a.s. retweeted
I'm going to make another attempt on #oil to explain why I think it's going to end up with a $40 handle in the best case, with a $20 handle in the cards (black swan). It has nothing to due with the fundamentals of the trade, and everything to do with prior precedent and existing market signals.
Bulls keep pointing to fundamentals as a basis for oil needing to bottom, making the case that it's cheap (it is) and needs to be bought. This is a good opportunity to remind you that markets are all about timing, and while you may be right you may also be early. Cheap can get cheaper and the "need" for a commodity price to rise doesn't often mean soon, it just means inevitably... and inevitably can be very expensive when you're early.
I like oil. Bulls are right to be bullish. In fact, all things being equal? All signals are in place for oil to put in a bottom and begin to rally. However there are several major caveats in play. Each of them are rare. Each of them are also extremely reliable historically. Each of them are also all taking place at the same time, which raises a major red flag.
#1 - The Gold to Oil Ratio
The single best indicator of a bottom in oil is the gold/oil ratio. When this ratio tops out, oil puts in a bottom nearly 100% of the time. This ratio is extremely powerful for several reasons -- not only does it help predict bottoms in oil prices, but it also predicts major downside risk and events in the broad markets.
Due to the inherent nature of both of these mutually exclusive commodities and the roles they play, this ratio effectively acts as thermometer when reflecting economic circumstances. The higher the ratio, the more trouble we should look out for. I'll exemplify this with more charts as we go on.
The first takeaway from the gold/oil chart right now, is that it's still in a clear uptrend, implying that we aren't ready for the bottom in oil.
The second takeaway, is that we can identify a very clear ratio level of ~30 which has reliably acted as a strong level of upwards resistance. In fact, it's been so reliable that once this ratio was approached, you could safely begin accumulating oil if not outright going all in. In terms of both price and time, you were at an inflection point for oil prices (and market catalysts).
The third takeaway, is that while both 2016 and 2020 managed to overshoot this reliable upwards barrier, it's clear that the ratio was short-lived above that level. The market didn't like this ratio being that high for any sort of duration. 2020 gave us a bit of an anomaly with it's massive spike, but it was nonetheless short lived in terms of duration. The ratio of 30 is extremely powerful, and the market doesn't like sitting above it.
What's clearly changing now in a bit of new precedent (and this is important) is that the duration by which we're remaining above this ratio along with the fact that we're steadily rising in a bullish upwards trajectory rather than quickly spiking and reversing is a massive red flag.
This time is definitely different. Something has changed and what this chart does is clearly visualize this change in sentiment vs prior precedent.
Here's a chart showing the relationship between this ratio and oil prices at the same time. Take note of where we are now.
#2 - Oil's Breadth From Moving Averages
Another excellent metric (especially when used in confluence with the gold/oil ratio) to predict a bottom (or accumulation zone) in oil is its own distance of price from its moving averages. The Weekly 200EMA appears to be the most accurate and powerful that I can tell.
Much like the aforementioned ratio, this chart also has very clear and powerful precedent. Extremely reliable.
The first takeaway on this chart, is that when oil prices fall about ~6.85 below the Weekly 200EMA, the market tends to support the oil price at those levels. This sometimes acts as a bottom, and other times it can slowly drift lower but the market doesn't often allow oil to drift much lower than that.
What's more important, is what happens when the market does allow oil to fall further than that. There's massive precedent which proves that this is a major signal of potential further downside. In fact, about 80% of the time this level of EMA breadth (price distance) is lost, oil has a tendency to completely collapse, suffering those large spike downs in price which are often correlated to major market events.
In 5 prior instances of oil losing this EMA breadth level, 3 led to direct collapse in price. 1 led to a temporary bounce before collapsing. Only 1 instance failed to collapse the oil price. Note we are below this key level now, after rebounding from the "last chance" zone already and failing to really.
We're now building further confluence of outcomes in our charts, since both the gold/oil ratio and the distance from EMA in oil itself each carry strong signals to warn of impending downside in oil prices that coincide with major events in the markets (2001, 2008, 2020, etc)
We now have 2 major red flags in play with exceptionally accurate historical precedent in predicting a major selloff in oil, each occurring at the same time.
CONCLUSION & TLDR
Oil bulls are right to be bullish (maybe it's better to say you can't blame them), since historically we have just about every "bottom" signal in place, with a massive caveat: The ultimate bottom ticker for oil is when the gold/oil ratio tops out. That's not happening. Clear uptrend.
This is also bad news for oil price stability, since the ratio is well above "broad market risk" levels which have a near perfect history of calling major downside events in the markets (yet to happen). It is during these events when we see oil get hit with a massive selloff.
Oil has lost all moving average momentum. Oil has a very clear precedent with 80% probability of outcomes that once it loses a key level on weekly EMA breadth (it has), the price of oil suffers a major spikedown/crash.
I could be wrong, obviously. Anything could happen. There are several reasonable catalysts that could prompt a bottom in the oil price that's atypical to normal cycles and would defy these prior precedents. I'm sure some level of war or geopolitical outcome could change the landscape for better or worse.
That being said and with all things being equal, we have several extremely powerful examples of price and market precedent in play (with 80 to 95% accuracy of outcomes), and all of them are flashing a bright red warning light that oil risks more downside -- likely occurring alongside a larger market event.
The good news is -- if I'm right, the bottom in the oil price should be quite easy to predict within 1-2%, perhaps even within a few cents (I've done this many times before, can do it again). Of course, we'd need the move to play out first and once it does, the confluence of our charts and known signals should easily allow us to call another bottom in another major commodity price.





