Will (@WillHW) profile picture

Music & entertainment law at SGD

London
Joined May 2010
Photo by Will (@WillHW)Photo by Will (@WillHW)Photo by Will (@WillHW)Photo by Will (@WillHW)Photo by Will (@WillHW)Photo by Will (@WillHW)
“One day, when it’s safe, when there’s no personal downside to calling a thing what it is, when it’s too late to hold anyone accountable, everyone will have always been against this.” -- Omar El Akkad
446
4,852
99
17,869
558,517
The full report by the Tony Blair Institute is out, in which they detail how copyright should be "rebooted" in the AI age. It is - and I don't say this lightly - terrible. It reads like a cross between a big tech lobbying document and a funding proposal for a new academic centre no one wants (it literally includes this). I've pulled out some quotes from the report and added my thoughts below. I wish I had time to write a more in-depth rebuttal. But this should give you an idea of its contents. I encourage you to read the whole thing yourself. ⬇️📄⬇️ “The UK government has proposed a text and data mining exception with the possibility for rights holders to opt-out. This … [would give] rights holders increased control of how their data are used.” This is not true. Existing UK copyright law gives rights holders full control over how their works are used by UK AI companies. Moving to an opt-out model would inevitably mean that many rights holders would miss the chance to opt out or fail to opt out all their works. It could *only* reduce the amount of control rights holders have. “A lack of clarity harms all stakeholders. This includes creators, who are not properly remunerated for their labour”. There is no lack of clarity over the current law; and creators are only not remunerated for their labour if British AI companies break the law. “Today, the application of UK copyright law to the training of AI models remains contested.” This is not true. I have seen zero arguments that commercial gen AI training on copyrighted work without a licence is legal in the UK. Even AI companies understand it is currently illegal. “Currently, United Kingdom copyright law provides insufficient clarity for creators, rights holders, developers and consumer groups”. Same point, still not true. “The free flow of information has been a key principle of the open web since its inception.” Putting your content online does not entitle anyone to use it for whatever they like, for free. “To argue that commercial AI models cannot learn from open content on the web would be close to arguing that knowledge workers cannot profit from insights they get when reading the same content.” This is a classic big tech talking point, but it is incredibly misleading. That humans will learn from your work is assumed when you create; we do *not* assume commercial gen AI models will be trained on it. Moreover, commercial gen AI models scale in ways no individual human can. Commercial gen AI creates hyper-scalable competitors to creators by exploiting their work. “Generative AI is here to stay. Already, music generator Beatoven .ai has built a fully licensed generative music model, and KL3M has produced a “fairly trained” large language model (LLM).” Yes - both these companies are certified under the Fairly Trained certification scheme I run. Both vehemently object to unlicensed training; both prove that it is possible to build gen AI models without stealing people’s work. These are terrible examples if the authors are trying to argue that we must legalise IP theft. They show the opposite - that it is possible to build gen AI without the theft. “Photography and sampling are key examples of technologies that sparked debates about creative ownership but ultimately led to artistic renewal rather than extinction.” Yes, but cameras are not built by exploiting the work of the world’s creators, and music samples have to be licensed. These are not in any way comparable to building gen AI based on IP theft. “But, in general, copyright controls copying; it does not control other ways in which those engaging with the material might use its intellectual content.” Training AI models involves copying. It is hugely misleading to suggest otherwise. “Developers are not set to make long-term profits from publicly trained data [so AI companies shouldn’t have to pay for training data].” This is an incredibly surprising argument. Why would VCs be investing so many billions of dollars into this space if there were not long-term profits to be made? “It is hotly debated whether model weights should be thought of as a copy of the training data.” This is intentionally misleading. Many of the lawsuits simply claim that training involves copying, which is not disputed