TheShiningWire (@ShiningWire) profile picture
Joined February 2023
Photo by TheShiningWire (@ShiningWire)Photo by TheShiningWire (@ShiningWire)Photo by TheShiningWire (@ShiningWire)Photo by TheShiningWire (@ShiningWire)Photo by TheShiningWire (@ShiningWire)Photo by TheShiningWire (@ShiningWire)Photo by TheShiningWire (@ShiningWire)Photo by TheShiningWire (@ShiningWire)Photo by TheShiningWire (@ShiningWire)Photo by TheShiningWire (@ShiningWire)
TheShiningWire retweeted
Lucy, you have just produced a lesson in accidental self-sabotage. You are desperately trying to frame the UK-wide concern over youth economic inactivity as an “abhorrent” media narrative, claiming that only a “tiny proportion” of young people actually receive these benefits. But then you published the actual data, which completely destroys your own argument. According to your own article, 5.11% of all 16-to-24-year-olds in Scotland are claiming Adult Disability Payment (ADP). That is more than 1 in 20 young people sitting on a disability benefit at the very dawn of their working lives. That is a massive socioeconomic crisis, not a statistical rounding error to be thrown away. It gets even worse for the SNP when you scroll down to your Universal Credit chart. Your own data proves that 4.27% of 16-to-24-year-olds in Scotland claim the health element of UC, compared to just 3.42% in England. You have published proof that Scotland has a significantly higher rate of young people trapped on health-related Universal Credit than England, yet your only takeaway is to attack the media for talking about it. The only thing “abhorrent” here is a nationalist paper trying to downplay a youth inactivity crisis just to protect the SNP’s 19-year record of failure in health and education.
2
11
18
463
TheShiningWire retweeted
Dave Doogan, the self-proclaimed “Aircraft Engineer” You have to love an SNP MP trying to score a Twitter hit by complaining about “taxpayer funded polling”. Dave, mate, are you entirely oblivious to your own party's record? Your SNP government went to the Supreme Court to fight for the right to keep their own taxpayer-funded polling secret. They used hundreds of thousands of pounds of public money trying to hide their internal polling on Scottish independence from the public. The audacity of an SNP politician pretending to be outraged about secret polling when his own party practically invented the genre is just astonishing. I wouldn't trust this “Aircraft Engineer” to build a paper plane if this is his level of political awareness.
🤔 Andy Burnham talking about his favourite pint? No bother. His favourite crisp? Easy. His taxpayer funded polling on Scottish independence? Top secret.
10
23
119
3,007
TheShiningWire retweeted
in scotland they think you're a high earner at £43k. the government and a lot of people genuinely think a £43k salary is “rich”. between £43k and £50k you pay 50% on every extra pound once you add national insurance. at £75k it's 45% income tax. and between £100k and £125k it's 69.5%. it's a socialist experiment, funded by the south. you cannot be serious, ambitious and try to thrive in a place like that. but hey, enjoy your free paracetamol i guess.
If you're a high earner in Scotland wanting to put £100 of petrol in your car: You need to earn £200, since the gov takes: 48% income tax (£96) 2% NI (£4) + your employer pays 15% NI (£30) On £100 of petrol, there's: 20% VAT (£16.67) fuel duty at 53.95p/litre (~£31.75) So you're really getting about £51.58 of petrol, whilst the government gets £178.42 Drive carefully now! 🚗 ⛽
28
55
3
741
64,657
TheShiningWire retweeted
Scotland seriously needs to question what devolution and Holyrood actually delivers for the money it consumes. After years of political theatre, constitutional obsession and endless blame-shifting and scandal, where is the meaningful improvement in people’s lives? Is this extra layer of governance delivering value, accountability and better outcomes, or has it become an expensive circus in its own right? Perhaps it’s time to stop treating devolution as untouchable and start asking whether it is actually working. Devolution should exist to serve Scotland, not to serve the political ambitions of unqualified grifters.
81
128
14
473
13,652
TheShiningWire retweeted
Replying to @ScotNational
Ah, yes, the SNP bravely defending the whisky industry from the evil clutches of Westminster. It is humorous that you are throwing a massive political tantrum over an inflation-matching 4.55% UK duty increase, while conveniently suffering from total amnesia about your own domestic policies. Did you suddenly forget that the SNP implemented Minimum Unit Pricing, explicitly designed to make alcohol artificially expensive in Scotland? Or that they spent years pushing for a draconian ban on all alcohol advertising, a move the whisky industry itself warned would devastate their global brand? You cant spend a decade financially penalising the alcohol sector in Holyrood, and then suddenly pretend to be their greatest champions just to score cheap constitutional points against Labour. The absolute hypocrisy of demanding Michael Marra “finds his voice” while your own party has spent years trying to gag the industry is hilarious.
