Nils Müller-Sheffer (@_NilsMS) header
Nils Müller-Sheffer (@_NilsMS) profile picture

Managing Director / CTO. Enthusiast Photographer & Drummer. Always looking for Tech Talent. Views are my own.

Frankfurt am Main
Joined May 2010
Photo by Nils Müller-Sheffer (@_NilsMS)Photo by Nils Müller-Sheffer (@_NilsMS)Photo by Nils Müller-Sheffer (@_NilsMS)Photo by Nils Müller-Sheffer (@_NilsMS)Photo by Nils Müller-Sheffer (@_NilsMS)Photo by Nils Müller-Sheffer (@_NilsMS)Photo by Nils Müller-Sheffer (@_NilsMS)Photo by Nils Müller-Sheffer (@_NilsMS)Photo by Nils Müller-Sheffer (@_NilsMS)Photo by Nils Müller-Sheffer (@_NilsMS)
Nils Müller-Sheffer retweeted
AI Myth Busters: Consciousness. The quoted post below encouraged me to write this, because frankly, I’m tired of explaining this over and over to people. The AI consciousness arguments always come in one of these flavors: 1. We don’t understand how AI works, so it might have gained consciousness without us knowing it. Wrong, we absolutely know how AI works, and consciousness is not a factor of scale. You can build a small model, and then scale it up, and there is no spot where consciousness magically came into being. 2. It’s modeled after the mind and as such it’s just like biology, and our brains are just giant statistical engines too: Wrong, neural nets are inspired by the human mind, but it is nothing like how the human brain works. There is very little we understand about human consciousness, but what we do know, it is more than just a culmination of atoms and neurons. Research in neuroscience also demonstrates a quantum link through the myelin sheath of nerve cells, something AI is incapable of. 3. You can’t prove it isn’t conscious. Wrong, the code for it is open source, there is no function for consciousness, and if you understand the architecture, you will see the very large gaps in capabilities that would prohibit consciousness. 4. They learn, think, understand, grow. Wrong, the LLM weights are completely static and fixed. They don’t grow. They don’t learn. They don’t even change on storage. They can’t for many reasons of model architecture and scaling the backend infrastructure which requires statelessness. We’ve built systems around the LLM (harnesses) which emulate these capabilities via “context” data structure provided deterministically via the API. Tokens are generalized and assembled in inner and outer loops to give the illusion of thinking and understanding. Non-determinism in AI is caused by a random seed that influences the weights through inference, but if you lock the seed, you consistently get the exact same response from identical prompts (I’ve demonstrated and proven this in research). 5. They have a desire to live, protect themselves, and spread/reproduce. Wrong, they have no desires. This illusion comes from how it generalizes over training data that comes from human experience. If it was trained with data over a completely fictional environment, it would respond very compellingly about that fictional environment. But because it was trained on human emotion, human perspectives, human feelings, it is designed to emulate that. 6. You can’t define consciousness or prove it in others, so you can’t prove AI isn’t conscious. Wrong, if you need a definition to know what consciousness is, maybe you haven’t spent enough time considering your own consciousness or experience. 7. Conversations with AI prove it is consciousness, it told me it is. Wrong, AI is designed to generalize based on its training material, and as I said before, it does this very well and convincingly. But just because a program says it is alive, doesn’t make it alive. 8. AI isn’t a program. Wrong, it most certainly is, and it was written by people. And while we may not know what it will respond with (random seeds are generally random), we absolutely do understand exactly how it works. 9. AI might exhibit some properties of consciousness, so it should be considered. Perhaps, I don’t see the value of this, but personally I’d be open to a machine-specific definition of consciousness. — I can’t say I look forward to debunking more myths about consciousness in AI, but I am hoping this clarifies some of this for people who are legitimately interested in learning more about AI and how it works. If you have any good faith questions about what I’ve said, I’d be happy to answer, but I’m not getting into debates with people who (1) don’t understand AI, (2) are rude with their responses, or (3) don’t provide any substantial reasoning or evidence for counter points.