in the slightest. (As an aside, it is very odd that they quote the robots.txt page from my personal site, when I have publicly pointed out that this is Squarespace’s default robots.txt page which cannot be changed. I would hope the people writing this report understood robots.txt well enough to be aware of that.) “Generative AI may never be good enough to be a substitute for all human activities for which people get paid.” This is a straw man. The competitive effects of gen AI on the works it’s trained on, and the people behind those works, can be huge, without AI being a substitute for “all human activities for which people get paid”. “Generative AI will continue to improve but its greatest value is likely to be in augmenting existing workflows, as demonstrated by platforms such as Invoke AI.” This *totally* ignores the mounting evidence that generative AI competes with its training data. Every study so far reinforces this common-sense hypothesis, e.g. that the introduction of ChatGPT decreased demand for freelance writing tasks by 30%. THEIR PROPOSED SOLUTIONS “The UK government should establish the Centre for AI and the Creative Industries.” I have no particular issue with the idea of a new academic centre. But it is totally nonsensical to propose this as some kind of solution to the AI / copyright problem. It is orthogonal to the question at hand. Why would creators give up strong copyright protections, which they desperately want, for a new academic institute, which no one is asking for? This is an absolutely insane proposition, and I am genuinely shocked it made it into the report. (It’s also worth noting that an early draft of the report I saw suggested that an eye-popping £50M a year would be a good price tag for this centre.) They suggest “a targeted levy on ISPs” to remunerate creators for their work being used. To be clear, this is a tax on consumers (their words) - “pennies per month for a regular household”. Charging consumers for training data, rather than the AI companies that exploit it commercially, is perhaps the most brazen big-tech talking point of the entire report. And, even more astonishingly, they argue that “the priority of this revenue would be funding the Centre for AI and the Creative Industries.” They want to let AI companies pay nothing for training data; instead charge the general public; and not even give the new tax revenue to creators, but instead give it to an unwanted academic centre. -- This report reads like it was written by big tech, capped off by a truly astonishing set of proposals that would be punitive to both creators and the general public - everyone, that is, except the AI companies who want to exploit creators' life's work for free, to build AI models that compete with them. It's perhaps not surprising that the Tony Blair Institute would align so closely with big tech interests. We can only hope the government doesn't give this report the same weight as the protests of the country's creators. Full report in the next tweet.
10
83
13
269
28,406
Copyright & antitrust lawyers take note! 👇 Google released its new "AI Studio" -- and Google employees are throwing a pirate party on social media 🏴‍☠️ Google employees like @mentzer_f are *actively* encouraging the use of the tool as a copyright & trademark theft machine This not only proves Google *knows* Gemini will be used for infringing outputs -- but shows that Google's own marketing is *encouraging* this illegal use Since yesterday, this pirate party has become rampant across social media in many languages, with many different Google employees cheering it on Absolutely shameful behavior by Google!
Replying to @googlejapan
@googlejapan こんにちは。御社のサービスGoogle AI Studioで、堂々と著作権侵害をしている人がいます。これプロモーションとしてマイナスではないでしょうか。生成AIの最も好ましくない(嫌われる)使い方に思われます。広報てして、何かアナウンスが必要ではないでしょうか。nitter.gq/kenn/status/1900071004…
6
88
2
274
15,930
163
3,996
100
16,902
425,967
Happy Halloween 🎃
222
453
117
2,284
517,739
10% of @coldplay proceeds from these events will be donated to Music Venue Trust to support grassroots venues, artists and promoters. Thanks also to @SJMConcerts @MetropolisMusic @LiveNationUK @WME @wembleystadium who will be adding their donations to this incredible gesture.
25
112
69
532
106,800
As a billionaire is doing the first private spacewalk, I am reminded of this. Whitey's on the Moon by Gil Scott-Heron.
106
2,520
149
8,413
387,670
Nationalise Ticketmaster.
1,589
1,337
676
17,948
2,521,413
Isabel Oakeshott: St George's School: £11,000 per annum for primary Gordonstoun School (the one the literal king went to): £45,000 per annum
Replying to @mardybum17
I grew up in Scotland. I trained as a tabloid reporter in Glasgow. Don’t tell me what tough looks like.
