CanadaFella (@maplebonk) profile picture

There is no CIA

In Your Head, Rent Free
Joined November 2020
Photo by CanadaFella (@maplebonk)Photo by CanadaFella (@maplebonk)Photo by CanadaFella (@maplebonk)Photo by CanadaFella (@maplebonk)Photo by CanadaFella (@maplebonk)Photo by CanadaFella (@maplebonk)Photo by CanadaFella (@maplebonk)Photo by CanadaFella (@maplebonk)Photo by CanadaFella (@maplebonk)Photo by CanadaFella (@maplebonk)
This guy thinks a meeting of 19 reform rabbis in America in 1885, in which they self admittedly reversed thousands of years of Jewish self identification as a nation seeking a return to its homeland, is somehow a strong argument in his favour.
The entire Adam Louis-Klein (@adam_louis52328) discourse on the alleged "Nazi-Soviet" origins of antizionism conflates the history of anti-Zionist propaganda with the intellectual and political history of antizionism itself. Antizionism didn't emerge from the Nazis or Soviet Union (lol). It emerged, in recognizable form, from internal Jewish discourses, decades before either regime existed. For example, a common anti-zionist argument seen today is that Jews are not a single (ethnic) nation. In pic related, we see the same argument articulated from the Central Conference of American Rabbis, the leading body of Reform Judaism, in its 1885 Declaration of Principles, effectively rejecting the idea of ethnical claims based on claims of descent from nations that existed 2,000 years ago. (We are of course now told that it is "hate" to agree with the position of the Central Conference of American Rabbis.*) This was articulated 82 years before the Soviet Union even got substantially involved in anti-Zionist propaganda. Palestinian-Arab thinkers also got involved in antizionism - after Jews, but long before any substantive propaganda role by the Nazis or Soviet Union. Speaking of anti-Zionist propaganda by states (the USSR, the Nazis, etc): Louis-Klein, as I mentioned, mistakes this propaganda for substantive ideological innovation. While both regimes engaged in anti-Zionist propaganda, they were appropriating existing discourses for their own ends. The Nazis and USSR played no substantial role in developing anti-Zionist thought. These states were just cynically adopting an anti-zionist position for reasons of geopolitics. Interestingly, the Nazis initially claimed to be sympathetic to the Zionists in the first several years of the regime, e.g. according Zionist organizations for German Jews privileges that no other Jewish organization enjoyed. This history should be seen with cynicism. For the Nazis, who of course had no interest in a Jewish state, promoting Zionism was a cynical exercise in pursuit of a broader political aim, namely encouraging Jews to emigrate from Germany. Some of the sillier antizionists read this history as proof of a substantive ideological affinity between Nazism and Zionism. Adam Louis-Klein is just as tendentious when he infers a deep ideological affinity between Soviet Communism and antizionism, or claims that the Soviets and the Nazis played a substantial role in developing antizionist thought. * Like many anti-zionist Jewish groups, the Council changed its position to pro-Zionist in response to Nazi persecution of the Jews.
7
You failed to read the definition.
43
Alonso is incorrect here. The definition of apartheid doesn’t not require the below to be apartheid.
Yeah, again, either ignorant or racist. Apartheid subjected people do conditions of life calculated to bring about their destruction. This is literally in the legal definition
7
146
This person is such a failure at life they need to blame Jews to feel better. Pathetic really.
Hahaha they called you out for blocking like a pussy. Get my country's name out of your profile, goywhipped mutt. Youre no real Canadian with this amount of Israel defending, move south into the country they already fully control
1
5
60
This person is too stupid to understand the issue here lol. Too funny.
Replying to @maplebonk
Learn to read a map, retard.
1
106
This guy is an inveterate liar.
No I called you racist for saying apartheid *did not intend to kill Black SA*. It does not need to be genocide to be murderous. You actually defended the apartheid’s record as *not killing*
1
6
74
He called everyone who disagreed with his views a racist. This is the perfect demonstration of how @Alonso_GD is a hack. He knows his views are fringe and rejected by the majority of scholars, activists and the TRC but argues that everyone who disagrees with him must be evil.
