gives him the Fredo speech, throwing Reed's military background and family in his face, a family we've seen, accusing him of disloyalty and treason, and throws him in the brig too. It's wonderful conflict between them, with a maturity you don't often see, since Star Trek doesn't like to put conflict between its cast members, and they do it here in a really effective way. Glen Hambly from Letter Decks is at tactical with Reed in the brig, and Reed tells the Klingon prisoner, we both want the same thing, a cure, our first hint that Reed has been told something of what's going on.
At the end, pressure builds in the warp core because of a Klingon subroutine planted by the interlopers, and T'Pol says if they slow down, they'll die, so we're going to do Speed, the movie. The cliffhanger has Archer telling her, do what you can, as he stands in the turbolift, with no idea what they're going to do, while Reed begs to help and Archer ignores him. Meanwhile, Phlox has been taken to the Klingon colony to work with Dr. Antaak, played by John Schuck, who played the Klingon ambassador in The Voyage Home and The Undiscovered Country, and he's excellent here, with James Avery, Uncle Phil from The Fresh Prince of Bel-Air, as the Klingon general hailing them.
It builds a little on David A. Goodman's idea that not all Klingons are soldiers, as we saw a lawyer in "Judgment," and now we see a doctor, though there's still plenty of Klingon in him, a great pickup of that idea. There's a lot in this episode, and it's all pretty much fantastic, and I can't think of a single element that doesn't work. It's fast paced, nonstop, with a lot of energy and confidence in the performances, and it's great to come back to Earth. It absolutely shouldn't be fantastic. It should be a bad idea, it should be silly, and it's not. If you think this is a bad episode, it's because you haven't watched it. 10 out of 10, on to part two.
Story by Manny Coto, teleplay by Mike Sussman, directed by Michael Grossman. Rating: 10/10. Next up: "Divergence."
1
1
382
"The Aenar." This is an odd one out as it relates to the three-episode structure, because in many ways the first two episodes play like a two-parter, with a really direct cliffhanger and plot lines that carry over, but their plot is largely resolved at the end of the previous installment, but for the little tease at the end. Perhaps someone reading this can comment on whether there was ever any thought of leaving it a two-parter. But they do continue the story, as the focus shifts to tracking down this marauder in the aftermath of the peace deal between the Tellarites and the Andorians.
The Romulans see this as a massive failure and a setback to their plans. T'Pol has been able to study the data Trip brought back and learns the drone is flown remotely by a highly telepathic pilot using telepresence, confirming what we saw in the tag, that the pilot is genetically similar to Andorians, though not identical. Shran, who stayed aboard to help, explains it comes from the Aenar, a highly telepathic Andorian subspecies living in the remote reaches of Andoria's poles.
So we go to Andoria for the first time in Star Trek history, and it's an ice world, the opposite of the Vulcan homeworld. Through some adventures underground that again have that pulp sci-fi vibe that's been sneaking into this season, they find the Aenar, and I love that they chose an advanced, very futuristic city under the ice rather than having them live in huts or caves. These are telepaths who will only read your mind with permission, and they're convinced of the crew's purpose.
We discover one of the Aenar has gone missing, the brother of Jhamel, played by Alexandra Lydon, who I recognized as Jane Saunders from the previous season of 24, and she agrees to go with them to find her brother. Meanwhile, the Romulans send two ships, having correctly surmised that it's Enterprise and the humans keeping the other groups together, and believing that if they can destroy Enterprise, they can split apart the alliance.
It culminates in an action climax as Trip and the crew build a telepresence unit in sickbay, with Ensign Walsh of Letter Decks helping set it up, and Jhamel uses it to commune with her brother and convince him to turn against his Romulan captors. They had told him the Aenar had been killed, the lie that motivated him to help them, and learning the truth foils the Romulans' plan. There's something interesting here about the culpability of drone pilots, given this was written at the very dawn of the drone era, before we fully understood the technology.
In a deleted scene, we see the Romulans involved arrested for their failure, a scene I imagine is still sort of canon, even though it isn't in the episode. Interestingly, none of this is really the heart of the episode. It's the first episode in quite a while to reference the events of Season 3 in some detail, and Connor Trinneer does a lot of heavy lifting. Trip talks about the fear he experienced stuck on the other ship, and while we saw him be quite heroic and willing to sacrifice himself, I don't know that we'd seen him despairing of life or of losing the relationships he's come to value. In fact, he told Malcolm there's nothing going on between him and T'Pol, but here he has to play that the experience has made him reevaluate his feelings, and I think he does so convincingly.
This has been bubbling under the surface for several episodes without it being clear what the show wants to do with the relationship, but here Trip clearly comes back feeling something very strong and isn't going to address it directly. He does reach out to T'Pol, saying he felt close to death and asking if she's ever felt that way, and she brings up the Season 3 finale and their efforts at Sphere 41. When he asks what she was thinking about, she gives a very logical answer about switching to auxiliary power.
It's obvious that what he's not saying is, I thought about you, and there's some discipline here, and good on André and Manny, the credited teleplay and story writers, for not making it too on the nose. We know what's going on, but he never comes out and says it. He does, however, speak to Phlox, in a great exchange where Phlox gives him a sort of, you just have to deal with these feelings, and Trip says, hey, you got me into this, you suggested Vulcan neuropressure, and Phlox says, you were having trouble sleeping. I'm not sure Dr. Phlox is being very fair to our boy Trip.
But it's nice to see them reflecting back on that plotline, which really is the basis of Trip and T'Pol's relationship, and the intimacy, not just sexual, that she has pulled back from since the trip to Vulcan in "Home," the marriage, and all that happened there. She invited him to her mother's house, an attempt to expand the relationship, and then as a result of everything, she's pulled back dramatically, and I think she's quite cruel to him here when she calls him out, saying, I think your feelings are affecting your work, which is not the thing to say in this moment.
Trip is very concerned about T'Pol when she attempts to use the telepresence unit herself, to her detriment, and we learn at the end she was right that Trip missed something in the unit, which Archer says wasn't ultimately dangerous, but still shocks Trip. He tells Archer his head wasn't on the work, and Archer doesn't press him until later in the scene, when Trip makes his big pronouncement that he'd like to transfer off Enterprise to Columbia. Archer asks why, Trip says, I told you, and Archer says, I haven't heard anything that explains this.
What Trip is saying is, I told you my mind wasn't on the work, and he believes Archer knows what's going on. Archer should know what's going on, because in "Observer Effect" he understands why T'Pol is asking about Trip, and yet here I think he willfully doesn't want to acknowledge it, and certainly not as a reason he might lose Trip, so he wants Trip to be explicit, and Trip refuses. I have no idea what Archer would have said if Trip had told him he can't get over his feelings for T'Pol and can't work with her, but I like to think Archer would have said, I understand.
Even as Bakula has flirted with showing a little possessiveness around T'Pol, and the writers have really leaned into her loyalty to him, I don't think we're dealing with a true love triangle. So I'm not quite sure why these two men couldn't have that conversation, except that, as I've observed before, Archer's relationships with his crew suffer over the last few seasons as he's burdened by command.
In this episode he makes a quick gamble that a ship they've detected, which looks like a freighter, is the Romulan ship, and orders full weapons. He's right, but it's the sort of decision he would have agonized over in Season 2. It's a real shame the show wasn't given the chance to bring this arc home, because it's a really interesting undercurrent, and we'll see more examples of Archer's estrangement from his crew going forward.
Thematically, the episode is really concerned with ideas of sacrifice, and while the first two episodes are much more about that Star Trek idea of putting aside our differences, and there's some of that here with the Aenar, it's almost more of a character episode. It's also Jeffrey Combs's last episode as Shran before the finale, and for my money, this is where Shran's story really ends, as the culmination of a story built over four seasons, and I'll address the finale when we get there.
