Ankit Doshi retweeted
For @RBI @RBIsays @FinMinIndia , making our lives worse. For India’s sake please get your act together. @nsitharaman @sanjeevsanyal @PMOIndia @narendramodi Our banks act like FEMA terrorists for inward remittance, make our lives hell. @RBi should penalize them for harassing us
The EDF (Export Declaration Form) rules are now in effect, and it seems like RBI and banks have conspired to create a new hell. Or actually 5 hells.
I consult for an American company. Raised October invoice. Received the Inward remittance. And bang! Mail from @HDFC_Bank detailing everything needed before the payment can be processed.
Let me tell you what the 5 hells are:
1. The hell of confusion – RBI clarified last month that the EDF rules do not apply to individuals. But looks like they haven’t told the banks. And CAs also don’t seem to know. There’s no official communication on who is exempt. Last I checked, I was an individual. No company, no LLP. But HDFC still wants me to file the EDF to credit my payment.
2. The hell of complexity – See the attached pic of the form the bank has sent in excel. It has 5 sheets. To be filled and submitted. Some abstruse acronyms like “AD” - no clue what it means. Some fields are mandatory. Some fields are to be filled by the bank. No idea which is what. And it needs a physical signature. Which leads to...
3. The hell of paperwork - They also sent a pdf with a bunch of request letters. I’m supposed to choose the right letter, print, sign, scan and submit. Creating more paper today is incredibly silly. And, I suppose, someone in the bank will have to upload all this somewhere. Reminds me of those hand-filled immigration forms. Pointless.
4. The hell of repetition – At least for me, most of the details are constant. One client, one payment. If it’s a one-time exercise, fine. I’ll grit my teeth and get it done. But no. These details have to be given month after month. Else… no payment will be credited.
5. The hell of unpreparedness – It would have been simple enough for RBI or HDFC to create an online portal for this. With dropdowns, saved formats, contextual help, etc. to at least make this easy. But that would be too convenient, no? So, they’ve chosen to dump the entire burden on the taxpayer.
I have no opinion or understanding of why this is needed. Maybe it is critical information. Okay! But why make the process so confusing and painful?
And poor communication has meant that the banks have just passed on the pain to the exporter, and even CAs can’t help.
Basically RBI & HDFC feel I should consult less, and comply more. Maybe my client will also agree :)
Ankit Doshi retweeted
India is probably the only country where a govt babu, whose department was directly responsible for mixing of water and sewage that resulted in the death of 30 innocent citizens, not only will not be punished but actually promoted, but the CEO of a private company, who doesn't have direct control over a factory where 2 workers tragically died, will be arrested immediately and sent to trial
How ridiculous can it get
CEOs of companies will now be arrested for incidents in any factory.
It was a tragic loss of life but this will make so many MNCs rethink India plans and expansion.
@Dev_Fadnavis
m.economictimes.com/industry…
Ankit Doshi retweeted
Fantastic video. Must see. (It's in Marathi).
P. S. : Absolutely not against any festival celebrations. Just against the speaker walls.
Ankit Doshi retweeted
The first step to getting better.
I am to blame for my problems. I am responsible for fixing them.
My interview with @nejatian, CEO of Opendoor.
This is a rare look inside a turnaround, while it's happening. It's raw, real, and violent.
Kaz took over $OPEN when it was months away from bankruptcy. His wife shipped a mattress to the office and told him not to come home until he had a plan to break even.
Some of what he told me:
• "All success is unique, but all failures rhyme."
• The most dangerous people in a company are competent but not mission aligned.
• Meetings are a bug in the system.
• The comfortable lies that sink a company are the same ones that sink careers (and countries).
(Shane and guests may hold positions in assets discussed in this episode. Nothing in this conversation should be considered investment advice, financial guidance, or a recommendation to buy or sell any security.)
Ankit Doshi retweeted
India's largest generation is Gen Z - ~400M, ages 14–29.
Bigger than the entire US population.
It's also the high-water mark. India's annual births peaked around 27M and are now ~22M. Fertility slipped below replacement around 2020.
