Susan retweeted
Whether John Swinney saw Dr Habib's letters or genuinely didn't see them until today, neither answer is remotely acceptable.
A consultant surgeon wrote to Scottish Ministers four times between 2023 and 2026, three times to the First Minister, warning about avoidable deaths after a 2022 review flagged 19 avoidable deaths out of 45 cases and was shared with the CMO and Health Secretary in October 2022.
If a system lets warnings on that scale get tossed away with routine civil service letters without ever reaching the First Minister's desk, the Permanent Secretary's review needs to publish every briefing and email before the end of the year.
This is totally dysfunctional and the First Minister’s response isn’t good enough.
If John Swinney genuinely didn’t see this correspondence until today that raises serious questions about how the Scottish Government has handled this scandal.
That’s why I have written to the Permanent Secretary asking for an investigation
Here's an idea, First Minister. If you must have your deputy hovering at your side as you face scary journalists in your post-FMQs huddle, why not at least allow her the dignity of being allowed to speak a word or two on her own account?
2
120
Susan retweeted
Understand the government's Permanent Secretary has now been instructed to look at internal processes around whistleblower correspondence.
Clearly there's a realisation that it may not be fit for purpose if a series of such letters can be sent without any red flags raised to FM.
John Swinney has told reporters he did not see the letters sent to
him by Dr Habib blowing the whistle on NHS Grampian. The consultant surgeon says he’s been raising concerns for a decade & wants a corporate homicide investigation into avoidable deaths.
@LBC l @LBCNewsScot
Susan retweeted
There are far too many civil servants who believe their job is to provide political cover for SNP ministers. This case illustrates how devastating the consequences of that can be.
So in all the presumed conversations with Constance and officials about what she was to say/do re NHS Grampian the small matter of Dr Habib's claims was simply never mentioned?
Who cares if Swinney stops journalist's interruptions of his huddle waffle with an imperious 'forgive me'? Ask the questions.
Susan retweeted
This must not be a repeat of the government’s approach to the Queen Elizabeth University Hospital in Glasgow or Eljamel in Tayside – denial, evasion, dragged kicking and screaming towards justice.
Families should not wait years for answers - they deserve answers from this Government today.
Susan retweeted
"The public were not told, families were not told, but the First Minister was told."
Scottish Labour leader @michaeljmarra says John Swinney and his government ignored concerns raised by whistleblowers about avoidable deaths within the NHS Grampian area. #FMQs
Has he got his hands in his pockets while addressing these extremely serious matters? And why does Gilruth have to stand there in silent solidarity?
Susan retweeted
Open letter of protest at Birmingham University’s plan to move the Shakespeare Institute from its home in Stratford-upon-Avon.
Signatories include Dame Judi Dench, Kim Cattrall, Sir Simon Russell Beale, Ralph Fiennes and Dame Harriet Walter. Please RT
savetheshakespeareinstitute.…
Susan retweeted
1. The SNP Government has just published details of its "mansion tax" plan for homes valued at £1m plus.
Edinburgh has 6,920 such properties, while Dundee/East Ayrshire/North Lan have ten EACH.
Given that the cash will be held locally, this is not redistributive.
Swinney appears to want minimal discussion or debate around proposed huge changes to the structure of councils and health boards across Scotland. We haven't to bother our little heads about it. Just trust in Honest John, and "choose Scotland". Patronising in the extreme.
Susan retweeted
Replying to @willie_rennie
@willie_rennie once more showing how a committee convener should behave.
Susan retweeted
CMAL have raised legitimate concerns about Ferguson Marine’s ability to deliver urgently needed vessels.
These concerns need to be addressed, and the government’s apparent decision to ignore them is folly in itself.
Susan retweeted
Replying to @larabirdsnp @theSNP
Lara, the absolute brass neck required to stand up and blame a Labour government that has been in power for barely two years for failing young people, when your own SNP has controlled Scotland’s education system, economic agencies, and employability programs for NINETEEN YEARS.
You are lecturing the Commons that “employability support is only beneficial if there are actually jobs available” who exactly do you think runs Skills Development Scotland?
Who controls Scottish Enterprise?
Who has presided over the Scottish education system for almost two decades? You are desperately trying to project 19 years of your own party's domestic policy failures onto Westminster just to score a cheap grievance point. If young people in Scotland feel they are being failed by a stagnant economy and a lack of proper employability support, the call is coming from inside Holyrood.
Susan retweeted
My complaint is being forwarded by a person who has this in her email signature. This is embedded at every level.
Been asked to fill in a survey following my submissions re the Conversions Practices Bill. This is what we are up against. This is the water in which they swim. I don’t ’think of myself’ as female. I am female. That can never change.
And what do I even say? Not option to refuse to answer as question ideologically loaded.

