Shran tells Archer he's probably not going to get another ship, and they may not see each other for a while, a great setup for why, as was rumored for the following season, he could join the crew, and having an Andorian aboard as they build this alliance could be a great thing. He beams off with Jhamel, who is clearly quite young and whom he befriends, and the finale will retcon that they have a relationship that produces a child. I think that's a little odd, since Talas died in the last episode, and while there's certainly some chemistry between Shran and Jhamel, it doesn't have to be romantic, and it isn't overtly romantic here.
A really wonderful script that shines in the character moments with Trip, T'Pol, Archer, and of course Shran, and it's a 10 out of 10, rounding out the final trilogy of Season 4 with a perfect score. We're heading into a two-parter that follows quite close on the heels of this episode, so in some ways it's almost like a five-parter, a mini run of consecutive episodes before we take the big break everyone's probably waiting for and dive into the mirror universe. We're very close to the end of the series, and I find myself wanting to slow down, but of course I can't. Thank you all for coming along on this ride, and come back tomorrow for more.
Story by Manny Coto, teleplay by André Bormanis, directed by Mike Vejar. Rating: 10/10. Next up: "Affliction."
285
"United." Any day we get to watch two Star Trek characters who are friends have to fight to the death is a good day. It's not a trope Enterprise has managed to do yet, but it has its traditions, really starting in "This Side of Paradise," when Kirk has to goad Spock into anger, which leads to a brawl, and taking its final form in "Amok Time," when Spock, possessed by the blood fever that comes with the Vulcan need to mate, is charged with killing his friend and captain.
Since then it's become a Star Trek trope in the best of ways, from "The Measure of a Man," when Riker has to prosecute Data, to DS9's "Soldiers of the Empire," when Worf challenges Martok. We pick up with Trip and Reed still trapped aboard the Romulan drone as it attacks a Rigelian scout ship while taking the appearance of Enterprise, and I love how Bakula delivers the line, "I'm told their trade commission is demanding compensation, and my arrest." Archer's becoming something of a wanted fugitive between the Klingons and now the Rigelians, and there's a whole dark file on him somewhere.
T'Pol and Mayweather come up with a plan quite similar to Picard's in TNG's "Redemption, Part II," but it requires 120-something ships, and Earth's are far too few, and too slow, so the only way to stop these attacks is for the Tellarites, Andorians, and Vulcans to work together. Unfortunately, Talas's wound, superficial last week, is now infected and filled with blue bile, and she begs Shran not to let her die unavenged. On Romulus, Senator Vrax berates Admiral Valdore and makes a fascinating claim, that the Vulcans will identify the ship as a modified warbird as soon as they examine the propulsion matrix.
That implies the Vulcans are aware of the Romulans at a military level. It doesn't necessarily contradict T'Pol identifying the Romulans by their language in Season 2, but by now one would think she'd volunteer anything she knew to Archer, so perhaps she has more secrets up her sleeve that she'd have revealed had the show continued. Perhaps those secrets could even serve as the basis for some estrangement from the future President Archer, should there ever be a sequel series, Star Trek: United, where T'Pol is not present in any apparent sense. That's just a thought.
We know the Vulcans and Romulans are related, as the Romulans say here, but in "Balance of Terror," the average Federation citizen doesn't seem to know, which seems quite obviously the result of a conspiracy of silence, the reality perhaps being so dangerous to the nascent Federation that it was hidden. That's supposition, and I'm not the first to make it, but this episode really sets up that the Romulan War wasn't humans fighting a mysterious race they'd never heard of, but a war with a regional power related to another regional power, the Vulcans, a connection hidden from history.
Valdore is ordered to bring the ship home, and we get our first glimpse of the Remans, created for Star Trek: Nemesis in 2002, so these are the only two Star Trek properties they appear in. They're a wonderful design, quite scary, and Letter Decker John Jurgens plays one of them. It's a shame we didn't get to continue the Romulan story, taking advantage of all the props and costumes made for Nemesis. Meanwhile, the Vulcans can only send 23 ships, because with the High Command disbanded, they don't have the crews to man what had been a vast military fleet.
This would be the beginning of why, by Kirk and Spock's time, there seems to be no Vulcan fleet or military, and why Federation starships follow Earth designs, not Vulcan ones. T'Pol asks how you expect Andorians and Tellarites to work together, and Archer points out they all have relations with us, so Enterprise can be the command ship, the beginning of why Earth's Starfleet would lead the Federation's. Archer also teases that the Romulans might come back with thousands of those ships, which I believe they do in the Jendresen script, and who's to say what role they would've played in the Romulan War?
Got to give real props to the Tellarite makeup, which I don't think has ever looked better, with wonderful articulation of the face and eyes, and the same is true of the Andorian antennae, which only in this series move by remote control, since modern Andorians have static antennae, which isn't as dramatically powerful. And I have to praise the Romulan production design, since the drone's bridge is obviously the same set as the control room on Romulus, which makes sense for a remote replica, but the architecture and the bird of prey emblazoned on the wall are really quite something.
Shran begrudgingly allows Archer to act as go-between, and I love his line, "You're not especially difficult to work with, Captain... You understand ethics and try to live by them," a sweeping condemnation of almost everyone else he knows. In a wonderful moment for fans, Shran examines the Enterprises on Archer's wall, and when Archer explains they all bore the name, Shran says his ship is named after an Andorian vessel too, and maybe one day someone will name ships after them, establishing what we've known all along, that this show only makes sense if Kirk's Enterprise is named after this one.
Then Talas dies, and Shran spills her blood on the Tellarite's hand, demanding the Andorian tradition of combat or the Andorians withdraw from the fleet. Thematically, it makes the point that we don't have to require our allies to share our culture or even our values, as long as we can find a way to all get along. In a really heartwarming moment, Archer reads the rules and substitutes himself for the Tellarite, and Shran admits he's Archer's friend. It's touching, but it doesn't dissuade him, and they're on a clock, as the Romulans intend to destroy their own drone ship.
We get another joke from T'Pol, as she walks in on Archer and asks, updating your will? Nobody calls it out, which is a missed opportunity. Archer explains the funny math, that if he withdraws, or if Shran dies, the Andorians will withdraw, and if the Tellarite fights and dies, the Tellarites will withdraw, so Archer's the only one who can be killed, because Starfleet won't withdraw. T'Pol has Travis and Hoshi look for a loophole in the code of the Ushaan, and spoiler alert, they find one.
I love the fight, the use of the cargo bay's standing sets, and the creative weapons. Credit to David Livingston for directing, especially the fight, and to stunt coordinator Vince Deadrick Jr. and the stunt team, as the opening shot, with everyone talking into the camera and showing the weapons, panning over to Archer, is so wonderfully staged. Just go watch it. Our good friend Glen Hambly of Letter Decks stands by as one of the Andorian seconds, and there's a great run of trash talk I often use in nerdy situations, like, "I'll take your blood to Andoria, to the Wall of Heroes." Archer wins by slicing off one of Shran's antennae, and the alliance is secure.
As the climax races on, Trip and Malcolm have to jump out of the drone into the vacuum of space, and Enterprise beams them aboard as the Romulan ship escapes. The penultimate scene is a favorite, as Gral says we have more to discuss than trade disputes and extends his hand to Shran, and Archer asks, why wait for the council chambers on Babel, a location we've still not visited in Star Trek? A beautiful visual effects shot pulls out from the conference room to the mixed fleet flying together, the beginning of the Federation. But one last spoiler shows the pilot of the Romulan ship isn't Romulan, but Andorian.
It's another very strong middle chapter, building on the previous hour with surprises, great character work, and action on both a galactic and personal level. Story is credited to showrunner Manny Coto, and you can see his excitement for setting up the Federation in a really practical way. All the cast get great moments, from Phlox with Talas and Archer, to Hoshi decoding the Ushaan, to T'Pol's doubts and the news from T'Pau on Vulcan. It's got all the energy of a show in its prime, and the next run holds together pretty strongly. This episode gets 10 out of 10.
Story by Manny Coto, teleplay by Judith and Garfield Reeves-Stevens, directed by David Livingston. Rating: 10/10. Next up: "The Aenar."
