
Physics with @ALICEexperiment @CERN, cycling (not that fast), supporting @Official_Darlo
England, United Kingdom
Joined November 2009
- Tweets679
- Following264
- Followers166
- Likes817
Lee Barnby 🇪🇺 retweeted
As a professor, I am often asked: Should students use AI coding agents for their research?
I have also been trying to understand this question myself, but until now, I had mostly learned about students’ use of AI indirectly, through conversations with them or by seeing the final results. It is rare to have a long, uninterrupted period in which I can closely observe how they actually work, what they delegate to AI, and how their decisions evolve from day to day.
The past three weeks at the Telluride Neuromorphic Workshop offered exactly that opportunity. Students propose their own innovative science and engineering projects, form teams, and work toward a demoable final presentation over three weeks. Here are a few things I noticed:
1. Productivity increased dramatically with AI. This was evident across both engineering and scientific projects. The ability to prototype an idea quickly has never felt so powerful or direct until I sat down with the students and observed their coding pipelines. For instance, one integrated-circuit group developed an asynchronous microcontroller with custom instructions, connected it to event-based sensors, deployed it on an FPGA, and produced a runnable demo with C code and a polished, configurable web interface. Completing all of this in three weeks would have been almost unthinkable a few years ago. Contrary to what people sometimes presume, many amazing ideas still emerge from discussion, while the Claude tokens are burning in the background.
2. Students are under peer pressure to use AI to keep up with the rapid pace of development. I noticed that students were more likely to use coding agents when other members of their teams were already using AI to finish their parts. Once some students begin moving much faster, the pressure to produce comparable results becomes very real.
3. The time budget shifts from debugging to planning. I noticed that students spent significantly more time planning their next steps while leaving much of the tedious plumbing work to coding agents. I saw far fewer of the typical frustrations caused by a “stupid bug,” which allowed students to focus more directly on system design and the actual problem they were trying to solve.
4. AI can be more focused on engineering solutions than scientific exploration. Students sometimes found that coding agents concentrated narrowly on solving the problem stated in the prompt, while overlooking instructions to branch out or explore less conventional possibilities. Instead of substantially modifying an established solution or pursuing a risky new direction, coding agents often preferred a safer implementation that was more likely to work. This is useful for engineering, but it can also discourage the kind of uncertain exploration that leads to genuinely novel research.
5. The biggest concern is understanding. Students increasingly delegate entire tasks to AI, which sometimes leads them to present systems or results that they do not fully understand. This is clearly harmful because it removes both the intellectual ownership and the educational value of academic research. A working demo is not enough if the student cannot explain why it works, where it may fail, and which technical decisions shaped the final result.
My conclusion is that AI in research is no longer optional. We need to embrace this change, but we must also separate two objectives that are often conflated: education and research project execution. Students benefit most from AI when they already understand the fundamentals, and when they use it to remove repetitive engineering work so that they can focus more deeply on the core scientific questions.
Students should still own the questions, the decisions, and the interpretation, even if AI writes much of the plumbing. My lab may soon become more AI-enabled. The challenge will be making sure the agents accelerate the research without becoming the researchers
#AI #Research #Engineering #Education
Brilliant
The company hired me to lead their "Agile Transformation."
I don't know what Agile means.
Nobody does.
That's why it works.
I make $425,000 a year.
To move sticky notes.
From left to right.
On a board.
The board is digital now.
The sticky notes cost $80,000 in Jira licenses.
Progress.
Day one, I said "we need to break down silos."
Everyone nodded.
Silos are bad.
I don't know why.
But destroying them is a career.
My career.
I introduced "squads."
Squads are teams.
But disrupted.
We disrupted the teams into teams.
Different names.
Same people.
Same problems.
But Agile problems now.
Agile problems are strategic.
A senior engineer asked what we're actually changing.
I said, "The mindset."
He asked what that means.
I said, "It's a journey."
He asked where we're going.
I said, "Toward agility."
He asked what agility means.
I pointed at the sticky notes.
They were moving left to right.
That's velocity.
We have velocity now.
The VP of Engineering said two-week sprints don't fit their work.
