
Feminist/Writer/Journo. Currently @Outlookindia. Former Polis Project, NewsClick, Asia Times
India
Joined May 2009
- Tweets6.3K
- Following1K
- Followers1.4K
- Likes9.1K
Aritry retweeted
This is what Pradip Krishen and I saw at Budh Jayanti Park in the Central Ridge:
A JCB bulldozer, ostensibly removing invasive trees, clearing everything else in its path.
It’s miraculous this forest survives in the heart of Delhi. But the govt’s own “restoration” efforts may now threaten its future.
Full interview on @newslaundry today!
Aritry retweeted
to be half as sharp, have half as much clarity and integrity as @ravish_journo one day!
Watch this report on questionable role of political party appointed agents in SIR.
Also mentions my reports from Delhi's Mustafabad among those of other states. youtu.be/b0ftQQO1a6g?t=493&s…
Aritry retweeted
Today our Delhi SIR petition was listed in the Supreme Court before the bench of CJI Justice Surya Kant, Justice Bagchi and Justice Mohana.
Following issues were pointed out-
• No actual ground level implementation of the directives given by the Supreme Court during the Oct 28 hearing. SC had held that use of Form 6 for deleted voters placed on the ASDD (Absent, shifted, dead, duplicate) list is an error as they are not first time voters and therefore enumeration form/ form 8 should be used, not Form 6. Court had also stressed that ECI must reach every excluded voter by publishing ASDD lists in the local-language at booth levels, and giving wide publicity through social media, whatsapp and loudspeakers.
• Following this, on Nov 6, ECI issued a letter to 7 state CEOs, including Delhi, directing that voters excluded from draft SIR roll should be allowed to fill enumeration forms. However, the SOP and timeline for implementing this was issued only on Nov. 17. As per the timeline, the distribution and collection of enumeration forms will start only today (ie Nov 19) and only a period 12 days has been allotted which will be inadequate for reaching the 47 lakh ASDD voters.
The Court was urged to order extension of the deadline and direct the ECI to report on compliance in terms of the number of ASDD voters who have filed enumeration forms. Further ECI and CEO Delhi must give wide publicity to actually reach the excluded people.
The bench said they will hear the matter on December 2 and take stock of the progress made, and if required they will order extension of deadline. The court said it has made note of the late availability of Enumeration Forms. Further, Court said that a report on the number of Enumeration Forms received from ASDD voters and number of Form 6, 7 and 8 received and approved should be submitted. Court noted that there was a question of institutional opacity but right now it was more important to stress on ground level penetration and reaching voters. Court said petitioners should also give wide publicity to the revised process to reach the excluded voters.
The petition and IAs were filed by Anjali Bhardwaj and Amrita Johri. The petitioners were represented by Advocate Prashant Bhushan along with Cheryl D’souza and Neha Rathi.
Aritry retweeted
1/9 - “Ayodhya hui hamari hai, ab Mathura ki baari hai.”
The BJP is bringing the Krishna Janmabhoomi issue into its political messaging ahead of the 2027 Uttar Pradesh Assembly elections.
A new slogan, “Radhey Radhey, Kamal Khila De”, points to a possible Krishna-centric campaign.
Is Mathura becoming the next Ayodhya?
Aritry retweeted
By deleting 13 crore voters from the voters list across the country under the guise of the SIR, the Election Commission of India is hijacking the sovereignty of the country to favour a political party to come to power : Justice Gopala Gowda, former Supreme Court Judge.
Adult franchise is a Constitutional Right. People of the country are the supreme, not the Supreme Court or the Election Commission, he adds.
Aritry retweeted
Statement : Meta told the Home Ministry it acted against 61,000 posts in the fortnight after Chalo Sansad. IFF calls for the record to be made public.
New Delhi, 13 November 2026
Meta has told the Indian Cyber Crime Coordination Centre (I4C), the cybercrime arm of the Ministry of Home Affairs, that it acted on more than 61,000 Facebook and Instagram posts it classified as violent and inciteful between 25 July and 7 August 2026, @ThePrintIndia reported on 12 November. That is about three posts a minute for 14 days. The period begins on the day the Education Minister resigned and the Cockroach Janta Party (CJP) ended its protest at Jantar Mantar, five days after police used tear gas and a lathi charge against its Chalo Sansad march.
