fry retweeted
The miners will not move until they have to. So, if you want Teranode to rule mainnet, build businesses and applications that generate transactions. They will be forced to move when transaction volume increases above wat SV Node can handle.
fry retweeted
BTC Has a New Problem. The Speculators Have Found Another Shiny Toy.
I suspect the current AI investment boom has considerably further to run. And that could be devastating for BTC.
Speculative capital follows excitement, expectations and the prospect of extraordinary returns.
For years, BTC enjoyed the luxury of being the fashionable destination for people chasing the next fortune.
Now AI offers a rather inconvenient alternative.
Companies building infrastructure, selling computational services, developing applications and generating actual revenue.
Of course, much of AI is also speculative nonsense. But at least there are businesses producing something.
BTC has a more fundamental problem.
What does it produce?
When investors can chase extraordinary returns in an industry developing commercially useful products, why continue financing an asset whose principal attraction is the expectation that someone else will pay more tomorrow?
Markets don't owe yesterday's fashionable speculation eternal loyalty.
The AI boom may eventually burst. But before it does, I suspect it will drain considerable speculative attention and capital away from BTC.
BTC doesn't need everyone to sell. It merely needs the next generation of buyers to find something more interesting.
And unfortunately for the HODL faithful, the world has discovered a new shiny object.
One that occasionally produces something besides another price chart.
fry retweeted
If you can't HODL $BTC, what is it good for?
Wall Street already turned 21 million into unlimited paper Bitcoin.
Bitcoin was supposed to be 21 million. Hard cap and no one can print more.
But they broke the scarcity.
Wall Street showed up with futures, perps, options, ETFs, prime brokerage, and wrapped BTC.
One real coin can now back six different paper claims at the same time!
Price is no longer set by people buying and holding real Bitcoin.
It is set by positioning, hedging, and liquidations in a derivatives shitcoin casino.
Same thing that already happened to gold, silver, and oil.
Once you can create unlimited paper claims against a scarce asset, the free market price discovery is gone.
They can manufacture supply, short the rallies, force the liquidations, and cover lower.
You can ignore it if you want.
But don’t pretend the 21 million thesis still works the same way once the paper market takes over.
Hold the real thing.
Self-custody.
Opt out of their scams 🧡
fry retweeted
#BSV führt Satoshis ursprüngliche Bitcoin-Vision konsequent weiter: Wolltest du Freiheit? #BitcoinSV
fry retweeted
New year. Lots to talk about.
Save the date: Community Town Hall, Thursday 14th January
2027 is going to be big for the BSV blockchain. Join us to hear how we’ve been supporting it, what’s still to come and how you can get more involved.
We’ll open up a space for your questions and share more on the agenda next month.
fry retweeted
An immutable, programmable record is only the beginning.
What I'm working towards is true digital scarcity.
Consider a digital item that Alice owns. Today, Alice can send it to Bob while retaining an identical, usable copy. That is copying, not transferring ownership.
I want a system where Alice transfers the digital item to Bob and Alice genuinely loses the ability to use it. Bob now controls it. No duplicate usable item remains with Alice.
Not an NFT pointing to something elsewhere. Actual digital scarcity, with enforceable transfer and exclusive control.
Now combine that with programmable transactions, contractual conditions, identity, property rights, micropayments and records that can be independently verified.
You can create digital goods that behave economically like physical property. Rights can be transferred, services metered, access controlled, and obligations recorded and enforced through technical and legal mechanisms.
That opens possibilities for software, media, intellectual property, digital assets, business processes and markets that cannot function properly when everything can be copied indefinitely.
And all of this requires massive scale and extremely low transaction costs.
The objective isn't another cryptocurrency to HODL. It's an economic infrastructure in which digital property, exchange and contractual performance become practical at global scale.
Recording history is one component.
Making digital scarcity economically real is the much bigger objective.
fry retweeted
I pity the BTC HODL cultists.
They have been taught that selling is betrayal, taking profits is weakness, and watching their wealth evaporate is somehow evidence of conviction.
An extraordinary investment philosophy: never realise a gain, never question the narrative, and applaud every loss as another buying opportunity.
One sincerely hopes they manage to get out before the end.
Unfortunately, a cult built around never selling has a rather obvious problem when everyone finally wants to leave.