3
17
2
72
845
TheShiningWire retweeted
After 25 years of devolution, what has Holyrood achieved that Westminster couldn't have done? Plenty of scandals, wasted money and constitutional obsession, but little evidence of transformational government. Many Scots are entitled to wonder if it's been worth it.
73
52
1
263
4,255
TheShiningWire retweeted
Replying to @larabirdsnp @theSNP
"Young people in Scotland deserve... ample opportunities — to earn, to save"? That is absolutely hilarious coming from an SNP politician. Who exactly has been in charge of Scottish income tax for the last decade? Your own government created a fiscal environment where anyone earning over £28,850 pays more tax than they would in the rest of the UK. You complain about this budget being a “cold, hard confirmation” that they aren't being “rewarded in return”, while your party actively penalises young professionals stepping into their careers with the highest tax burden in the country. It takes a staggering level of brass neck to cry about a UK budget hurting a young person's ability to save when your own Scottish Government is the one eagerly emptying their pockets the second they get a decent graduate job.
3
22
97
987
TheShiningWire retweeted
This is the official SNP account actively peddling the exact same orchestrated disinformation i caught Tom French and Dave Doogan pushing! You are claiming that “800,000 Scots will have higher gas bills” and blaming “Westminster control”, while deliberately hiding the fact that this change is caused by replacing regressive standing charges with unit prices! Anti-poverty charities have demanded this exact reform for years so that vulnerable households only pay for what they actually use. You are weaponising a progressive policy that helps the poorest families just to manufacture a fake constitutional grievance and beg people to “Pledge your support” for independence. It is absolutely shameless economic illiteracy from the SNP.
2
53
2
151
3,543
TheShiningWire retweeted
Replying to @ChrisMusson
The Scottish Government has spent the day claiming a “real terms cut of £650m” to excuse their own domestic fiscal incompetence. Now, independent experts at the Fraser of Allander Institute and SPICe have stepped in to confirm Westminster is actually delivering a “total of £600 million more in funding for the Scottish Budget between 2026-27 and 2029-30”. Yet, they are openly lying to the Scottish public by framing it as a cut to justify your own disastrous budget mismanagement.
3
53
3
141
2,432
TheShiningWire retweeted
I earn £100 grand a year. I have a detached house. 2 cars and my wife is a full time home maker. I can just about afford this. I probably couldn’t afford the house I own if I was buying for the first time today. My salary puts me in the top 5% of earners in the UK. Top 5% to have a similar standard of living to Homer Simpson. That is a disgrace. We have a flatter salary distribution than Soviet Russia and the highest taxes and borrowing costs we’ve seen in generations. Success is almost impossible because our tax system means hard work makes you a stressed out tax cow, not wealthy and certainly not free. We need something radical. Less state. More family. Less handouts. More reward for risk. Instead. Tomorrow, Labour will offer another batch of policies which will send one message to aspirational Brits: why bother.
I read a piece in the FT this week about the price of being middle class in Britain now and it said a couple earning £436,000 combined take home £216,000. That’s a crazy amount of tax, and it doesn't include VAT on purchases, council tax, stamp duty or other taxes (I think does include pension contributions). I can’t stop thinking about it.
532
1,116
119
13,534
1,570,103
TheShiningWire retweeted
You are absolutely right that independence would “transform mortgages and pensions”, Richard; it would transform them into financially crippled assets. As the SCG’s own 2026 currency report admits, a new Scottish Pound will act as a shock absorber via the exchange rate, meaning the forced conversion of pensions instantly devalues everyone's retirement savings. Furthermore, to halt the massive capital flight triggered by launching an unbacked currency with a 9% trade deficit, your central bank would be forced to set interest rates sky-high, immediately destroying everyone's mortgage payments. Touting this deliberate financial ruin as a positive transformation is absolute delusion.
6
43
2
166
3,835
TheShiningWire retweeted
Replying to @afneil
The sheer financial incompetence of the Scottish Government is staggering. While nationalists constantly moan about Westminster budgets, the SNP is wasting £27 million a year paying 800 public sector workers whose jobs no longer exist. Because of their dogmatic 'no redundancy' policy, one NHS Highland employee has literally collected a full taxpayer-funded salary for 17 years without doing a specific job. To make matters worse, multiple public bodies are now covering up the true scale of this waste by refusing to disclose the salaries. This is gross administrative negligence on an industrial scale.
8
36
224
7,769
TheShiningWire retweeted
Breaking news...... Storm Austen is predicated to stop more Boats in 24hrs than Labour have in 2 years…..