The Internet Freedom Foundation (IFF) condemns the absence of any public account of this action. Meta disclosed the figure to the Home Ministry at a meeting on 21 August, and it became public only because the minutes were filed in the Supreme Court's suo motu proceedings on digital arrest scams.. In IFF's assessment, the minutes record direct pressure from the Ministry of Home Affairs on the content Meta carries.
As per the report in The Print a meeting was chaired by Rajesh Kumar, I4C's chief executive, and followed reviews by the Union Home Secretary, a parliamentary committee and a court-monitored committee on digital arrests. Its scope was wider than financial fraud.
According to ThePrint, I4C sought an in-person briefing on "how the algorithm amplifies or suppresses specific content and viral accounts", an analysis of bot networks across prominent handles, and Meta's draft guidelines on deepfakes and re-uploaded content for review.
The minutes, as reported, do not state what the 61,000 posts concerned. It is not known which agency, if any, flagged them, or which law or company rule Meta applied. I4C itself did not accept aggregate figures when Meta cited 70 lakh pieces of content removed, it asked for examples with links. Users and the public are entitled to the same detail.
Complaints received by IFF show what was being restricted on Instagram as the period began. Here we are relying on our own inbound queries and requests for pro-bono help and legal assistance.
1) On 23 July, a story about the protests shared by a private account with 137 followers was made unavailable in India through what Instagram described as "an automated system implemented pursuant to legal requirements" under the IT Rules, 2021.
2) On 24 July, a reel by the journalist Ila Kazmi showing a Delhi Police facial recognition van scanning protesters at Jantar Mantar was withheld on a notice from "The Government of India / Law Enforcement under Section 79(3)(b)", which referred her to the Government of India for any questions. The Delhi High Court has directed the Home Ministry, the IT Ministry, the Delhi Police and Meta to produce the notice and will next hear the case on 17 November.
3) On 28 July, three days after the minister's resignation, Instagram withheld a video published on 15 June by the current-affairs page Unmutezone under the title "Why Modi Can't Ask Dharmendra Pradhan to Resign?". Its editor reported that a second video was blocked on 3 August.
Press reports describe similar restrictions. Newslaundry reported that an interview by the journalist Yaqut Ali with a former CJP spokesperson, posted on 26 July, was blocked in India within minutes, and that Facebook reels on the protests by the creator Jyoti Yadav, including an interview with AAP's Sanjay Singh, were restricted. It later reported restrictions on Instagram posts by Scroll and The Hindu about pellet-gun victims in Kashmir. None of this content is violent or inciteful, and Meta has not said whether it forms part of the figure.
The Home Ministry is involved at each stage from notices under Section 79(3)(b) reach platforms through the Sahyog portal, which I4C operates where close to 1.95 lakh blocking orders were issued to Instagram, Facebook and YouTube between March and July 2026, most of them through the portal, and Meta has integrated its systems with it so that flagged content can be restricted without human review. On 27 July the Delhi Police, which reports to the Home Ministry, was reported to have directed platforms to remove posts it considered offensive to the Prime Minister. Meta's transparency report lists violence and incitement among the categories that I4C refers to it. A ministry that operates this channel and also reviews Meta's enforcement figures and algorithm is supervising online speech.
We regret to state that the Supreme Court's own proceedings have provided an avenue for such censorship without sufficient checks and balances. In the suo motu digital arrest case, in which it directed intermediaries to place their proposals before I4C, and in the Just Rights for Children Alliance matters, in which it indicated that platforms may lose safe harbour, the Court has largely acted as a facilitator of executive action rather than as an adjudicator of its constitutional limits. The objectives of curbing fraud and protecting children are legitimate, but the supervision they have enabled now extends to lawful speech and results in censorship without legal authority.
These restrictions do not have a basis in law and often executive rulemaking is being used to circumvent the fundamental right to freedom of speech and expression. Section 79(3)(b) sets a condition for a platform's immunity and in Shreya Singhal v. Union of India (2015), the Supreme Court confined it to court orders and government notifications within Article 19(2). The power to block lies in Section 69A, which requires written reasons, committee review and, following Tanul Thakur (2022), a copy of the order and a hearing for the author. Rule 3(1)(d) of the IT Rules requires each intimation to state reasons, the provision, the unlawful act and the URL, and to be reviewed monthly by a Secretary-rank officer. These requirements cannot be met through an automated integration with a three-hour deadline, whatever share of the 61,000 posts came through Sahyog.