341
"Babel One." This episode is what people think about when they think about the fourth season of Enterprise, and about where the series could have gone after the cancellation. I got to read Erik Jendresen's script for Star Trek: The Beginning, a film developed at Paramount around 2005 to be produced after this series ended, and it draws heavily on this episode and the ones that follow.
This episode begins to explicitly codify things Star Trek fans had merely assumed or inferred about the Federation and its origins. It's an homage to both "Journey to Babel" and "Balance of Terror" from the original series, and it's doing a lot, with everyone at their best. Enterprise has been assigned to escort a Tellarite delegation to a summit with the Andorians, clearly Earth growing into its role as a mediator, since its role in the Vulcan and Andorian conflict has bought it some cachet.
Unfortunately, an Andorian ship captained by Shran has been attacked and sent a distress call, and Shran claims he was attacked by a Tellarite ship, so now Enterprise has two groups aboard that don't like each other. It reminds me of TNG's "Lonely Among Us," with the snake people and the rat people who don't like each other either, written by D.C. Fontana, who also wrote "Journey to Babel," a fun little homage. There's a great scene where Archer plays mediator between the Tellarites and the Andorians and can't keep them from fighting, but Archer also seems a little biased, since he sits and drinks with Shran, and he doesn't sit and drink with the Tellarites.
Archer is forced to investigate, and they're attacked by what appears to be an Andorian ship, even though Shran tries to call it off. It turns out it's not an Andorian ship at all, and when they beam a team over, Trip and Reed are stranded aboard in a firefight. With Hoshi's help, T'Pol determines the ship has holographic emitters that let it appear as any ship it wants, and weapons that can be reconfigured to mimic different species, so it's clearly been attacking the Andorians as the Tellarites and vice versa.
We're given a little insight before the characters figure it out, but T'Pol runs the power signature against their records and we get a callback to Season 2's "Minefield," revealing this may be a Romulan vessel. Archer surmises the Romulans may be threatened by a regional alliance between the Andorians and the Tellarites, and we of course know from the Vulcan arc that the Romulans played a large role in the conflict between the Vulcans and the Andorians. This drone holoship also begins to explain how it might be possible, as established in "Balance of Terror," for humans to have fought a war with the Romulans without ever seeing them.
We see the crew of Romulans behind this ship, with Brian Thompson, a great sci-fi actor who was in The Terminator, played a great Klingon in TNG's "A Matter of Honor" when Riker goes aboard a Klingon ship in an exchange program, and of course played the alien bounty hunter on The X-Files. He's excellent as Admiral Valdore, in charge of this holographic ship program, and Letter Decker Glen Hambly is the masked pilot flying the ship through some sort of interface. Glen also plays one of Shran's Andorians, recovering in sickbay and later in the corridor firefight.
Enterprise is damaged and has to flee, stranding Trip and Reed aboard in their spacesuits with no atmosphere, so they have to source oxygen from within the ship and make their way to the bridge. With Reed over on the alien ship, tactical is effectively manned by Gen of Letter Decks. Meanwhile, Shran, not content to trust Archer, works with Talas, who we learn is not just his subordinate but his lover. He explains he had no choice but to be in a relationship with his subordinate, because she insisted, and Bakula gives a great understated delivery of, I hope you made the right choice. Clearly, Andorians don't have HR departments.
Talas attempts to distract a MACO with her sexuality, and the MACO puts up a good fight and doesn't fall for it, but she overpowers him, and they raid the Tellarite quarters. Archer intervenes, convinces Shran to back off, and explains what they've found, but unfortunately, the ambassador's aide grabs a weapon and shoots Talas. We're told she's fine in this episode, and in the next we learn she's not, and I'm not sure if that was decided further down in development or why the red herring, perhaps it was just better not to introduce that element here.
The cliffhanger comes as Trip and Reed reach the bridge of this enemy ship to find it empty, and we see the Romulans we've been watching are actually in a room, in a building, on Romulus, and we get that to be continued. The Romulus depiction is CG, clearly modeled on the city from Nemesis, which was itself a 3D reconstruction of the matte painting from "Unification," which saw Leonard Nimoy appear on TNG on Romulus. That matte painting had a great deal of charm while being quite flat, and the CG reconstructions never quite have the charm, but they're recognizable and realistic, and this one looks quite nice.
Fans complain that the Romulans are wearing their uniforms from Nemesis, but I never really had an issue with that. We only ever saw those uniforms in that one movie, and for all we know the Romulan military went back to a style from 200 years earlier for reasons we're unaware of, so it's not worth nitpicking. It's the same outfit Todd Stashwick wore in "Kir'Shara," and I think it's much nicer and more believable than the high-shoulder-pad TNG outfits, which I wouldn't want to see again, though I wouldn't mind a recreation of the original series Romulan outfits had the series continued.
We learn a lot about Tellarite culture, that insulting them is key to communicating with them. I'm not sure that lines up with the Tellarite we saw in Season 2, but he was a lower-level freighter captain, and these are statesmen and politicians, so it may be very different. Clearly there was a desire to make these Tellarites more like those in "Journey to Babel," which they certainly resemble in behavior, and it's fun, with Trip talking about how refreshing the Tellarites are and Archer leaning into it, basically telling them they smell and to get out of here.
We also learn T'Pol's divorce is final, and Trip seems to really regret getting involved with T'Pol. He tells Malcolm as much, and it's very grounded, with Reed expressing genuine concern for Trip and his feelings. These characters have gotten very comfortable in their own skin by this point. This is act one of three, with a lot yet to come, but it's already clear, as Archer tells T'Pol when discussing why the Romulans might not want a stable region, that these people all need to get along, or they won't be safe.
It's a great episode, co-written by Mike Sussman and André Bormanis, two of our writers who've been with the show the entire time, and there's an ease to it. I will say the Talas in her underwear scene is verging on the frat boy humor we haven't seen in a long time, but it's not so bad.
It's always fun to see Shran, and these episodes are really what people think of when they think of Shran. Before this he's not in the show that much and his role is usually limited, so when people talk about wanting Shran as a regular, these are the episodes they mean. I think part two is even more exciting, and we'll talk about that tomorrow. 10 out of 10 for "Babel One," a really excellent episode of Star Trek.
Written by Mike Sussman and André Bormanis, directed by David Straiton. Rating: 10/10. Next up: "United."
1
311
"Observer Effect." I always think of this episode whenever anyone criticizes Enterprise for not being authentic Star Trek, because it's a perfect example of Enterprise doing a classic Star Trek episode, maybe in a way only it could. And by golly, as I wondered how it would hit me this time, I broke into tears when T'Pol asks Archer to let her know if Commander Tucker regains consciousness, and he says, I'll let you know right away. The way the two actors play Archer's awareness of their relationship is really quite something.
This is Judith and Garfield Reeves-Stevens's second script for the show, and while their first largely centered on new characters, this one is focused on the crew. There are little anachronisms in the dialogue that don't show a full awareness of what we've all seen, and clear attempts to make characters more interesting that I don't necessarily have a problem with. Fans criticized Hoshi running a Molly's Game style poker game at Starfleet training, but it doesn't alter the character much, and for those who take issue with her hacking the door, I remind you, she hacked the Xindi weapon.
But the big objection most fans had when this aired, and remember, people may still have been skeptical of the season, with only two of the three-part arcs aired, was the use of the Organians from the original series' "Errand of Mercy." It isn't merely whether humans could have met them before, since there's no way to know, and humans obviously knew about the planet Organia. It's the behavior and language of these Organians, which bear no resemblance to the ones in the original series, and a lot of fans couldn't wrap their heads around that.
I'm not going to argue the point, because it's sort of irrelevant. Had the writers chosen a different name for the species and not made this a prequel, I think it would be ranked much higher, certainly among the standalone episodes of Enterprise, and I think it deserves that accolade. The premise is simple. It's an outbreak episode, and while "Singularity" comes close, I would argue it's the only actual outbreak episode in the series.
