Reed Esau πŸ‘» (@reedes) header
Reed Esau πŸ‘» (@reedes) profile picture

The bad kind of skeptic, coder, hiker, diver, and skier. Recently authored book series dealing with bullsh*t, summarized at #RealityTrackingDaily

Space Coast, Free State of FL
Joined February 2008
Photo by Reed Esau πŸ‘» (@reedes)Photo by Reed Esau πŸ‘» (@reedes)Photo by Reed Esau πŸ‘» (@reedes)Photo by Reed Esau πŸ‘» (@reedes)Photo by Reed Esau πŸ‘» (@reedes)Photo by Reed Esau πŸ‘» (@reedes)Photo by Reed Esau πŸ‘» (@reedes)Photo by Reed Esau πŸ‘» (@reedes)Photo by Reed Esau πŸ‘» (@reedes)Photo by Reed Esau πŸ‘» (@reedes)
My β€˜Welcome to Florida’ deluge of rain overnight. Cat and I will retreat to camper van if water intrudes into house. β›ˆοΈ
3
6
129
Though more rain is coming, I expect (hope?) this is high water mark.
1
22
It was the high mark. My efforts to prepare for water intrusion into house were for naught! Now water slowly receding as the storm drains accept it.
2
Nov 2 - BLUFFING projects more force than is there: knowledge, confidence, authority, backing, willingness to escalate, or implied consequence. The goal is to make other people grant weight or deference before seeing the support. 1/3 #RealityTrackingDaily
1
1
48
A bluff can work through menace, but also through composure, prestige, procedural language, or performed certainty. It borrows reality from your caution. People may back off because challenge feels risky, awkward, or unnecessary. 2/3
1
23
Lower the temperature and ask for the claim in operational form. Who is backing this? What evidence exists now? What consequence can be imposed, by whom, and on what grounds? A bluff often depends on other people supplying the missing force. 3/3
15
Fun rendering. Needs more Dharma stations, jughead, and the Black Rock. At least before it blew up. (I'm surprised no attempt has been made to spin off a new series, such as a Dharma prequel.)
Rebuilding the entire LOST island in 3D.
52
Notorious case of audio pareidolia where our betters indulge their need to be morally outraged by willfully misinterpreting otherwise benign phrasing. 😸
Nick or Treat 1985-2002, they couldn’t air this today
2
79
Nov 1 - EMOTIONAL MANIPULATION uses feeling as leverage so judgment narrows and another person becomes easier to steer. The issue is not that emotion is present. It is emotion being exploited to do persuasive work that fair reasons could not do. 1/3 #RealityTrackingDaily
1
46
Fear compresses time. Guilt and shame make refusal feel ugly. Pity distracts from contradiction. Flattery and belonging cues lower defenses. Outrage makes restraint look like betrayal. Each emotion creates a different pressure route. 2/3
1
23
Ask what you are being pushed to feel and what that feeling makes harder to examine. What would happen if you slowed down, asked for evidence, or said no? If emotional force rises with scrutiny, something is steering your judgment. 3/3
16
Curious to know if signaling your virtue is now considered a Stoic principle. πŸ€ͺ
33
Theater in its various forms (eg, security theater) attempts to subvert our perception of reality. As AI bots comb through the huge body of scientific research looking for flaws, as in this case, it'll show what the replication crisis has been pointing to: shoddy/faked results!
People who have been in research fields develop a felt sense that most "research" (in almost any field that isn't exactingly technical) is research theater, and many superstar careers enjoy star status not because of a unique connection to the truth but because of a unique connection with an audience. No one really has the time or stature to, from a position of objectivity and trust, bring popular researchers to heel. But it will get increasingly hard to hide from serious critique. The machines can do critique now, at the level of depth and rigor previously only possible for the academically deranged. We're going to have to revise a lot of what we "know" about the world that isn't really knowledge but is actually just received popular consensus - like floating voltages without grounding wires. The grounding wires are coming.
1
31
Oct 31 - BELIEF PERSEVERANCE is keeping a belief after its evidential support has weakened, collapsed, or faced serious challenge. Reality has started asking for revision, but the belief remains sticky. 1/3 #RealityTrackingDaily
1
25
Beliefs often do more than describe the world. They support identity, dignity, relationships, past commitments, and larger worldviews. Correction then stops feeling like a factual update and starts feeling like threat. 2/3
1
17
Ask what would change your mind and what this belief is doing for you besides describing reality. Can your self-respect survive revision? Belief perseverance weakens when changing your mind feels like course correction, not annihilation. 3/3
12
Oct 30 - EXTRAORDINARY CLAIMS are claims that would force unusually large revision of what you already have strong reason to think is true. Extraordinary does not mean weird, offensive, unfamiliar, or inconvenient. It means revisionary. 1/3 #RealityTrackingDaily
1
2
64
Evidential demands should scale with the size of the rewrite being requested. A vivid anecdote, confident witness, unexplained anomaly, or loose demonstration may deserve attention. It does not automatically earn a wholesale revision. 2/3
1
1
30
Ask how much this claim would force you to revise and whether the support has earned that revision. This keeps inquiry proportionate without turning novelty into proof or orthodoxy into a veto. 3/3
1
19
The Paul Lynde Halloween Special first aired 50 years ago today, on October 29, 1976. I was 11 and have no recollection of watching it at the time. If you have not seen it yourself, you have no idea what you're in for! (Link to video in reply.)
1
3
243
I wonder if Billie β€œWitchiepoo” Hayes knew she was mere inches from Gene Simmons notorious tongue? 😸
39