Further, we state that while it may constitute a category of harmful speech, "Violent and inciteful" is not a ground for state mandated censorship under Article 19(2). Shreya Singhal protects discussion and advocacy and permits restriction only at the stage of incitement; a video asking why a minister has not resigned is discussion. Nor is there any clear statutory basis for I4C to perform the function of review a platform's content guidelines or to ask which accounts its algorithm promotes.
Our demands
1) The Ministry of Home Affairs must publish the minutes of its meetings with Meta in 2026 and state how many of the 61,000 posts were flagged by I4C, the Delhi Police or any other agency through Sahyog.
2) Meta must publish a breakdown of the 61,000 posts by the rule or law applied, the action taken and the requesting authority, and give each affected user the notice on which it acted. Further monthly breakdowns with qualitative disclosure is necesary.
3) I4C must withdraw its requests to review Meta's draft guidelines and to be briefed on its algorithm. Oversight of this kind requires a law made by Parliament and may only be performed by an independent regulatory body with a clear mandate and objective.
4) The Union Government must publish the monthly Secretary-level reviews under Rule 3(1)(d) for July and August 2026.
5) Meta must end the automatic execution of government and police flags in India and provide human review, a reasoned notice and an opportunity to respond before any restriction.
Users whose posts or accounts were restricted in India in July or August 2026 may write to [email protected] with screenshots of each notice.
Aritry retweeted
SIR: Nearly half of the new voters added to Bengaluru’s final electoral rolls after the SIR have no records in the Form 6 & Form 8 applications
Read: thehindu.com/news/cities/ban…
Aritry retweeted
BREAKING: A cyberattack hit 178 major organizations, including Zoom, CNN, BBC, Fox News, HSBC, Ledger, Equifax, Salesforce, IKEA and Air France-KLM, by loading malware on the Optimizely Web platform, exposing visitors to scripts built to steal payment data and exploit iOS devices, per security firm Report URI.
Banking and finance was the hardest-hit sector, with 32 organizations affected, including the UK's HSBC across multiple markets such as the US, Hong Kong, Mexico, Singapore, Australia and the UAE.
Aritry retweeted
We have written to the @ECISVEEP and CEOs of 7 states regarding the shocking and flagrant non-compliance with Supreme Court’s directions and ECI’s own instructions.
On Oct 28, SC had said that it was an ERROR to use Form 6, with its declaration of being a first time voter, to re-enroll deleted voters on the ASDD (Absent, Shifted, Dead, Duplicate) list. Following this, on Nov 6, the ECI issued instructions that such voters can fill enumeration form instead of Form 6 and their old EPIC number would be restored. Despite passage of more than 10 days, there is NO implementation on the ground. CEO Delhi website continues to require deleted voters to fill Form 6 to re-enroll.
We've identified another pattern in content takedowns. Posts on Instagram discussing @SoniaGandhi's memoir, 'Belonging: A Journey of Love,' are being restricted in India. 👇🧵
(1/3)
#freespeech #FoE #censorship
Aritry retweeted
#BREAKING Counsel appearing before CJI Surya Kant says 'you don't deserve to sit in the chair, you don't have integrity"; #SupremeCourt mutes the proceedings
CJI told the counsel to wait, saying 'we will see', but the counsel refused to wait
He mentioned that his matter was urgent, and apologized at the outset for mentioning.
Counsel: This item was given to Mr. Justice [Surya Kant] in his office on 2 November. After 15 days, he has not given me reply. So I am forced to come before this court.
J Mohana: You can't mention anything like this
Counsel: No, I came as it's emergency. I'd like to submit my apology first. Please you just see the papers
CJI: We will see, you just wait
Counsel: No, I won't wait. You can't sit in that chair, you don't deserve. You don't have the integrity for that.
Aritry retweeted
Young people in #Pakistan are not less angry than their counterparts elsewhere in Southasia, but their response has not been to occupy public squares, build movements or attempt to transform the political system. Rather, as one student put it, “it is to acquire a passport, apply for a visa, sit an English-language test and leave as early as possible. When almost every door is shut on us, we must look for doors that are still open.” Salman Rafi Sheikh (@Salman_Sh1987) writes: himalmag.com/pakistan-youth-…
Aritry retweeted
Shooting the Messenger!
