Reality-Based Lawyer (@realitybasedlaw) header
Reality-Based Lawyer (@realitybasedlaw) profile picture

Attorney, landlady, feminist in LA County, fighting for rational rental laws. Former newspaper journo. Non-socialist YIMBY. Grew up in Glendale rental housing.

Palmdale, CA
Joined December 2025
Activists: "Landlording is inherently abusive and exploitive." Landlord: (uses the Ellis Act to stop landlording) Activists: "oh no, we must END THE ELLIS ACT"
The Ellis Act is enemy #1 of tenant groups when you browse their social media pages. It's what they fear the most. Those units are out of the rental market forever, it's harder to change state law, and the evictions are harder to dismiss.
2
4
462
85,627
Except: Just Cause laws discourage landlords from selling and going away. Tenant activists don't want landlords gone. They want them trapped.
24
Holy cow. Takes a $100k payment to the tenant of a single-family house to get them to leave so the owner can sell in Pasadena? I knew things were bad. But not that bad.
In Pasadena, we are seeing $50,000 to $100,000 extortion payments in order to sell houses that are tenant occupied right now.
4
4
23
619
Dependency (child welfare) law and eviction law are similar in important ways. Both involve someone else having possession of something of yours, so delays work against you. In both, it's a lot harder to get back possession than most people think it is.
Jason really needs to get his rear in gear and start doing monitored visits with his baby and working a reunification plan. IRL everything depends on the free parent when the kid is a court dependent and the other parent is incarcerated. Asking Lucia "How's the little man?" when she calls from prison does not bode well for his fatherly involvement.
105
Looks like Jason and Lucia's baby is placed with a relative, which may be helpful. But not always. They're on the same strict reunification timeline, and relatives, just like unrelated foster parents, are often eager to adopt young children.
Jason really needs to get his rear in gear and start doing monitored visits with his baby and working a reunification plan. IRL everything depends on the free parent when the kid is a court dependent and the other parent is incarcerated. Asking Lucia "How's the little man?" when she calls from prison does not bode well for his fatherly involvement.
84
Boggles my mind how many normal, smart people still don't understand that rent control also, always, means eviction control. It means leases can't end, and that a landlord can no longer terminate based on a no-fault 30- or 60-day notice. Any rent control has to also prohibit leases ending. Otherwise, landlords would get out of rent control by nonrenewal or the no-fault notices when the rent is under market.
30
16
2
309
78,813
For everyone nitpicking this post about "they CAN evict to sell": If a law makes it extremely expensive and time-consuming to exercise a right, it's almost like not having that right. @SinaiLawFirm was correct about everything that matters. All these Just Cause Ordinances are forced, by the state's Ellis Act, to provide some way for property owners to evict to sell their house, ie, exit the rental market. But the politicians hate it. It would never pass in today's climate. So, they impose high relocation costs, require lengthy notice, and create procedural stumbling blocks. Meanwhile, they tell voters "sure, you can evict to sell." But if it takes $25k+ up front in relocation money, plus a year notice, plus lots of bureaucratic compliance, and then you still have to file an eviction case if the tenant doesn't leave, and that costs you another $25K in legal fees and another six months, well ... You can see why an 85-year-old Sun Village homeowner would be upset when she finds out what it takes to get her loser relative out so she can raise money for elder care.
Starting January 2027, almost all single family homes, condos, and new apartments in west LA will have just cause renter protections. This means that if you lease a home for rent the tenant can stay there forever as long as they pay the rent and don't break the lease. You can't terminate the lease if it expires and you can't ask the tenant to leave if you want to sell. That's true for the following cities: Los Angeles City LA County unincorporated Culver City West Hollywood Santa Monica Pasadena
5
11
56
2,107
You could tell progressive Californians that mandatory female circumcision "prevents homelessness," and they'd cheer it. Until the bad occupant is on their property. Then it's "why can't we just change the locks?"
Replying to @realitybasedlaw
what are you bitching about? sounds very fair. And keep people from being homeless.
1
7
391
Another problem in our all-too-common scenario with the loser relative paying a token rent: Even if the tenant doesn't pay his pittance, LA County doesn't allow eviction until he is behind more than two months of "Fair Market Value," not of his actual, low rent. FMV for a 1BR in LA County is $2,402/mo. You can't evict him until he's $4,804 behind. So, if you're charging him $300, he can go 16 months without paying a cent before you can even give him a pay-or-quit notice. And as long as he keeps his balance shaved down to just below the minimum, you can't do anything about the $4,803 he's behind. It's a permanent loan. And no, if it's a duplex, ADU, or other multifamily unit, you can't raise his rent to FMV in the unincorporated county. You're under strict rent control, no matter how far under market his rent is.
Replying to @realitybasedlaw
Can you raise the rent to the maximum so he can’t pay? Then evict? I see why people turn to foul play.
6
9
1
79
4,990
Jason really needs to get his rear in gear and start doing monitored visits with his baby and working a reunification plan. IRL everything depends on the free parent when the kid is a court dependent and the other parent is incarcerated. Asking Lucia "How's the little man?" when she calls from prison does not bode well for his fatherly involvement.
