Jonny Dixon-Smith retweeted
Reality Denied
Elon Musk’s interview with The Economist exposed a political absurdity: basic common sense now sounds radical because the elite progressive left has spent years treating reality as a nuisance rather than a guide. Secure borders, safe streets, fiscal restraint, and institutional competence are not fringe positions. They are the minimum requirements of a serious society.
That is why the debate has become so warped. Too much of the progressive left now operates in a post-factual universe, where ideology is treated as evidence and evidence is treated as negotiable. In that environment, ordinary standards of order and accountability are recast as oppression, while failure is excused with slogans.
The same argument would be celebrated as wisdom if Obama made it and denounced as extremism when Trump does.
The result is a public discourse detached from consequences. If you point out that uncontrolled migration strains public services, that crime affects working families first, or that governments cannot borrow and spend forever, you are no longer making a practical argument. You are accused of hostility, ignorance, or worse.
Musk’s real value in this conversation is not that he is universally right. Which he is. It is that he forces the confrontation between reality and rhetoric. And once that confrontation happens, the weakness of the left’s worldview becomes obvious: it can explain feelings, but it cannot reliably explain facts.
The middle of the political spectrum has not become more extreme. The left has simply moved so far from reality that common sense now looks like rebellion.
This 🤞
1. Transfer the tens of billions earmarked for net zero to defence and supply chain resilience, to create a major industrial/defence sector, thereby creating skilled jobs in UK, rather than China (as net zero does)
2. Radical tough love welfare reform to get 1m people of working age into work, thereby cutting the welfare bill and increasing the tax base. Coupled with massive expansion of German-class STEM skill apprenticeships.
3. Radical reform of planning laws to stop nimbys/greens from thwarting every major infrastructure development. Put judges/courts in their place when it comes to such matters.
4. Put rocket boosters under high-speed rail link between Leeds-Manchester-Liverpool. Brook no opposition/delay.
5. Unleash North Sea oil/gas + slash energy bills by removing all green levies. New breed of gas-fired and smaller nuke generating stations.
Much more to suggest. But this should be good for starters.
37
Good stuff from @SpeechUnion as ever
Earlier today a @Guardian journalist sent me this query:
Dear Toby Young,
I'm Aisha Down, a journalist at the Guardian. I'm getting in touch because we're planning to report that the US state department is considering a grant of $5m to Free Speech Union, your organisation, as part of a new grant-making scheme, and wanted to give you the chance to comment. We would appreciate receiving your comment by 14:30.
We are considering reporting the following:
- The grant to the FSU is part of a package to Maga aligned groups that former US officials have condemned as a misuse of public money to seek influence over foreign politics and interfere with democracy.
- It is rare for the US government to fund partisan political organisations in western countries.
- These grants are likely to pose a challenge to Andy Burnham, who has said he will be "very upfront" with Trump about any disagreements.
- These grants - including to your organisation - are "sole source" grants, meaning they are to be awarded without any competitive process. This is unusual for a highly regulated process which usually requires grantees to show they have a track record for handling funds and clear plans for the money.
- This lack of process has been criticised as "outrageous and absurd" by former US officials, and as "gross incompetence" and "horrible stewardship" of US taxpayer money.
- Your organisation does not appear to have a track record of handling grants of this amount.
- We describe your organisation as "a rallying point for “anti-woke” grievance" which "frequently allies itself with rightwing causes" and say that you, Toby Young, appeared on Rees-Mogg's GB news show earlier this month to warn about 'Soviet-style' censorship in the UK.
- The state department says that its grant to FSU will “support campaigns promoting free speech and countering digital overregulation across the UK, Europe and Australia”. The sole-source award is justified “due to FSU’s global network of free speech activists”.
We would like to fully and fairly reflect your point of view and look forward to your statement. Thank you,
--
Aisha Kehoe Down
Senior Tarbell Fellow,
Guardian News and Media
I replied as follows:
It sounds like a pretty garbled story.