Two non-corporeal aliens in possession of Reed's and Travis's bodies jump between all of the main cast, and credit to the writing, and to director Mike Vejar and the cast for making it all land, because you always know which of the two each character is playing, and the performances are remarkably consistent. They'd also really figured out the lighting on the ship for the digital cameras by this point, and the photography is quite smooth and pleasant.
These aliens come to this place in space to observe how different species react to what we'd think of as a moral dilemma, doing the trolley problem live, until they find a species that passes their test and initiate first contact. This is some of the language people don't find compatible with the Organian story, but otherwise it makes total sense, since an advanced race that has evolved beyond the physical and how it interacts with subordinate races is an old sci-fi concept.
And of course, the situation is a disease. Trip and Hoshi have contracted a silicon-based virus, a bit of a callback to "The Devil in the Dark," where silicon-based life is still only a theory, and there's no cure. There's great character work, especially from Connor Trinneer and Linda Park as the infected, and the decon chamber has been redesigned, and for the first time in the show's history, they don't disrobe. Hoshi asks if they should use the gel, and Phlox says they don't know what it is yet, and that's the end of that.
It quickly becomes clear this is a deadly disease the human immune system can't fight, and the aliens fill us in that they've seen species like Klingons and Cardassians deal with this by killing their infected crew, while the more benevolent one and the colder one argue over whether humans are any different. When Phlox catches on, they reveal they can wipe memories, since they feel their existence shouldn't affect anything and they're just observing, hence the title.
Hoshi, as her mind goes, hacks the decon security and exposes herself to the ship, which leads them to sedate the two patients. Phlox thinks radiation can cure it, but they have to move them to sickbay in EV suits, and Hoshi goes into cardiac arrest, with great cutaways to T'Pol watching from the bridge. In sickbay, Phlox can't handle the adrenaline needle with gloves on, and Archer says, no, I'll be your hands, Enterprise needs a doctor right now more than it needs a captain. That moment gets me, and the Organians say they've never seen that before.
Hoshi dies, and the cure doesn't work on Trip. Phlox sends Archer to the bridge, where he tells T'Pol he hopes she stays in command and doesn't let Admiral Gardner put someone over her, which is naive, Captain, because there's no way in hell Starfleet lets a Vulcan stay in command of the flagship, but it's a nice sentiment. That's when she asks about Tucker, a really beautiful moment between the actors. After the call, Trip passes away, his vital signs drop out, and then his body sits up as the benevolent Organian.
Archer does something that's a twist on what Kirk might do. When Kirk is confronted by gods, and there are many, Landru, Apollo, as late as Star Trek V, he tends to fight them, and kill them if he can. Archer begs God, and accuses God of being less than human, lacking empathy and able to observe suffering without intervening. It's the classical atheist critique, the problem of suffering, and I find the way Bakula plays it quite moving.
He prevails on one of them, who cures them and saves everybody, which is the definition of a deus ex machina, and perhaps softens some of the emotional impact. The Organians also seem to have cured Trip's five o'clock shadow, because when we see him in sickbay afterward, he's clean shaven again. As I look at it now, I'm not sure about the implication that there's something uniquely altruistic about humans. Klingons and Cardassians have violent cultures, but I think the Illyrians Archer stranded in the Expanse would have been compassionate.
In this series, what makes humans a catalyst for growth and peace is more a quirk of circumstance and serendipity than an essential quality of the species. I think the idea is that humans are capable of great acts of care and compassion, and when they choose to do so, it's something very special and perhaps divine. At a fable level, that works very well, though tonally the episode may not quite get it across, and I see why people were put off by it. I still don't think that's fair, and it's worth a rewatch, since you probably haven't seen it in 20 years.
This may be my first time since COVID, and having gone through a medical crisis like that gives you a different perspective. It's one of only three truly standalone episodes this season, with "Daedalus" and "Bound," and like the standalones of the original Battlestar Galactica, you can feel the reduced budget. I'd wager this episode and the previous one were written a bit as backstops, both bottle shows, to save a little money and give the producers time to change course if the arc strategy didn't work.
Some years ago, the Skirball Center held a showcase of Star Trek, and Enterprise was the only series at the time that wasn't showcased. Had I been able to suggest one episode for its theme of Star Trek's history and impact, I think this would have been an excellent choice. Well written, well directed, and well acted, it's a philosophical episode in some of the best traditions of Star Trek, and I give it an 8 out of 10.
Written by Judith and Garfield Reeves-Stevens, directed by Mike Vejar. Rating: 8/10. Next up: "Babel One."
249
"Daedalus." Another episode that plays a little better than I remember on rewatch, though it's considered one of the weaker episodes of this season. A lot is borrowed from the original series, as the backstory for Emory Erickson, the inventor of the transporter, played by Bill Cobbs, is very similar to Dr. Richard Daystrom's, having found success young and lived in its shadow, in a way that does feel a little derivative.
But there's also a lot mined from the relationship between the Archers and Erickson, since Jonathan Archer's father was a warp specialist, along with some interesting implications about the culture and history of Starfleet, even in this pre-warp 5 period. The episode is really a ghost story, and contrivances of the plot let them dim the lights in an area of pure blackness with no stars. After the blowouts of the last few episodes, you can perhaps feel an attempt to save a little money, with very few shots on the full bridge or with the full cast, many regulars seen in only one or two scenes, and a ship that feels very empty for no real plot reason.
The core drama is interesting. Emory is ostensibly testing a new long-range transporter he says will put starships out of business, and ironically, JJ Abrams would invent a similar transporter in his Star Trek movies that equally called into question the use of starships. But Erickson reveals this was a ruse, such technology is impossible, and he's actually here to rescue his son, the victim of a transporter accident in this region of space 15 years ago, who he believes still exists in some way and can be beamed back.
This coincides with the appearance of an apparition, a "ghost," as it were, which kills a crewman and badly injures T'Pol's hand. It appears to be made of deadly radiation, somewhat reminiscent of the spatial anomalies from Season 3. Trip in particular is very angry about being lied to by Erickson and about the death of the crewman, and thinks they should abandon the search. He accuses Archer of letting his personal feelings drive this rescue, and Archer threatens him with insubordination, part of an ongoing plotline of Archer pulling away from his friendliness with the crew into a sterner role as captain.
It also provides some mild thrills as a bit of a horror episode, and it's well directed, with some great walk-and-talks through the sets. But again, it falls into that category of not really knowing who to root for, the technology and science of it all are a little hard to track, and when at the end we rescue the son only to watch him die, it just feels very sad and unclear what exactly we're meant to take away from it. There are some great performances by the guest actors, though, and the show shows it can still do standalone episodes.
There's a great little subplot where we learn T'Pol has been reading the Kir'Shara, and that it has led to something of a religious revival on Vulcan, an overnight change. As I thought about it, this isn't historically unprecedented, with the Great Awakening in American history and the Reformation in Europe. A change in the perception and understanding of a core belief can quickly lead to social change, and Vulcan appears to be undergoing that, certainly as it relates to things like Pa'nar Syndrome, which Phlox confirms she's cured of, and mind melding.
Again, we're not quite privy to what exactly is different in these teachings, and I think the episode gets a little cute with it when Trip basically says she's spending all her time reading her Bible, which feels a little dated at this point. There's a scene where she tells Trip she has new priorities and won't have any time, and it's like a breakup scene, except, unless I've missed the implication, nothing's been going on with them for quite some time, and we're told it's only been a week since Vulcan, so T'Pol was married until a week ago.
It feels like an attempt to forestall the evolution of a relationship without any clear sense of what the characters want, but fortunately, I know where this plot is going, and they were able to course correct. The actors are lovely in these scenes, it's very nice to see them together, and it's always nice to see Trip pining for T'Pol, and T'Pol reacting when Trip doesn't chase her the way she wants.
