
Economist. Assoc Prof IER, @Hitotsubashi_U. Political economy, economic development. @IIES_Sthlm alumni. 日本語: @ShuheiKitamuraJ
Joined September 2021
- Tweets56
- Following350
- Followers798
- Likes40
Pinned Tweet
🚨Hi #EconTwitter,🚨
I would like to introduce "World Historical Battles Database (WHBD)", which contains information on about 8,000 battles in world history from ancient times to the present day.
Thread (1/9)
Shuhei Kitamura retweeted
How has the Spanish economy performed over the very long run?
To answer, I use Leandro Prados de la Escosura’s (@LdelaEscosura) data on real GDP per capita from 1277 to 2024. I express Spain’s figure as a ratio to Britain’s, since Britain was the first economy to achieve modern economic growth, from around 1660, and has been the leader, or close to it, ever since.
Spain, within its present borders, was prosperous in the Late Middle Ages, well ahead of Britain, then a peripheral corner of Europe. The Black Death and its aftermath hit Spain harder, and by 1360, the two economies had converged.
That parity held until 1600, when Spain began a long decline, in absolute terms (on the eve of the French Revolution, it was barely above its 1600 level, after a deep slump in between) and in relative terms (Britain pulled steadily away). The standard explanations, the Habsburg wars, and the serial bankruptcies run into one problem. They can account for the poor performance between 1550 and 1650, but not for the stagnation between 1650 and 1789. 140 years of stagnation is far more than wars and debt under the Habsburgs can explain.
The series also shows that Spain did not benefit from its empire. That is a problem for every theory tying colonies to modern growth. At most, one can argue that colonies were a necessary condition for takeoff (I do not believe even that, but leave it for another day). One cannot argue that they were sufficient.
The period from 1789 to 1936 was no kinder. The economy grew a little, and Spain built a modern but unfinished liberal state. Yet it never closed the distance to Britain. It is hard not to read the period from 1789 to 1936 as a national failure and the Civil War as its final consequence.
The recent efforts of some historians to paint those years in brighter colors strike me as unfounded. Spain did not fail at modernization as badly as China, but it did not succeed. A deeply corrupt dynasty, closed and incompetent elites in Madrid, Barcelona, and Bilbao, and an economic policy built on intervention and protection (by 1920, Spain was the most protectionist economy in the Western world, so much for the friends of protection) together made the country a basket case.
A cruel civil war left Spain at its historical low, with just 31% of the British GDP per capita. The foreign visitors who arrived in the early 1950s found a poor, backward country.
Policy in the first twenty years of the dictatorship was awful. Autarky was not so much imposed by the Allies as chosen. Spain’s rulers, using their quasi-fascist Weltanschauung, believed growth would come from state intervention, closed markets, and unorthodox fiscal and monetary policy.
Then, in 1959, policy changed. Spain adopted a more orthodox fiscal and monetary policy and opened to foreign investment and trade. The results were spectacular. For forty years, Spain grew briskly and became the modern country it is today. By 2001, it had reached 77% of British GDP per head.
But the internal contradictions of two things eventually became binding: the growth model launched in 1959, and the political regime created by the 1978 constitution. By 2024, Spain had slipped back to 74% of British GDP per head. This is worse than it looks. Britain itself has done poorly over the past twenty years, and losing ground to a weak performer is a bad sign.
Spain stands at a crossroads, economic and political. The country’s foundations no longer work, but its political and business elites have failed to understand this fundamental reality. A good grasp of its economic history helps make sense of its present predicament.
Thank you @MarshallBBurke!
"Heat shocks make painters paint more brightly" was not on my climate impacts bingo card. Cool paper by @ShuheiKitamura. No wonder Dutch renaissance painting was so dark - it was freezing in the Netherlands in the 1600s... arxiv.org/pdf/2307.15540.pdf
Shuhei Kitamura retweeted
.@ShuheiKitamura @osaka_univ_e finds land redistribution from landlords to tenants in #Japan after WWII led #farmers to use lower-cost #agtech and less family labour, driving #emigration to urban areas
ow.ly/Rmn450LCwZJ #STEGWorkingPapers #EconTwitter @FCDOResearch
Hi #EconTwitter #PoliSciTwitter,
I wrote a paper on 🛸 and politics using data from the United States.
I found that UFO sightings affect electoral outcomes and the beliefs and behaviors of voters. 🧵(1/9)
These results indicate that UFO sightings lead voters to believe that UFOs are “unidentified threats” that warrant further defense enhancements and scientific research. UFOs seem to have no small impact on politics and public policy, although their true identity is unknown. (8/9)
Draft (preliminary and complete) available here: osf.io/tme8f (9/9)
9
Thanks to @PascaliLuigi and @joachim_voth for organizing such a great session. The first day was great and I am looking forward to the second day. Wish we could have met in person. Get well soon! :) #bseforum
events.bse.eu/live/files/372…
It's finally happening😎! "Towards Sustained Economic Growth" #bseforum (co-organized with @joachim_voth).Can't tell you how long I have been waiting for this. An in-person event, finally, with my favorite crowd in my Barcelona.. and then.. I got Covid🙄.
events.bse.eu/live/files/372…
Hi #EconTwitter, #PoliSciTwitter:
My colleagues and collaborators (incl. myself) have created this data platform for social scientists. This website contains links to a variety of data sources for conducting research in social sciences. Enjoy! :)
sites.google.com/view/osipp-…
I'm looking forward to our session on economic growth and structural transformation on Saturday (3:45-5:45 EST) hosted by @MelissaLDell. I'm presenting my work on land reform and structural transformation using historical data of Japan. #ASSA2022 aeaweb.org/conference/2022/p…
Wow. Thanks everyone! :)
The most popular #econtwitter content this week was this from @ShuheiKitamura:
3
Good morning from Japan. I woke up very surprised this morning because I didn't expect such a great response. Thank you all for your likes, retweets, comments, follows, etc. I'm very happy to know that so many people are interested in this kind of data.
Thread (1/4)
To this end, I would love to collaborate with historians, conflict researchers, economists, political scientists, computer scientist, etc. to further improve the dataset.
(3/4)
1
3