Delhi Police registered an FIR and later detained Surendra Singh Azad after he shared videos showing thousands of dead fish in the Yamuna near Wazirabad and questioned the government.
The FIR was registered following complaints from the Flood and Irrigation Department and the Delhi Jal Board.
Aritry retweeted
The animal experimentation Draft Rules, 2026 will take Indian sciences to the dark ages . By lowering scientific safeguards, we make it cheap and easy for the foreign companies to cut up and kill our animals.
Secy Animal Husbandry, Naresh Gangwar and Chairman CCSEA, Dr Kumara Muthusamy, please withdraw these draft rules. Here foreigners make money and our animals pay the price.
Check here: dogwithblog.in/object-lab-an…
Aritry retweeted
Libraries of lies: The Tamil Nadu scam involving fake authors, stolen ISBNs, and AI slop
If you are from Tamil Nadu and have by now read a lot about this, then I suggest you read first section and skip to third for some very very interesting detailing
thenewsminute.com/tamil-nadu… #
Aritry retweeted
m.thewire.in/article/media/i…
The Wire received the documentation and writes the article now as a confirmed story.
Thank you for quickly going over it and getting it out there 🙏
Aritry retweeted
Exclusive. ECI’s internal records of 2024 elections: On 51 seats of Maharashtra, Haryana and J&K, votes counted differed from votes cast. ECI rules say such mismatch should trigger probe into possible rigging.
@TweetSumedha & @VenkateshNSS report
1/6
reporters-collective.in/trc/…
Aritry retweeted
With drought declared in 85% of #Maharashtra & many areas in #Gujarat, #Rajasthan, #Telangana, wages are lost, savings depleted, meals cut down, healthcare deferred & children pulled out of school
@iyerkavi writes why #India must move from managing growing drought to addressing the deeper governance crisis
Link 👇
Aritry retweeted
Delhi Police asks X to take down IFF's account and posts. IFF will challenge the notices in court unless they are withdrawn.
The Delhi Police has asked X to remove the Internet Freedom Foundation's account, six of its posts, the accounts of SFLC and @geoblockedindia, and posts by 16 other users, on the ground that they defame the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh. The posts document and comment on a legal notice sent in the RSS's name to IFF, SFLC and @geoblockedindia, which demanded that the three stop criticising and documenting government blocking orders. IFF received copies of the two police notices from X on the morning of 3 November 2026.
IFF calls on the Delhi Police to withdraw both notices. If they are not withdrawn, IFF will challenge them in court.
What has happened
On 29 October 2026 at 9:54 PM, IFF, SFLC and the operator of @geoblockedindia received a two-page "legal notice" said to be issued on behalf of the RSS. It asked the three to stop opposing the government's blocking directions, stop documenting restricted content, stop posting details of geo-blocked posts, and confirm in writing within seven days that they would comply. It was signed by an unnamed "Authorised Signatory". Several RSS office-bearers have since said on X that the notice is not authentic. IFF replied to the notice, wrote to the RSS at its official address asking whether it had authorised it, and published both the notice and its reply on 30 October.
On 31 October 2026 at 8:06 PM, the Special Commissioner of Police (Crime), Delhi Police, filed an "Illegal Content Report" with X (reference LD-321926). It listed two posts: IFF's post of 30 October on the notice, and SFLC post of the same day. The stated reason was that the posts are "defamatory towards the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh under Section 356 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023". The boxes for "safety/security", "defamation" and "other" were ticked. The fields for the nature of the court order and court order details were left empty. The desired action was "Remove/withhold content".
On 1 November 2026, a second notice arrived in the RSS's name. It said the matter had been handed to the Akhil Bharatiya Adhivakta Parishad, that complaints had been filed in several states, and that requests had been made to block IFF's X account and suspend the organisations. The Delhi Police had made its first request to X the previous evening. IFF did not know this until X told it on 3 November.