Free Speech Union International, which is the umbrella group that FSU UK, FSU Australia, FSU New Zealand, FSU Canada, FSU South Africa and FSU Brazil sit within, has expressed interest in applying for grant funding from the US State Department. This would be to promote the right to freedom of expression in those countries, which, far from being a partisan cause, is a universal human right. But it hasn't submitted a formal application and, consequently, has been awarded no grant from the State Department or any other branch of the US Government.
You've mischaracterised the FSUs, all of which are non-partisan organisations that defend people who get into trouble for exercising their right to feee speech regardless of their political views. The FSU UK, for instance, is currently paying for the legal defence of a protestor who's being prosecuted for holding up a sign saying "I support Palestine Action", as well as a protestor for wearing a t-shirt at a Unite the Kingdom rally for saying "Fuck Islam Christ is King". Yes, we helped Lucy Connolly appeal her sentence -- we thought a prison sentence of over two-and-a-half years for a single tweet was excessive -- but we also tweeted yesterday, condemning the arrest of Heather Herbert and offering our support. Yes, we came to the defence of Nigel Farage when he was debanked, but we've also offered to help the Canary in its recent debanking case. So to describe the FSU UK as a "rallying point for anti-woke grievance" is misleading. We are a rallying point for those who want to defend the right to freedom of expression.
Best,
Toby
The @Guardian then ran this story:
theguardian.com/us-news/2026…
You be the judge of whether you think this is good journalism.
11
I’m still pro-EU but this is spot on
As a nation we are skint, and many are suffering, because
(In order of magnitude):
1. We spent a generations wealth trying to track an airborne respiratory virus.
2. We decided to engage in unilateral economic disarmament by way of Net Zero, with the rest of the world looking on laughing whilst eating our lunch.
3. Leftwing “progressiveness” infected my party who allowed our institutions to be led by our left wing opponents, gave succour to Quangos and grew the state, all to be nice and not offend their dinner party friends.
4. Adherence to short term “popular” politics rather than harder, driven, long term needs of the country. Rather than tell the average voter they are like 6 year olds who haven’t learned delayed gratification we continue to give them biscuits when they scream. So in short a lack of leadership.
5. Incentivising idleness and punishing success.
The least consequential thing that’s happened in recent decades is Brexit, a marginal impact when compared to any of the above.
10
#Dubai - here we come
5 things 3 years in Dubai taught me that nothing else in life could have.
1. Safety isn’t a personality trait of a country. It’s a policy choice.
I leave my phone on a restaurant table here and the waiter chases me down the street to return it. The same phone in Paris gets stolen in 90 seconds. London has 91,000 phone thefts a year. SF has people stepping over fentanyl bodies on the way to meetings. None of this is about culture. It’s about which governments still bother enforcing the laws they have.
2. Low taxes don’t mean a broken state.
Dubai charges 0% income tax and delivers cleaner streets, faster hospitals, working metros, and a functional police force. France charges 53% and can’t give you a doctor in under 6 months. The problem in the West was never the tax rate. It was where the money actually ends up going.
3. Boring is the most underrated luxury in the modern world.
Just sunrise, coffee, and a city that works. Every Western capital feels exhausting within 48 hours of landing now.
4. Your environment beats your willpower every time.
In a place where the system isn’t fighting you, your output goes up without trying. Most Westerners spend half their daily energy just absorbing the friction their own country creates on purpose. Move to a place that works and your ceiling rises overnight.
5. The countries that lecture the loudest are always the ones quietly losing.
Europe spends every news cycle explaining why Dubai is “fake” or “soulless” or “doesn’t have culture.” Meanwhile every founder I know who actually has options ends up here within 18 months of visiting. Real winners don’t write op-eds about why they’re winning. They just keep raising their prices.
