
Doktor ohne Abitur @humboldtuni Coordinator Inequality Working Group @ysi_commons Economista de los Andes RT≠endorse / Favorite≠like
Berlín
Joined August 2008
- Tweets9.4K
- Following1.8K
- Followers375
- Likes143K
Pinned Tweet
Replying to @derjavi
tl;dr: I finished my PhD after a nightmarish ride and I’m feeling like this:
Francisco Franzl retweeted
In Dune: Part Two you can see harkonnen soldiers flying. But there's no scene where main character react to this saying out loud: "They fly now!?" It's mainly because movie was written by competent writers.
Francisco Franzl retweeted
El problema de fondo de Antioquia es que estos paisas ya no existen. Ahora todos son como Westcol y Karina García.
Francisco Franzl retweeted
David Graeber's Debt: The First 5,000 Years is a better contribution to our understanding of money, and debt than anything Carl Menger wrote.
I understand this is deeply upsetting to Austrian Economists, but anthropology doesn't give a fuck about your origin myths.
Francisco Franzl retweeted
The outcry from some economists over AI-assisted writing is a bit ridiculous.
The discipline abandoned the idea that good writing (and, to some degree, intellectual depth) was worth valuing and rewarding a long time ago.
It's kind of late for us to look there for purpose.
Francisco Franzl retweeted
"The real difference is methods. Heterodox economics is an avowedly political project not a social scientific effort to better understand the world. And I have nothing against political projects just shouldn't confuse the two."
In fact, it is quite the opposite. Heterodox economics is largely concerned with institutional economics. As such, institutions — like money — are described and analyzed. Unlike orthodox economics, there is no bias towards state-led solutions, but rather a market bias. Reality is explained as an 'equilibrium' brought about by individuals. The 'capital market', the 'labour market', the 'goods market' — the 'holy cross' of supply and demand — is invoked, although it is built on sand due to problems of aggregation (just google the Cambridge Capital Controversy). Hence, policy advice is neoliberal, focusing on finding the right 'incentives' for private investment (de-risking), pollution (trading certificates) and employment (pushing down wages). Fallacies of composition (not everyone can save, for example) are ignored. Any empirical reality that goes against a model's processes or data is ignored. New Keynesians, for example, create an abstract model based on assumptions that can be empirically tested. This did not stop them. They neither saw the financial crisis coming nor could they explain it. No time for worry. The fact that there is no 'Nobel', as mentioned by Jason Furman? Ignored. Free trade theory was "applied" in the 2000s, with the US losing almost one in three manufacturing jobs. Did that trigger a return to industrial policy in the orthodox academic journals? Nope. Have orthodox economists learned anything from MMT? It does not seem so. You still claim that taxpayers finance the government, despite there being not a single paper that explains the details, whereas there are literally dozens of papers describing balance sheets and accounting mechanics published by MMT economists. Have any orthodox economists learned that showing only public debt means omitting the private and external sectors, and that there is a bigger picture?
So, the orthodox paradigm is centred on a pro-market and anti-government core, which is highly ideological. People are assumed to be rational, and society is dismissed as an irrelevant concept. This paradigm cannot be touched. It is a political programme enabled by those who saw the fall of the Soviet Empire as meaning that the 'end of history' was near. Orthodox economists have enabled policies that have rolled back the state (thus diminishing democracy) and brought in finance. The policies it has supported over the last forty years — financialisation, privatisation, etc. — have created many problems, including climate change, inequality, mass unemployment and inflation. These problems cannot be solved by the same theories that created them. If there is any hope of solving the problems of the 21st century, it lies in rethinking them from a heterodox perspective.
The fatal challenge to heterodox economics is that there isn't actually orthodox economics.
Just take a few recent Nobels: behavioral, information failure, institutions, bubbles, financial fragility, labor monopsony (sort of), Schumpeterian creative destruction, etc.
Not to mention RCTs which are emblematic of how much economic research is empirical and only lightly if at all structural.
The real difference is methods. Heterodox economics is an avowedly political project not a social scientific effort to better understand the world. And I have nothing against political projects just shouldn't confuse the two.