On 2 November 2026 at 8:51 AM, the Special Commissioner of Police (Crime) filed a second notice with X (reference LD-322956). It lists 40 URLs. Thirty-seven are posts. Three are the entire accounts of @internetfreedom, @SFLCin and @geoblockedindia. This time the boxes for "Hate speech", "defamation", "safety/security", "enforcement of court order" and "other" were all ticked. The court order fields were again left empty. The stated reason reads: "The posts constitute defamation and illegal content under Section 356 BNS. Under Rule 3(1)(d) of the IT Rules, 2021, read with Section 79(3)(b) IT Act, lawful notices require action within 3 hours."
The 16 other users are @ProdctiveUseful, @PanjwaniManoj, @jidge_, @RatanSharda55, @baxiabhishek, @SchrdingersDbag, @ashleshbiradar, @seemay, @NasirHussainINC, @Being_creat_ive, @AjoyDharmavaram, @othlaw, @_ananyaaa, @AimPoojaind, @incorigibleBhai and @rraoind. Their posts, as far as IFF can tell, comment on the notice or on the notice about it.
X forwarded both notice to IFF on 3 November 2026, at 8:47 AM and 10:03 AM, saying it was doing so "in the interest of transparency" and that IFF may wish to seek legal counsel and challenge the request in court. X's emails do not say that it has acted on the requests. The Delhi Police has not written to IFF, and no court has been approached, as far as the reports disclose. SFLC and @geoblockedindia have separately reported notifications from X about requests from the Uttar Pradesh Police, the Telangana Police and the Delhi Police's Cyber Crime unit, one of them against the whole of the @geoblockedindia account.
IFF's position
IFF condemns this legal action. A police force has made itself the enforcement arm of a private legal notice whose authenticity the organisation it names has not confirmed, and whose demand was that three organisations stop documenting censorship. The notices would deliver exactly what the notice asked for as they would also remove the accounts of the three groups in India that keep public records of what is blocked, and of who ordered it.
The posts in question are about a legal notice sent to us. They quote it, criticise how it was drafted, and say that we will carry on with our work. A person who receives a threat is entitled to publish it and answer it and that is not defamation of the sender.
In the three weeks before the first notice, IFF assisted 86 people whose accounts were suspended or whose posts were withheld in India. SFLC's Free Speech Tracker recorded about 268 content restrictions and 83 account restrictions in the first 29 days of October. @geoblockedindia publishes the orders behind such blocks when platforms disclose them. None of this is unlawful. Documenting censorship and challenging it in court is what the Constitution expects of citizens.
IFF will not delete the posts. If the Delhi Police does not withdraw the notices, we will challenge them in court.
Why the reports are unlawful
Defamation is not a police matter. Section 356 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 is a non-cognizable and bailable offence. Under Section 222 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023, no court can take cognizance of it except on a complaint by the person aggrieved.
Under Section 174 of the BNSS, the police cannot investigate a non-cognizable offence without an order of a Magistrate. The Special Commissioner of Police (Crime) is not the person aggrieved. The notices disclose no complaint by the RSS and no order of any Magistrate. Whether a statement is defamatory is for a court to decide after hearing its author, with the defences of truth, fair comment and good faith available to that author.
In Subramanian Swamy v. Union of India, (2016) 7 SCC 221, the Supreme Court upheld criminal defamation on the strength of these safeguards. A police officer who asks a platform to remove speech as defamatory has decided the question himself, without a complainant, a court or a hearing.
The posts are protected comment. Exceptions 1 to 3 to Section 356(1) protect the truth published for the public good, opinion on the public conduct of public servants, and opinion on the conduct of any person touching a public question. The posts publish a notice that was sent to us and give our opinion of it. The RSS, if it sent the notice, chose to enter a public question. If it did not, the posts defame no one.
Further, Section 79(3)(b) and Rule 3(1)(d) do not permit this. In Shreya Singhal v. Union of India, (2015) 5 SCC 1, the Supreme Court read down Section 79(3)(b) so that an intermediary acquires "actual knowledge" only through a court order, or a notification from the appropriate government or its agency that unlawful acts relatable to Article 19(2) are being committed. The court said that it would be difficult for intermediaries to judge the legitimacy of the millions of requests they receive, and that the burden must not be placed on them. Rule 3(1)(d), as amended in November 2025 and February 2026, now requires the intimation to come from an officer not below the rank of Joint Secretary or Deputy Inspector General, to be reasoned, and to specify the legal basis and the nature of the unlawful act, subject to a monthly review by a Secretary-level officer. The three-hour window the notice invokes applies to a lawful order that meets these conditions. A web form that ticks "hate speech" and "enforcement of court order" while leaving the court order fields blank, and that gives one sentence of reasons for 40 URLs, is not such an order.