There must still be someone willing to buy.
fry retweeted
The Real Bitcoin? And Why It’s Worth Discussing
Whichever way you look at it, this was an extraordinary gathering of people at Frybrook House on 5th November including Craig Wright @Dr_CSWright @CsTominaga , Neil Oliver @thecoastguy, Connor Murray, Kurt Wuckert Jnr., @kurtwuckertjr, Sir Toshi @SirToshiTV, The F-in Farmer @The_f_in_Farmer, Gavin Mehl @GavinMehl, and Gary Kealy @2sierra22.
Is BSV the real Bitcoin? Could it bring freedom to the people?
Personally, I think these are valid questions at this time and I'm not afraid to explore them.
Enjoy the edited highlights of this special day here: youtube.com/watch?v=qGgz1rIu…
Satoshi's Abandoned Bitcoin Forum Raised a New Mystery
An archived forum created by Satoshi Nakamoto recorded an admin login on June 17, 2014, nearly five years after it went quiet.
The board launched in November 2009, shortly after Bitcoin's $BTC creator published the whitepaper. It had only three members, including accounts linked to Nakamoto and early developer Martti Malmi.
A 2009 email shows Nakamoto handed Malmi the admin credentials. That makes the 2014 login impossible to attribute to either person with certainty.
Both had access, so the identity behind the 2014 login remains unknown.
The login has renewed speculation about Satoshi's possible activity years after disappearing from public view. However, it offers no proof that he returned.
Find more about Bitcoin: bsc.news/topics/bitcoin
fry retweeted
And Here's Why This Doesn't Matter in the Same Way for Real Bitcoin: BSV.
BTC has built its security narrative around hash rate, as though continually increasing computational expenditure were the ultimate measure of economic security.
It isn't.
Proof of work is one component of Bitcoin's security model. It establishes an ordering mechanism and makes competing histories costly. It does not, by itself, determine legal ownership, transaction validity or the economic consequences of attacking the network.
BSV's economic proposition is different.
The objective is a network supporting large-scale commercial transactions, where miners earn revenue by providing services rather than depending indefinitely on rising coin prices and block subsidies.
As the subsidy declines, transaction-fee revenue must become the foundation of mining economics.
A miner processing millions of economically valuable transactions has a business to protect. Attacking the network risks destroying customer relationships, future revenue and commercial investment.
That is the distinction between treating mining as a speculative race for block rewards and developing it as an industrial service.
Of course, BSV still uses proof of work. Hash power remains relevant to reorganisation resistance, and dormant ASIC capacity cannot simply be ignored.
But hash rate alone is not a complete measure of economic security.
The relevant questions are who provides the service, what revenue they earn, what assets and relationships they risk, and what an attack would actually cost.
BTC celebrates computational expenditure as though burning more electricity automatically creates more value.
BSV's intended model is to make transaction processing commercially valuable.
Security should emerge from sustainable economic incentives, not an endless competition to subsidise increasingly expensive hashing.
The difference is between paying for a lottery and operating a business.
fry retweeted
BSV Starts Mattering When People Finally Understand That It Is a Commodity.
One of the most ridiculous ideas to emerge from cryptocurrency is HODL.
Imagine applying that philosophy to an actual commodity market.
A natural gas trader buys gas before winter because demand is expected to increase. Prices reflect storage, transportation, supply constraints, weather forecasts and anticipated consumption.
When circumstances change, the trader sells.
When demand falls, inventories rise or forecasts change, prices adjust.
That's how commodity markets work.
Now imagine a natural gas trader announcing that he will never sell his gas because selling represents a betrayal of the gas community.
He doesn't care about demand. He doesn't care about storage costs. He doesn't care whether anyone needs the gas.
He simply believes that gas must always increase in price.
We would quite reasonably conclude that he has absolutely no understanding of commodity economics.
Yet cryptocurrency has managed to turn precisely this behaviour into an investment philosophy.
Commodities are acquired because they have uses. Their value emerges from demand, supply and the economics of consumption.
There are commodity speculators, certainly. There are inventories, hedging arrangements and long-term positions.
But none of these requires a religious commitment to never selling.
And this is where BSV needs to be understood differently.
BSV becomes economically relevant when people acquire it because they need to use the network.
Businesses purchase transaction capacity. Applications consume it. Service providers price their offerings. Miners compete to supply processing capacity.
Demand should arise from actual economic activity, not from convincing the next buyer that the price must rise forever.
There will be periods of higher demand and lower demand. There will be seasonal patterns, business cycles and changing transaction volumes.
Prices should respond accordingly.