6
52
1
399
3,418
TheShiningWire retweeted
Replying to @LauraEWebsterr
Complaining about a hypothetical £1 trillion wealth fund while ignoring your own movement's fiscal blueprint is typical nationalist amnesia. That North Sea money wasn't “frittered away”; it was spent on the NHS, pensions, and a UK-wide welfare state that Scotland disproportionately benefits from. To build a Norwegian-style fund, a government has to run massive structural surpluses, which means enforcing brutal public spending cuts or severe tax hikes. Even more embarrassingly, the SNP's own 2014 White Paper relied on spending every single penny of projected North Sea revenue just to plug the structural deficit on day one. You cannot demand a £1 trillion savings account when your own foundational independence prospectus required burning the cash immediately just to keep the lights on.
2
7
1
73
1,222
TheShiningWire retweeted
Replying to @JohnSwinney
You are standing in a £350m factory whose entire business model relies on Scotland being part of the UK. Sumitomo didn’t invest in the Cromarty Firth to sell high-voltage subsea cables to an isolated Scottish domestic market of 5 million people; they invested to supply the massive GB-wide National Grid and build the undersea transmission links powering the entire British economy. Scotland is an attractive inward investment destination precisely because international manufacturers gain direct, frictionless access to the UK’s 67-million-person internal market without customs borders, trade tariffs, or currency risk. Claiming this investment somehow proves the case for breaking away from the very domestic market that justified building it is a breathtaking dishonesty John.
7
54
1
243
2,955
Replying to @BBCRadioScot
@BBCRadioScot Diabolical interview with Russell Findlay. Martin Geisller doing an impersonation of a wee angry bloke in the pub. Compared to the fawning, mealy mouthed kid gloves shown to SNP politicians this was terrible. I rarely listen to BBC Scotland and certainly won’t now
2
87
To Lloyd Quinlan who replied below and turned off replies. What a miserable little Nationalist coward you are.
5
TheShiningWire retweeted
Replying to @LauraEWebsterr
It is genuinely hilarious watching the editor of The National try to take the moral high ground on transport journalism. You want to know why the media is focusing on the backlash from “reactionary businessmen”? Because those businessmen own the buses, the depots, and the infrastructure. The SNP is about to plunge a government with a £5 billion structural deficit into a multi-million-pound legal war to seize control of a network they have no capacity to run. And pointing to “our own capital city” as a success story is embarrassing. Lothian Buses is run by the local council, completely untouched by Holyrood. Whenever the SNP actually takes “public control” of transport, we get the Ferguson Marine £400m black hole and a nationalised ScotRail crippled by slashed timetables and daily cancellations. Proclaiming to be doing real journalism by speaking to “actual BUS USERS” while deliberately ignoring your own party's catastrophic track record of managing public transport is why nobody outside the nationalist echo chamber takes your paper seriously😂.
4
14
1
80
1,751
😳 @JohnSwinney telling the Easdale brothers to “watch their language” rather neatly illustrates the very attitude they're complaining about. He's the @ScotGovFM of Scotland, not the nation's headmaster. His job is to answer criticism, not to expel people who express it in terms he finds disagreeable. I've experienced this culture myself. Challenge a policy, question a funding decision or expose an uncomfortable truth, and suddenly the conversation becomes about your tone, your language or your attitude. Anything, it seems, except the substance of what you've actually said. It's a remarkably convenient way of avoiding difficult questions while making the person asking them the problem. Democracy is not simply the right to vote every few years. It also requires the freedom to challenge those in power without fearing that your livelihood, funding, reputation or opportunities will suffer as a consequence. And that is where my criticism of the SNP goes considerably further than its apparent dislike of dissent. My concern, informed by my own experience, is that criticism can carry identifiable institutional consequences, while compliance and political conformity can bring equally identifiable advantages. That is a far more serious allegation than a government being thin-skinned, and it deserves proper scrutiny. The Easdales have the resources and public profile to challenge the government openly. Many smaller organisations, particularly those dependent on public funding, do not enjoy that luxury. For them, the perceived price of speaking out can be enough to ensure silence. A government doesn't have to ban criticism to discourage it. It merely has to create an environment in which people believe there is a price to pay for speaking their minds. So perhaps, rather than lecturing his critics about their manners, the First Minister might reflect on why people feel compelled to use such strong language in the first place. Democracy isn't a classroom, Mr Swinney. The electorate aren't your pupils, and disagreement isn't a disciplinary offence.
Scotland’s First Minister has told a bus company boss to watch his language after he branded him a dictator over plans to bring the country’s bus network under public control. i.stv.tv/4zDMZjI
91
265
21
1,086
33,745
TheShiningWire retweeted
I fixed the SNP Conference whiteboard for them...
14
58
1
261
9,110