It's a weaker episode, and it feels like they'd run out of some money. But I do like the idea of a Black man being the inventor of the transporter, in the tradition of Daystrom, which was groundbreaking in the 1960s, and having us meet that character, a completely unexplored area of the Star Trek canon that hasn't really been explored since. It's an interesting footnote in the history.
Written by Ken LaZebnik and Alan Brennert, directed by David Straiton. Rating: 5/10. Next up: "Observer Effect."
87
"Kir'Shara." That episode just blew by as I watched it. It's a really epic and exciting conclusion to the trilogy, and while a lot of information has been building up over the last few episodes, everything simplifies out here pretty effectively. Archer, T'Pau, and T'Pol are together with a plan to get the Kir'Shara to the Vulcan capital on foot. At the beginning, we see footage that's ostensibly an Andorian test of a Xindi weapon, but if you're paying attention, you'll recognize it from Season 3's "Proving Ground," when Archer foiled the Andorians' attempt to steal it, so we know they don't have this technology.
It's a nice little reference back, and the start of the episode's Iraq parallels. For those who need a history lesson, after 9/11 the United States took a very aggressive posture against not only those who committed the attack, but also, in my view, other nations geopolitically opposed to US hegemony, including an "axis of evil," described by then President Bush in his 2002 State of the Union as Iraq, Iran, and North Korea.
This all grew out of the 1990s, when there was a malaise in certain circles due to the sense that we didn't know who the bad guys were, and that part of the American identity had been defined by opposing the Soviet Union. Star Trek VI handles this very well, dramatizing what happens when your enemies have to become your friends. Some embraced the era of peace, but not everyone, and to some, 9/11 justified their fear that there's always an enemy, thinking that certainly continues today. A campaign against the terrorist groups who brutally murdered thousands on 9/11 was logical, but it wasn't sufficient to their need.
I suspect that task was a little too easy. Terrorism on that scale wasn't so much rampant as the great powers were oblivious to the risks, and once they turned their attention to it, the threat was resolved fairly quickly. But there was a lot of fear in the country, and those who already had an outline of the nations they thought opposed American interests felt it was the perfect time to label them. Whether Bush himself was one of these people or was prevailed upon by them, I don't think anyone could really know. And the claim that a nation is pursuing weapons of mass destruction never accounts for how many nations already have them.
One could argue those weapons are what gives a "great nation" the ultimate deterrent against invasion, so it's not irrational for nations at odds with the US to pursue them. The implication is always that they'll use them on the US or an ally, but what's more likely is they would insist on concessions without having to fear the threat of American military force. Iraq was claimed to have or nearly have weapons of mass destruction, and over 20 years later, the stockpiles were never found. This episode, in the briefest of terms, summarizes that history, and it's quite effective, blunt, and critical.
Meanwhile, Trip and the crew are seeking out the Andorians, who helped us against the Xindi, and there's a great little scene with Reed questioning his decisions. It's one of the more professional exchanges we've ever seen these guys have, since they're typically pretty buddy-buddy, and it foreshadows what we'll come to expect from Starfleet crews. They got used to being out in the middle of nowhere, acting unilaterally on behalf of Earth, but now they're closer to home, and their decisions have different consequences. Trip feels strongly that they need to prevent this war, so he pursues this course.
V'Las learns about the Kir'Shara from his agents and dispatches a Vulcan commando squad led by Major Talok, played by Todd Stashwick, better known to Trek audiences now as Captain Shaw from Picard, here playing what we'll learn is a double agent for the Romulans. This leads to a series of great action scenes in the Forge, where electronics don't work, so the commandos use lirpas, the weapons we saw in "Amok Time," likely large ceremonial versions, while these seem lighter and more portable. I'm usually a critic of sci-fi leaning too heavily on swordplay, but Star Trek has a great tradition of spectacular alien weapons, like the bat'leth, that make these fights feel different.
Talok accuses T'Pol of being involved with the Syrrannites who blew up the embassy, but as a double agent, he was probably involved in the bombing somehow, so he has to know the truth. So why is he trying to deceive her? I feel like the decision to make him a double agent may have been a last-minute change, though I have nothing to back that up. It's conceivable the character is playing a long game, and if we take him at face value that he served with T'Pol on a previous mission, then this Romulan infiltration goes back extensively.
We get great moments between T'Pau and T'Pol, who discuss Pa'nar Syndrome, the disease T'Pol has suffered from since Season 2. T'Pau reveals it's curable, caused by people mind melding who don't know what they're doing, and the High Command has suppressed knowledge of the cure, so she mind melds with T'Pol, both to cure her condition and to help her experience something of her mother. And I loved when Archer uses the Vulcan neck pinch on Talok, and T'Pau says to him, "Your technique has improved."
Meanwhile, in space, Soval and Trip try to persuade Shran their warnings of an imminent attack aren't some sort of ruse, and Shran resorts to abducting and torturing Soval, with help from Letter Decker Glen Hambly, to make him crack. This leads to a great exchange about the meaning of the name Narak in the Vulcan language, and some great trash talking from Soval, which Shran takes very well. He ultimately comes around, believes them, and takes the Andorian fleet to meet the Vulcan fleet, with Enterprise getting in the middle.
T'Pol is captured, so Archer and T'Pau go on alone into the Vulcan city, where they interrupt the attack by showing the Kir'Shara to the Vulcan ministers. Archer looks like he smells when he comes into that council chamber. When V'Las attempts to destroy the Kir'Shara, Minister Kuvak, played by John Rubinstein, who's been expressing skepticism all along, has had enough, stuns V'Las, essentially executes a coup d'état, and orders the attack on Andoria stopped, saving Enterprise.
Soval and T'Pau are now part of the new government, with a plan to take a less militant approach toward Earth and dissolve the High Command, which Archer welcomes. The same priest who married T'Pol takes the katra from Archer. He's Jack Donner, who played a Romulan commander in the original series. We won't hold that against him, but they need a younger priest, lest we have the same problem all over again. Archer can do the Vulcan salute now, feels more centered, and says he'll take up meditation, which T'Pol glibly remarks would be beneficial.
While it ends on a high note, we discover at the very end that Major Talok is actually Romulan, working with V'Las, and that their ultimate plans are still in motion. It's a huge reveal, aided by a weird discontinuity in Romulan makeup, since TNG added head ridges that don't really make sense but let you distinguish them. Talok didn't have ridges earlier, so we have to assume cosmetic surgery, and why he undid it is unclear. It's a really engaging twist that makes this a 2,000-year, almost holy war between two factions of Vulcan history still fighting for dominance.
Mike Sussman gets in a lot of references, most notably Mount Seleya, which T'Pol uses as a diversion, the lirpas, and Talok's mentions of T'Pol's past in the High Command's military. It's a really strong, really optimistic action episode where the good guys win, and it sets up a lot of material. This is another 10 out of 10, so this arc gets a perfect score. It's amazing how far the show has come and what they're able to achieve consistently, week over week.
Written by Mike Sussman, directed by David Livingston. Rating: 10/10. Next up: "Daedalus."
213
"Awakening." We roll right into this episode with two parallel plot lines. Ambassador Soval has lost his job and has come aboard Enterprise to advise the crew as they search for Archer and T'Pol on the surface, because he knows the High Command is going to attack the Syrrannites, and they want to get Archer and T'Pol out before it's too late. Meanwhile, Archer and T'Pol meet T'Pau, who we spoke about last time, leading a group of Syrrannites that also includes T'Pol's mother.
A lot of philosophical ground is covered, the idea, of course, that the Vulcans must return to the teachings of Surak, without us ever being told much about what that means beyond rejecting violence and duplicity, and T'Pol in particular finds this group suspicious and calls them a violent cult. Archer, however, begins having visions following his mind meld with Arev, who we learn is actually Syrran, the founder of the Syrrannite sect, and T'Pau reveals Syrran was in possession of the katra of Surak.