The objective is not to make everyone hold BSV. It is to make BSV useful enough that people continually need to acquire and spend it.
That is a fundamentally different economic model from BTC.
BTC enthusiasts celebrate coins that never move.
A functioning commodity economy depends on exchange, production and consumption.
A commodity that nobody uses is not demonstrating extraordinary scarcity. It is demonstrating an absence of demand.
And an economy in which everyone refuses to sell eventually discovers that it has no market.
BSV will matter when people stop treating it as a lottery ticket and start treating it as an economic input.
Buy what you need. Use what you buy. Sell what you don't need.
Let supply and demand establish the price.
That is how commodity markets develop.
HODL is not an economic theory.
It is what happens when speculation replaces economics and nobody wants to admit that the entire business model depends on finding someone willing to pay more tomorrow.
fry retweeted
BTC: The Real Trouble Begins When the Miners Start Disappearing.
And $13,000 is not where I expect the story to end.
That is merely where the rollercoaster may stop for a while before the economics become considerably more unpleasant.
The real problem begins with mining.
Bitcoin miners don't operate on enthusiasm. They have electricity bills, equipment costs, financing obligations, depreciation and shareholders expecting returns.
As BTC prices decline, mining revenue falls. Less efficient operators become unprofitable. Equipment is switched off, businesses consolidate, and some miners disappear entirely.
The difficulty adjustment may keep blocks arriving, but it doesn't magically restore lost revenue or replace departing investment.
Then comes the halving.
Every four years, the block subsidy is cut in half. Unless transaction fees or BTC prices compensate, miners earn less for providing the same service.
And here's the delightful irony.
The mechanism celebrated as creating scarcity also progressively removes the financial incentive supporting the network.
Fewer profitable miners mean greater pressure towards consolidation, reduced aggregate security expenditure and increasing dependence on transaction fees that may never materialise at the required scale.
At $13,000, the economics would already be uncomfortable.
After another halving, they could become brutal.
That is where I see the possibility of BTC eventually falling below $1,000.
Not tomorrow. Not necessarily next year. This is a process that could take several years as declining prices, subsidy reductions and deteriorating mining economics reinforce one another.
Of course, the faithful will celebrate every miner shutting down as another wonderful demonstration of market efficiency.
Until they discover that a payment network requires someone to pay for its security.
Michael Saylor can buy the dip. Influencers can draw another rainbow chart. The exchanges can advertise another recovery.
But none of them can repeal the economics of mining.
My longer-term expectation is a period of stagnation around $13,000, followed by increasing mining pressure and the possibility of sub-$1,000 BTC over the following years.
The rollercoaster has already enjoyed its climb.
The next act is not simply about the price falling.
It's about the economics supporting the ride becoming progressively harder to sustain.
And unlike the passengers, the miners can actually get off.
fry retweeted
BTC: The Rollercoaster May Have a Final Resting Place. Around $13,000.
I suspect BTC won't simply collapse straight to zero. Markets rarely provide such convenient entertainment.
There is likely to be a holding point, and my expectation is that it will be somewhere around the previous four-year low of approximately $13,000.
Why?
Because speculative markets develop psychological anchors. Previous lows become reference points, bargain hunters emerge, and investors convince themselves that an asset must be cheap simply because it was once considerably more expensive.
At $13,000, I suspect BTC could stabilise for a year or longer.
There will be trading. There will be rallies. There will undoubtedly be influencers announcing that the next bull market has begun.
But here's the rather unpleasant economic problem.
Stability is not growth.
An asset that sits at $13,000 for a year produces no capital appreciation. Inflation continues eroding purchasing power. Investors incur opportunity costs, and speculative enthusiasm gradually loses its most important ingredient: rising prices.
BTC's greatest marketing achievement has always been persuading people that tomorrow's buyer will pay more than today's.
Remove that expectation and the economic proposition becomes considerably less attractive.
A prolonged period of stagnation could therefore be more damaging to BTC's speculative appeal than another spectacular crash.
The rollercoaster doesn't necessarily need to plunge directly into the ground.
It can simply stop.
The passengers sit there, waiting for another climb. The operators continue collecting fees. And the faithful insist that remaining stationary is actually bullish.
My prediction? A possible floor around $13,000, followed by prolonged stagnation, perhaps for a year or more.
Not an immediate disappearance. A slow erosion of the speculative investment case.
And that, economically, may be the more interesting route towards eventual failure.
After all, the worst thing that can happen to a rollercoaster isn't necessarily a crash.