The notices by the Delhi Police are disproportionate. They seek to remove three accounts in their entirety, with years of posts, over six, four and eleven posts respectively. They sweep in 16 third parties whose only connection is that they commented on a public controversy. In Anuradha Bhasin v. Union of India, (2020) 3 SCC 637, the Supreme Court held that any restriction on speech must be necessary, proportionate and the least restrictive measure available, and that orders restricting speech must be published and reasoned. Removing an organisation's entire account for criticising a legal notice fails each of these tests.
The effect is to silence documentation of censorship and providing legal aid to Indian internet users. The accounts named are those that record blocking orders in India. The notice asked them to stop. A takedown request that accomplishes the demand of an anonymous private notice is not law enforcement. It is the use of state power for a private end, which Article 14 forbids.
Our demands
1. To the Delhi Police: Withdraw reports LD-321926 and LD-322956 and confirm the withdrawal in writing to X and to IFF.
2. To the Delhi Police: Disclose the complaint on which the Special Commissioner of Police (Crime) acted, the authority under which the reports were filed, and whether any order of a Magistrate under Section 174 BNSS exists. Disclose every request made to any platform in this matter, including those made by the Cyber Crime unit against @geoblockedindia.
3. To X: Do not act on the reports. If any content is withheld in India, tell the affected user before acting, give them the full request, and name the legal basis. Publish both reports to the Lumen database, as the reporting form itself contemplates.
4. To the Ministry of Electronics and Information Technology and the Ministry of Home Affairs: Have the Secretary-level review required by Rule 3(1)(d) examine these intimations, and tell police forces that Rule 3(1)(d) is not a remedy for defamation, which the law reserves to the person aggrieved and to the courts.
5. To the RSS: State publicly whether it authorised either notice or any complaint to the police. If it did not, say so to the Delhi Police.
If the notices are not withdrawn, IFF will challenge them in court. We will continue to document blocking orders, to publish them, and to provide legal assistance to anyone whose account or post is withheld in India. Nothing in these notices changes that.
Aritry retweeted
So, as per Home Minister of India, as of 2026, India's voters rolls had '3 crore infiltrators'. That is mind boggling!
First, the Home Minister himself must explain since when have such 'infiltrators' been living and voting in India? And if they voted in all elections that happened pre SIR, how can the results of those elections be considered legitimate?
Second, Amit Shah himself has been Home Minister since 2019 and BJP has been in power at the centre and directly responsible for India's national security since 2014. What have they been doing since then if '3 crore infiltrators' continued to not just be present in India but also voting all this while?
Third, when RTIs were filed to ask how many foreigners identified in SIR so far, it turns out that of the 13 crore deleted, only 1600 were 'suspected foreigners'. These responses were given by Chief Electoral Officers of different states. So, are they lying? Or is Amit Shah lying?
Fourth, Amit Shah also says that of 13 crore deleted, 6.15 crore are those who 'shifted'. So, if someone shifted from one place, they should have been deleted from that place but also added to the place where they shifted to. The net effect would have been 0. But in every state where SIR happened, deletions heavily outnumber additions. So, where did these people shift to? Out of India? Or left Earth altogether and shifted to Mars perhaps?
Fifth, Amit Shah also says that of the 13 crore shifted, 3 crore are dead. Field verification and public audit, even when done in a few booths finds almost 30% wrongful deletions, including alive persons marked as dead! So, if even one of these 3 crore 'dead' people turns out to be alive, doesn't that raise questions on the correctness of the whole exercise?
SIR is nothing but a sinister attempt to mass disenfranchise genuine voters, largely from the marginalised communities - minorities, Dalits, adivasis, transgenders, women- and turn them into second class citizens!
And the definace with which BJP is defending SIR indicates that they are the ones benefitting most from the process, but soon it will become the cause of their downfall as well!





































