
Associate Prof @CAUKiel | Middle Eastern & Islamic Studies | Arab World & Turkey | interested in the big questions about religion, society and politics
Kiel, Germany
Joined August 2012
- Tweets2.2K
- Following356
- Followers606
- Likes1.5K
Pinned Tweet
Im Podcast mit @vorpolitisch spreche ich über:
- Alltagsreligion in der arabischen Welt, was gesellschaftlich akzeptiert ist und was nicht;
- welche Religionspolitik Staaten wie Ägypten und Libanon betreiben und warum sie nichts zur Bekämpfung von islamischem Extremismus beiträgt;
- warum alternative Philosophien und Lebensentwürfe jungen Menschen bekannt, aber häufig nicht die Praxis umsetzbar sind;
- was ich für die Aufgabe der Islamwissenschaft halte;
- und vieles mehr ...
+++ NEUE FOLGE +++
Heute: Sebastian Elsässer @sebomasr , Associate Professor für Middle Eastern & Islamic Studies.
Wir sprechen über Islam, Religionspolitik und Lebensrealitäten.
podbean.com/eas/pb-qjk7d-1ab…
Sebastian Elsässer retweeted
These tourism entry rules sound shambolic & possibly more restrictive than Assad’s were for me to first travel to Syria.
I mailed my passport to DC for a single entry stamp as an undergrad in 2008. But paying for minders/mandatory babysitters is Iran, Turkmenistan, N Korea stuff
These new Syrian visa requirements were rolled out without any prior notice and left hundreds of passengers stranded or turned away. I’ve been hearing from people who work in tourism all day that they are incredibly concerned about how much this will hurt a sector that is only just starting to recover.
Plant die Muslimbruderschaft ein Kalifat in Europa?
In meiner Rezension auf Qantara.de bespreche ich das Buch „Kalifat nach Plan“ der französischen Autorin Florence Bergeaud-Blackler. Ihre These lautet, dass die Muslimbruderschaft und ihr Umfeld Europa Schritt für Schritt unterwandern.
Meine Kritik:
▶️ Die Muslimbruderschaft ist heute so schwach wie lange nicht. Sie wurde in Ägypten entmachtet, ist in mehreren Ländern verboten und im Exil zerstritten.
▶️ Die Autorin wirft sehr unterschiedliche Gruppen in einen Topf, etwa linke Aktivist:innen, Feministinnen, Salafisten, Rapper und Halal-Firmen. Daraus macht sie einen einzigen Akteur mit einem geheimen Plan.
▶️ Ihre These lässt sich gar nicht überprüfen. Wer fromm auftritt, gilt als Beweis, und wer unauffällig lebt, gilt als getarnt.
▶️ Dass viele Muslime in Europa konservativer leben als der Mainstream, hat viele Ursachen. Ein Masterplan gehört nicht dazu.
▶️ Wer den europäischen Säkularismus verteidigen möchte, braucht Fakten und eine sachliche Debatte, keine Verschwörungserzählung.
Sebastian Elsässer retweeted
Haben Staaten ein Existenzrecht - oder nur Menschen? Ein paar Takte Sachlichkeit von Völkerrechtler Markus Krajewski. sueddeutsche.de/politik/exis…
Sebastian Elsässer retweeted
Nach einem derart dummen Satz kann man gleich aufhören zu lesen.
Die Unfähigkeit, zwischen Grausamkeiten des Krieges und Grausamkeiten "der Juden" zu unterscheiden, eint den Autor da wohl mit Antisemiten.
Eine lesenswerte und diskussionswürdige Einordnung des extremistischen Phänomens “Palästinismus” api-depositonce.tu-berlin.de…
Sebastian Elsässer retweeted
Morocco's female labor force participation is only 20%; it remains poor and religiously conservative.
Unlike India, however, arranged marriages have radically declined, as more young people seek their own partners, based on emotional companionship.
And that matters, enormously, because it means that a man can only get a wife if he's actually nice to women, demonstrating care, compatibility, and devotion.
What explains this divergence?
Sebastian Elsässer retweeted
Which region is more socially conservative?
The Middle East & North Africa OR South Asia?
To answer this, we could look at attitudinal surveys, laws or behaviour.
If you look at just one indicator, whether men have the freedom to choose their own wife,
MENA has actually seen an expansion in young men's personal freedoms: arranged marriages have radically declined.
Why is this?
My next essay at ggd.world
What seems to be the largest public opinion survey in #Syria’s history just dropped.
3,600 Syrians. Every governorate. 500+ questions. Fieldwork Sept 28 to Oct 15, 2026. Margin of error ±2-3%.