1
1
1
8
460
In real life, Jason and Lucia in GTA6 would probably not get their kid back. It's been too long. Here's how foster care works: There's a court case. You either get ordered a reunification plan at the beginning, by the court, or you don't. If you're allowed reunification (not happening if you're in prison for years), you get evaluated in six-month time periods. For a baby, you're only supposed to get six months total. If the court decides you're not ready in six months, your parental rights are terminated. That's permanent. The baby's current foster parents adopt him. No contact unless they choose to allow it.
1
1
10
1,350
Unincorporated LA County has all these same restrictions. But unlike West LA, much of the unincorporated county is rural, still rents for less than $1000, and has open desert within a block. Imagine letting your loser grandson stay in an old 1BR ADU for a few months in back of your 1950s house in rural Pearblossom for $300/month from his mental health disability check. It's supposed to be temporary while he gets things together, but of course he never does. Now, you want to sell the house so you can afford a retirement home. LA County says you have to 1) hire him a relocation consultant, and 2) pay him $12,688 relocation (it's higher because he's "low-income," as are nearly all unincorporated Antelope Valley tenants). Also, 3) he's entitled to a one-year extension on his move date, due to his depression and anxiety. If he takes the money and time, and still doesn't leave? You still have to go through eviction court, and he's still got the right to a jury trial and a free attorney from the county. If you're dealing with a large property, say, a 4BR house, they're entitled to $21,411. Regardless of what their rent is.
Starting January 2027, almost all single family homes, condos, and new apartments in west LA will have just cause renter protections. This means that if you lease a home for rent the tenant can stay there forever as long as they pay the rent and don't break the lease. You can't terminate the lease if it expires and you can't ask the tenant to leave if you want to sell. That's true for the following cities: Los Angeles City LA County unincorporated Culver City West Hollywood Santa Monica Pasadena
34
54
9
528
61,204
Let me clarify, there is no "city of West LA." (sorry, I don't go south of Acton much). This means "various jurisdictions that comprise the west LA area."
8
1,238
Reality-Based Lawyer retweeted
LA: We desperately need more housing. Also LA: Let’s make renting out that housing so legally risky that nobody wants to be a landlord.
Starting January 2027, almost all single family homes, condos, and new apartments in west LA will have just cause renter protections. This means that if you lease a home for rent the tenant can stay there forever as long as they pay the rent and don't break the lease. You can't terminate the lease if it expires and you can't ask the tenant to leave if you want to sell. That's true for the following cities: Los Angeles City LA County unincorporated Culver City West Hollywood Santa Monica Pasadena
42
118
1
1,761
52,055
Here's another trick: Calling it "Just Cause Eviction" when you outlaw the expiration of leases. Many normal people think Just Cause means, for example, you can't kick someone out for a discriminatory reason. They are surprised to learn it means you're limited to a narrow list of reasons you can make someone move. No more 60-Day notices. Sometimes, this even applies to guests who don't pay rent.
The greatest trick the urban left ever pulled is making the term “affordable housing” mean not “housing which is inexpensive” but rather “special, highly-regulated units which are legally mandated to be held at a below-market rate” Total linguistic coup
4
10
97
3,938
Reality-Based Lawyer retweeted
I have never seen the LA river even remotely close to this high. At what point does this bridge get closed?
199
323
28
1,391
41,680
When pols say they want to "preserve affordable housing" normal people think they mean, like, government shouldn't tear it down. Or maybe give people grants to fix it up. What it really means if that if you already charge low rent, they want to make it illegal for you to raise it. Thus "preserving" its affordability.
The greatest trick the urban left ever pulled is making the term “affordable housing” mean not “housing which is inexpensive” but rather “special, highly-regulated units which are legally mandated to be held at a below-market rate” Total linguistic coup
3
3
18
950
Anyone ever actually hired a relocation consultant? I have no idea where to find one or what they cost.
2
9
1,947
Remember, these are the people California progressives prioritize as the "poor" and "most vulnerable."
Replying to @amybarnes_usa
I can top that! Had a repeat offender stab a manager in the head with pinking shears. She'd already lost her lengthy eviction case, and a restraining order was granted against her. But she kept coming around the property as a "tenant organizer" lol. Police arrested her, but county dismissed her charges once she'd mentally stabilized. Despite the fact she had previous felony convictions for assaulting another landlord and poisoning his dog. She went on to be convicted of another felony for animal abuse ... at her supportive housing program. No lie. But she's still housed there.
16
928
AI makes it much easier for pro-pers to drive up eviction costs. I had a client give up recently against two nontenants whom her late husband had allowed to park their RV for free on the property (didn't realize they were *living* in it). They hoarded the area with junk, which caused the county to cite her, refused to let her throw away the junk, and refused to leave. Claimed she was harassing them for even asking. (Yes, I found criminal drug history.) She'd have won the jury trial. Their story was ridiculous, claiming they were tenants because they did chores on the property. (They did not.) But she couldn't afford the jury trial. And AI helped them defeat summary judgment by the skin of their teeth.
Every state has some procedure for tenants to fight unjust evictions. The problem with California is that the procedures are so burdensome for the landlord they create big incentives for defendants to fight losing cases. And most defendants, based on the evidence, have a losing case. But they gain lots of extra time by fighting losing cases, and it usually costs them nothing. It costs the landlord a lot.
1
2
17
1,141