The katra is a concept from Star Trek III: The Search for Spock, the Vulcan immortal soul that can be passed on in advance of death, and so Archer is having visions of Surak, played by Bruce Gray. In fact, he finds himself in a mind space set during the wars of 1,800 years ago, where we see nuclear explosions on the surface and Surak himself suffering from radiation sickness, but Surak says that out of the ashes his people found a new way, and that the Vulcans of our time are in danger of returning to the old ways of violence.
Administrator V'Las's intensity is ramping up in this episode, as he's bound and determined to wipe out the Syrrannites in a quite bloodthirsty way. It's another 9/11 reference when he says we don't sit by and do nothing when our people are attacked, and the reply, that no, you traverse vast wastelands based on false information, is a slight allusion to the Xindi, but more so to the invasion of Iraq, which was starting to clearly lack the WMDs that were its predicate. This arc will lean heavily on that history.
The critique of the performance is one thing, but it's interesting that the other Vulcans, while clearly uncomfortable, do nothing to stop him. He seems to have absolute power and be something of a dictator, with lines like our society rewards merit, and V'Las has shown a singular talent for governing, which smell of corruption, but if he is a dictator, why is he operating in the shadows? He often comes off as a black hat villain because of the way he's playing it, and it might be more believable if he appeared cold and logical enough for the other Vulcans to accept.
But T'Pol has criticisms of the Syrrannites as well, and T'Pau finds it unacceptable that Surak's katra is in a human, though T'Pol's mother insists Syrran chose Archer for a reason. They insist he undergo a ritual to give the katra to a Vulcan and threaten to do it by force, which deeply offends T'Pol and drives a wedge between her and her mother. Archer goes willingly, only to learn Surak wants the katra in a human because a human is neutral. Perhaps that implies even T'Pau's militance comes from the influence of the High Command and mainstream Vulcan culture.
So the mind meld fails, the katra remains with Archer, and he learns of the existence of an artifact called the Kir'Shara, which contains the original teachings of Surak and is nearby. Archer leads T'Pol and T'Pau on a quest to get it, a lot of Indiana Jones in this, as the High Command begins its attack on both Enterprise and the sanctuary. We actually see Trip get into the fight with the Vulcans that was foreshadowed back in Season 2's "Cease Fire," as they're outmatched by several Vulcan cruisers and have to withdraw, which allows V'Las to destroy the sanctuary without witnesses.
Hearing Admiral Gardner, whom we never meet in the prime universe, order the ship away, and the crew disregard it, is very different than if it were Admiral Forrest, so we're already getting dividends from the choice to kill him off in the previous episode. T'Pol's mother is mortally wounded, and it's a real tribute to Joanna Cassidy that in only two episodes, "Home" and this one, she leaves such an impression you read in a whole bunch of history. Her death scene with Jolene Blalock is quite moving, as Jolene is overwhelmed by emotion, regains her composure, but can't stop the tear rolling down her face.
The episode ends with Soval telling Trip the Vulcans are planning an attack on Andoria, believing the Andorians have Xindi weapon technology. He's skeptical, but knows an attack is imminent, and Trip sets course for Andoria. A lot of themes run through this episode, like oppressive governments scapegoating factions they find politically or culturally inconvenient through anti-terrorist mechanisms, and a setup for a preemptive strike, which is more a discussion for the next episode.
But there's also religious fundamentalism, as T'Pol's relationship with her mother has been impacted by her mother pursuing what could only be considered a more fundamentalist religion. There's no deity, but not all religions are deity based. It drives a wedge, because T'Pol cannot understand or relate to it. It's interesting that we know from later Star Trek that the Syrrannites are basically right, or at least that the Vulcans we see later are more peaceful and benevolent, and that this Reformation was necessary.
This is not necessarily a progressive idea, although one might suggest pacifism and nonviolence are progressive, and there are religions with peaceful teachings that yet embrace violence or ignore those aspects of their teachings. A critical idea I learned from John Barton's great book, A History of the Bible, is that the Bible did not create Judaism and Christianity, but Judaism and Christianity created the Bible. In other words, the sacred texts are products of the movements, not vice versa, which goes a long way to explaining the inconsistencies we see in religions and their adherents.
In Star Trek, the Vulcans are a people and a culture that grows and evolves, and the teachings of Surak, "the father of all we now hold true," as Spock greets him in "The Savage Curtain," were developed to let the Vulcans survive their passions, their violence, and their base nature. So they may be foundational and ancient to this group, but they weren't when they were created, and with their influence, it is possible that modern Vulcans will evolve into something completely new, rather than revert 2,000 years into some sort of ideal of religious purity.
We can never turn back the clock, whatever anyone may think, but it is possible to move forward embracing the wisdom of the past while acknowledging that our mistakes come out of the past too. We don't get to watch how exactly the Vulcans reintegrate these lost teachings into their culture, and it would be too easy to think of it as a whole group of people suddenly going new age with a new guru, and some people have done that, but those changes can be very superficial. That said, it's very moving, and very cool, that the episode makes Jonathan Archer, and humans, the catalyst that helps this great society find its footing again.
I want to turn back to Kara Zediker, who does an excellent job as T'Pau, with the slight intolerance for other cultures we see in the original episode, perhaps a little less refined. There's a twinkle in the original T'Pau's eyes when she deals with Kirk, and it's nice to think some of that comes from Archer, as this is assuredly the beginning of her association with him, as she works to reform the Vulcan government and oversee the alliance with Earth and the Federation, even if she turns down a seat on the Federation Council. Kara plays her warming up to Archer and T'Pol quite well.
The mind meld ritual scene is quite off-putting, a little bit disturbing, and I'm pretty sure she says plak tow multiple times, which, as I recall from "Amok Time," is the blood fever, so I want someone to translate her little ritual and why she's repeating blood fever over and over, but I could be mistranslating my Vulcan. I'm giving this a 10. They've really found their footing with this more serialized style of storytelling.
Written by André Bormanis, directed by Roxann Dawson. Rating: 10/10. Next up: "Kir'Shara."
156
"The Forge." One of the most important episodes of Enterprise, and a really significant moment in the history of the fictional Star Trek universe. It's our second visit to Vulcan this season, but where "Home" did its exteriors on blue screen, this time we get location work on Vulcan for the first time since Star Trek IV: The Voyage Home. As in that film, the sky is red, though in this era a sort of Martian red, as opposed to the blood red of the original series, based on work done for the 2001 Director's Edition of Star Trek: The Motion Picture.
Digital sky replacement was a relatively new technique, and the ability to simply select the sky and change its color without much cost was very exciting, so it's used extensively here, with exteriors shot in Simi Valley and the actors free to walk around without any compositing. It's a shame that, due to the logistics of filming in Canada, more recent depictions haven't kept this aesthetic practically. The JJ Abrams movies used Vasquez Rocks, Vulcan in The Voyage Home, but gave Vulcan a blue sky for reasons I'm not clear on, and depictions of Vulcan that were building toward consistency lost coherence.
We meet Administrator V'Las, head of the Vulcan High Command, played by Robert Foxworth, a great actor who'd been on Star Trek before as DS9's Admiral Leyton. At STLV this year, Mike Sussman noted the performance isn't what the writers intended, since he was written as a traditional Vulcan but plays it extremely emotionally. Perhaps the arc's twist, that he's a Romulan agent, informed it. Had the storyline continued, it could have been explained retroactively, maybe by revealing he's part Romulan, or that the Romulans have been drugging him, so I give it the benefit of the doubt, and it's still effective for the story.
This episode is really dense and excellent. It's written by Judith and Garfield Reeves-Stevens, their first script for the show, but they were prolific Star Trek novelists, which is how they were recruited, and they were masters of Star Trek lore. This episode attempts to reconcile past lore with Enterprise's in a way that is quite successful, because Enterprise's Vulcans, while dramatically effective, interesting, and logical in their own way, don't much resemble Sarek, and certainly not Spock, from the original series and The Next Generation.