It's discovering that nobody wants to buy another ticket.
fry retweeted
People don't all need to build infrastructure capable of handling one million transactions per second.
That's the entire point of specialised infrastructure, division of labour and economies of scale.
But if the network itself cannot sustain one million TPS when demand arrives, then every business depending on that capacity fails to scale with it.
Demand doesn't magically create throughput. Engineering capacity must precede demand, not follow a catastrophic bottleneck.
You don't build an economic system by hoping someone will fix its limitations when customers arrive.
A system that cannot handle the demand it promises is not scalable. It is a promise waiting to fail.
fry retweeted
BTC: The Greatest Rollercoaster in Financial History. 🎢
For years, the Bitcoin faithful have proudly described their investment as a rollercoaster.
And for once, they've managed to find an analogy that actually works.
You see, a rollercoaster begins at ground level, climbs to extraordinary heights, terrifies everyone aboard, and eventually returns to where it started.
The passengers scream. Some vomit. Others insist they're having the time of their lives.
And the people running the attraction collect the money.
Sound familiar?
BTC has already enjoyed the exciting part. The magnificent climb, the breathtaking summit, the wonderful moment when everyone believed gravity had been permanently abolished.
Now comes the descent.
Naturally, the enthusiasts are shouting, “Buy the dip!”
Rather charming. Imagine being halfway down a rollercoaster and insisting that the falling carriage represents an excellent opportunity to purchase a higher seat.
The difference, of course, is that a real rollercoaster has brakes, safety inspections and someone responsible for ensuring the passengers survive.
BTC has influencers.
The climb was speculation. The descent is economics.
And remember, ladies and gentlemen, the ride isn't over until we're back at zero.
Please keep your arms, legs and remaining savings inside the carriage.
The fun part is just beginning.
fry retweeted
And BTC, stripped of theatre, did not magically become a global financial system because several thousand men had shouted at one another online for a decade.
A system must work.
A payment network must process payments.
A commodity must have use.
A market must contain more than speculation, leverage, slogans, and people selling one another the privilege of being exit liquidity.
That was the lesson written across the wreckage.
Not in gold.
Not in orange.
In red.
The man with the cup sat beneath the cracked MicroStrategy sign, and the passersby avoided his eyes with the courtesy cities reserve for failed gods. Some pitied him. Some laughed. Some photographed him. Most simply walked past, having learned, at last, that attention is not capital and fame is not liquidity.
A young man stopped beside him.
He wore an orange cap. Of course he did.
“Was it worth it?” the young man asked.
The beggar looked up slowly. His eyes still had the old intensity, but now it had nowhere profitable to go.
“Worth it?” he said.
The young man nodded.
The beggar smiled, revealing the ruined architecture of a once-expensive confidence.
“My boy,” he said, “it was never about worth.”
And for one brief second, the old prophet returned. The cadence. The certainty. The magnificent fraud of absolute conviction.
“It was about price.”
Then he shook the cup.
Inside, one coin rattled.
Not BTC.
Not a satoshi.
Just a quarter.
Legal tender.
Backed, irritatingly enough, by the fact that someone still had to pay taxes.
The young man stared at it.
The beggar leaned closer and whispered the last great lesson of the Bitcoin empire:
“Liquidity, my dear boy, is what remains after belief has left the room.”
Then he looked back at the street, where the screen above the exchange office still flashed the final joke in red:
MARKET CLOSED FOR MAINTENANCE
Somewhere, a former influencer posted that the dip was temporary.
Somewhere, a fund marked its short book.
Somewhere, a believer explained that no one truly understood Bitcoin.
And somewhere far above them all, in the clean indifferent air where numbers have no mercy, the reckoning continued.
It had only just begun.
fry retweeted
코인마켓캡(CMC)의 #BSV 프로필 점수가 47%에서 87%가 됐다는 개빈 멜의 소식이다. 그가 10월 초부터 공개적으로 정정을 요구해 온 일이다. CMC 원본 데이터와 웹 아카이브 사본으로 대조해 보니 숫자는 맞다. 9월 21일 47.22%, 11월 19일 87.34%.
점수보다 흥미로운 건 그사이 소개글이 어떻게 바뀌었느냐다.
[빈칸이던 2,100만]
9월 21일 BSV 페이지의 최대 공급량 칸은 비어 있었다. 그런데 같은 페이지 소개글은 "원래 비트코인 프로토콜이 정한 대로 BSV는 최대 2,100만 개"라고 적고 있었다. 한 페이지가 두 가지 말을 한 셈이다.