20
288
15
2,296
126,631
BREAKING: All 3 major labels are suing AI music generators Suno & Udio. The RIAA is coordinating the lawsuits on behalf of Sony, Warner & UMG. Hammer, dropped. Here's the details: Today, two federal copyright infringement lawsuits were filed: 1. against Suno in the District of Massachusetts 2. against Udio in the Southern District of New York Why? It's been clear to anyone with ears that Suno & Udio have trained on copyrighted material for their AI models, with zero transparency, plan to compensate, or seek licenses. The RIAA calls it "mass infringement of copyrighted sound recordings copied and exploited without permission by two multi-million dollar music generation services. AI companies, like all other enterprises, must abide by the laws that protect human creativity and ingenuity. There is nothing that exempts AI companies from playing by the rules." And there ARE ways to do this & play by the rules: 1. Train only on licensed catalog 2. Compensate artists & songwriters 3. Full transparency It just takes a little longer & requires actually caring about creatives. Just last week JenAI dropped their fully licensed & transparent genAI model. And voice-cloning companies like VoiceSwap & SoundLabs are doing the same. Music isn't anti-AI. It's anti-theft. As the RIAA states: "The music community has embraced AI and we are already partnering and collaborating with responsible developers to build sustainable AI tools centered on human creativity that put artists and songwriters in charge." So, how does the RIAA know Suno & Udio use copyright materials? They cite 4 examples: 1. Suno's lead investor all but admitted it with this statement: "if Suno had deals with labels when this company got started, I probably wouldn't have invested in it. I think they needed to make this product without the constraints." (smart) 2. Udio execs said their AI was trained on "a larger amount of publicly-available and high quality music" that was "obtained from the internet" and was the "best quality music that's out there"... (I mean...come on) 3. They left producer tags on their output. 4. Users have generated obvious sound-a-likes. WHO WILL WIN? It all comes down to fair use. Either way, we'll finally have an answer on the legality of generative AI music training in the US. I hope it's an answer that protects artists & songwriters. We can do this in a way where more than 1 or 3 AI tech companies win.
54
161
78
491
83,629
I still can't get over how bad AI has become. And this is coming from a computer scientist who spent over a decade studying and programming AI. I fucking LOVE AI, but here are 10 reasons I absolutely fucking hate it now, a 🧵 ...
570
11,871
1,301
48,772
5,986,423
💰Artists are the biggest employers in the live music industry! Listen to Lily Fontaine, from @Englishteac_her, talk about some of the many costs paid for from artists' fees - frequently resulting in the artist making nothing. See our campaign asks below. #SupportingArtists
2
28
3
81
18,883
Nadhim Zahawi’s SLAPP has now resulted in disciplinary action for his lawyer. A thread on why it happened, and what it means - for the lawyer, for SLAPPS, and for Zahawi himself.
118
1,716
159
5,339
1,250,278
Unelected bureaucrat David Cameron explains how we need the Rwanda plan because of Brexit 🤦‍♂️ Anushka Asthana, "Hand on heart. If this had come up when you were PM, would you have gone with this Rwanda policy?" David Cameron, "We had a situation where you could return people directly to France.. People land on a beach in Kent, you take them straight back to France.. You therefore break the model of the people smugglers" Anushka Asthana, "Shouldn't you be trying to get that?" David Cameron, "That's not available at the moment" Anushka Asthana, "Because of Brexit?" David Cameron, "(Yes) Because of the situation we are in (having left the EU)" The UK has participated in the Dublin process since it was inaugurated in 1990. When the UK left the EU, the UK left the Dublin agreement and we no longer have the automatic right to return asylum seekers back to France. So Brexit was to take back control from unelected bureaucrats, and here we have David Cameron an unelected bureaucrat in charge of our foreign policy. And Brexit was about taking control of our borders and asylum seekers, and we've lost the ability to return asylum seekers to France, and instead have to spend over £1,000,000 to send asylum seekers to Rwanda, in a 1 in 1 out policy i.e. for every asylum seeker we send to Rwanda, they send us one of their asylum seekers, so we don't have fewer asylum seekers, we're just shuffling asylum seekers around. Hundreds of millions for a PR campaign to appease racists while there is a cost of living crisis in the UK and millions of Brits living in poverty. Disgraceful.
331
2,611
363
5,823
1,117,387
We are delighted that the Noise Abatement Notice has been amended in favour of @nightanddaycafe with the judge agreeing to the noise levels that we offered to @ManCityCouncil in June 2023 as part of joint testing and negotiations.
43
182
104
1,492
182,421
Glastonbury... only without the artists who started their careers in Grassroots Music Venues
11
180
31
361
78,232
I just figured out if you search for a classic guitar pedal on Spotify, people have made entire playlists featuring that particular pedal
108
566
115
7,097
512,796
Delighted to have Ally Horn, @willhw of @sgdlaw and Willie Ryan join us to discuss the legal side of the business.
1
2
361
Yet more evidence of the importance of teaching music in schools. We need to reverse its slow eradication from the curriculum. Playing a musical instrument or singing is linked to better memory in older age theguardian.com/society/2024…
9
23
1,629
🎉Applications are now open for the Accelerator Programme 2024! Applications for 2024's programme must be submitted by 10am Monday 26th February 2024. 🔗Check out themmf.net/resources/acceler… for more information!
11
6
9
4,221