Best decision I ever made. 🇦🇪
30
This was my biggest fear about the philosophical & social consequences of Lockdown:
Do too many young people lack an appetite/resilience for working? Why are so many 16 to 24-year-olds claiming they're too ill to work? Obviously the welfare system is full of perverse incentives - you can be better off on benefits than with a job. But it seems there are deeper problems eating away at generational resilience - eg, the medicalisation of everyday problems, or the fact that many young people have internalised the Lockdown lesson that health trumps jobs, school, economy etc...
1
21
Jonny Dixon-Smith retweeted
I went to a state school.
I used to be against private schools. I used to think they were toffs & people who thought they were better than us.
Then I matured.
I now realise that in the main, the people who send their kids to one are just normal folk who have decided to prioritise best education for their children and often make significant sacrifice to do so. Alongside this, they also help fund the state education system, which they don’t use.
Whatever problems state schools face, it certainly isn’t as a result of private schools. If anything, kids going private eases pressure on the state system.
The closure of these schools are utterly tragic for the kids affected.
The policy attempts to damage the private system are an act of societal self-harm.
Anyone who celebrates it, is frankly, a fool.
edp24.co.uk/news/26058426.th…
Jonny Dixon-Smith retweeted
A shower screen shattered all over my wife this week.
Over the next 72 hours, the NHS got almost everything wrong.
A cautionary tale of a system that is broken (with the usual caveat that everyone working in it is doing their best) 👇
I called an ambulance.
All good at first: “It’s on its way.”
Ten minutes later: “Actually, there are no ambulances for hours - can you get her to hospital?”
So I loaded my bleeding wife into the car, along with the kids and the dog, and drove to A&E.
Ten hours later, she came home - having given up after not even being offered a plaster.
The next morning, we called our GP: “Any chance she could see a nurse?”
“No - as the ambulance referred her to hospital, we can’t see her.”
So I went to the pharmacy and bought a first aid kit.
Because apparently that’s where we are now - me and a pack of plasters, in one of the richest countries in the world.
This morning, still in pain, still untreated, and with a ballooning foot, we went to an urgent treatment centre.
At first, smooth. She was seen in under two hours. X-ray done.
“Nasty cut, but nothing broken.”
Relief.
Two hours later, the phone rang.
It was the hospital.
“Sorry - we got that completely wrong. Your foot is broken and the wound needs antibiotics.”
If it wasn’t so serious, it would be laughable.
And the truth is - anyone who uses the system has a story like this.
We need to stop clinging to an idealised version of the NHS and have a grown-up conversation about how to fix it.
Free healthcare for all should remain a principle - but pretending the current model works isn’t helping anyone.
Almost every other developed country combines public healthcare with some level of private provision - and all deliver better outcomes as a result.
Yet in the UK, even suggesting that tends to get shut down before the conversation starts.
That’s not protecting the NHS. It’s protecting a cult.
We don’t need ideology. We need honesty about what works.
We need a brilliant NHS in practice for all of us - not one we’re told to revere while it quietly crumbles, and where anyone who speaks up is dismissed or discredited.
When are we going to get serious about the things that actually matter - and have the difficult national conversations needed to fix them?
We don’t need to abandon the NHS.
We need to be honest about fixing it.
We shouldn’t just shrug our shoulders.
We have to be better.
We need to vote for real change.
Our refusal to change the NHS is obsessive to the point of insanity, given the data. Suicidal empathy , to quote @GadSaad
This is the reason why we can never reform healthcare in the UK — or even have a sensible debate about it.
The moment anyone suggests alternative/additional ways of funding health Labour rushes out privatisation smears and claims US private health insurance is being proposed.
Labour has been doing it for decades. It explains why the NHS is effectively beyond reform.
The two worst health systems in the rich world are in America and the UK. It’s why nobody has ever copied them. It would be mad to go from ours to theirs (or vice versa).
But Europe is awash with health systems that can call on several sources of funds, including many with compulsory public health insurance schemes. They have better health outcomes than the NHS. They are free at the point of use (like the NHS). Most of them are better funded.