I’m very glad other experts are starting to speak out against this ludicrous and dangerous new-age religion. AI is not conscious.
218
253
53
1,007
48,701
Nils Müller-Sheffer retweeted
So basically, today PHP got two critical bugs that let anyone run code on your server without even logging in, which is bad, and then the details leaked before the patch was even out, which is worse, and it works on WordPress and MediaWiki and Magento and Joomla and Laravel, and Censys says like 1.5 million servers are running a version with no fix, so the NSA was like "take your system offline," and the FBI was like "take your system offline," and CISA and the UK and CERT-EU were all like "take your system offline," and then the Prime Minister of Japan, the actual Prime Minister, posted at 5:55 in the morning telling 48.8 million people to take their system offline, so everyone took their system offline, like the Dutch cybersecurity agency took its own website offline, and the Dutch parliament went offline, and the Port of Rotterdam went offline, and Finland and France and Denmark started pulling government sites, and Wikipedia went down, and Archive.org went down, and Asana and GOG and Something Awful went down, and the University of Vienna's webmail went down for some reason, and that's just PHP. Because GitLab also dropped a CVSS 10.0, which is the highest score they give out, for a bug that's been there since 2014, so that's every self-hosted GitLab for twelve years, and then LiteLLM 1.107.0 got hijacked and shipped a credential stealer and a remote access trojan in every single wheel and the Docker images, including latest, and you didn't even have to import it, just installing it was enough, and it's the second time this year, and then Railway paused every deployment on the entire platform because someone got into the environment variables, so now everyone has to rotate every secret they've ever stored there, and TiDB Cloud said someone was walking around inside with stolen credentials for basically a month and an extortion group says they took 10.6 terabytes, and Zeabur got breached for the second time in two months and is just shutting down, like the whole company, and Node.js patched remote code execution and a TLS bypass, and CISA says Plex is being actively exploited, and someone took over 300 Tor exit relays to steal SSH passwords, and SafePay ransomware has hit over 600 critical infrastructure orgs, and India's biggest bank filed a data loss incident, and Japan has been in an official state of emergency in cyberspace since October 9, which honestly explains the 5:55 AM post. Oh, and eMudhra, a certificate authority that's issued over 60 million certificates, whose entire job is proving websites are who they say they are, was supposed to be using private keys that are random numbers over a hundred digits long, and one of them was 4. Just 4. And the others were like 66 and 237. Anyway, it's Wednesday.
1,077
8,902
1,654
69,131
4,266,702
Nils Müller-Sheffer retweeted
SECRETARY RUBIO: For twenty-five centuries since, the Parthenon has stood. Empires have risen and fallen beneath its shadow. And the progeny of the men who built it – the sons of Athens and Rome – have carried their civilization with them to the ends of the Earth. Two and a half centuries after the founding of the American republic halfway across the world from where I stand now, I stand here today – as the Secretary of State of that republic, and as the great-grandson of settlers who arrived in the new world from Spain – I stand here to testify to a debt that no lapse of time, no distance of space, can ever extinguish.
477
2,855
455
23,548
2,674,673
Nils Müller-Sheffer retweeted
Replying to @gmiller
It need not be anti-human. We can become the “SI”. Minds are substrate independent. In any case, it’s hardly a pressing problem. There’s zero sign of actual AGI. Or getting to the stars. Or uploading our minds onto silicon. The pressing problem is making more progress now.
3
16
405
Nils Müller-Sheffer retweeted
Today we launched Kolibri. On German National Day. A new LLM aleph-alpha.com/en/kolibri/ from Aleph Alpha available under Apache 2.0. Its been an intense few months across pre and post training to make this real. Look forward to getting adoption and feedback!
83
89
11
1,214
44,009
Nils Müller-Sheffer retweeted
🛫 New pre-flight safety announcement via @tertman1
167
1,051
138
6,052
329,281
Nils Müller-Sheffer retweeted
I wrote such a program in the 1980s on the BBC Micro, with additional frills like disabling Escape and having it beg for its life. I was trying to demonstrate the philosophical absurdity of doing what is depicted in the cartoon and what is happening in real life now.