No Indian generation will ever be this large again.
Sooner or later, we will see all constituents of business and society - businesses, governments, entertainment, sports etc - take them very seriously.
A good time to remind ourselves of India’s most important policy imperatives:
1. Create 20 million jobs per year
2. Ensure that schools & universities deliver high-quality education to every young person.
3. Rethink entrance exams as the way to select students/aspirants.
Ankit Doshi retweeted
After being criticised for ending his hunger strike in the presence of Union Ministers, activist Sonam Wangchuk releases a long video message. Says, he “did not cut any deal” with the government and ended his hunger strike as he feared a crackdown against students at Jantar Mantar. He said he did not press for Education Minister Dharmendra Pradhan as it is inevitable due to the ongoing CJP protest and movement across the country . “Instead, I focused on getting justice for the students and young people against whom FIRs have been registered. We saw what happened after Ladakh incident on September 24,2025, around 80 people were arrested and thrown in jails. For me the future of these young people is more important. Government wasn’t ready to give a written assurance but I refused to end my hunger strike without this key point,” he said
Ankit Doshi retweeted
The NEET issue is not just about an exam paper leaking. It is a leak of trust, a leak of patience, a leak of restraint, and its way to becoming a leak of faith in the system. My (serious) take.
NEET is not just an exam paper leak
It's a leadoff trust, patience & restraint.
Ankit Doshi retweeted
Mesopotamia was never the cradle of civilisation. India was.
I spent forty years in international shipping, not academia. When I began researching the history of maritime trade, I had no orthodoxy to defend. I followed the evidence, and it kept arriving in the same place: the Indian subcontinent.
Nineteenth century archaeologists dug in Mesopotamia because the climate preserved artefacts, the biblical sources pointed them there, and the Ottomans allowed the excavations. That is the entire basis for the myth of Mesopotamia as "the cradle of civilisation."
Nobody applied the same rigour to India. Mohenjo-daro was not discovered until 1922. By then the narrative had already hardened.
What was actually there was the largest civilisation of the ancient world. Three hundred cities. Fifty thousand people in each, by 2600 BC. Two thirds of them stood on the banks of the Sarasvati, the central and greatest of the seven rivers described in the Rig Veda, flowing down from the Himalayas before the river vanished entirely by 1900 BC. The Vedic kings claimed territory stretching "sea to sea," from Afghanistan to Maharashtra, some 1.5 million square miles, against Egypt's 13,000. A dock at Lothal built to handle thirty ships of sixty tons, unmatched in Europe for four thousand years. When it was first excavated, it was recorded as a bathing pool.
When the scale became impossible to dismiss, the theory was not corrected. It was replaced with a story of pale-skinned nomads from the steppe who supposedly arrived around 1500 BC and brought civilisation with them. There is no evidence. The chronology doesn't work. The Vedas describe no invasion.
In 2019 a Harvard-led genetic study revived the claim, and the press reported it as confirmation. It was not. The same study found the builders of these cities were indigenous. The Sarasvati river that the Rig Veda described had already dried up before these newcomers arrived. What the study also found is that a small group of men, arriving after the Sarasvati had already dried up, interbred with the existing population and left a genetic signature. That is all.
So, where they chose to dig was mostly an accident of climate and access. The Aryan invasion theory was constructed because an Indian civilisation that owed nothing to Caucasians was a fact the late nineteenth century could not accommodate.
Link to full Substack essay with sources in the comments below.
Ankit Doshi retweeted
Mad respect for @_soniashenoy for such beautiful articulation on the current state of affairs.
Day by day, more and more people are voicing their opinion, especially women, an absolutely fantastic sign for a vibrant thriving democracy!
Ankit Doshi retweeted
Ages of the Founding Fathers on July 4, 1776
James Monroe, 18
Aaron Burr, 20
Alexander Hamilton, 21
James Madison, 25
Thomas Jefferson, 33
John Adams, 40
Paul Revere, 41
George Washington, 44
Now check the ages of our three branches of government in 2024...