It establishes that the government of Vulcan at this time is made up of people who are not strict adherents to the true teachings of Surak, the Vulcan patriarch who established their logical philosophy. It also has allusions to sci-fi classics like Dune, and yes, even the original Star Wars, as a desert science fiction tale of an early 20th-century variety, in a way that hadn't been seen on Star Trek since the original series, if at all. It's retro in that way, perhaps fitting for a prequel.
In a flashback 17 years ago, we see a Vulcan discovering some sort of artifact. In the present day, our good friend Admiral Forrest and Ambassador Soval are at the Earth Embassy on Vulcan, working toward joint Vulcan-human missions, when a bomb destroys part of the embassy and Admiral Forrest loses his life. While this might be too harsh, this is the first of what would become something of a Manny Coto trope, because he loves to kill beloved mentor figures, like President Palmer on 24 and a whole host of Jack Bauer's love interests.
That said, Forrest, while a great character, was a small part of the show, and moving forward, his loss means Archer's new superiors are less friendly to him and his interests, which is a source of dramatic tension. It also gives Archer a reason to be personally invested in the investigation. The Vulcans blame the Syrrannites, a sect we might call religious fundamentalists who claim to be the keepers of Surak's true teachings, with DNA evidence from someone called T'Pau.
Longtime fans know T'Pau from "Amok Time" as "all of Vulcan in one package," the only person ever to turn down a seat on the Federation Council, and Spock never mentioned his family was important enough that she would officiate his wedding. Here she's played by Kara Zediker, who I also got to meet at STLV this year, and she's also a dream. Her first question was whether Celia Lovsky's accent from "Amok Time" was a Vulcan accent, and she was told no, it was the actress's own accent, and she shouldn't use it.
Meanwhile, T'Pol's husband shows up with a gift from her mother, supposedly a family heirloom she's never seen before, and it turns out to be a secret map through the Forge, an ancient Vulcan desert possibly created by the atomic wars that preceded Vulcan's embrace of logic. She and Archer secretly travel this path, where technology doesn't work, which makes them invisible to sensors but leaves them without phase pistols, communicators, or tricorders, another way it feels a bit like an '80s fantasy movie.
Trip, Reed, and Phlox continue the investigation and prove, to their own satisfaction, that the bombing was a High Command false flag operation, but the High Command dismisses it, and Soval is to be punished for aiding the humans. He's the one who encouraged Archer to conduct his own investigation to honor Forrest's sacrifice, and he becomes Archer's ally for the first time. Between Forrest and Soval, the show is taking supporting characters who've been frozen in place and putting them in motion, and it's paying dividends.
On the surface, we see a sehlat, another original series reference, and get great humor from the Reeves-Stevenses, with T'Pol saying she was never late with her sehlat's dinner as a child. Archer tries to be the manly man, only to discover T'Pol has an inner eyelid, a reference to "Operation: Annihilate!," and doesn't need water the way he does, while he needs sunglasses and a hat and falls behind her running from a sandstorm. As McCoy says in "Amok Time," hot as Vulcan, now I know what that means.
They're saved by Arev, played by the great Michael Nouri, arguably the first of this type of Vulcan in the series, a Syrrannite devoted to logic who isn't aggressive or duplicitous and believes Vulcans should not lie. He tells us of the bombs falling 2,000 years ago and those who march beneath the raptor's wings, a wonderful allusion to the Romulans, long surmised to be a Vulcan offshoot. Here, they're an army that sounds a little like Nazism, defeated by Surak and forced to flee to found their own expansionist empire.
T'Pol's mother is a Syrrannite, hence the map, and Arev is taking them to her, but he's mortally injured in a sandstorm, and before he dies, he mind melds with Archer and says, in Vulcan, "remember." We were told the Syrrannites have Surak's katra, a reference to The Search for Spock and the immortal soul Spock transferred to McCoy in The Wrath of Khan. Suddenly Archer knows the desert and the secret entrance to the Syrrannite hideout, where they're ambushed in a scene that looks so much like Dune, as if the Fremen are surrounding them.
It's high drama and high tension, all questions and no answers, and it's a level up. Everything on Vulcan and in the caves is gorgeous and beautifully lit. They're still calibrating the lights on the ship sets, which were built back when they shot on film, but these digital cameras handle darkness so much better, with whole scenes lit practically and done quite dark, yet you can see everything. It excites me even now as a fan, with all the little nuggets and story points they drop, and the show does build on them going forward.
Written by Judith and Garfield Reeves-Stevens, directed by Michael Grossman. Rating: 10/10. Next up: "Awakening."
349
"The Augments." The third act of this Augments trilogy does something very clever in its cold open. It creates a double cliffhanger. In the first few seconds, Archer manages to solve the problem we ended the last episode on and protects everyone in the control room. But we learn he's now in danger from the pathogens, just as we go to credits. I've never been a big critic of the title sequence, but with the show at this level of intensity, the upbeat version of "Where My Heart Will Take Me" is a funny anachronism.
Archer's solution, I would argue, is the beginning of a trend in films that has always bothered me, although this is one of the more responsible depictions. The idea that someone could be jettisoned into space without protection, be retrieved, and survive. I don't think I have to tell you the films. Guardians of the Galaxy, The Last Jedi. They always come up with reasons the person could survive, but never tell you beforehand. They still want to use being jettisoned into space as peril, and then it's like, oh, kidding, which undercuts the whole point.
This one at least has him transported a split second after he hits vacuum, and he comes in covered in some sort of ice crystals. So I'm okay with it. It's visually exciting. It's just a pet peeve of mine. For Letter Deckers, Gen is at a station in that opening scene. Also, Star Trek jokes are back. The last two episodes were by writers new to the series, but this one is by series stalwart Mike Sussman, and you can tell. Archer asks if there's anything they can do to avoid showing up on Klingon sensors, and Trip quips, "I could paint a Bird of Prey on the hull." You're not getting that joke from anyone but the most hardcore Star Trek writers, and it is appreciated.
As a third act, it's a satisfying conclusion, though it doesn't introduce many new ideas, except a nature versus nurture debate. Oddly, Archer seems to come down on the side of nature, at least when it comes to augments. Through most of the episode, he seems to believe it's inevitable these people will be homicidal maniacs. Granted, the characters do nothing to dissuade him.
Malik comes up with a horrific plan to use the diseases they stole from the Cold Station 12/Wuhan lab against a Klingon colony, starting a war with the Klingons that would give them cover to escape Starfleet and Earth. Soong is incensed and dismisses it out of hand, which leads Malik to take over the ship and confine him. Persis, who, perhaps contrary to Archer's beliefs, seems to have true empathy and some sort of love for her father, aids in his escape, which she pays for with her life.
So I don't think the episode is necessarily taking Archer's side in the debate, nor Soong's. Maybe it's saying reality lies somewhere in between. Meanwhile, Trip and T'Pol are transitioning into some sort of will they, won't they. Trip is an old-fashioned kind of guy, so when T'Pol says something like she's still adjusting to her marriage, he doesn't see it as an opening. That's how you know he's a good man. He's still quite protective of her, and makes sure Soong doesn't get to make jokes about T'Pol.
Speaking of Soong, he comes back aboard Enterprise, back into the brig where he started, and convinces Archer to let him help. In their argument, Archer cites "superior ability breeds superior ambition," a line from "Space Seed," attributed here to a eugenics scientist later murdered by an augment. To Archer, this is proof of the nature hypothesis, and Spock arguably takes that position in "Space Seed." But it does beg the question, what would it take for an augment to be good? The episode doesn't really wrestle with that, and maybe it sets up future storytelling.
We also see a promotional stunt. Entertainment Tonight anchor Dayna Devon, credited as N.D. Engineer, and ET filmed a news item of her guest starring. She looks more like a model than a Starfleet engineer, but I won't begrudge them, given everything they were doing this season to get people to watch the show. It's no Melvin Belli in "And the Children Shall Lead," so we give it a pass.