Francisco Franzl retweeted
I'll assume this post is due to ignorance and not bad faith. There are differences in ONTOLOGY, epistemology, which translate into different views, even if there are commonalities in some (many?) conclusions.
PD: funny to see "financial fragility", and the omission of CLASS.
The fatal challenge to heterodox economics is that there isn't actually orthodox economics.
Just take a few recent Nobels: behavioral, information failure, institutions, bubbles, financial fragility, labor monopsony (sort of), Schumpeterian creative destruction, etc.
Not to mention RCTs which are emblematic of how much economic research is empirical and only lightly if at all structural.
The real difference is methods. Heterodox economics is an avowedly political project not a social scientific effort to better understand the world. And I have nothing against political projects just shouldn't confuse the two.
Francisco Franzl retweeted
This is the frustrating thing about mainstream Econs. They see diversity of *topics* and think it represents genuine diversity in *theoretical foundations*. Completely oblivious to the historical narrowing of what counts as Economics that led us to this situation.
Francisco Franzl retweeted
50 years of macroeconomics in a nutshell:
Lucas: “Your Keynesian models are full of ad hoc assumptions. We need proper microfoundations!”
SMD: “Well, individual rationality doesn't guarantee nice aggregate behavior.”
New Classical macroeconomists: “Aggregation is a problem? Let's just model the entire economy as ONE representative agent. Problem solved.”
New Keynesians: “Cool. Now let's throw in some ad hoc assumptions to make it work.”
And that's how ad hoc assumptions became microfoundations.
Francisco Franzl retweeted
We are deeply saddened to share the news that Perry Mehrling passed away this morning at the age of 67.
Perry was the father of the Young Scholars Initiative. He believed profoundly in young scholars, in their ideas, and in the importance of creating a community in which they could learn from one another and find their own voices.
Perry, you leave an enormous hole in our midst. Our hearts are aching, and we will miss you dearly.
The YSI community will carry your legacy forward. Your ideas, your generosity, and your commitment to generations of young scholars will remain with us.
Thank you for everything, Perry.
Francisco Franzl retweeted
If confirmed, this is telling: Russian data centres get hit, and online activity around AfD suddenly plummets. 📉
So much talk about German patriotism… then the connection from Russia goes down. 🤔🇷🇺
Francisco Franzl retweeted
"Ecosia also has concerns about whether Mistral aligns with its environmental goals, given the large share of nuclear power in France’s energy mix..."
pendant ce temps en Allemagne
Berlin-based search engine Ecosia, used by government services, is dropping its French AI partner, Mistral, its CEO told POLITICO.
The company will now bet on open-source models, including those from China.
vist.ly/5mh5y
Francisco Franzl retweeted
This is a problem you won't see in Economics, since we only award Nobel prize to those with tenure at the top departments.
Francisco Franzl retweeted
This is what it feels like to do a zoom call with an important client and my boss is taking it in his car
Funfact: Um kostendeckend zu sein, müssten wir auf allen Autobahnen und Bundesstraßen eine Pkw-Maut in Höhe von ca. 11 Cent/km einführen. Also wird jeder Kilometer Autofahren mit ca. 11 Cent/km subventioniert.
Francisco Franzl retweeted
Axiom 2 is absurd
Kurt Gödel, the logician behind the incompleteness theorems, also constructed a formal argument for God’s existence.
He never published it.
Using modal logic, Gödel defined God as a being possessing every “positive” property. The argument then rests on a striking premise: if such a being is possible, its existence is necessary.
Gödel showed the proof to Dana Scott around 1970.
The argument remains controversial. Its axioms, especially the notion of a “positive property,” are open to philosophical criticism. Some formulations also lead to modal collapse, where every truth becomes necessary.
It is not an accepted mathematical proof of God.
It is a remarkable example of how far formal logic can be pushed.
Francisco Franzl retweeted
I resigned from Apple today. I spent the last three years doing foldable research at both google and apple. Neither company is acting responsibly. They are racing straight to self-improving foldables and gambling with our lives. More thoughts below.


