What Syrians actually want, in their own numbers 🧵
damascusinstitute.org/wp-con…
Sebastian Elsässer retweeted
Eine von meinen obsessiven Ideen ist, dass Martin Hikels Virtue Signalling einer unerschütterlichen Israel-Solidarität die politische Krise in Berlin mit verschuldet hat. Wem war damit geholfen, dass der Lokal(!)Bürgermeister von Europas größter palästinensischer Community
„Ich weiß es aus Neukölln. Es ist auf den großen Hochzeiten und in den Moscheen immer wieder gesagt worden: Wählt die Linke. Das ist unsere Partei. Die sind als Einzige für Gaza und gegen Israel“ – berichtet @FranziskaGiffey
welt.de/politik/deutschland/…
Sebastian Elsässer retweeted
The "hurt people hurt people" comment from Abdul was insensitive and ill-timed but we should recall that hurt people hurt people was basically the entire thrust of President George W. Bush's Freedom Agenda — the idea being that if people don't have peaceful avenues to express their grievances through the democratic process, they're more likely to resort to violence. It became fairly mainstream after 9/11 to argue that hurt people hurt people and that it was necessary to understand the context (or "root causes") of terrorism in order to effectively fight terrorism.
Replying to @shadihamid
The condemnations have been weak tea. He never fully walked back hurt-people-hurt-people. The constant AIPAC drumbeat is a huge part of the problem which, charitably, he does not understand
Sebastian Elsässer retweeted
Me on Democrats and the racialization of Islam:
"You have people like Zohran and Abdul who are very openly and outwardly Muslim, but it’s interesting the way their Muslimness is represented. When you think about Zohran, we don’t actually know a lot about the content of his faith or how practising he is or what he actually believes. It seems that Muslimness has become almost like a racial identity, that it’s evidence of being a marginalized group. It's no longer a theological category. And I know that frustrates some people, but Zohran is so popular and so successful that people are largely okay with that trade-off.
I think Abdul is interesting because he is definitely quite practising, and we know that Islam has been an important part of his life. But again, it doesn’t come out really fully. And I think there’s a lot of reticence for even these openly Muslim candidates to talk about the content of their faith, especially when it comes to social issues.
Abdul has had major opportunities to say things on trans athletes in women’s sports. He went on Fox News and was asked a question about that, but he punted. Democrats are so careful about not offending constituencies that even when they might have socially conservative values, they don’t actually express them. And I think there’s a real bind there. Like, can you be a fully fledged member in good standing of the Democratic Party and sound off conservative notes on LGBTQ issues? And it’s not clear that you really can."
Sebastian Elsässer retweeted
Is it Orientalist to ask why the Muslim world fell behind?
My @compactmag article is now Open Access:
compactmag.com/article/why-t…
It examines Muslim societies' early golden age and current underdevelopment—and how Edward Said's important book is now used to dismiss critical analysis.
Ich habe noch nie verstanden, warum Law and Order nicht ein genuin linkes Thema ist.
Niemand braucht befriedete städtische Räume mehr als arme Leute, die nicht ausweichen können in die grünen Vorstädte oder in Gated Communities.
Was ist daran so schwer zu verstehen?
Vielleicht bin ich naiv, aber ich würde einfach mal annehmen, dass Polizei und Verfassungsschutz ihren Job machen, egal wer gerade an der Regierung ist. Dafür haben wir ja einen Verfassungsstaat mit starken Institutionen und einer unabhängigen Justiz.
Elif Eralp möchte Regierende Bürgermeisterin Berlins werden. Doch in einem internen Vermerk zeigt die Linkenpolitikerin, dass sie sich vor Terrorsympathisanten mit Kontakten zur Hamas fürchtet. Kann so jemand für die Sicherheit in der Hauptstadt verantwortlich… Link in X-Bio.
1
2
279
Sebastian Elsässer retweeted
Excellent article by @Sami_Moubayed about Syria's education system.
He worries that the growing effort to Islamize Syria's schools means the end of a century-old experiment in Syrian modernity and its efforts to build an identity that can unite all Syrians.
Read the last 2 paragraphs:
"Over the course of the 20th century, Laique’s reputation, feeding on its facilities and bilingual instruction, hardened into something close to folklore. Syrian families would send their children regardless of sect or religion, mainly because Laique promised something that confessional schools did not: a Syrian identity. All of that came to a grinding halt when the school’s administration recently took the controversial decision to separate boys and girls, nearly two years into the administration of President Ahmad al-Sharaa. The change was framed as the school complying with the wishes of parents, sparking backlash from many secular voices, the Syrian intelligentsia and the school’s alumni."
