Ryan Pramberg retweeted
You work your ass off solving really hard problems day after day for decades, and this is what you get: anyone could have done it.
As an investor, I can tell you the limiting factor isn't investment. It's founder ability.
Ryan Pramberg retweeted
A word of caution: This election was a referendum on Trump with independents & many conservatives voting to stop him. It was not an embrace of Sanders-style progressivism. Yes, Democrats should fight for their principles, but they've not yet won over the public on this stuff.
Ryan Pramberg retweeted
The only thing that would sway my vote this election is six text messages from an unidentified number during my work day.
Ryan Pramberg retweeted
It's surprisingly revealing to ask: if someone's name were a unit of something, what would it be a unit of?
Ryan Pramberg retweeted
The moment drawing became “do this, get that,” it stopped feeling like play.
That is the overjustification effect.
A reward can turn a want into a chore.
Ryan Pramberg retweeted
The Great Inversion: AI Is Quietly Draining the Public Internet of Thought
Something profound is happening to the Internet, and almost no one is naming it clearly.
I have been cataloging it of the last 4 years.
For decades, the web’s most valuable resource wasn’t bandwidth or servers. It was the messy, public give-and-take of human questions and answers.
I was a Top Writer on Quora for nearly a decade as well as a massive pre-crazy Wikipedia contributor — I lived in the space of that give and take.
Someone would hit a wall, open a forum, type out the problem, and a conversation would form. Ideas were stress-tested in the open. Nuance appeared. Dead ends were marked. Better questions got refined in real time. That entire process — the friction, the disagreement, the collective thinking — was left behind as searchable, linkable, durable public knowledge.
That flow has reversed.
The same questions, the same moments of curiosity or confusion, are now more routed into private AI interfaces. A person opens a chat window, types the prompt, receives the output, and the entire exchange vanishes into a closed ecosystem.
The assumption we must make (because it is true) is that the AI company stores both the prompt and the response. The thinking that once would have become part of the shared human record is instead locked inside a corporate training silo.
This is not a minor shift in user behavior. It is an inversion of the Internet’s original knowledge architecture.
Public discourse is being systematically stripped of its higher-signal material. As the internet’s data gets more and more noisy in a very really way it is growing quiet.
The questions that used to generate the richest threads the ones that forced people to clarify assumptions, admit uncertainty, or synthesize across domains are the ones most efficiently answered by AI. What remains on the open web is increasingly the residual: lower-effort posts, performative arguments, recycled takes, and the questions that still feel too social or too ambiguous for a model.
AI then trains on that thinning residue, while the better thinking is captured privately and never returns to the commons.
The result is a strange feedback loop. The public Internet becomes less thoughtful precisely because the thoughtful interactions have been privatized. And the models, trained more and more on what is left behind, risk becoming increasingly fluent in the lesser exchanges that now dominate the surface.
This is not the usual complaint about “AI is making people dumber” or “forums are dying.” Those are symptoms. The deeper phenomenon is structural: the migration of human cognitive surplus from a public knowledge commons into private, non-reciprocal data reservoirs.
The Internet is no longer primarily a place where thinking is externalized and shared. It is becoming a place where thinking is extracted and contained.
The novelty of this observation is that it reframes the problem away from content moderation, engagement algorithms, or even AI capability. The core issue is architectural. We have inverted the direction of knowledge flow. What once leaked outward into a shared substrate now drains inward into silos that do not, by default, give back.
The long-term consequences are massive under-discussed as not noticed.
How does a civilization maintain a high-quality public epistemic environment when its best questions are no longer asked in public? What happens to the training data of future models when the richest human reasoning is locked behind commercial walls? And what cultural muscles atrophy when the habit of thinking out loud, in front of others, becomes rarer?
This is the silent inversion of the Internet. The data once destined for the commons is now shunted into AI. The thoughtful exchanges are disappearing from the surface, and the models are learning from what remains.
That is the novel dynamic. Everything else is downstream of it.
Ryan Pramberg retweeted
Congratulations to the #ALWS26 champions from @CarpetLandRugs!
Ryan Pramberg retweeted
Can we pass a law that says that Government is never allowed to say "free" and instead they must always say "tax-payer funded"?
Ryan Pramberg retweeted
The irony of English majors being among the least religious is that half the Western canon becomes incomprehensible if you don’t know the Bible.
Ryan Pramberg retweeted
Absolutely insane stat: The U.S. has added $450 billion to the national debt since July 1. That’s over $15 billion a day.
“There are two ways to enslave a country. One is by the sword. The other is by debt.” – John Adams
Ryan Pramberg retweeted
Tax the rich.
“New IRS data finds that the top 0.1% of taxpayers (roughly 154,000 returns) paid $440 billion in federal income taxes in their most recent year.
The bottom 80% paid $350 billion.
Meaning the top 0.1% paid more than the entire bottom 80% combined.” — h/t IRS, @Rothmus , @profstonge
Ryan Pramberg retweeted
For any scandalous story that upsets you, ask: How many such stories should we expect in a well-functioning country with 340M people?
Ryan Pramberg retweeted
Anthropic maintains that it is entitled to train for free on all the world’s output, even if the author objects. But if a competitor trains on Anthropic’s output after paying for it, that is IP theft. The hypocrisy is breathtaking.
btw anthropic's internal document on this literally said "we don't want it to be known that we are working on this.”
it was called project panama.
here's exactly what happened:
1: anthropic concluded that books were the cheapest way to build a world-class model because they gave claude curated facts, structured arguments, compelling stories, and writing “an editor would approve of.”
2: once anthropic decided it needed books at enormous scale, its first solution was piracy.
it downloaded 7m+ books from online libraries including libgen. the judge later wrote that although anthropic had legal ways to buy them, it chose piracy to avoid what dario amodei called the “legal/practice/business slog.”
3: that piracy created a massive legal risk.
so in february 2024, anthropic hired tom turvey, the former head of partnerships for google books, to find a legally safer way of obtaining “all the books in the world.”
4: turvey first contacted major publishers about licensing their catalogs.
those attempts didn’t produce agreements, so anthropic chose a route that required no publisher permission: buying millions of physical books through distributors and used-book retailers.
5: within about a year, anthropic spent tens of millions acquiring and scanning millions of books, including many rare and 1/1 titles. one vendor proposal targeted 500,000 to 2 million books in six months.
6: to scan that many books within months, the vendors physically dismantled them.
a hydraulic cutter removed each spine. the pages were trimmed to size, fed as loose sheets through high-speed industrial scanners, and converted into searchable PDFs. the paper remains were then sent for recycling.
7: these PDFs were fed into claude as training data.
the complete collection became a private, searchable anthropic library that the company planned to “store forever.” the scans aren’t available to the public and were never open-sourced.
Ryan Pramberg retweeted
My students sometimes ask why they should memorise things in the age of Google and LLMs. But internalised facts are your bullshit filters and your raw material for creative association. Facts outside your head are inert.
🇪🇺 This year the European Union will again make more money from fining US tech companies
Than from the total tax income from Europe's own public tech companies!
⚠️ We have fined Google €890 million for breaching the Digital Markets Act, by promoting their own services and restricting customer access to alternatives on Google Search and Google Play.
link.europa.eu/vrNJTx






