But Labour puts them out of bounds, refuses even to discuss or consider. So patient care suffers. NHS struggles on.
Labour is always telling us we need to get closer to Europe. It’s where we belong. But not when it comes to health, where it insists no lessons can be learned. Pretty pathetic, really.
32
Jonny Dixon-Smith retweeted
The Islamic regime in Iran is the one that just a few weeks ago slaughtered 32,000 protestors, and then,
when relatives came for the bodies, demanded payment for them
One of the nastiest regimes the modern world had ever known, now supported by many of the marchers
Jonny Dixon-Smith retweeted
It's not just phonics: Schools have failed to teach reading because they ignore 50+ years of findings in cognitive psychology that reading depends on general knowledge. ED Hirsch has been banging this drum for a long time but Ed Schools shut their ears because the whole idea was unromantic & had a vaguely right-wing aroma. Now he joins with Dan Willingham to make a strong case that kids can't read if they don't have the background knowledge that makes sense of the rarer vocabulary, allusions, and understandings that allow us to read between the lines - which all reading requires. educationnext.org/rediscover…
Jonny Dixon-Smith retweeted
🚨 Wow. The Islamic Regime in Iran has f*cked up that bad that the Arab states and Islamic countries have completely called them out.
Saudi Foreign Minister:
“I do not understand how they claim to defend Islamic causes while attacking Islamic countries”
"They are not attacking just one nation — Saudi Arabia, Bahrain, Kuwait, Qatar, the UAE, Oman, Lebanon, Jordan, Iraq, Türkiye, all are Islamic countries, and all have been targeted."
"Even before this war, what was Iran’s contribution to the Islamic world?"
Isn’t it mad that the Arab world hates the Iranian Regime but there are some in the West seemingly support the regime? (we all know it’s only because these people hate Israel)
Proud to say, I attended both 🙌👍🙏
Two London Protests in May 2021 - during lockdown measures, covid jab rollout and mandates - prior to being 'granted freedom' in July 2021, both attended by hundreds of thousands of people.
I need to say this again; unapologetically, and without dilution. A slightly emotional moment here, anyone who lived it will understand... others just want to forget.
To the people who stood up in 2020 and kept standing when it would have been safer, easier and more convenient to acquiesce - you matter more than history will ever properly record. This one's for you, the un-'vaccinated,' the early freedom fighters.
Anyone who 'woke up' and spoke up in 2022 or later will never understand what it was like. They cannot. There has been nothing - not before, not since - that compares to the psychological warfare, the social exile, the professional destruction, the coordinated humiliation of those years. It was singular. It was relentless. It was designed to break people.
And still, you stood.
You were mocked as irrational. Painted as dangerous. Deplatformed. Censored. 'Fact-checked.' Threatened. Arrested. Some of you were physically assaulted. Some lost careers, friends, reputations, family. The hostility didn’t just come from institutions, it came from neighbours, colleagues, strangers in the street. From the self-proclaimed 'compassionate.' From the enforcers of 'safety.' From police who forgot restraint. From citizens who forgot humanity.
I know. Because I was there. I was arrested - sometimes violently - beaten, charged and convicted. Multiple times. Arrested as a terrorist and placed on a watch-list as a 'prolific anti-vaxxer.'
They tried to outlaw your speech - literally. They tried to erase your questions. They wanted silence... total, obedient silence.
And you refused.
History has a pattern: the people who are first to speak are always punished hardest. It is only later - when the dust settles and the narrative softens - that others cautiously admit what those early dissenters endured.
But those of us who were there know.
We know the cost.
We know the fear.
We know how alone it felt.
And we also know this: without those stubborn, 'crazy,' humanitarian, brave souls who refused to comply, who tried to inform others - the damage would have been worse. The injuries. The deaths.
You were not reckless. You were resolute. You were not selfish. You were principled.
You were not insane. You were early.
And whether the world acknowledges it or not; lives were saved because you would not be intimidated or coerced into silence.
That kind of courage doesn’t disappear just because the headlines move on.