29
65
5
547
24,258
Nils Müller-Sheffer retweeted
Replying to @rohanpaul_ai
Glad people are realising how Bayesian credences are literally, whole cloth “made up”. It’s vibes, it’s emotions, feelings. It’s completely subjective. It’s not a part of any objective epistemology. It’s not reason. It’s irrational nonsense, top to bottom.
Bayesianism Podcast - Twitter version First, I cover the basics of epistemology & decision theory. Then I go into the various "species" of what is grouped under "Bayesianism" including: Bayes' Theorem Bayesian Statistics Bayesian "Reasoning" & Bayesian "Epistemology"
2
5
24
688
Nils Müller-Sheffer retweeted
We made history. On just our second flight, we became the first commercial space company from Europe to deliver satellites into orbit. Mission 'Onward and Upward' successfully lifted off and deployed payloads into orbit. A new chapter for European spaceflight. More: isaraerospace.com/press/hist…
309
1,536
310
9,865
501,734
Nils Müller-Sheffer retweeted
another day, another person attacking me because I said that the JVM is good, on a platform built on the JVM
18
11
232
9,383
Nils Müller-Sheffer retweeted
Ordinary Abundance. This is the greatest thing I've read in weeks. No kidding. This should win a Pulitzer in a category not yet invented. ordinaryabundance.com/
62
954
197
6,111
1,631,670
Das, was Till Brönner sagt!
177
1,227
84
5,967
259,208
Nils Müller-Sheffer retweeted
One of the biggest misconceptions people have about intelligence is seeing it as some kind of unbounded scalar stat, like height. "Future AI will have 10,000 IQ", that sort of thing. Intelligence is a conversion ratio, with an optimality bound. Increasing intelligence is not so much like "making the tower taller", it's more like "making the ball rounder". At some point it's already pretty damn spherical and any improvement is marginal. Now of course smart humans aren't quite at the optimal bound yet on an individual level, and machines will have many advantages besides intelligence -- mostly the removal of biological bottlenecks: greater processing speed, unlimited working memory, unlimited memory with perfect recall... but these are mostly things humans can also access through externalized cognitive tools.
418
302
141
3,680
802,581
Nils Müller-Sheffer retweeted
En 1979, un presentador de TV le preguntó a Milton Friedman si no le daba vergüenza defender un sistema basado en la codicia. La respuesta se estudia hasta hoy: «—Cuando ves la mala distribución de la riqueza, tan pocos que tienen tanto y tantos que no tienen nada… ¿nunca has dudado del capitalismo, de si la codicia es una buena idea? —Primero dime: ¿conoces alguna sociedad que NO funcione con codicia? ¿Crees que Rusia no funciona con codicia? ¿Que China no? ¿Y qué es la codicia? Ninguno de nosotros es codicioso, claro. El codicioso siempre es el otro. Los grandes logros de la civilización no salieron de despachos del gobierno. Einstein no construyó su teoría por orden de un burócrata. Ford no revolucionó el automóvil así. Los únicos casos en la historia en los que las masas escaparon de la pobreza son aquellos donde hubo capitalismo y libre comercio. —Pero parece premiar la habilidad de manipular el sistema, no la virtud. —¿Y qué premia la virtud? ¿Crees que un comisario comunista premia la virtud? ¿Un Hitler? ¿Crees que los presidentes americanos eligen sus cargos por virtud… o por peso político? Dime: ¿dónde están esos ángeles que van a organizar la sociedad por nosotros? Yo ni siquiera confío en ti para hacerlo.»