I said, "That's waterfall thinking."
Waterfall is bad.
Like silos.
I don't know what waterfall is.
But I know it's bad.
She stopped talking.
Waterfall accusations end conversations.
We had a retrospective.
In the retro, we discussed what went wrong.
Everything went wrong.
We put it on sticky notes.
Then we moved the sticky notes.
Into a column called "Parking Lot."
The Parking Lot is where problems go to die.
It's full.
We don't look at it.
That's agile.
Velocity is up 40%.
I defined velocity.
I also defined the points.
I also defined the stories.
We're crushing it.
At the things I made up.
To measure.
Ourselves.
The CEO asked for ROI.
I showed a chart.
The chart went up.
Charts should go up.
This one did.
I didn't label the Y-axis.
Nobody asked.
Leadership is confidence.
We do standups now.
Every day.
We stand.
For 45 minutes.
Standing is agile.
Sitting is waterfall.
My legs hurt.
But we're transforming.
The transformation is now "Phase 3."
Phase 1 was assessment.
Phase 2 was implementation.
Phase 3 is "continuous improvement."
Continuous means forever.
Forever means job security.
I'm very secure.
My contract was extended.
Three more years.
For "cultural impact."
The culture is confused.
But impacted.
Agile transformation isn't about being agile.
It's about transforming.
Continuously.
Toward more transformation.
The destination is the journey.
The journey is billable.
302
Another @ALICEexperiment result showing creativity in going outside of the original goals
[Press Update] ALICE solves mystery of light-nuclei survival
Find out more: home.cern/news/news/experime…
249
Action Against Illegal Waste site on the River Cherwell - urgent action needed. Please sign the Petition! c.org/xqmGTbBPj5 via @UKChange
73
Introducing the Clartiverse™ telescoper.blog/2025/02/16/i… via @telescoper
96
Lovely early evening 🌈 view from @DerbyUni Markeaton Street campus.
Fantastic team performance by @Official_Darlo 11 men putting everything into it from start to finish.
1
81
First @Official_Darlo game of the season 🤞Away at @ROFCOfficial
2
174
Lee Barnby 🇪🇺 retweeted
10 years of ALICE physics just got published!
home.cern/.../ten-year-journ…...
link.springer.com/.../10.../…
#cern #physics #particlephysics #Quantum
Good event with excellent talks from industry speakers.
This Post is from an account that no longer exists. Learn more
1
167
Renewed. Mine was 666th pledge 👹
𝗕𝗢𝗢𝗦𝗧 𝗧𝗛𝗘 𝗕𝗨𝗗𝗚𝗘𝗧 24/25 The Final Day!
You have raised over £150,000 and we are within £25,000 of this year's target 👏
Every penny will boost Steve and Terry's playing budget for next season
You can pledge 👇
yourclub.darlingtonfc.co.uk/…
#WeAreDarlo #YourClub
141
Just re-tweeting (X-ing?) my LinkedIn post with a link to my studentship opportunity. I am re-advertising for September 2024. Please let potential PhD students know. Deadline 13 May. linkedin.com/posts/leebarnby…
Shame I can’t be there but we resumed the semester here in Derby already! I can just imagine Alison saying this sort of thing.
It's day 2 of #IopAppHeppNp2024 and the weather is, as Alison (session chair) says, perfect for a conference. Nuclear and Astroparticle physics await!
1
107
Bought my first rail season ticket for over 4 years - £960 for 6 working weeks (1m 10d)! First train was cancelled, not an auspicious start. It was cheaper, by £19.50, to buy two tickets with an intermediate station. A return would cost £125.80 so substantial saving but … 1/n
2
1
127
… I don't use those because there are no *day* returns on this route. In fact it is cheaper to split tickets, at a different station to that above, and buy 2 day returns which total £52.40, or £43.40 if you are willing to change stations at Birmingham. However … 2/n
60
Oui au train direct de Londres à Genève ! / Yes to a direct London-Geneva train ! - Sign the Petition! chng.it/87SynNNH via @UKChange This would be great 5 hours London-Geneva. Also Derby is only 90 minutes from St. Pancras
63