It remains.
And it matters.
Still.
If you survived that.
If you did not acquiesce.
If you kept fighting...
I know I’ll see you soon.
Because that time was not just a test of compliance for the masses, it was a test of endurance.
And you passed.
Now, get ready... once again. We warned about what's looming, too. And we cannot afford to be 'vindicated' in the same way again. We must stop it in its tracks.
But this time, the army is larger.
The truth has spread farther.
The awareness is greater.
And our strength - tested, forged, unyielding - stands truly fucking steadfast.
Thanks to @OracleFilmsUK for making sure history - and the truth - was captured and preserved.
13
I accept the some of what Trump does is insane but the media bias against him is unhelpful. The world has changed ; globalism has failed; and Donald Trump is shaking things up - we need to realise that
34
#education #edutwitter - what do you think ?
The scrapping of an Eton-backed free sixth form in Middlesbrough tells us more about Labour than any manifesto ever could. A project designed to educate the brightest children from one of the poorest parts of the country was not stopped because it failed, cost too much, or lacked need. It was stopped because it threatened to succeed. And success, when it cannot be controlled, is intolerable to this government.
This was not a fee-paying outpost or a vanity scheme. It was a free school, approved under the last government, partnered with a proven academy trust, aimed squarely at deprived pupils with high academic ability. The offer was simple: take children who show promise and give them an education equal to the best in the country. That should have been uncontroversial. Instead it triggered hostility, suspicion, and finally cancellation. Not because of what it would have done, but because of what it symbolised.
The real offence was a four-letter word: Eton College. That name short-circuited reason. Local Labour figures spoke of "elitism" while opposing a free school for poor children. Ministers talked about surplus places and SEND funding while quietly abandoning a project already designed to address a regional attainment gap that everyone admits exists. None of it holds up. The explanations came after the decision, not before it.
Look at the facts Labour prefers not to dwell on. The North East lags badly behind London on A-level results and university entry. That gap has widened, not narrowed. This school was explicitly designed to deal with the A-level drop-off that has trapped bright pupils in the region for years. Its location was central, its funding secure, its academic model tested. Scrapping it did nothing to help SEND pupils and nothing to raise standards elsewhere. It simply removed an option that would have worked.
What happened in Middlesbrough fits a pattern we have already seen. When schools succeed by insisting on discipline, knowledge, and high expectations, the response from Labour is not curiosity but suspicion. Not imitation but obstruction. Katharine Birbalsingh and Michaela showed what happens when deprived children are taken seriously. Instead of being celebrated, that success is treated as a problem to be managed. The lesson is the same here: excellence outside the approved model must be neutralised.
The Education Secretary, Bridget Phillipson, claims the money could be better spent elsewhere. That argument collapses on contact with reality. Identical Eton-Star colleges have been approved in other Labour-run areas. The money exists. The model is acceptable. What differed in Middlesbrough was not need, but politics. Local ideological resistance was indulged, and bright children paid the price.
This is the quiet cruelty of modern Labour education policy. It speaks endlessly about disadvantage while dismantling the very ladders that allow people to climb out of it. It treats aspiration as a threat and excellence as exclusion. It would rather keep everyone inside a failing system than allow some to rise beyond it, because rising exposes the lie that background is destiny.
We are told this is about fairness. It is not. Fairness would mean expanding opportunity wherever it appears. What Labour practices instead is levelling by denial. If not everyone can have something, no one should. If a school might allow working-class children to outperform expectations, it must be stopped in case it embarrasses the system.
Middlesbrough did not lose a school. It lost permission to excel. A message was sent to its brightest children: know your place. That is not compassion. It is control. And until Labour grasps the difference, it will keep dressing envy up as justice and calling restraint care. Ministers will feel nothing. Children will pay the price.
"Bridget Phillipson, claims the money could be better spent elsewhere. That argument collapses on contact with reality."
18




