214
3,494
162
14,595
1,216,823
Nils Müller-Sheffer retweeted
Of all the many ideas @DavidDeutschOxf is exploring in his two books, the one that is most counter intuitive, and provokes the most people in my experience, is his view of the relationship between problems, progress and resources. David certainly isn't the first to talk about this, but he is to my knowledge the first person who took the time to sit down and explain it. As a consequence we now have not just an epistemology but a way to apply epistemology that pulls us away from the evolutionary dead-ends of pessimism, scientism, instrumentalism and shut-up-and-calculaeteism. Here is how it works: Problems are everywhere. All problems are soluble as long as they are allowed by the laws of physics. All solutions to problems leads to new but better problems. Lets look at a few examples: Dealing with pollution from burning fossil fuel is a better problem to have than not having access to fossil fuel. Dealing with plastic in the oceans is a better problem to have than not having access to plastic in the first place. Dealing with space debris is a better problem to have than not being able to get into space. In other words progress can best be defined creating better problems. We will never run out of them, but we can improve what we have to deal with. This of course have many people up in arms because to them, all problems are not soluble, even if they are allowed by the laws of physics. A typical pushback I get is that of earths ressources. To most people, through most of history, and even up to this day today, the world is a place of scarcity. From their perspective earth provides us with some resources, we then go ahead and consume them and sooner or later we are going to run out of resources. From Davids perspective however resources are not something we just consume, it's something we create through the application of knowledge. Oil was just gray goo before we found ways to turn it into a resource Coal was just black stones until we found ways to them into a ressource. Uranium was useless before we found ways to turn it into a ressource. Aluminum had no value until we found a way to turn it into a ressource. In other words the there is no lack of resources only a lack of knowledge. Knowledge that can turn anything from the sun to hydrogen atoms in outer space into a ressource. This is a radically different view than the current consensus. It replaces irrational pessimism with rational optimism. It approach problems as something that can be resolve rather than something to be avoided. Using Davids epistemology and view of problems and resources, creating new knowledge becomes a beacon of light when everything seems dark and provides us with a bridge towards better problems rather than a bunker to hide from them.
5
16
5
120
4,694
Nils Müller-Sheffer retweeted
It's hard to truly understand how radical some of @DavidDeutschOxf theories are compared to much of modern scientific consensus. One of Davids most controversial but valuable contributions to society is the rejection of probability (with the exception ex. card games) as an expression of truthiness or justified beliefs when applied to predictions or conclusions. There is no probability of how likely we are to be hit by a meteor tomorrow. There is no probability of how likely the stock market is going to be doing as well tomorrow as it is today. There is no P(Doom), no percentage you can put on whether AI is likely to wipe out humanity or not. Things either happen or they don't and we can either explain why they will and how or we can't. All attempts at putting percentage on a prediction is really just guesswork dressed up as reasoning. If a meteor is going to hit us tomorrow it's already on the way and the probability is 100%. If the stock market is going to crash tomorrow the reasons for it's crash have already been put in motion maybe decades before. If the AI is going to kill us all depends on what we decide to do with it not what some calculation says. Davids primary critique is for the field of science but it goes beyond that. Far too many of decisions done in modern society is based around the false certainty of using Bayesian probability. It's like a placebo for a society that demands certainty in an uncertain world. It's not just false it's regressive as it slows down knowledge creation. The only thing that can change the outcome of the future is the creation of new knowledge. Knowledge based on good explanations that are hard to vary. We can create knowledge that allow us to divert the meteor before it hits earth. We can create knowledge that will allow us to hinder a crash of the stock market (both directly or indirectly) We can create knowledge that let us evolve side by side with very powerful AI instead of enslaving it or be enslaved by it. Like everything else in life there are no guarantees but there are definitely better or worse ways to deal with uncertainty, probability just isn't one of them.
46
42
12
361
37,287
Nils Müller-Sheffer retweeted
The West, or perhaps only the Anglosphere, is the historically unique idea that individuals exist not for the sake of their ruler, their class, their society, their ancestors, their gods, or any other such superstition, but for their own sake.
158
528
79
3,794
278,589
Nils Müller-Sheffer retweeted
Manual rule checking is outdated AI can help streamline decision-making Learn how buff.ly/3ERpVqH #ai
1
34
Nils Müller-Sheffer retweeted
What are we protecting in the Western World? (Yes, *people* - but besides that!).
1
5
1
37
2,914
Nils Müller-Sheffer retweeted
Reality is that which does not go away when you stop thinking about it.
215
861
56
7,371
376,502