This is also why a Fine Arts supervisors are so important for band, choir, theater, dance, art, and so much more.
Veteran teachers don’t struggle with feedback because they’re unwilling to grow.
The issue is the system treats a first-year teacher and a 20-year teacher the same. That doesn’t make sense.
A new teacher is building a foundation. They need structure, modeling, and direct feedback. A veteran teacher is in a different place. They’ve taught thousands of lessons, worked with hundreds of students, and refined their craft. They need someone who can challenge them and understand their level.
But the system applies the same rubric, checklist, and process to everyone.
And it’s not working.
Large-scale evaluation reforms haven’t shown meaningful gains in student achievement. In another study, only about one in four teachers said feedback actually improved their teaching.
That should tell us something.
The strongest research points elsewhere. Instructional coaching shows significant improvement in both teaching and student outcomes. Why? It’s ongoing, specific, and grounded in real classrooms. It meets teachers where they are.
That’s the difference.
You can standardize evaluation, but you can’t standardize growth.
We’ve tried to fix weak feedback by making it more standardized. The problem isn’t the form. It’s the fit.
This isn’t about administrators doing something wrong. Most are doing what they’ve been asked to do. The system just doesn’t match the complexity of the work.
A veteran teacher doesn’t need more boxes checked. They need someone who understands what they’re trying to do and can think with them at a high level.
Evaluation should be less about judging and more about helping.
More aspirational. More conversational.
Not “Here’s what to fix,” but:
What are you working on?
What’s been effective?
Where do you want to grow?
Because growth is voluntary. You can require evaluation, but you can’t force improvement.
That comes down to credibility and relevance.
Teachers act on feedback when they believe the person giving it understands their work, content, and students.
That’s why coaching works. It’s ongoing, specific, and built around real practice. It creates ownership, not compliance.
Veteran teachers don’t ignore feedback because they think they know everything. They ignore feedback that doesn’t match their level.
After enough years, you learn to filter what helps from what just checks a box.
Because growth isn’t one-size-fits-all.
And pretending it is doesn’t make it better. It just makes it look more organized.
References:
National Bureau of Economic Research
American Educational Research Association / American Educational Research Journal
Review of Educational Research
1
48
Truly…a highlight of my summer each year. VBS at CrossBridge Church was a huge success, and I’m thankful for the opportunity to work with our children’s ministry here.
56
March resources for my teacher friends: nafme.org/advocacy/music-in-…
20
Music plays such an important role in the lives of our students, and we want to bring awareness to this. Alabama Music Educators Association (AMEA) will be sharing some great ways for you to get involved on our social media accounts. Be sure to follow!
1
1
21
To my friends that are music teachers, I want to personally encourage you to share all of the exciting things you are doing with your bands, choirs, orchestras, or elementary music classes. Performances, rehearsal videos, community events, and everything in between - share it!
1
1
MIOSM is an opportunity for music teachers to bring their music programs to the attention of the school and the community, and to display the value that school music brings to students of all ages.
1
9
It’s officially March 1, the first day of “Music In Our Schools Month.”
The purpose of MIOSM is to raise awareness of the importance of music education for all children—and to remind citizens that school is where all children should have access to music.
1
1
45
If you are in the area, stop by and say hello! Our Concert Band performs at 1:20 pm. Symphonic Band performs at 3:15 pm. Wind Ensemble performs at 5:00 pm.
14
Really enjoyed having one of my former high school band directors, Mr. Bill Connell, at Oak Mountain this week to work with our ensembles. My 17th MPA as a teacher is this coming Tuesday, March 4 at Thompson High School in Alabaster.
1
30
One of my favorites!
Let's try this again. Universe of Energy, a 🧵
I wanted to do this because I really think Universe of Energy was the most underrated EPCOT pavilion, no thanks to an underwhelming 1996 rehab that overstayed its welcome.
The actual substance of the attraction's content besides the Dinosaur diorama was nothing to look back on. But everything else, the complexity of the ride system and effort behind show quality is captivating.
Opening day attraction, 1982. It was actually one of the first structures to go vertical along with Spaceship Earth.
23
Thank you to Phil Wilson (AMEA President), Rob Lyda (AMEA Past President), and Heather Holmes (AMEA Recording Secretary) for walking me through the conference preparation this year. I’m excited to continue working with our incredible board in the future!
9
watching the Dr. Tim keynote to remind us of the “why” in what we do, and catching up with dozens of current and former students who have decided to make music teaching and performance a core part of their lives.
1
9
I was on the move most of time, but captured a few photos to remember this week. Some highlights included seeing my Alma Mater perform an incredible concert (Grissom Symphonic Band 1 under the direction of one of my mentors, Theo Vernon),
1
2
The 2025 Alabama Music Educators Conference has wrapped, and it was an incredible 4 days of renewal and growth. This year as President Elect role, I was able to discover all of the wonderful things happening in our band, vocal, orchestra, elementary, and higher ed divisions.
1
22
Travis Bender retweeted
Concert Band 🎶 Symphonic Band 🎶 Wind Ensemble
Join us! Two premieres of new works, plus some classics, including Molly on the Shore, Buglers Holiday, and Stars and Stripes Forever! 🇺🇸
Excited about this!
Universal Epic Universe opens May 22, 2025 at Universal Orlando Resort. Select multi-day tickets and packages will go on sale October 22. Bookings for Universal Helios Grand Hotel, a Loews Hotel, will also be made available.
Learn more: spr.ly/6010qn57C
1
15
Spent some time this weekend at Symphony Hall in Atlanta, meeting with the NAfME Southern Division Presidents, Past Presidents, and President Elects. Thank you, Susan Smith and @AtlantaSymphony for hosting us! Lots of great things in store from NAfME and the AMEA. 🎶
21
Celebrating @SouthwestAir 53rd Birthday by traveling to Las Vegas!!!
19
Travis Bender retweeted
The Walt Disney Company has shared that Disney Legend Richard M. Sherman has passed away at 95.
Last year, Disney shared a video of Sherman returning to Walt Disney’s office to play “Feed the Birds” for ‘Once Upon a Studio.’
This recording was done on a Friday afternoon, which was when he played the song for Walt Disney before he passed away.
