개빈은 10월 3일(UTC) 공식 정정 요청서를 보낸다고 밝혔고, 10월 6일 글에 이렇게 썼다. "상한을 찾을 수 없으면, 나는 무제한일 수도 있다고 보고 넘어간다." 처음 보는 사람의 눈이다. 같은 글의 다른 문장은 이랬다. "사람은 프로토콜이 아니다. 인물 싸움은 데이터 정책이 아니다."
그가 10월 6일 아직 비어 있다고 쓴 칸은, 10월 13일 아카이브 사본에서 2,100만으로 채워져 있다.
[소개글의 첫 문장]
옛 소개글은 "BSV는 2018년 비트코인캐시(BCH) 블록체인의 하드포크로 생겨났다"로 시작했다.
새 소개글은 이렇게 시작한다. "BSV 블록체인은 확장 가능하고 안정적이며 기업용으로 준비된 데이터 네트워크를 제공하도록 설계된 공개 블록체인이다. 원래 비트코인 백서에 적힌 원칙, 곧 작업증명으로 지키는 개인 대 개인 전자 화폐 시스템을 따른다."
옛 글의 단서어도 사라졌다. BSV가 원래 비전을 실현한다고 "주장한다(claims)", 원래 프로토콜을 따른다는 "말이 있다(allegedly)" 같은 표현이다. "BSV의 창립자는 누구인가" 항목은 "누가 BSV 생태계를 유지하고 지원하나"로 바뀌었다. 옛 답에는 nChain, 크레이그 라이트 박사, 캘빈 에이어, BSV 협회가 있었고, 새 답에는 BSV 협회만 있다.
갈라져 나온 곳에서 시작하던 소개가, 따르는 문서에서 시작한다.
[숫자에 붙은 조건]
단서어가 빠진 자리에는 조건이 붙었다. 테라노드의 초당 100만 건에는 "이 시험 결과는 운영 네트워크의 지속 처리량을 나타내지 않는다"는 문장이 따라붙는다. 결제 한 건 약 0.000005달러라는 수수료에는 "1KB당 100사토시, BSV 가격 20달러일 때"라는 가정이 붙는다.
[먼저 짚을 것]
CMC는 프로필 점수를 "프로젝트가 CMC에 제공한 데이터의 완성도와 최신성"으로 정의한다. 새 소개글을 누가 썼는지는 페이지에 나오지 않는다. 어느 쪽이든 CMC가 BSV를 원래 비트코인으로 인정했다는 뜻은 아니다.
점수는 가격도 아니다. CMC 데이터로 BSV는 9월 21일 17.20달러, 11월 20일 14.76달러였다. BTC 페이지는 100%인데, 그 소개글에는 "2021년 현재(As of 2021)" 사토시의 정체는 알려지지 않았다는 문장이 아직 남아 있다. 점수는 칸이 채워졌는지를 잴 뿐이다.
[남은 목록, 확인해 보니]
개빈이 100%를 위해 정리한 제안 가운데 몇 개는 원본으로도 확인된다.
Whitepaper 버튼은 생겼지만 비트코인 백서 PDF가 아니라 BSV 개발 문서 사이트로 간다. 그도 백서 PDF 연결을 다음 과제로 꼽았다.
BSV 지원 지갑 칸의 Electrum은 공식 사이트 제목부터 "Electrum Bitcoin Wallet"이다.
CMC 지갑 목록에 있는 Trezor는 자사 지원 코인 목록에 BSV를 올려 두지 않았다. 지갑은 집계 사이트가 아니라 지갑 공식 사이트에서 확인하는 편이 안전하다.
[생각해보면..]
#BTC 페이지의 백서 버튼은 2008년 백서 PDF로 간다. BSV 페이지는 그 백서의 한 줄을 소개글 첫머리에 걸었다.
어느 쪽이 그 문장대로 돌아가는지는 백서 9쪽을 펴 보면 안다.
#Bitcoin #비트코인 #CoinMarketCap
BSV's CoinMarketCap profile score went from 47% on Oct 2 to 87% today. Max supply now shows 21M, the white paper is linked, and the description has been rewritten.
Thank you to everyone who worked on it. I wrote up the change requests that could get it to 100%:
gavinmehl.substack.com/p/bit…




