Ankit Doshi retweeted
We can confirm that we don't wish to add Gautam Gambhir to our coaching staff. He clearly has talent, though. To take those Indian players and deliver those results in Ireland takes truly remarkable gifts.
His name is Ranjitsinh Disale.
He wanted to be an engineer. When that did not work out, his father suggested he train as a teacher instead.
In 2009, he was posted to a government primary school in Paritewadi, a small village in Solapur district, Maharashtra. The school was a crumbling building wedged between two storerooms, one of which had been used as a cattle shed.
What he found there troubled him.
Girls were being married off young instead of being sent to class. Attendance was poor. The textbooks were written in a language many of the children, who spoke Kannada at home, could not properly read.
He decided to fix all of it, starting with the books.
He learned the children’s mother tongue and rewrote their textbooks in a language they could actually understand.
Then he did something no one in India was doing at the time.
He printed unique QR codes inside the textbooks, allowing students with access to a phone to scan a page and instantly access audio poems, video lessons and practice questions.
A village school in Solapur had built a digital classroom out of paper and printed squares.
The results changed the village.
Girls’ attendance reached nearly one hundred percent. Teenage marriages in the area stopped. His QR code idea worked so well that the Maharashtra government adopted it across the state.
The following year, the national education body embedded QR codes in textbooks across the country.
In 2020, Ranjitsinh Disale won the Global Teacher Prize. He was chosen from more than twelve thousand nominations across roughly one hundred and forty countries and was the only Indian in the top ten.
The award carried one million dollars, around seven crore rupees.
Then he did something no winner had ever done before.
He announced that he would give away half the prize money, dividing it equally among the other nine finalists so that their work could continue as well.
He said teachers are the real change makers.
He meant all of them, not just himself.
A man who became a teacher only because engineering did not work out changed how an entire country learns, and then gave half his fortune to the people he had competed against.
Follow for stories India deserves to remember.
Ankit Doshi retweeted
🚨 Massive controversy erupt in Wadala (East) ahead of #MumbaiMonsoon.
While private contractors were paid crores for mechanical drain cleaning, residents of LBS Nagar & Korba Salt Pans caught them using child laborers to manually haul toxic garbage out of deep nullahs with zero protective equipment.
This isn't just a scam; it’s a criminal violation of child rights. Strict action needed NOW! 🚨
#MumbaiNews #BMC #ChildExploitation @mybmc @CPMumbaiPolice @NCPCR
Ankit Doshi retweeted
Congress govt in Telangana invoking the stringent UAPA against a Twitter user for his alleged critical remark against the government. This is how the Congress restores the freedom of expression when it is in power.
Ankit Doshi retweeted
Three teenagers. Three investigations. One question that shook India’s biggest school board.
When millions of students were busy checking their marks, these students started examining the system itself.
What began as individual questions soon turned into a national conversation about transparency, accountability, and trust in CBSE’s new digital evaluation process.
Scroll down to see how teenagers put India's exam evaluation system under the spotlight.
And tell us: Should students play a bigger role in holding educational institutions accountable?
#EducationMatters #StudentVoices #CBSE #YouthPower #PositiveChange
[CBSE Evaluation System, Student Accountability, Education Transparency, Digital Exam Evaluation, Indian Education Reform]
Ankit Doshi retweeted
Watch: When asked the NTA/CBSE has denied their OSM system was hacked. What is your understanding as you happen to know the hacker Nisarga, CBSE class 12 student Sarthak Sidhant says, "I know Nisarga from a long time, Nisarg is my long time friend and Nisarga is not lying about hacking the OSM portal, Nisarga has complete create, read, update, delete access to the OSM portal, he also has access to the portal released in CBSE circulars. So if CBSE is talking that CBSE does not know about it, why did CERT acknowledge it? CERT acknowledged the vulnerabilities like what Nisarga offered, so CERT did acknowledge the vulnerabilities, so I say CBSE is not right about telling that the OSM system was not hacked."





