The ending, with Malik attempting to launch his bioweapon at the Klingon colony of Qu'Vat, which is coming back later this season, plays out a bit like the end of The Wrath of Khan. It's not as egregious as Star Trek Into Darkness, but it's certainly an homage. There's a countdown to a weapon about to detonate, Enterprise foils it and disables the Klingon ship, and then there's a series of shots of Malik crawling across the bridge exactly as Ricardo Montalbán did in the film, ready to detonate the ship rather than the Genesis device.
Soong begs him not to, because the ship has all the embryos on it, and some of the augments may still be alive. Malik is hell-bent on death before dishonor. The problem with Malik as an antagonist is that he's not likable. He has no redeeming characteristics. Even Khan was charming, and Soong is a charming antagonist you can relate to. Malik is a traitor and a dirtbag. He kills his own girlfriend. The Xindi Commander Dolim at least had a little charm. And he was a reptilian.
So some of these ending beats feel a little rote, a bit like a horror movie, or an alternate what-if ending to The Wrath of Khan. Malik presumably beams off before the Klingon ship is destroyed and ambushes Archer and Soong in a hallway, and Archer blows a hole through his chest, presumably after the stun setting doesn't work. Does Archer have a thing against augments? I don't know. He seems a little remorseful.
In the end, Archer tells Soong they're saving all his research, and maybe one day it can be put to good use, which would indicate he might be softening on the idea that genetic engineering must always lead to a bad outcome. Soong, however, has adopted that position fully. They've flipped positions, which maybe reaffirms that reality is somewhere in between. The episode ends on a little joke, as Soong says he might switch over to cybernetic life. It'll take a generation or two, and we can assume his work leads to Lieutenant Commander Data, the character Spiner originated on The Next Generation and played for most of his life, as recently as 2023.
It's a very satisfying conclusion that proves the concept of the arcs works. This was the test balloon. If it had been a disaster, I don't know if they could have pivoted, but it certainly would have discouraged fans. But they were encouraged. A very entertaining three hours of Star Trek, and it set the stage for an even more popular arc. This episode gets an 8, which I think is a great score, because it gives the arc an average of 9 out of 10.
Written by Mike Sussman, directed by LeVar Burton. Rating: 8/10. Next up: "The Forge."
191
"Cold Station 12." In my memory, this was my favorite of the three. We'll see if it holds up. We open with a flashback of Soong raising his augment children in what looks to be a very pleasant environment. I don't understand why their clothes got so tattered. It's a small part of the episode, but props to the casting department for casting kids you instantly recognize as the adults we've already seen.
In the present day, Soong is already at odds with his children. He's determined to free the remaining embryos but doesn't want to take lives to do it, something Malik doesn't understand at all. Meanwhile, Enterprise finds an augment left behind on the colony, Smike, a reference to Nicholas Nickleby, as the episode points out. He seems rather easy to subdue for an augment. And back on the Klingon ship, Malik shows he's adept at lying, making his killing of Raakin seem like self-defense. We know it was not.
Soong hijacks a Denobulan freighter, as we learn the station is manned by Starfleet and Denobulans. We didn't necessarily think all Denobulans were doctors, but they're clearly a scientifically advanced race. It's also really fun to see Spiner as the antagonist, playing the dramatic roles Data never really got to. Data wasn't plotting and scheming and telling people to surrender and prepare to be boarded.
Dr. Jeremy Lucas, who we've heard about in "Dear Doctor" and "Doctor's Orders," is on the station, so Phlox asks to join the landing party. Fun note, Phlox uses the term landing party, as in the original Star Trek. Lucas is played by the great character actor Richard Riehle, who passed away this month. Our condolences go out to his family. He was in The Fugitive, Glory, and Office Space, appeared in TNG's "The Inner Light," and worked with Scott Bakula on Quantum Leap.
Archer befriends Smike, gives him a nice dinner, shows him a photo of his parents (fun Photoshop job there, everyone), and assures him he won't be treated harshly. Phlox and Archer have another great conversation about the Eugenics Wars. Archer recounts his father's illness and death, which genetic engineering might have prevented. Phlox says Soong is brilliant, a shame he had to be incarcerated. Archer says, he broke the law. That's why he was in prison, and that's why I'm going to put him back.
That is an incredibly telling line for Jonathan Archer, clearly an institutionalist who believes in the law and the rules, even when someone might have a point. Conservatism bleeding into Star Trek? Maybe Archer needs to learn a little empathy, or maybe it's this stalwartness that makes him a good leader. Stability requires stable enforcement of laws, but also laws that are just and fair. Star Trek has never been in favor of anarchy. It's these quiet moments that provide the most food for thought.
As we are on the verge of an AI revolution of sorts, Star Trek's warnings about genetic engineering might be pertinent. Anything that empowers a human being beyond what has been normalized has the potential to empower that human being to do great harm. In Star Trek, these beings grow up never knowing life without their abilities and invariably use them for their own self-interest. And society doesn't function if individuals only pursue their own self-interest. That's why the idea of the Übermensch is antithetical to Star Trek's values.
One could argue an enhanced human would possess enhanced moral reasoning and conscience. But nothing suggests those qualities are genetically inherent. They seem to require some instruction, even if only by example, and as depicted, the supermen never had an altruistic role model. Soong certainly isn't one. Perhaps scientists, whether they design enhanced humans or AI systems, must be so possessed of ego themselves that they can't be expected to set the example of, say, a priest, or even a fifth-grade teacher.
Lucas claims he doesn't know the vault code, and Soong seems to willfully believe him, I think because he doesn't want to torture him. Malik, of course, will have none of it. For these augments, everything is about the goal, and no rule or law should restrain them. They seem to have no concept of conscience, and I think they're a clear picture of the antisocial elements that live among us. This is why it's my favorite of the three. It has the most interesting issues.
Malik's truly dastardly plan is to put one of Lucas's colleagues in a test chamber and release a pathogen unless Lucas talks. Is one human worth all of our lives? It's a cold calculus you hear from those who want to justify killing people whose guilt has not been proven, whether on fishing boats in the Caribbean, in villages in the Middle East, or on the streets of the United States, standing in front of SUVs. If I had any criticism, it's that it's a little too obvious how evil these people are, when plenty of people in power make the same calculation, and we all go about our business.
Riehle gives a fantastic performance as Lucas refuses to break. Soong folds and tries to give the antidote, but Malik refuses, a harbinger of things to come. Archer gets a great line that should be quoted more. "Whenever a group of people starts believing they're better than everyone else, the results are always the same." Malik says they were defending their right to exist. I want you to think about that. Archer says they've already killed over 25 people. Their existence has a pretty high price.
25 people seems like a small number to me, after what I've seen over the last few years, from the COVID pandemic to the wars raging around the world, and that is very sad. Archer orders T'Pol to destroy the station, and she and Trip set out to do it without question, knowing it will kill Archer, Reed, and Phlox. I've been critical of these sorts of orders in certain sci-fi franchises, but this makes sense. It's a remote, secure biological facility with dangerous things that can't fall into the wrong hands.
It's a Wuhan-type lab, and maybe if Wuhan had a self-destruct, it could have saved us all a lot of grief. Then the augments' Klingon Bird of Prey chases Enterprise through an asteroid field. In 2004, this kind of dynamism was something you didn't even see in the Star Trek movies. Back on the station, Archer makes a break for it with Smike, and Bakula takes a good beating in this episode. Malik kills Smike, supposedly an act of mercy, and releases the pathogens, ending on a cliffhanger, with a musical cue I always loved, as Archer climbs through an access shaft to stop it.
I was right. This is my favorite of the three. This season reaches extremes that used to take this show many episodes to build up to, and it works. Maybe it's the structure. This is the Empire Strikes Back of the trilogy, dramatic without having to do the setup or the resolution. It'll be interesting to see how often I prefer the middle episode of these arcs. I've always felt that way about the Andorian arc. The Vulcan arc, I think the first one is the best. We'll see.
Written by Alan Brennert, directed by Mike Vejar. Rating: 10/10. Next up: S4E6, "The Augments."
239



















