Phillip Dolitsky (@phillyd97) header
Phillip Dolitsky (@phillyd97) profile picture

Currently Off X | Speechwriter | Military Strategist and Ethicist | Thinking things, not words | Unrelenting Realist | Analog Life Enthusiast |

Joined March 2012
Photo by Phillip Dolitsky (@phillyd97)Photo by Phillip Dolitsky (@phillyd97)Photo by Phillip Dolitsky (@phillyd97)Photo by Phillip Dolitsky (@phillyd97)Photo by Phillip Dolitsky (@phillyd97)Photo by Phillip Dolitsky (@phillyd97)Photo by Phillip Dolitsky (@phillyd97)Photo by Phillip Dolitsky (@phillyd97)Photo by Phillip Dolitsky (@phillyd97)Photo by Phillip Dolitsky (@phillyd97)
Logging off X for a little bit. Find me at my Substack if you'd like to connect!
3
530
An unforgettable trip to New River Gorge National Park There is real beauty out there in the world. All it takes is to look up
3
165
But the internet is unfiltered on the Tesla...
Rav Gershon Ribner: Every Ben Torah should buy a Tesla, even if you can't afford it. Says it's pashut bitul Torah not to drive one. sites.libsyn.com/252176/bein…
3
349
Taking a break from my Twitter break to highlight this great essay in @EngelsbergIdeas by @Benjamin__Rhode If you've never written or received a letter written in fountain pen, you're missing out on the sublime. The lost magic of the fountain pen engelsbergideas.com/notebook…
2
154
Taking a break from my Twitter break to just say that I’ve been reading this book and am finding it really incredible. Ramban has not gotten his scholarly due, so this is a truly monumental work. Learning so much on every page
5
2
19
1,799
The crisis facing Western statecraft isn’t too much legalism or too little realism. It’s a crisis of formation. Why the polymath-statesman disappeared – and why that matters now. My new essay for @EngelsbergIdeas
The great European statesmen of the 19th century understood that diplomacy is a fine art, which requires a cultivated mind and the courage to cross narrow disciplinary boundaries. The lost art of statecraft | @ChountisFabbri engelsbergideas.com/essays/t…
6
16
1
59
7,483
Very grateful to the fine folks at @EngelsbergIdeas for turning the essay I wrote with @lukemoon1 into an audio essay. Give it a listen!
2
185
Phillip Dolitsky retweeted
This is a magnificently excellent essay from @milstrategymag & @phillyd97. I cannot recommend it enough. Below is the core message in an extended excerpt, with which I entirely agree, that transcends the single issue of Truman's decision on the atomic bombing of Japan. It deals with the inescapable tragedy of high statescraft in a fallen, Hobbesian world: "Politics, Machiavelli told us, is the realm of tragedy. If a moral and ethical system cannot accommodate that fact of political life, if it cannot speak to real life and war as we must live and act within it, one’s moral system, it seems to me, lacks morality. I do not say this casually at all. My teacher, Rabbi Aharon Lichtenstein, once noted that fidelity to Halakha, Jewish Law, is at times “agonizing,” and that the role of the posek, a decider on Jewish Law, is one of the most agonizing and painful positions to occupy.[11] Rabbi Lichtenstein noted that the posek is very often “confronted by situations in which Halakha comes into apparent conflict with human needs – not simply with shallow utilitarian desires, but with genuinely worthwhile needs. Under these circumstances, the process of decision can be soul searing.” In many instances, he notes, the confrontation 'may be absolutely irreducible, the result being genuine tragedy.' In other words, the posek’s position is soul searing precisely because he cannot abstain from action. Neither too can the statesman or his strategists. He must take part in a world of action. If we are to live on this side of heaven, genuine values will inevitably compete with one another, especially in that all too human activity we call war. Great leaders of all stripes, we hope, will rise to the challenge and grapple mightily with that competition of values. They might, like Secretary of War Henry Stimson, have a heart attack because of how brutal and agonizing it is to act in a world of competing values. But a moral system—certainly moral judgement—has to contend with this fact. Moral thinkers who do not and will not contend with the reality that Truman faced, who will not offer or propose serious alternatives in the world of action, engage in a certain dereliction of moral duty that I find too bitter to attempt swallowing. We now know what the alternative courses of actions were available to the president. Knowing that, did he choose wrong? I think not." This reminds me of a letter Kissinger wrote to his parents after serving in the US Army in occupied Germany after the Holocaust, "To me there is not right or wrong but many shades in between. "The real tragedies in life are not in choices between right and wrong. Only the most callous of persons choose what they know to be wrong…Real dilemmas are difficulties of the soul, provoking agonies, which you in your world of black and white can’t even begin to comprehend.” Those who refuse to act in order to keep their hands clean from the blood of necessity are unfit for leadership.
“To sit at the corner of strategy and ethics is to sit in a very lonely intersection. But because the two interact, they are worthy of our serious thinking and consideration.” A strikingly apt and thought-provoking article, not to be missed. Always free to read 👉 msml.ink/4n2igqn #Strategy #MilitaryEthics #MilitaryStrategy #Japan #Gaza #usarmy #IDF
1
1
2
433
A spectacular essay from one of our greatest foreign policy thinkers, @RLHeinrichs. I think we also have to recognize that many on the right have finally seen the allure of the postmodern worldview/philosophy. The left used it deftly for years, some on the right are using it now
My first essay in the @TheFP, on the push to rewrite America’s identity to turn her focus inward and to turn her back to the world she helped build.
1
2
8
1,752
Oh, he's an honest historian? Name all historians
The true history of the Jeffrey Epstein case, from America’s most honest historian. Darryl Cooper, live. Thursday, 8PM Eastern.
3
2
515
Here is why you should not be using #ChatGPT by @OpenAI. After it gave me false quotes and page numbers on Bernard Brodie's views on escalation, I told it that I was fact checking it and that everything it said was wrong. And this was its response. ChatGPT knows it lies!
1
1
271
I have the privilege tonight of addressing a group of grad students about strategy. One of the points I'd like to make to them tonight echoes @AaronBMacLean's point here: avoid AI. Just to prove a point, I asked ChatGPT to tell me about Bernard Brodie's views on escalation 1/
2
3
8
1,939
It began spitting out quotes and lines and page numbers, and then says: "[Strategy in the Missile Age] This is Brodie’s most important and comprehensive treatment of escalation. Especially chapters 11–13." That book does not have 13 chapters! Nothing was correct! 2/
1
146
As I discussed in a recent piece for @RCDefense, the strategist needs to be a sort of caveman. Strategy requires a retreat, and it most certainly requires a commitment to not use LLM that are all to quick to spit out falsehoods. realcleardefense.com/article… 3/3
132
Phillip Dolitsky retweeted
Suppressing viewpoint diversity can harm learning. It does not follow that promoting it helps learning. What our universities need is to restore the value of learning. By contrast, aiming for "viewpoint diversity" endangers learning further.
Replying to @BrandonWarmke
Also: it’s very weird to have the view that academic institutions could fulfill the their research and teaching functions if everyone had the same beliefs. Of course viewpoint diversity is valuable.
3
10
4
81
10,726
"I Thank The Gods of War We Went When We Did" Reflections From My Trip to Europe, by @phillyd97 open.substack.com/pub/philso…
82
Do any of my writer friends here use Scrivener instead of Word? Do you like it? Why?
129
Phillip Dolitsky retweeted
We created AI in our image, so I really don’t know what people were expecting would happen.
8
17
5
164
6,368