Taliesin’s Map (J. Dolan) (@StructuralMyth1) header
Taliesin’s Map (J. Dolan) (@StructuralMyth1) profile picture

Narrative Researcher (MA, English) Comparative Mythologist https://nitter.gq/t.co/gm332p73cd Breoghanist Author of The Comparative Guide to Celtic Mythology:

Joined December 2020
Photo by Taliesin’s Map (J. Dolan) (@StructuralMyth1)Photo by Taliesin’s Map (J. Dolan) (@StructuralMyth1)Photo by Taliesin’s Map (J. Dolan) (@StructuralMyth1)Photo by Taliesin’s Map (J. Dolan) (@StructuralMyth1)Photo by Taliesin’s Map (J. Dolan) (@StructuralMyth1)Photo by Taliesin’s Map (J. Dolan) (@StructuralMyth1)Photo by Taliesin’s Map (J. Dolan) (@StructuralMyth1)Photo by Taliesin’s Map (J. Dolan) (@StructuralMyth1)Photo by Taliesin’s Map (J. Dolan) (@StructuralMyth1)Photo by Taliesin’s Map (J. Dolan) (@StructuralMyth1)
The updated Vedic influence on the Bible playlist m.youtube.com/playlist?list=… The waters parting and collapsing on greedy pursuing enemies is a characteristically Indian story The changeless fiery theophany speaking its 3 part mystical name is a characteristically Indian story
1
2
17
7,195
Replying to @Aesiric_Media
“Hard polytheism” is actually a more radical claim than that so you’re being coy to soft sell it while strawmanning “soft” polytheism. And I get that it’s more Wikipedia than you doing so, but it's not the definition you appear to use in debate.
1
6
90
Replying to @Aesiric_Media
No one ever claimed the ancients didn’t have polytheism. It’s that “hard” polytheism is a modern construct directly contradicted by the most ancient texts. You can’t make a post without an “aw shucks I’m too dumb for reading comprehension” strawman
1
17
192
What are the known traits of talking out of your ass when you don’t know a subject
4
48
as Zeus Agamemnon. This clears up the other things you were confused about.
4
57
You’re citing Dumezil’s arguments and calling them schizo. He is the one who said Achilles is an Indra type. See this Destiny of a Warrior screenshot. I’ve repeatedly said Achilles has Thunder and Ares type myths. D. also says Zeus is Mitra-type, while Agamemnon was worshiped
2
4
102
Since you won’t believe me or the biggest scholars in the world today, here is an AI summary so hopefully you can realize this is the basic reading, and then you’ll also have the basics.
5
62
You’re slamming your head against a brick wall here man. You are trying to force your preconception of hard polytheism onto a text that, on the plain and consensus scholarly reading, is describing one god becoming another god, over and over again.
2
5
96
an “actual thing” shared by the gods and nothing “vague.” Your translation is 100 years outdated. How do you explain away “you become Pusan through your journeys”? You’re arguing that becoming someone “through” something means not becoming them?
2
5
79
Here are the commentary by Jamison and the translation by Jamison and Brereton 2014. They say that Savitar “becomes” Mitra and also Pusan, as the hymn flatly states. The word dharmabhih does not mean “functions”: per the commentary, it has to mean “supports” or “laws” here,
1
5
79
They’re emphatically on the same side in this hymn, and in every case I’ve ever seen.
5
48
And Mitra is categorized as a deva in texts about the Deva-Asura conflict, so your explanation doesn’t make sense.
1
5
63
Ignorant babble. Has nothing to do with this passage and it says the reverse of what you're saying. SAVITAR is becoming Mitra and Pusan here. You're quoting a translation from 1866 and I'm quoting the most up to date scholarly translation from 2014 and yours still supports me.
2
6
92
I’ll have to see if I can balance that with maintaining the focus or not, but it’s a good thing to consider
3
32
Replying to @ArchonAvalon
Actually have been meaning to
1
4
36
And you are master over impulsion, just you alone, and you become Pusan through your journeys“. So this is a thorough mystical theology.
1
7
114
In case anyone thinks Agni becoming the gods is explained away by a messenger role, Savitar also becomes the other gods in an early hymn. 5.81.4-5: "Savitar… you become Mitra, o god, through your supports.
1
6
120
And Agni becoming the gods isn’t explained away by any role Savitar also becomes the other gods in an early hymn. 5.81.4-5: "Savitar… you become Mitra, o god, through your supports. And you are master over impulsion, just you alone, and you become Pusan through your journeys"
1
6
128