Elon ⚪ (@hadithworks) header
Elon ⚪ (@hadithworks) profile picture

phiLOLogist

Joined May 2023
How exegesis can influence the contents of Hadith 🧵 In a Sunni hadith, the Prophet warns against a hellbound group of women who are “kāsiyāt ͑āriyāt” (clothed & naked). This seemingly contradictory phrase troubled exegetes: how can one be clothed & naked at the same time? [1/8]
4
10
42
9,207
Hadith & the Talmud: David asked why people say "God of Abraham, Isaac, & Jacob" but they don't say "God of David". God answered "because they were tested & withstood the tests & David wasn't". [Then God tested David]
5
22
3
96
5,799
The Hadith is clearly Rabbinic in origin, as it identifies Isaac as the son whom Abraham attempted to sacrifice. The identification of Isaac as the sacrificed son likely led many traditional Hadith critics to deem this tradition as "weak"
3
1
1
14
961
Sufyan al-Thawri (Iraq, d. 161/787) transmitted a version of this hadith where he replaced "David" with "Moses"
2
338
One of the prophet Musaylima's followers referred to him as "The Commander of the Believers" (أمير المؤمنين). This is further proof that the title "Commander of the Believers" existed before the Caliph 'Umar adopted it, probably even in the prophet Muhammad's lifetime.
10
6
42
4,522
Kister wrote about these early uses of the title "Commander of the Believers".
1
5
904
And see my previous post: nitter.gq/hadithworks/status/211…
Who was the 1st person to be called "The Commander of the Believers" (أمير المؤمنين)? The usual answer is 'Umar, when he became caliph. However, one report claims that 'Abdallah b. Jahsh went by this title, when the Prophet sent him on an expedition.
3
546
Elon ⚪ retweeted
Who was the 1st person to be called "The Commander of the Believers" (أمير المؤمنين)? The usual answer is 'Umar, when he became caliph. However, one report claims that 'Abdallah b. Jahsh went by this title, when the Prophet sent him on an expedition.
1
1
1
22
1,712
Who was the 1st person to be called "The Commander of the Believers" (أمير المؤمنين)? The usual answer is 'Umar, when he became caliph. However, one report claims that 'Abdallah b. Jahsh went by this title, when the Prophet sent him on an expedition.
1
1
1
22
1,712
“… but in terms of producing knowledge, producing insights… insights that have not already been published in German scholarship in the 18th or 19th centuries… I think we are not making ANY noticeable advancements. And AI will make that transparent”. @ChristophHeilig on Biblical scholarship in the age of AI. I highly recommend this excellent interview with @mbird12. Link 👇
3
7
36
1,948
Excited to be at @TelAvivUni today for the MindIL Computer Science conference, presenting our poster on “SHAMS: SHami Annotated Multi-dialectal Speech”
3
1
1
24
872
Access on my GitHub the Riwāyāt corpus, the largest online corpus of Islamic traditions, which contains around 1M traditions, from both Sunni and Shi'i sources.
5
15
119
3,660
The Prophet had a mosque in Medina with 2 qiblas (prayer niches), 1 facing Jerusalem & 1 facing Mecca. The 2 qiblas remained through Umayyad times until al-Mansur’s reign (754-775 CE), when the superfluous qibla was removed to avoid confusion. Here’s why it had 2… 🧵[1/6]
3
10
34
3,648
Alternatively, in both cases, the story about Muslims switching direction mid-prayer is a dramatic invention meant to highlight the Muslims’ willingness & eagerness to adopt Mecca as THE direction of prayer. [5/6]
1
8
443
Whatever the case, at least 2 early mosques retained physical evidence of the switch from Jerusalem to Mecca, by having two different mihrabs (prayer niches) facing 2 different holy cities. FIN [6/6] Pictured: niche for Torah scrolls in the Dura Europus synagogue [Wikimedia]
11
416
My article "Early Sunni Witnesses to Jaʿfar al-Ṣādiq’s Teachings" has been published in the Festschrift in honor of Etan Kohlberg (message me for a copy) brill.com/display/book/97890…
9
32
197
6,724
Replying to @MARazack26
مع الاحترام لابن رجب فمن الجدير بالذكر أن غلام خليل ربما لا يكون الوحيد الذي ينسب هذا الحديث للزهري فإنا نجد عند ابن سعد أنه ينسب نفس الحديث (أو حديثا شبيها به) للزهري عبر ثلاثة من تلاميذه الآخرين ومع أننا لا نعرف بالضبط ما متن حديث الثلاثة من الممكن أنه قريب من حديث غلام خليل
2
275
من يهتم بشخصية غلام خليل كمحدث فأنصح قراءة ثْريدي هذا القديم nitter.gq/hadithworks/status/166…
1/14 Do Hadith transmitters influence the contents of the traditions they transmit? A little case study from al-Qushayrī’s “Epistle on Sufism” (transmitted 438/1045) & from “the Malady of the Hearts” by al-Kharāʾiṭī (d. 327/938).🧵
107