If a used car salesman says if you walk away then dont ever come back to my dealership do you believe him? @GavinSBaker
Gavin Baker on memory LTAs: “You might blow up your entire business and your franchise by breaking an LTA. And that was never the case before”
Talking about memory makers moving buyers onto long-term agreements (LTAs), he works through the game theory of what happens to a buyer who walks away from one:
“Let’s just think about the game theory of breaking an LTA. So there’s four companies that matter at scale. There’s Amazon with their Trainiums, there’s Google with their TPUs, there’s AMD, and then there’s NVIDIA who’s much bigger than everybody else combined.”
“Let’s just say it’s 2027, it’s very important to realize memory is, the more memory you put with FLOP for a given unit of compute, the more tokens you get out. It’s the single most important thing you could do to increase kind of token output per unit of compute. And then that obviously definitionally actually lowers costs, which is why the demand hasn’t responded at all negatively. There’s been no elasticity just because it’s kind of the only, it’s the axis that is dominating all others. And this is at some level, a giant Game of Thrones or emperors between these companies.”
“And okay, it’s 2027 or '28, you’re vaguely tempted to break one of these LTAs, try and get a lower price. But to a large degree, market shares are, I think for the next several years, are going to be determined by supply chain allocations and what you have pre-purchased. So if you break the LTA and you, and this is assuming we’re not in a severe oversupply situation, the game theory even holds in a severe oversupply situation. If you break your LTA, and then in the next two or three years, for any reason, leverage shifts back to the memory guys, you’re out of business. It’s over.”
“Let’s just say Google breaks an LTA. There’s an oversupply. I’m making this up, in '28, '29. They break their LTAs. Well, if they’re breaking their LTAs, it probably means, your oversupply, prices are coming down, and then, capacity naturally contracts. Well, what do you think is going to happen to Google’s allocations? And then, this is a cyclical industry, and oversupply is followed by undersupply. What do you think they think is going to happen to their allocations next time?”
“So I just think given that this is the axis around which kind of everything is revolving, man, you might blow up your entire business and your franchise by breaking an LTA. And that was never the case before.”
2
796
Black Shiba Munger retweeted
People forget that NVIDIA, as recently as 2018–2020, was basically a cyclical gaming GPU company whose growth was juiced by crypto mining.
The business was so exposed to speculative crypto demand that NVIDIA literally got fined by the SEC for failing to disclose how much of its gaming growth came from miners.
We somehow pretend like this thing has always been the stalwart backbone of tech economy or some shit.
Reduced risk of open-ended compute spending by Chinese players if US further tightens chip exports
Tencent bulls, isn't this exactly what you wanted?
Dont let a good affair go to waste (or 3 affairs)
475
If Jensen is irreplaceable then Nvidia is not worth $4T.
I disagree, Jensen Huang is practically irreplaceable from $NVDA.
And it's like if you took out Elon from $TSLA, the valuation and confidence in the company would collapse.
The foresight to bet on CUDA before AI took off, build the Neocloud ecosystem...
The move to secure critical supply chain capacity years ahead of demand, and sell rack-scale systems (with CPUs, networking, etc).
Turn the ASIC threat into another opportunity by investing in $MRVL, MediaTek, to compete against $AVGO. Bringing them all into Nvidia's NVLink ecosystem...
Is absolutely insane foresight. Jensen practically architected both the financial and industrial ecosystem surrounding the current AI trade.
Jensen took Nvidia from a startup to a $5T+ company, and the fact he managed to keep growing that with projected FY2028 70% constrained forward growth... at these levels.
Is equally as absurd.
I normally don't post negative things about companies... but even if you don't see material revenue or roadmap changes in the next 2 years.
Ousting the face of the AI trade and a technology visionary might spell disaster for Nvidia long term.
2
484
$SE
3Q results
What are they hiding in "Other Services" (expenses up 86% YoY on flat sales wtf?) Sea Cloud? How come no one asked at the call?
Shopee GMV deceleration, Adj EBITDA/GMV flat, I thought we were supposed to grow + monetize at the same time? When 2-3%??
Monee NPL ratio uptick, credit provisioning accelerating vs. loan book growth, but but but trust the AI underwriting?
Are there still any bulls left?
GENDA is up 20% today. Any bulls/bears here?
On 2Q earnings, I didn't think it was that strong although low expectations + stronger SSSG of domestic arcades (maybe management hinting share repurchases helped too).
Longer term, Japanese IP popularity remains the biggest tailwind. But can also point to issues including management turnover, aggressive accounting, increasing debt, lower M&A discipline (?) etc.
1
2
1,412
Black Shiba Munger retweeted
Most interesting tech opportunity in China?
18%Cloud/software
40%Humanoid/factory
20%Robotaxi/autonomy
22%Chips/compute
60 votes • Final results Black Shiba Munger retweeted
Buy the top 1 or 2 industry leaders and hold for 10 years
35%Spirits
10%Beer
55%Tobacco
71 votes • Final resultsWhere would you like to travel for your next vacation?
56%Japan
20%China
12%South Korea
11%Other Asia
64 votes • Final results 989
Most interesting tech opportunity in China?
18%Cloud/software
40%Humanoid/factory
20%Robotaxi/autonomy
22%Chips/compute
60 votes • Final resultsBuy the top 1 or 2 industry leaders and hold for 10 years
35%Spirits
10%Beer
55%Tobacco
71 votes • Final results Black Shiba Munger retweeted
Ugh.
I'm doing it. I'm jumping on the substack bandwagon.
I simply have too many Japanese ideas. I certainly can't buy all of them. And just tweeting them out feels like a waste. So I'm gonna grift you 10 bucks a month for it.
I also have a slightly different spin on things.
Good insights on Nexon (3659) 👇
Replying to @EAS000010
Dungeon Fighter's success is remarkable. It's done $22 billion in lifetime sales and still broadly growing. I did enjoy Mahoney's presentations/speaking events, but his ability to make good decisions were not nearly as good as his ability to tell a good story.
Not to get into the weeds too much, but Nexon's acquisition of Big Huge (Dominations) and Pixelberry (Choices) have been pretty bad, but given sizes involved not disasterous. Mahoney has pushed western growth hard, but it's basically non existent today. Had they avoided all western investment they would have done better. Even today, they should just divest give up on the Western market. Maybe MapleStory global could be profitable and it could be run out of Korea.
Arc Raiders has a shot in the West. The Finals / First Descendant were decent attempts, but I don't think they're going to turn a profit.
2
1,572
Black Shiba Munger retweeted
What does this mean for Air Water? Bullish
Air Liquide to buy South Korea's DIG Airgas for $3.3bn (=20x EBITDA).
reuters.com/business/energy/….















