The Civil Heretic (@ddtmatter) header
The Civil Heretic (@ddtmatter) profile picture

Pragmatic Christian independent / 3.5% Relentlessly question & challenge. Ruthlessly pursue truth. Do it all with polite facts...plus a dash of sarcasm.

Wisconsin
Joined July 2024
Photo by The Civil Heretic (@ddtmatter)Photo by The Civil Heretic (@ddtmatter)Photo by The Civil Heretic (@ddtmatter)Photo by The Civil Heretic (@ddtmatter)Photo by The Civil Heretic (@ddtmatter)Photo by The Civil Heretic (@ddtmatter)Photo by The Civil Heretic (@ddtmatter)Photo by The Civil Heretic (@ddtmatter)Photo by The Civil Heretic (@ddtmatter)Photo by The Civil Heretic (@ddtmatter)
The Civil Heretic retweeted
The Dana White saga gets funnier.
33
207
25
1,748
157,136
I have been holding my tongue about something that happened during the Ohio gubernatorial race. I refused to speak while the election was underway because I did not want my words mistaken for an attempt to influence anyone’s vote. But now that the election is over, I have something to say. For nearly twenty years, my ministry has taken me among the homeless, the abused, the exploited, and the forgotten. I have sat with victims of sexual violence and witnessed the lifelong wounds of childhood trauma. What Vivek Ramaswamy’s campaign did to Amy Acton was among the most morally repulsive things I have witnessed in American politics. They took a woman whose stepfather was indicted for raping her when she was twelve years old and featured her mother, from whom she had been estranged for nearly fifty years, in a political advertisement attacking her credibility. The advertisement challenged Acton’s account of her childhood without mentioning the sexual abuse allegations or the circumstances of that estrangement. When people expressed their horror, the campaign defended it. Imagine examining another person’s childhood suffering and fractured family relationships, then deciding those wounds might help win an election. Anyone who has worked with survivors of childhood sexual abuse understands the painful realities of denial, betrayal, shame, and estrangement. A child growing into a successful adult does not erase what happened. Nor does a parent’s denial make that suffering disappear. I find it equally disturbing that an elderly mother, whom Acton herself described as unwell, was brought into this spectacle. Whatever her own struggles or responsibility for the past, exploiting that fractured relationship was grotesque. To everyone who defended this, consider the message you sent to survivors. To the young woman whose family refuses to believe her. To the man who has carried the shame of childhood abuse for forty years. To the frightened child who has yet to tell anyone. What did you teach them about the value of their suffering? I am a priest. I believe in repentance, forgiveness, and redemption. But none of those things requires me to pretend that deliberate cruelty is anything less than a grave moral failure. Your political allegiance does not absolve you of moral responsibility. You do not get to set aside your conscience during an election and retrieve it afterward. If your loyalty requires you to defend the exploitation of a childhood sexual abuse survivor, your loyalty has become an idol. And if your conscience cannot recognize the wrong here, examine what political tribalism has done to it. This is not about Republicans or Democrats. We have a choice as a people: continue excusing cruelty from our preferred political camp, or summon the courage to condemn it wherever it appears. Amy Acton deserved better. Every survivor who watched this unfold deserved better. And God help us if we have reached the point where winning an election matters more than protecting the dignity of a wounded human being.
1,680
8,944
661
43,717
1,753,621
The Civil Heretic retweeted
One of the more exciting parts of this election - among many - is the return of a religious left.
1,377
1,901
829
19,716
3,591,092
The Civil Heretic retweeted
Donald Trump put himself on the ballot, which is why we won IN A LANDSLIDE. Thank you for your attention to this matter!
359
4,589
81
37,286
307,326
I am grateful to all of you who are trying to keep Europe and the United States together. There are so many people with good hearts in America who sincerely want evil to lose and Ukraine to stand strong. These are the very hearts that helped Europe defend its freedom, and that fought on D-Day, won the Cold War, and want what is best for Europe. Hearts that want to be allies, not to divide or humiliate Europe. I believe most Americans still feel this way. And at the end of the day, the American people will have their say. Putin will listen to America if America really turns up the heat on him and makes one thing clear – either he chooses peace, or he gets no more money for his war. From an address to the participants of the European Council meeting. (2/5)
2,475
9,349
360
52,429
777,989
The Civil Heretic retweeted
Representative James Talarico has never received treatment from Lindner Center of Hope.