Replying to @KenanPerry
I think it is pretty clear I think he is correct and that I’m saying his views are in the minority. Do you think you’re very smart for picking this up or something
1
8
94
This was not the outcome of the case lol. At all.
unavailable
43
David is a virulent and conspiratorial antisemite of the lowest degrees and anyone who thinks he should be allowed in regular society is likewise a racist.
Replying to @NafeezAhmed
@Tracking_Power has done more for the AntiZionist movement than most people If it wasn’t for his NPO on @habibi_uk there would be no Ben Tait story I’m feeling disappointed at reading your response. David may not be perfect like most flawed human beings but he is entitled to his views. Stand up for something more than Government propaganda
53
Alonso is categorically incorrect here and should know better. Batustans were not meant to eliminate black South Africans. For example, about 7 people out of 500-600k survived Belzec death camp.
I’m sorry, again, are you defending the bantustans as *not* eliminationist in nature? Do you think people were *not* meant to die there? Bc yes, that is either ignorant or racist.
24
This says a lot about the academic milieu that @Alonso_GD operates in. Unable to actually engage with criticism, he resorted to baseless ad hominem, which itself is a pretty explicit admission that he has nothing of value to add. Pathetic.
Again, are you defending apartheid as not eliminationist? Just say it - say “I think the bantustans were fine, people were not meant to die there”. Complete your apartheid minimisation already
1
3
14
370
We should all be reminded that this “academic” argued that every stream in Israel was a military base before. He is a clown who lobs baseless insults because he cannot actually refute the arguments.
4
43
This professor is actually just a clown with a piece of paper. This is deeply pathetic and should send a clear message about what a disingenuous and malicious scumbag this person is.
Again, are you defending apartheid as not eliminationist? Just say it - say “I think the bantustans were fine, people were not meant to die there”. Complete your apartheid minimisation already
4
14
209
A key material difference, Nazism had at its core the necessity of eliminating Jews globally. This isn’t a difference of means but fundamental ideological demands. It’s wild to see professors showing their whole ass so willingly. @Alonso_GD is a fool.
No, bc that is not the claim. The claim is precisely the opposite. That the specific methods were different, but the ideologies are not materially different. You’re the only one here making rankings about human suffering
1
3
42
If he opposes “hierarchies of human suffering” then by definition they both have to be equal.
I’ve not said they are equally bad. Neither did Asmal. I’m precisely arguing against hierarchies of human suffering. I’m saying there is no meaningful difference between the ideology of hate that led to apartheid and the one that led to the holocaust, 2 of humanity’s worst crimes
1
10
409
This is an obviously AI generated video. @AndrewVAD is a moron.
unavailable
1
1
52
Needless to say, this is an AI generated video and @AndrewVAD is seemingly unable to admit it, though he makes clear he knows. You don’t need to push AI videos to support Palestinians and it says a lot that you do so.
19
Well let’s add history to things @ismail_lamie displays incompetence on. France had just lost the Algerian war and the suez crisis, they wanted to avoid inflaming relations with the Arab states, especially given it was French jets used to destroy Arab airforces on the ground.
Replying to @Cassandre587605
Pourquoi la France (fournisseur d’armes principal d’Israël à l’époque) a-t-elle imposé un embargo sur les armes contre Israël après cet acte d’agression? (C’était sous De Gaulle d’ailleurs 😊)
1
5
230
This guy lasts he does “international law work” and is vague on describing what he does because in actuality he has no professional experience working in IHL. He does commercial arbitration work. He’s intentional in this obfuscation as well.
Replying to @colwight @grok
I’ll let you and Grok jerk each other off whilst I do actual international law work. Have fun buddy 😊
1
8
240
“Zionists risk their lives”? Yes. The entire IDF consists of Zionists lol.
Replying to @Aaron98_89
This would be strategic. Not sure it would be necessary to destroy Israel. We could potentially just make sure they lose all their influence and power to destroy the world—disarm them. Israel would never let an American cross into Gaza to fight against them. Zionists risk their lives? Watch the video again.
2
33