"To date, the Education Ministry has not intervened, but many are worried about the direction in which Syria is heading. Last year, entire chunks of Syrian history were crossed out of textbooks, including aspects of the pre-Islamic past and women pioneers. Some of the amendments were controversial but understandable, like eliminating all mention of the 1973 October War with Israel, given that it was led by Hafez al-Assad. But gender separation at a mixed school with Laique’s history takes the fears to a completely new level. Laique, after all, is not just an ordinary school but a century-old experiment in Syrian modernity, and any change to its practices will be interpreted as a verdict on that vision. The school’s founders — those French educators, the reformist premier, the elite Damascene families who enrolled their children — were all engaged in an act of imagination. They believed that Syria’s future would be built by people who had learned to think across the lines that had previously divided them. That belief is now in danger."
By @smoubayed in @newlinesmag
newlinesmag.com/essays/a-cha…
Sebastian Elsässer retweeted
The Syrian Ministry of Education reissued multiple textbooks, erasing female figures (incl Mona Lisa) & statues & adding hijabs on the heads of women and teens. The move aroused widespread controversy among Syrian civil society & marks another step taken by Syria's post-Assad authorities to shift the country's culture toward conservative interoperations of Islam. Additional examples of changes: facebook.com/mohammad.assall… & facebook.com/mohammad.assall…
Das könnte erklären, was mit Constantin Schreiber („Die Kraft des Islams“) passiert ist.
Houellebecq is often portrayed as an anti-Muslim writer but I don't think that's quite right. Submerged within his work is a kind of Muslim envy. He almost seems to wish that European civilization had the same spiritedness that Muslims (supposedly) have.
3
1
352
Sebastian Elsässer retweeted
I've been reticent to jump into the moral panic about @AbdulElSayed's supposed ties to the Muslim Brotherhood. But I'll say a few things that should be obvious but apparently aren't, as someone who studied the Brotherhood for years and wrote several books about them. First of all, so what if Abdul's mom was involved with the Egyptian Muslim Brotherhood in the 1970s? What does that have to do with Abdul? You shouldn't be judged for something your parents did or didn't do before you were even born. That's plainly guilt by association.
As for the Egyptian Brotherhood itself, it hasn't been involved in political violence since the 1940s/50s and even those incidents can't really be described as terrorism, since they didn't target innocent civilians for political gain. In the decades since, the Brotherhood has repeatedly renounced violence and committed themselves to pursuing their aims through the democratic process. It's little accident that Al-Qaeda's number two, Ayman al-Zawahiri, wrote an entire book condemning the Brotherhood as lackeys and disbelievers, precisely because they had agreed to abide by the rules of the democratic game.
Of course, it's totally fine to dislike the Brotherhood and what they stand for. They advocate for the application of Islamic law in politics and for a larger role for Islam in public life more broadly. In short, they're illiberal and we as Americans probably wouldn't want to live under their rule. But I don't see how one could describe them as an "extremist" organization. Their views on Islam — as ample polling makes clear — are fairly mainstream by Egyptian standards. I'm not sure it makes a lot of sense to judge the Brotherhood according to liberal, American standards.
Before the Trump administration, successive U.S. administrations engaged directly with Muslim Brotherhood officials and maintained open lines of communication with their leaders, which made sense. They were the largest mass movement and opposition group in Egypt and it would have been foolish to ignore them from the standpoint of U.S. national interests.
Even if you hate the Brotherhood, it should also be possible to hold the view that their members and supporters shouldn't be repressed or killed and should have the right to participate in politics and contest democratic elections. Democracy, at its core, is about the right to make the wrong choice.
In many ways, MAGA as a movement is more radical than the Brotherhood was in Egypt both before and during the Arab Spring. At the very least, MAGA — like the Brotherhood — is illiberal. And the Republican Party under Trump has a dubious relationship with democracy. After all, a significant number of Republicans, including Trump himself, didn't respect democratic outcomes in 2020 and sought to overturn a legitimate election.
The GOP's attempt to demonize the Brotherhood and paint with the guilt-by-association brush is just another way to vilify peaceful law-abiding American Muslims by portraying them as having foreign ties and dual loyalties. It should be rejected as such. The idea that Abdul is some secret Muslim Brotherhood member is absurd on its face.
I wish the Republican Party would make up its mind about people like Abdul and Zohran, both of whom take the Democratic Party's line on LGBTQ rights and even trans athletes participation in women's sports. Sure, their faith is important to them and it influences them — but Republicans should welcome the fact that there are prominent Muslim politicians who are normalizing talking about one's faith in public life, especially after criticizing the Democratic Party for being inhospitable to people of faith.
Sebastian Elsässer retweeted
Die Realität der Olivenernte im Westjordanland, voller Gewalt gegen palästinensische Bauern und auch westliche Journalisten.
Replying to @infinite_jaz
This video captures settlers beating Heidi. They clubbed her, kicked her. Pulled her up off the ground to beat her more. Robbed her of all her equipment. If she didn’t have a helmet—and if she was Palestinian—she could be dead.






