4,297
9,637
3,317
59,994
10,289,925
The account that proved Nick Sortor’s call was AI was just suspended. I’m sure it’s just a coincidence right? @elonmusk
105
1,756
35
8,813
116,396
The Civil Heretic retweeted
If I told you what Republicans were actually doing right now, you wouldn't believe me — you would think I was lying, that it's actually too cruel and corrupt to be true But it's true 10 things Republicans have done in the last 10 days 🧵
34
679
52
2,128
355,458
The Civil Heretic retweeted
At least 7-8 protesters have interrupted Trump’s rally so far. In Texas. Wow.
A police officer forcefully removes another protester from the Trump rally
290
2,340
56
17,613
277,264
The Civil Heretic retweeted
The absolute difference in kind between the human intellect and the mere simulations that AI technology yields is a longstanding theme both of Christian philosophical anthropology (recently reiterated in Pope Leo XIV’s Magnifica Humanitas) and of secular philosophical critiques developed by thinkers like John Searle, Hubert Dreyfus, Roger Penrose, and many others. If there is any problem with the phrase “artificial intelligence,” it is with the word “intelligence,” not “artificial.” Indeed, calling it “artificial” at least has the merit of suggesting that it is a mere simulation, just as artificial grass is merely a simulation of grass. By contrast, “super intelligence” and the other phrases Trump uses here imply that AI technology does in fact have intelligence in the sense we do, and to a greater degree. If Trump insists that this is so despite having no competence whatsoever to speak on the subject, that would be laughable but harmless enough if it were merely the expression of a personal opinion. But it is an outrage for him to try to use the power of his office to pressure those engaged in public discussion of this issue to adopt his favored terminology. Normalizing this usage can only facilitate the spread of the grave error of conflating AI with genuine intelligence. No self-respecting academic or public intellectual who agrees with the critiques of AI mentioned above should go along with this ridiculous novel usage. More importantly, no one who has any respect for the truth should do so.
Trump: Super intelligence or SI, and that's the official name in the United States. I'll be signing a very powerful executive order. I spoke to President Xi. He loves it. When you say artificial intelligence, it's artificial. This is extreme intelligence. It's superior intelligence. It's supreme also intelligence. But the word super is the best word of all and it's the simplest.
34
68
15
365
25,205
The Civil Heretic retweeted
Trump has said the Iran war is almost over at least 60 times. It's been 212 days. 19 service members are dead, 800+ wounded, $43 billion gone. We counted every broken promise with @votevets.
29
518
27
1,078
146,094
The Civil Heretic retweeted
Leavitt: Democrats are always incredibly disingenuous. They do 360s on every single policy position they have.
1,351
266
779
3,250
4,282,349
The Civil Heretic retweeted
An absolutely brutal mistake by Sen Eric Schmitt (R-MO) and his staff 24 years of covering Congressional hearings … I’ve never seen anything like this
“You have the teams wrong sir.”
550
5,282
156
31,977
1,882,676
The Civil Heretic retweeted
I suspect we're approaching a time where if you want to protect creative work, it has to be something that can't be digitized. AI has made is so that creative works speed run through the lifecycle from cool to cliche in a matter of months. This contributes to our cultural stagnation, making it hard for real creators to produce something with meaningful, lasting effects on other real creators. Everything becomes a meme, which is to say meaningless and trite.
Can't believe that Dario, Elon, Sam, Theo and I all agree on this.
168
850
59
12,424
790,378
The Civil Heretic retweeted
Extraordinary reporting: "Kremlev’s previously unreported relationship with Trump Jr. represents an extraordinary development: a member of Putin’s circle financially supporting the president’s son and gaining intimate access to the Trump family." propublica.org/article/donal…
99
700
48
2,611
59,213
The Civil Heretic retweeted
Trump is a failing authoritarian whose approval ratings are tanking. Like any bully, when he feels humiliated, he lashes out. But what he doesn’t realize is that his authoritarianism and his bullying are waking up America’s great sleeping giant.
85
465
14
1,354
36,191
The Civil Heretic retweeted
Trump promised $5,000 stimulus checks from DOGE cuts. You got 0. Trump promised $2,000 stimulus checks from tariffs. You got 0. Trump promised $1,000 checks from Obamacare cuts. You got 0. Trump promised $1.98 gas. You got $4+. Trump now has more promises for you.
549
7,471
229
30,242
592,056
The Civil Heretic retweeted
Suicidal empathy.
17
43
3
271
10,414
The Civil Heretic retweeted
13% of Americans in the new Reuters/Ipsos poll now “Strongly Approve” of Trump’s job performance. The cult is shrinking daily.
86
391
16
3,064
54,564